Who Gets to Tell the Africa-China Story?

  Рет қаралды 2,812

The China-Global South Project (CGSP)

The China-Global South Project (CGSP)

24 күн бұрын

So much of the framing of Chinese engagement in Africa is done through the prism of Western media, academia, government, and civil society. Stories about debt traps, malign influence, and exploitation are all firmly embedded in the larger discourse about Africa's relations with China.
Conversely, the relationship is also framed in equally binary terms by Chinese media and government narratives.
But there's growing demand from African stakeholders to tell a radically different story about this relationship, one that is far more nuanced and puts African interests at the center.
A new collection of papers published by the Africa Policy Research Institute explores the emergence of non-Western-centric narratives. Eric & Cobus spoke with Lina Benabdalla from Wake Forest University, Yu-Shan Wu from the University of Pretoria, Yunnan Chen from ODI, and Folashadé Soulé from Oxford University, four of the world's leading scholars in this field who contributed to this collection for their perspectives about what a new Africa-China story looks like.
JOIN THE DISCUSSION:
X: @ChinaGSProject | @stadenesque
Facebook: ChinaAfricaProject
KZfaq: / @chinaglobalsouth
FOLLOW CAP IN FRENCH AND ARABIC:
Français: www.projetafriquechine.com | @AfrikChine
Arabic: عربي: www.alsin-alsharqalawsat.com | @SinSharqAwsat
JOIN US ON PATREON!
Become a CAP Patreon member and get all sorts of cool stuff, including our Week in Review report, an invitation to join monthly Zoom calls with Eric & Cobus, and even an awesome new CAP Podcast mug! www.patreon.com/chinaglobalsouth

Пікірлер: 17
@chinaglobalsouth
@chinaglobalsouth 23 күн бұрын
Africa Policy Research Institute: Exploring the Role of Narratives in China-Africa Relations (afripoli.org/exploring-the-role-of-narratives-in-china-africa-relations) by Folashadé Soulé, Lina Benabdallah, Yunnan Chen, Yu-Shan Wu, and Cobus van Staden.
@mariomastadon7650
@mariomastadon7650 22 күн бұрын
Another informative discussion. Thanks!
@medicuswashington9870
@medicuswashington9870 22 күн бұрын
China and Russia supported the African colonies freedom fighters. The Chinese Premiere Dzou Enlai visited President Kwame Nkrumah four times in Accra Ghana. Russia built a city Kwabenya and supplied the buildings , personnel and machinery to produce radio isotopes. Russia also built silos for Ghana cocos to escape the United States hegemon deflating the price of cocoa. China and Russia have favors to call in. Thanks for your information and commitment.
@JA-pn4ji
@JA-pn4ji 23 күн бұрын
Corbus and Eric, I like your podcasts and admire your attempts at neutrality. However, very often when challenged, you resort to evidence from [flawed] authority and seek shelter in academic opinion. Academia is flawed and not objective - especially in the non-quantitative humanities, with academics often resorting to casuistry when the evidence contradicts the ideological/geopolitical direction that benefits their academic aspirations or benefactors. In short, the environment from which an academic is speaking influences their interpretation of global events, and very often they speak to their career credibility, prestige, and aspirations [amongst peers] unless speaking anonymously. This is especially so for academics who have chosen to be employed by privately funded think tanks. For instance, the Rockefeller Foundation known historically for eugenics and population control, funds opinions and narratives on China-Africa. The Western media remains the most powerful organ of influence in the world. It is not objective, and its slurs live on beyond the realization of factual truth. Africans unfortunately are heavily influenced at both grassroots and leadership levels by the output of the Western media. How else can you account for the disqualification of Chinese investments in Africa such as the $10 billion Bagamoyo Port project while a similar project in S. America, the Chancay Port project approaches completion. This illuminates the damage to African economic interests that is being done by the Western narrative. And it is even more insidious, as the China 'debt trap' narrative led African countries to shun Chinese infrastructure 'Capital Investment' loans (at 3% interest) that would have laid the groundwork for restructuring their economies with greater economic throughput and exports, instead enthusiastically adopting Western commercial Eurobond loans (at 7% +) for recurrent fiscal support. With rising US interests these loans now command 10% + in interest payments. No surprise, that with the turn in the economic cycle, African countries [now swimming naked] have greater nominal debts than they ever had. Leading to protests and food riots in Kenya and Nigeria. That is the disservice that academic equivocations - on challenging the Western 'Jedi mind tricks' narratives on economic facts, have done to Africa. It is also a symptom of what the pervasive presence of Indian academics - tacitly pushing anti-China narratives [the source of the Sri Lanka debt trap narrative adopted by the West], in the field of 'development economics' has enabled. Allowing the West to influence [gaslight] the weak-minded to its will - with its 'Cosby Show' propaganda - and ultimately maintain its geopolitical hegemony. I go so far as to paraphrase the words of Harriet Tubman into China's intent: “I helped many debt-enslaved nations; I could have helped a lot more if only they knew they were debt-enslaved nations” As to the Chinese narrative, its critical consideration by your podcast is a distraction. It is nowhere as powerful or as effective as the organs that broadcast the Western narrative. Besides, the Chinese by their recent (< 50 years) involvement in Africa can be permitted some leeway or mistakes in their narrative. Comparing the Western and Chinese narratives without consideration for the length of Western involvement in Africa (> 400 years) makes for an unbalanced comparative bias. It is akin to comparing the essays of a high school student with that of a professor.
@thekonkoe
@thekonkoe 23 күн бұрын
The challenge is in identifying an alternative. That’s in part the topic of this particular episode. Journalism and academia both have mechanisms and systems of conduct for assessment and correction (although as you say the criteria might be skew). These mechanisms in academia while also imperfect are relatively transparent and frequently employed. What other source can be relied on, and why is it preferable?
@JA-pn4ji
@JA-pn4ji 23 күн бұрын
@@thekonkoe I am not advocating for alternative sources that exclude academia. I'm advocating for the additional consideration of 'alternative sources' (Social media and KZfaq commentators) as well as a critical consideration of the background of academic guests and the environment that influences their opinions. Academia lags behind 'alternative sources' in opinion-forming by an order of years. For instance, Deborah Bräutigam's rebuttal of the Chinese 'debt trap' narrative only came more than 3 years after the narrative was planted and disseminated. "Allowing the lie to fly before the truth can catch up". Thus giving a false narrative ample time to percolate [and be echoed] into global consciousness, such as to continue to have an impact despite being academically refuted. "Good deeds are seldom remembered; bad deeds are seldom forgotten." And even this podcast can be classified as an 'alternative source' to the reports, books, and journals that pervade academia. Indeed, Corbus and Eric acknowledge the importance of 'alternative sources' where they err, in my opinion, is to assign the task of popular opinion discovery solely to African academics. In this way choosing to serve through their podcast as a filter for academic opinion to a popular audience rather than a two-way dialogue to/from academia. Let's also hear from popular opinions not just from people singing for their academic supper [credentials]!
@DanFeldmanAgileProjectManager
@DanFeldmanAgileProjectManager 23 күн бұрын
Rules based order is short hand for the North Atlantic liberal order, which is just essentially a unipolar, hegemonic order - “do what we say.”
@bola0909
@bola0909 22 күн бұрын
​@@thekonkoeAbsolutely, nothing in life, less alone in academia or Jornalism is transparent. Almost everything aired in the Western Media is scripted, calculated and aimed for a specific set of goals. I don't belong to the class that blame anyone, including the West for problems afflicting Africa though. No one is place on this World for the purposes of solving someone else's problem.
@mariomastadon7650
@mariomastadon7650 22 күн бұрын
It's better than China bad bad bad propaganda, tight?
@Hystericall
@Hystericall 22 күн бұрын
Rules based, lol, we all know by now that means the US rules and can change whatever international laws to suit its interests. In fact, there are no rules in the US' Rules Based Order. Show me where the US rules are written.
The Impact of Chinese Overcapacity on Developing Countries
48:57
The China-Global South Project (CGSP)
Рет қаралды 3,8 М.
How China's Changing Economy is Impacting Africa?
1:14:28
The China-Global South Project (CGSP)
Рет қаралды 5 М.
Как бесплатно замутить iphone 15 pro max
00:59
ЖЕЛЕЗНЫЙ КОРОЛЬ
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
What it feels like cleaning up after a toddler.
00:40
Daniel LaBelle
Рет қаралды 88 МЛН
A little girl was shy at her first ballet lesson #shorts
00:35
Fabiosa Animated
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
I'm Excited To see If Kelly Can Meet This Challenge!
00:16
Mini Katana
Рет қаралды 26 МЛН
The war in Ukraine and the decline of the West | #1623 with Douglas Macgregor
2:01:30
What Africa Can Learn About China's Urbanization
41:37
The China-Global South Project (CGSP)
Рет қаралды 4,2 М.
Where Actually is the "Global South"?
11:19
TLDR News Global
Рет қаралды 143 М.
Is China surpassing the West in influence in the Arab world?
26:36
The Newsmakers
Рет қаралды 376 М.
China-funded infrastructure across Africa force difficult decisions for its leaders
1:25
Conflict scenarios with Russia and China
1:33:36
Brookings Institution
Рет қаралды 43 М.
Niall Ferguson: After the Treason of the Intellectuals
50:15
University of Austin
Рет қаралды 348 М.
How Will China's Energy Transformation Impact Its Relations With Gulf Countries
8:07
The China-Global South Project (CGSP)
Рет қаралды 663
'India Doesn't Know China Well Enough, It's A Weakness'
21:03
Strategic News International
Рет қаралды 118 М.
Как бесплатно замутить iphone 15 pro max
00:59
ЖЕЛЕЗНЫЙ КОРОЛЬ
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН