#CourtTV - MA v #KarenRead

I am not a police officer or a ETM but if all that’s going on in my front yard , I’m going outside and see what’s happening

So none of the sober ppl driving seen the “black blob” but the drunk person did? 😂

Nick made a great point. She would've spoke out the NEXT DAY and said, "That's! What I saw".

My dog would have been going crazy with all that activity out front... even w no sirens going...

Waiting for the snowplow operator to testify

She is lying , because she never mentioned that to anyone until today

These people are lying their asses off to protect their friends. Most couldn’t remember any times. After all this time this girl comes out with this story & never told anyone, liar! My big question is why did they get rid of the dog & sell the house. Looks as tough John was attacked by a dog those marks on his arm is not from getting hit by a car. I’m not buying it!

She is lying about that because she had nine months to talk to people to get her story straight. I don’t buy her testimony at all.

The injuries on the victim's body are not consistent with being hit by a car.

Owner, experienced police officer, not even coming out of the house

The defense isn't saying it was a hit, they aren't claiming to know exactly what happened or how it happened, or that it was set up at the bar. They are simply saying that Karen didn't kill him, that his injuries are not injuries from a hit and run accident, that they look more like they are injuries from a beating or an ambush. I think they invited them over not to beat him up, or kill him, just to party, and that maybe Higgins did want to let him know about what happened with Karen and that it turned into a fight and got out of hand. Regardless of what happened I think most people have to agree that a hit and run makes no sense, his injuries are more consistent with a fight, and that there are far too many coincidences. To say that conspiracies and cover ups never happen, especially in families, law enforcement or small towns is insane. Another thing to remember is that the defense doesn't have the burden to prove Karen's innocence or prove what happened inside that house, only to create reasonable doubt which I think they are doing pretty good at proving, especially so far in the beginning of the state's case.

I think it was a terrible accident, but no one wants to fess up to it ... The only person I feel sorry for is Officer John O'Keefe. RIP young man! 🌻

Julie Naigle not deceptive?🤣 So we're supposed to believe the drunk girl? Not me.

Omg she is such a liar lol this has become a joke. No one believes her. So only 1 drunk person saw the black blob but no one sober 👀👀

I'm a retired Law Enforcement Officer and none of this case, so far as shown any guilt of Karen Read. The only thing that the Prosecutor jas tried to establish is that no one of the witnesses could have done this horrific murder. She testified today that the first time that she said she viewed the "black blob" was 5 to 6 feet long black object. The first and only time she reports the "length" was admitted upon "her recollection with Lally, DA, hours before her testimony today. Hey Vinnie, drunk admitted partier, is Nagel's testimony, and I believe you need to rewind from before this case even went to trial with Attorney Melanie Little, who has followed this case from the beginning! Please do not be fooled. There was never a black blob, Officer John O'Keef was always seen in a blue and white sweatshirt, no jacket and white tennis shoes. Not a black pair of shoes, no puffy jacket...until JO'keefes body was discovered by EMS. She stated that she could still see parts of the yard as still having grass and pavement still visible. Remember, Brian Higgins was parked in front of the mailbox when supposedly Karen Read supposedly arriving, driving forward, never backing up, leaving John O'Keef to enter 34 Fairview Drive. Common sense screams incredigulity!!!

Just a thought but the amount of people drinking and driving could of been any 1 of them

I find the judge very frustrating.

Unbelievable, not once did she ever say that.

Yeah the same witness who also testified that she doesn't recall ever being in JJ's house and then we find out she babysat and dog sat for them and clearly was in their house. Not a credible witness whatsoever, something's not right with this witness, she lies under oath and should be charged with perjury as soon as the system allows, I hope the jury is listening..

How was there snow underneath John's body, if he was supposedly killed BEFORE snow accumulation on the lawn??? 🔥🔥👀👀🚩🚩

Why did Colin Albert need a lawyer previously? I bet that little punk is always in trouble.

Caitlin Albert’s boyfriend sounds like a real intellect 😂😂

Not guilty she definitely didn't do this.

Thank God Karen Read has good attorneys and doesn't have to rely on public defenders⚖️🙏

Did Vinnie say explosive testimony for the prosecutor? Hardly. She’d been at that house for hours drinking and you’re telling me she’s the only one who saw “the blob”?

We knew she “Karen” was at the scene. Seeing her SUV earlier actually helps her case. John wasn’t in snow for 6 hrs.

How convenient. One witness to a black SUV and a dark blob. She’s the only one looking out the window 2x and happens to witness the state’s evidence. No sale!

Vinnie, not sure if you’re just trying to be dramatic for ratings, but I struggle to see how you can think Julie Nagle’s “black blob” testimony is so impactful. She admitted she was drunk. She couldn’t even remember if she brought her own beer to the house that night! Furthermore, she admitted in cross that she is quite tight auntie JJ… the same woman who asked Julie for a screenshot of her text exchange with Ryan. Julie also dramatically embellished her version of what she saw that night over and above what she originally said in her “interview” with Proctor 8 months after the fact. Her testimony is about as worthless as it comes.

These ppl give new meaning to the word “Massholes”.

i find it suspicious that a highly drunk person could remember the times and the directions the suv pulled up.

Julie, why didn’t you call the police/ambulance if you did saw something???? Just imagine, your action could have saved him. Is it because, you’re making it up?

Not gonna lie, Tristan's "high Maintenance" crack was pretty hilarious....caught everyone off guard. So far I see no burden of proof from the prosecution....gonna be pretty tough to get a jury to convict 2nd degree murder

The family is thick as thieves!!!

I do not believe (for a Boston minute) that this girls testimony is honest and truthful. She never said anything prior to today, that moment. I believe that the prosecution needs to have someone say "I saw him right after midnight" I absolutely think she is just another liar coming out of that house.

I would think the snow plow driver operating Frankenstein would notice the “black blob” on the white snow

They were all drunk.

Is this really a win for the prosecution? The drunk girl sees a black blob but the sober driver didn’t? So many questions go unanswered in this case.

Tristan was lying today also, he was told to say that. It is so obvious.

I've never been so anxious to hear the coroner take the stand ever, following any case.

Lies lies everywhere there’s lies!!

So the only witness to something on the lawn is an intoxicated person? I have no dog on this hunt, but this is weak.

I can't believe there are no photos of John's body. We don't even know exactly what part of the lawn he was on

Vinnie, why don’t you EVER mention in news report that today was first Juliana Nagel ever mentioned the size. You’d think she’d have wanted this information before. I find her testimony & body language totally incredible. It also doesn’t speak to who or what left said black blob in that part of the grass.

The jury doesnt need to figure out what happened. They need to decide if CW proved her guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

Who else doesn't trust vinnie? This man has made some of the most outlandish statements!!

Her blink rate was so fast when she was explaining the ‘blob’. I don’t buy it

Supposedly, John was dropped off around 12:20 a.m. How could all these people leave, Brian Higgins parked at the mailbox, no one saw any body at anytime!!!

Hit theory is ridiculous

What about the prosecutions theory that Karen floored the SUV in REVERSE at 24mph for 60 feet in a snowstorm to hit and kill John, and no one noticed that??

This is an unbelievable witness....... She did not say anything after she new jo died...quote..... She put Put two and two together!!! She said nothing to law enforcement Not the next day or two days even a month after. Wth

A hit, more than likely an argument, turned fight that went wrong.

Well what did she think it was ? A tree ?

Lmfao. Has NEVWR SAID THIS TO ANYONE BEFORE TODAY! Anyone who believes ANY SINGLE person on the stand, hey come to my place, I have a good deal for ya.

I thought Mrs Albert said REPEATEDLY that she was walking around cleaning Not Sitting! So many mess ups.

She is the perfect witness to claim she saw something! She isn't one of them! She's lying!

I’m so thankful for y’all to do these videos for us because I haven’t been able to sit & listen to this trial as much as I would like to but it’s going entirely too slow in the court room. I believe that Karen is innocent

It's amazing how selective these peoples memories are 🤔

Horrible what cops are doing to Karen Read.

In the snow- a human sized, dark blob would at least cause me to yell stop, and get closer. I don’t know how cold it is there, but I went to college in a snowy area, and it’s ten times more important to make sure none of your friends (or strangers, for that matter) pass out, outside. A literal matter of life or death in cold climates. If this weren’t compounding with EVERYTHING ELSE, I might not be overthinking it to this point, but as it were…. I mean, this seems to be pretty central to their case, and in that light- pretty weak sauce. If she was too drunk to make anything of it, then how is it credible enough to be used here? Just doesn’t do what they’re trying to make it do for me. (NOTE: I’m by no means implying she’s at fault in any way, I’m just saying it presents credibility issues in context of a MURDER trial. These are exactly the types of things jurors will be thinking about, and discussing when the time comes.)

That blob witness is not credible at all.

If their snow on the grass and a car lights are on the snow is bright so if their was a body you will notice it.

Incredibly important to the timeline yet she just remembered today 😂. And McCabe didn't put "2and 2 together when KR rang to find Officer O'Keffe in the morning. Sooooo much BS. A sad day for the family hearing this is how their son was treated and not even called an fallen Officer in a murder trial?

Hey Vinnie "the copblower" Politian! Enough with your beloved witness Nagel. the white blob! Why you invite Colin Albert's lawyer every day?

NOT GUILTY!!

All LIARS

Oh my God!! Seriously???! I grew up in the 70s and there was a horror movie called The Blob.......could this have been it????? WTF with the testimonies of this clan .

Were we watching the same case? She didnt say she saw the black SUV and then saw the blob. No, she saw the SUV through the window. Later she went out the front door and did not see the object or the suv. Then she was in her vehicle and, for the first time, saw the blob Someone had dumped the body at that point

How dare the guest say he didn't see anything deceptive? Anyone who could say that after listening to Crazy Julie's testimony is not to be trusted himself, I wouldn't invite this lousy nontruth seeking guest, back to the show, he's just taking up space, Court TV.

That she sow a six feet blob does not mean anything, they beat him up and then trough him out. Karen is innocent!

This lady is lying!

Heavy snow but none atop of the black blob!

They are all lying. They are sort out there stories with each other to set up Karen.

she's the only one who ADMITS to seeing anything. hmmmm

If I drove down an unlit road at 50mph and there was a body laying on the side of that road I 99 percent sure I would notice it.

Too many lies in this trial.

Vinny, c'mon man. You don't believe she saw a "black blob" and didn't say anything to anyone when she heard a man died in that exact spot? If that's the case she's more disrespectful to OJOs family than anyone else for not reporting it

That girl is lying.. I don't believe a word she says

Vinnie started out seemingly pro prosecution but I think after hearing their case (or lack of) he is now seeing the holes and discrepancies and flat out lies by the prosecution witnesses

What type of relationship did Julie Nagle have with Brian Jr in Jan 2021? Has it evolved? 8 hrs of drinking together? Was Collin drinkingl?? Wasn't he only 17 ?

Oh the obvious lies !!! These witnesses Deserve Consequences as much as the real killer !! Cough cough where’s Collin ?

I think she had some mushroom soup at the party? 😆

Only thing people seem to remember is that they never looked at the lawn. Wtf remembers that?

How could you not mention seeing a blob after hearing that someone is dead? No way . How would you keep quiet, nothing for months? It's a day you wouldn't forget, even if your memory is different from others, but honestly, you would say something. Unless you didn't see anything. I don't know what happened that night but listening to the testimony 😌 it's really not good for the prosecution so far. But I'm still waiting for more proof, but do I believe she had seen a blob and no mention? No, I call BS 🫤but what do I know 🤔

Tristin Morris stated he was driving carefully and cautious but didn't see a "black blob" in the front yard? But Julie Nagel who had been drinking all night and conversing with Jenn McCabe about PB& J did? GTFOH

Has ANYONE whose taken the stand so far told the truth at All???!!!??? Ive never seen such a liar like this blob on the stand today!

She seems really cocky little nervous about way she answers questions

I didn't see nuttin and nuttin didn't see me....🤨

She is lying. I don’t believe her at all …liar

Why aren’t you talking about the star witness being drunk?

I can't believe you are actually buying what the Prosecutor is trying to lay down! Please Vinnie, please do research and not try to get clicks! There is an electrical box right in front of the flagpole, where JN said she first saw a black blob. Then today she states hours before her testimony stated today, that now she said it was a black oject, 5to6 ft. Btw, none of any of the Alberts, McCabes, friends that were there ever identified the SUV was Karen Reads vehicle. Both Sara and Julie probably don't know what happened that night. But there is no way, from drinking from 8 pm until almost 1:30a.m. Sara and Julie were sober! Even Julie Nagle admitted she was drunk and happy to join making peanut and butter sandwiches with Jen Mccabe and Sara! Karen Read is innocent. The Judge is bias, to the point of clearly unfair. She even helps the DA and says, "Mr. Lally would you like to object to that"? The crime didn't have to take place in front of anyone, the basement was redone, the dog rehomed, the family home of generations was sold, The crime scene was never secured properly or investigated properly. When I was a Police Officer, if a fatality especially was discovered, we obviously first investigated the closest location of the crime. Which, being the front yard, feet in front of the front door, was the Alberts' home! NEVER DID ANY INVESTIGATORS, if you want to call them, do any investigation of the home. All witnesses have so far, have different stories and different timelines. Ask Auntie Bev, the Judge that will not allow a reason for an Objection, stated before the trial began! Cuts the Defense off, whenever she feels like it, has sustained over 69% of the PA's objections, and only 38% of the Defense Objections. Only breaks when Defense is on cross, and tells Defense, no more questions. This is such a travesty of justice, but I don't lose heart because I know the FBI is watching, just like the rest of the entire world! Then, like one DEA agent has spoken clearly his most educated opinion, which creates way more credible than click seekers, makes more sense than uneducated properly trained law enforcement officers! Witness statements never taken, individually, written, signed recorded, etc. Some of the witnesses weren't even interviewed until 18 months later. Some not even until hours before their testimony in this trial, to be "coached". There are way too many red flags and even people that live in Canton Mass. that fear the Alberts. Btw, you do know that the FBI are and have been investigating the "investigators and the Prosecutor , Michael Morrisy, and his office", right!!!??? Please start from the beginning and get the true facts before you try to get clicks from a very possible innocent person facing her life in prison 😢 Suggestion, put your Big boy pants on ", put away your desire for fame, try to get justice and follow the bread crumbs from the very beginning! Watch Melanie Little, Uncivil Law, Duty Ron, researched by the BEST! I'm very disappointed with you Vinnie, I followed you and gave to your own Channel when you branched out on your own.

The dog marks on his arm

But yet she (the ⭐️witness) is the one who can't remember if she brought her own beer to the birthday party 🤔

I hope after this trial and Karen is found innocent, the O'Keefe family sue the Albert's for every penny they have to take care of those two kids. There are an awful lot of conspirators who will be facing prison soon. I hope they all remember that. Just disgusting

O'Keefe could have been hit by Nagel's party. He could have been hit by Higgins, who was parked in front of the letter box at some point. Suddenly, Higgins' car vanished in thin air???

Why would John's body be there if Karen hit him. It would make sense that she dropped him off on their driveway. I have never dropped someone off far away from a driveway.

This case is so crazy.

Black blob? She is lying 🤷 Arent there a time of death? Or injuries to prove it was a car? There must be some hard evidence, you cant convict someone with these "evidence" .. Love from Sweden 🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪

To pull out of the driveway and drive past the house… headlights light up that small yard. Enough with the “it was dark it was snowing” excuse… oh I was looking at my feet as I walked out blah blah. Do these people think the jury is stupid? This clown “investigation” and sham trial is an utter disgrace. John deserves better. Karen is 100% factually innocent.

Think about it. Let's say the Albert's are 100% innocent as was everyone in the house that night. That means their friend just died on their front lawn. What do you immediately do? That's right, you ask all your family and friends if they saw anything when they left the property. That MUST have happened if they are innocent. 100%. Julie said on the stand nobody asked her that question until yesterday. What absolute nonsense. Are we also expected to believe she knew she saw something and didn't come forward with that for 28 months. For the love of God people. This trial needs stopped. NOW.