I have a double mackinaw packer coat with fleece collar. I packed mules in the mountains with it for 25 years. Still have it. The biggest advantage it has over ANY modern coat? You can dry it over a campfire without melting it. We Cowboys wear silk wild rags around our neck to keep the itch down. The pass through back big pocket is for game. Grouse, rabbits, etc. You will pass that coat on to your grandchildren.

Since everyone is correcting me saying the back pocket isn't for a map but rather for carrying dead game,, Filson themselves calls the pocket "a full-width map/chart pocket covering the entire back" - but yes, you can also fit a dead pheasant in there! ✰ Also, check out my 10 Best Boots On the Market! kzfaq.info/get/bejne/b9Gle9yqysyyd3k.html

Great video. I went to the same Filson store in the LWS about a month ago to pick up this jacket in Charcoal... This is the greatest fucking jacket I've ever bought, arguably the best 400 bucks I've ever spent. It's extremely classic but interesting, too the point where people comment on it pretty regularly (and I notice a lot of people looking at it). The fit is fantastic if you're like me, and you're sick of jackets made for skinny European models where you can't fit hardly a flannel underneath without seriously limiting your arm mobility. You have FULL mobility in this jacket and it's so refreshing. Another huge thing is, living in nyc, it'll be freezing outside, but then you go in to the subway for a ~45 minute ride and you're sweating your balls off. Not with this jacket. It allows for that temperature variation, and you won't get out of the train with a damp undershirt, which for me is a huuuge relief. 11 out of 10 for this jacket. If you're on the fence, hop off and get this jacket.

If you wear it 90 days a year, and say you live for another 30 years. That is 2,700 wears and works out as 14 cent a wear. Good price in the long term.

I'm a retired professional forester. I've had two Filson cruisers in 50 years. The first one I basically "outgrew" as I gained a few pounds over the years, lol.

Setting the record straight on this - please read below. That is not a game pocket - that is a map pocket. This jacket is specifically designed for Timber Cruisers, it is not really a hunting jacket. You could use it for hunting if you wanted, but a wet pheasant is going to leave a stain. Hunting jackets usually have a pleated game pocket that is easy to clean. This jacket is designed for Timber Cruisers. And that back pocket is designed to hold maps, lots and lots of folded maps. A Timber Cruiser was someone who works for a logging company and hikes the woods taking notes on his maps, (emphasis again - lots of maps) indicating: timber types, tones per acre, board feet per acre, average trunk sizes measured DBH (that is Diameter Breast Height), dry bulb and wet bulb measurements, obstructions, map revision, and plotting for logging access roads. The Cruiser will usually have one set of maps for each of those criteria. The 4 narrow slot pockets at the chest are to hold different colored grease pencils for marking the various maps. The maps are then scrutinized back at the office to plan future logging operations. Now if you want to use this for hunting, (as I am sure people have) be my guest, but I myself wouldn't put anything fresh back there. Signed: Sincerely, a former forest worker. PS: these are awesome coats that seemingly last forever, though the cuffs will get frayed. I myself have only been able to wear out one. I currently have: 2 double Macks, 3 single Macks, 4 Cape Coats (my second favorite), 4 simple Jack-Shirts (my most favorite), a canvas Logger, and a canvas Packer. Over the decades I have burned through more expensive Gore-Tex shells than I can count or remember. But, if I were on a bush plane in Alaska going down, and faced with the prospect of a multi week walkout to civilization, I would hope that I would be wearing one of these. And if I could only own 1 coat, it would be a Mackinaw Cruiser. (in green). Cheers !

I bought a vintage union made filson mackinaw on eBay and its a tank. Made in the 1940-1950s and will probably outlive me.

Just picked up a vintage Woolrich double-Mackinaw. Two layers on the sleeves, back, and 1/2 the front. Filson used Pendleton wool to make their coats, so a Pendleton coat is basically the same. Woolrich, Soo Woolen Mills, and others made the same type of high-quality wool garments. Lots of them out there to enjoy.

thank you for your reviews! As always very informative and transparent. Love your style and I always have a good laugh with your videos! Cheers!

Once you have a jacket with a poacher's pouch, you'll always look for it. As for Filson products. Everything I've gotten from them has been phenomenal. But they're overpriced. That said, if you get the US-made stuff, you'll never have to buy another one as long as you live. If you're someone who doesn't need a lot of options in your life, this is the perfect coat.

As a long time Seattle area resident and equally long time Filson customer, I can attest to the quality. Jac-shirt's are perfect for most NW weather

Excellent product. I’ve had mine for just about 20 years. It works most of the time but when you have those extremely cold windy days in the single digits I need to break out my parka.. I also wear the FILSON wool vests which make an excellent second layer.

mine is a navy/black version, with buffalo plaid lining. LOVE IT. The back pocket as I've been told is to carry your birds. The ones your lab retrieves. Awesome.

Hey man, thanks for the mention. I wear my dad's coat and will be leaving it to my son. One thing you might want to mention is that it's buttons for closure vs snaps or a zipper. The buttons do take a bit longer to fasten than a zipper or snaps. And as to the sizing, you are on point with buying it a bit larger. Winter coats should always be bought with some extra room since you might be wearing a bulky sweater or an extra layer underneath.

Thanks for the comment about the sizing. I just got a Mackinaw for Christmas and I was questioning the fit. But people at the store laughing in your face blew me doubts away. Also this coat and hearing you say that it will last for the rest of my life makes me aware I won’t live forever. I’m already anxious leaving it in a Diner on some road trip in 30something years. And makes me wonder which kid I want to hand it over to once I’m getting old even though I don’t have any kids yet. Great Video! Happy Holidays!

Cool review! Thank you!

Always into heritage brands. They somehow carry the great craftsmanship back in the day till today.

Love the video! I love how you do items that arent the most trendy but still good products. I wanted to see if you would do a pair of corcoran 1510 jump boots??? I'm interested in your opinion. Theyre only 140 bucks which is interesting.

Great review, I have both as well, regular and double. Both second hand on eBay from fellows who moved from the cold north to Florida and Texas respectively. Not much need for a heavy wool Mackinaw in either state. My regular weight is green/black plaid, the double is all green. Both were also in "long/tall" versions which are great on my 6'6" frame. Coats to last a lifetime. I also owned a vintage Woolrich, red/black plaid "Pennsylvania Tuxedo"

Good review. Thanks.

Thank you a lot for this! I just got mine and I absolutely love it! Best coat ever!

FINALLY, I've been waiting for this video lmao

Presently have a forest green Mackinaw cruiser (size 42, newer models do not come in numerical sizes). The back pocket IS a map pocket made for US Geological Survey (USGS) maps.Handwarmer pockets did not appear until the Seventies or early Eighties. I once had the double Mackinaw in Advantage Timber camouflage in size 42 and WAS slightly smaller in cut as noted by the presenter. Filson has outlet shops in Washington and Minnesota that have lower prices on returned items.

I've had one for many years and agree with everything you say! It's a wonderful jacket overall.

Love that enthusiasm!

I have one like that from the 60s made by Carter’s, I get complements all the time. It’s my favorite coat.

For the record, I used to work in the Filson headquarters in Seattle, and I definitely would have put you in a medium long.

The plaid versions are 26 oz btw..and I do wear mine with a tshirt (your skin will get used to it). I own the double due to the temps I live in, absolutely love it. I own many of the top brands of outdoor gear (arcteryx,Patagonia,norrona,old Sierra designs etc) filson would be my choice if shit hits the fan.

I use a similar coat for my winter snowshoe mountain hikes, sometimes at minus 20.

My Barbour Beaufort also has that big pocket in the back. It’s awesome. I throw gloves or a winter hat in there and I forget it even is in there. Then when it’s cold, my gloves are there.

I've had one for years, in green. It's held up well, of course. I think some of you guys would like Empire Wool and Canvas stuff.

Now this jacket looks great on you!

Just here to say nice choice on pen. That particular uniball is a fantastic choice. Cheap, smooth and just overall perfect for everyday use.

thanks, great video.

Thank for the very best review of the Filson coat. I was so tired of hearing about someone’s dads or grand fathers coat. This is the type of review that makes me ready to make a purchase. Thanks again.

Best review on Mac jackets in KZfaq .

Hey @stridewise can you make a review of the Weatherwool. Good raves about it online.

I recently obtained one of these on Ebay. From what I've learned about deciphering label, I think it was made in 2012. But, the cuffs only have one button, not two like I expected. Any insight as to why?

Hey nick i saw you doing a pre workout review i was so surprised i guess you do loke squats

Sticker shock for sure. I love Filson stuff though. I kind of wish I didn't sell my mackinaw cruiser, had the fairly-rare brown one. I still have a Yukon wool Weekender jacket (AKA Mile Marker), which is a really nice, less scratchy wool. Warmth is hard to compare since I didn't own both at the same time, but probably just a little less warm than the mackinaw. But I just layer if it's really cold. I prefer the cruiser pocket layout, but I like how the wool weekender is somewhat of a field coat - has a draw string for the waist and drapes pretty nicely.

I just picked up a mackinaw Jac shirt for 210 brand new. Ox blood color which is 26oz wool with 8 oz cotton lining. It’s got insulted sleeves as well. I live in California so the look of mackinaw cruiser would look odd so I went with the Jac shirt. I can’t recommend it enough. It breathes better then my Arc’Teryx Atom Lt jacket.

Still one of your best reviews. I have three of their wool coats and don’t find them itchy at all. They are warmer than anything else in cold, damp weather by far, in my experience.

Have you thought about making a video on iron heart flannels?

This coat in black was my first Filson product. And get this, I found it on the ground in Alaska, in perfect shape.

I loved the bloopers lmao

Oi Nick, have you ever considered the Merino Mountain Shirt by McNair Shirts? Supposedly in the same class as the mackinaw wool cruiser.

Hey Nick! You mentioned selling your double mackinaw in the video. I am willing to buy that.

Can you review your Thursday leather jacket?

Love the Saddleback

Can you please review socks? Thanks for your help!

Great Video along Great Information about the Jacket , but I have only one. question.. I am 6'6 &195 lbs my Sleeves length are 39' so what size do think I should order ...

Filson’s now like Barbour, every hipster wants one to wear with their Blundstone or 1000 Mile boots. But the best cruisers are Johnson Woolens Mills hands down.

Never selling mine. Great vid

Sweet video, just checked ebay and they've got a few in my size but not a cheap coat!

Any chance you’ll review the 🧦 socks you typically wear with your 🥾 boots? Are you a wool, cotton or dress sock guy?

For a costly plaid wool, I would hope that they would take the time to make sure that the plaid would line up. I love the design tho.

I’ve never worn one of these, they seem great, but it’d take some going to beat the legendary Swanndri!

I was thinking of this jacket but I heard that the weatherwool all around jacket is better.

Dat forest green is beautiful.

Mine has no snap closures at all, just traditional button closures. Anyone know how old that would have to be?

I only ware wool socks year around. My feet stay reasonably cool and dry in the summer and in winter they perfectly warm and dry even when my boots have completely failed to keep water out. I'm seriously considering one of these.

I have the Woolrich version of the same coat and love it. Woolrich has gone off the rails, so now I buy Filson.

Great. Now I have to buy one.

I have a green one that is old. Well I am no longer young either. Check out the story of Patrick - Duluth Woolen Mill and the original Mackinaw fad. Their slogan was Bigger Than the Weather.

Where was the pipe for comparison accuracy????

Does anyone know how to check if the product is genuine?

I bought a green one two years ago and yes it is pricey but I wear it literally every day in the fall/winter. I have no need for any other jacket.

whahahaahah love the bloopers in the end. by the way in The Netherlands this jacket already cost 500 euro's

Would like to see you do a review on the Stirlingwear Peacoat

Nick, I can tell you had a good time doing this one!

What is the height and weight of the owner/host?

Spray inside with wool conditioner to soften it up

Hello there! Thank you for this thoroughly, we'll put together video. As I'm into market for my first one, as many of us here, it would help immensely if you would tell us your height/weight and chest measurements. The large fits you just perfect! Hope you are well, TGA

These things are legit. I don't really have a purpose for them, but this was a great overview.

I have had my Mackinaw Cruiser for years, it is my go to for a cold New England winter day. It just looks out of place to me in NYC, but I guess times have changed. Good review. If it ends up being too itchy for you, just let me know and I will take it off your hands.

Have you tried out the Mackinaw Jac-Shirt for comparison? Slightly cheaper and has a flannel lining which might help with the itchiness.

I always thought these would look very bulky because of all the front pockets, but it looks alright on you. I have something similar from Pendleton (I think from the 90s). I 100% agree that these are best bought second hand.

The back pocket is similar like the Barbour jacket used to put the NEWSPAPER something common in the 20 century!!!!

Check out the double mackinaw cruiser

You can often find these on Sierra trading post at the end of the winter each season - often for under $200!

Do you have any experience with the Filson Mackinaw Jac shirt? Trying to decide between the two. Also, if you don't mind me asking, what are your personal sizing dimensions? I saw you have a large. That will help me decide a size for the cruiser. Thank you so much!

Thanks so much.. Certain generations of Filson based on board room battles and CEO casualties, their stuff has (S/M/L/XL) sizing or it will have numbers sizing. (40/41/42/43....ect) I wish it would settle.

Nick, how would you compare this to a down parka?

Please somehow get hold of and review the redwing sawmills? Im absolutely lusting after these boots, i love and own my british and italian dress shoes/chukkas i.e crockett & jones, alfred sargent, loake but i need a great winter boot. I am seriously thinking about pulling the trigger on these as not just my first pair of redwings, but also my first pair of serious boots (aparts from hiking boots and chukkas). Id love to see you review them.

Should be fine in NYC for even the worst weather. I have the double Mackinaw. Great coat and wind resistant.

how tall are you? and what size chest may i ask. trying to work out if i need xl or l, thanks

How do you clean/wash it?

idk... you talk a good game bro. I been thinking about it also for a while and made the move. I also ordered a vintage one online!

check out McNair shirts in the UK they are amazing, can do made to measure for perfect fit well worth a look if in the UK

Is that a buck mason henley? Think I have the same one! Also, is double mackinaw unlined too?

Hmm. My 1940s Woolrich is designed identically but is lined with a comfortable cotton. I bought it for a song at an antique shop. Made in Pennsylvania.

Boots: Red Wing Trousers: Pike Brothers Shirt and Jacket: Filson Bags: Filson This my perfect combination.

I live in wa state. The holy grail of work coats. I wear my all year round..

Any chance you tried the Filson Cape Coat in your coat hunt? Just grabbed one for a steal off eBay....curious how you think they compare (if you tried it)...

Being from PA Woolrich used to be the jam. They’ve changed quite a bit over the years unfortunately. Fortunately there’s still lots of gems to be found in thrift stores.

Very easy to have a tailor stitch a layer of denim, or piece from an old black cashmere sweater on that collar to fix the itchiness. Or just always wear a scarf with it.

I’ve owned one for 7 years, it’s still my go to jacket.

These must be popular. Most of their stock of these jackets is sold out or only available in the odd sizes. So much for waiting for a post holiday sale.

thank you

It is getting too cold around here for my usual Levi Denim jacket. I will look at getting one of these.