so according to you people who grow wheat and rice are not farmers . is their is no limit to your andhbhakti . if guys like you are that worried then let punjab export its produce via pakistan border . you guys don't have to buy a single grain . let punjab make deals with middle east countries and just promise indian government won't ban exports from punjab if their is wheat or rice shortage in india.

​@@TheJohn222222 First pay the actual market price of inputs like fertilizer,power etc.... Don't boast on freebies paid by other taxpayers...

@@aloksoni5474 open the market then take away all your subsidies . a punjabi farmers gets about 8000 rs in subsidies from central government per acre . that is nothing . take example of wheat, in 2022 wheat price in international market was 3500 rs per quintal while msp was 2200 rs farmers lost 1300 rs per quintal . per acre wheat yield is 20 quintal in punjab . so punjab farmer lost 26000 rs per acre just so that people like you can be fed. solution is simple. no export ban on agriculture and let international buyers compete with indian buyers . no need for subsidies. farmers in punjab will grow what they get the best price for.

@@aloksoni5474 electricity is supplied by Punjab state government , Delhi has nothing to do with that .

​@TheJohn222222 Is there no limit to your hatred bro !!! MSP is only working for middle men ...Need of the hour is the access for the farmer to better seeds , fertilizers and technology ...But no one wants to do this ..waive the Loan , give them some money and make them beggars as they form the biggest vote bank !!

most of you will not be born because your parents would have of starvation if not because of punjab haryana . have some shame chutia .

The slow transition away from agricultural employment has witnessed a reversal after 2019, with a notable rise in agricultural employment &, currently, a decline especially in manufacturing. India’s manufacturing under shrank from 17% in 2010 to 13% in 2022 to 11% in 2023, as per Index of Industrial production performance data. Even with govt push, in 10 years, manufacturing in India has fallen, mainly due to Inflation. Customs process is difficult in India compared to China. The average import tariff imposed by India on WTO members is 18.1%, compared to 7.5% for China and between 0% and 5% rate in Vietnam. The money that companies put into the future of their businesses, for things like new machines & factories, is stagnant. Firms are not seeing demand to increase their capacity. India’s manufacturing activity slipped has slipped in 10 years. Middle-class business create a lot more jobs, trains the youth and increases the per capita income of the country. We are not an export-driven economy such as China or Vietnam. So if domestic demand is not picking up, then you are likely to have problems. Instead of doing cheap politics (voters are not blind), do some vikas for middle-class businesses who actually create jobs. A nation grows when the middle-class has more money in their pockets. 50% of the poorest Indians with jobs pay 64% of the total taxes, 40% of middle-class in India pay 33% of total taxes, while the wealthiest 10% in India only contribute 3% of taxes; Indian express: India's poorest 50 percent pay two-thirds of gst, oxfam. The 8 crore new employment in 4 years data by RBI, includes the rise in "unpaid" workers like housewives & the rise in people going back to agriculture due to joblessness! India's official unemployment data, CMIE: 2024 (6 months) = 9.2 percent 2023 = 8 percent 2022 = 7.33 percent 2021 = 6 percent

Due demonetisation and gst msme has suffered after that covid came that causes serious disruption in market which has hurt small business very hard. Govt should stop it's focus on signing FTA because product are still not competitive in international market instead it should try to increase domestic consumption.

​​​​@@xxyz2023your oxfam data is wrong. Also you are making a mischievous point here percentage contribution manufacturing has declined over the years not because manufacturing is going down it's going because other sector are significantly doing much better then manufacturing. last year gva growth in manufacturing is 9.2%. Other point india gdp in 2011-12 was 5.2percent but share of manufacturing was still high it doesn't mean economy is doing good.

@@dheerajpimoli9539 India’s manufacturing under shrank from 17% in 2010 to 11.4% in 2023, AS PER THE "Index of Industrial production performance" data. You can check

first remove export ban . poor farmers have to pay for sick bastards like you because of rice and onion export ban . they can get much better price in international markets.

Don't blame telecom companies for the hike. They are paying heavy spectrum license fees to the govt, and they were barely making any profits. And without profits, they can't improve their infrastructure to improve service. The real reason for price crash on e-NAM is oversupply. Mindlessly everyone growing same crop, that too water-guzzling crops. Respect concept of demand and supply.

Just see what were the data price for internet.... ur eyes will open

Do you remember prices before entry if jio rs 251 for 1gb , calla and sms rate over and above that.

Everyone needs a hedge .. so diversify .. at the end of the day farmers are capitalists businessman