Sir I myself am a PhD CSE student at one of the old IITs and the work culture is not at all good here. I think the direct PhD selection process should be rigourous and looks like it isn't. I joined in Jan 2020 right before COVID which was in March 2020 for 2 years we were at home during COVID and currently in my fourth year now and I have no papers. I think there is a lot of insensitivity among a few Professors who ask for unrealistic goals like publishing 5-6 papers(when they just published 2 papers in 7 years of their PhD) to graduate from here. There is no placement support for PhD as well, I don't think there is any point of going with this process coz there is no support when it comes to finances and support as a Phd student for your thesis from Professor's side coz of their incapability. IMPORTANT NOTE FOR FUTURE ASPIRANTS: I would request every student please do Mtech before PhD or else do direct PhD only if you have a bit of research experience coz it's uncertain and one with financial issues needs certainty when it comes to work. Also, if your financial condition isn't good better not to join PhD coz it's risky and as a senior I can tell you this coz of what I am going through. There was nobody to guide me when I was applying and abt to join this as I'm the first one in my family to enter IIT but my dear sisters and brothers please take wise decision. My financial condition isn't good at all and reality of getting an Mtech if you are unable to do direct PhD here is myth. College won't allow you to leave easily especially your advisors, I heard one story(just one in four years) where student literally fought for MTech and this is the condition. You'll suffer very badly and eventually you'll be on your own once your stipend ends. So please think before leaving what you are doing right now before joining PhD/direct PhD especially in India.

Simple truth .. In India companies prefer btech rather than mtech phd ..

well said sir! PhDs feel inferior to mtech or btech students when it comes to employment...great concern!

Sir, you are absolutely correct. Many students prefer to do Ph.D. from abroad than India, and there are many viewpoints on it. Most of the faculties at the Higher Institutions in India are incompetent. Also, one can save money if he/she is doing PhD abroad. There are not enough resources which are required for cutting-edge research. Getting a PDF(post-doctoral fellowship) is much easier if you have done PhD abroad and so on...

🙏You are donig a GREAT job sir ! Thanks !!

I support the good cause raised by vijendra sir. the academic fraternity needs to realise that they are failing in creating an environment which promotes research and development and in turn, is hindering the country's growth. I do not understand the logic in giving more weightage to mtech than phd in assessing a candidate for a prospective job role. i mean this is a very serious issue that the system is discouraging the students to pursue phd. no country who claims to be an upcoming global leader can reach where it wants to reach by doing what is being done here. i guess we dont want to dissociate our country from the tag of snake charmer. service sector is only one engine of our economy. for the indian economy rocket to take off, we need all of its engines fired simultaneously. more research creates more sectoral expertise and in turn create industries relying on those low cost home grown expertise. in short the quality of research directly relates to the standard of living of the country. because everything boils down whether it is affordable or not. media should take note of it and try to make sense out it and ask questions to relevant authorities.

The first reason is the stipend which students are getting during PHD The same issue you raised earlier. Another reason is the job opportunity especially in the private sector (R&D).

thanks sir for making this vedio before see your vedio i plain for direct phd for make career in teaching field but now i not go for direct phd and try for by mtech thanks for save my time and energy

It's a great concern especially for Direct PhD candidate

Salute 🙏 you sir to raising concern on direct phd holder students. I am also a victim of the same situation and struggling to get in a job after doing phd from IIT Guwahati. The waitage criteria ( 25 marks for mtech and 5 marks for phd) of marks almost kill our job opportunities and don't even got lecturer job in polytechnic college despite have PhD from IIT... Now i realise that direct phd from IIT is totally waste.

India me to according to aicte recruitment rule 2019 minimum criteria m tech hi hai.. Uske bad state level me written exam lene ka rule hai.. Koi v phd candidate, post doc krne wale easy me written exam nhi crack kr pate hai.. Bihar government engineering college me to 96 percentage m tech wale ka hi selection hua hai.. Now days 2024 chal rha hai.. Ab time aa gya hai.. Recruitment rule review and revised krne ka.. Indian government ke sath sath state government v higher qualification and research paper ka koi jayda point nhi de rha hai.. Ye sb matter pe aap log kv aicte ke chairman se question kriye.. And unka vision puchiye..

Mujhe lgta hai.. Your pedia team ko bihar government ke science and technology department ke director, sectary se interview lena chahiye.. Kyunki yha v m tech wale ko 10 percentage weight tha.. Aur phd ka 5 point weight tha.. Yha phd and research publication ka koi weight nhi tha.. Iss rule ke according phd and post doctoral wale ko v written exam qualified krna hoga uske bad interview dene ka mauka milega.. Phd and post docc.. Wale only 1_2 percentage hi written qualified kiye honge.. 96 percentage only m tech holder jisne gate, ies and psu ka prepared krta tha.. Uska selection hua hai... Aap se request hai.. Aap kv bihar dst ke director and sachiv se interview kr ke puchiye aisa selection se.. Bihar ka college kaise growth hoga.. Kya vision hai.. Jb m tech holder wale ka government assist professor me permanent job ho jata hai.. To yhi log part time phd nit patna me admission le rhe hai.. Full time koi admission lena nhi chah rha hai.. Issi recruitment rule se.. Upcoming research krne walo ke liye bihar science and technology department ye rule demotivate krne wala hai.. Isspe ho sake to aap bihar engineering university ke vice chancellor se v interview le sakte hai. Ki aapke university me m tech aur phd course ka kya vision hai.. Aapke pass PhD holder kitne faculties hai.. M tech course me padhane wala faculty m tech hai ya phd holder... ???

Sir, i myself joined in an Institute with gate score as a Jrf and i need to convert my jrf to sponsored phd program in that Institute. Sir, i don't have any intrest in doing phd. I just joined as a jrf so that can help me financially and sir what do now can i leave this after i get any other job. I have only completed btech ans directly joined in this programme aa few weeks before. Which now i feel aa very wrong decision Sir can you please tell me what do now should i quit now itself or wait until i get a good core job

I agree with you sir, we don't have good hpcs to simulate, 1 month wait karna padta hai permission ke liye. Sign karne wala nahi aya woh leave me hai, lab ka jo hai woh phd wale ka pass hai prof didn't allow me to use it 1 month gaya. Time waste 5 years acha naukri chodo pakore bhejoge tho bhi famous ho jaoge jyada paisa kamaloge. Sorry to say this but that's the reality.

Agree

Sir I am a sales engineer....leaving the job for phd is good...? It is worth doing phd from second generation IIT.

Don't demotivate students sir , aap chate kya ho

minimum criteria for the assistant professor should be PhD

Sir aaj he hostel m shift hua orr aapki ye video dekhli

Sir apki email ya telegram mil skta kuch guidance leni thi