What a perfect way for them to end the year, they’ve been so phenomenal all year, I’m so impressed by them! 2024 let’s go!!!

XGの新しい曲が出る度に あなた方のリアクションを本当に楽しみに待っていました。 XGに感動してくれて応援してくれることを本当に心から感謝します❤

お二人に、沢山の笑顔と希望と幸せが溢れる、素晴らしい日々が永遠と訪れますように😊

You ladies are easily some of my favorite reactors. You're always authentic and genuine with how you feel about the content you're reacting to and your audience appreciates that so much.

I'm not a big fan of Christmas songs and ballads, but I feel that this song is just too good, no matter what you like, how can you not enjoy this? Their voices, their rap, their musical maturity, the production... XG is truly unique.

I know ya'll have been going through some rough times so thank you for taking the time to get to this when you could. Seeing the raw emotion this song brought out of Esosa made it hit me in the feels again. From starting the year with Shooting Star/Left Right and ending it with Winter Without You. May you both have a warm Holidays. Reach out to friends, loved ones, family. Thank you again from ALPHAZ. We appreciate the support and love you show the girls.

悲しいことに両親といい関係を築けなかった私にとって、クリスマスやお正月といった"家族と笑い合う日"はいつもなんだか複雑な気持ちで過ごしていました。幸せな家族に対する憧れを完全に捨てることが出来ず、羨ましくて妬ましい、そう思ってしまう自分に嫌気がさす時期です。でも今年はXGとサイモンが素敵なクリスマスプレゼントをくれました。状況は人それぞれ違うと思いますが、クリスマスに悲しい感情を持つ全ての人にこの曲が寄り添ってくれると思います。

おかえりなさい💕 私も一緒に泣きました😢 最高のreactionありがとう。

I'm very aware that Chisa and Juria's vocal lines are excellent, but Maya's voice still amazes me. Rap skills, DANCE... so much talent, it's scary!😱💖

こうやってxgの歌声が人々の心に響いて届いていくって素敵だよ

The song is 100 out of 10! 🔥🔥💯🫶🏼❄️

私もあなた達のXGの動画を楽しみにしている1人です^_^ いつも同じ気持ちでリアクションしてくれて有難う❤これからもXGをずっと応援して下さい❤大好きです❤️

私も最初見た時に涙が出ました。😢❤ 本当に素晴らしい曲です。

I cried too. I MISSED MY FATHER AFTER LISTENING TO THIS. its like winter without him

Chisa Yelling - recreates a scene from Love Letter (1995) Japanese movie where characters husband is lost and never found in a snowstorm in the mountains. She goes there to yell out to him "How are you?". She replies to the echo. "I'm doing fine.", knowing the echo is the only response she will ever get. Girls crying - they surprise each of them with a video message from their family who they really have not seen for 5+ years during their training. This XG original song is a unique Christmas gift to us.

3か国語が飛び交ってる、すごい… XGに届けーーー！！！！

XGのリアクションとてもすきです❤ マヤちゃんの声で天国に行きました☺❤ I do love your reaction to XG❤ I was sent to heaven with Maya's voice☺❤

🥹🤍🎄❄️♾️🙏

Hinata really shined for me in this song, I love that we’re getting to see her show off her vocal talents.

I lost my dearest aunt on December 3rd, IT WAS AWFUL AND SO SAD, and I was being strong and not crying a lot, but XG released this song and all my walls fall down with me, it was something amazing that someone in another country could undestand me🥺 (sorry for my bad english)

早くあなたたちがXGに会えますように願っています！

お帰りなさい！ とても楽しみに待っていました🥰🥰あなた達のリアクションが本当に大好きです…！

Pure perfection, xg needs more recognition worldwide

お二人のリアクション大好きです🥰泣ける！泣ける！！泣ける！！！😊😂❤🎉🎄🎅🎁✨

I appreciate your heartfelt response to this song. It resonates with me emotionally too. XG possesses an irresistible charm and undeniable talent that's hard to articulate. Their docuseries deepened my connection with each member, drawing me into their individuality and stories. It's more than their music - it's their personal and professional saga that captures the heart. Usually, girl groups don't catch my attention, but XG is an Xtraordinary outlier. They even made me an Alphaz 😎. They exude a unique 'IT' factor. Being present at KCON LA and witnessing their dynamic presence and strong commitment firsthand was incredibly moving. Their talent is captivating, with each performance highlighting their dedication and passion. XG is more than a music group to me; they're a sensation. Observing their rise to fame is thrilling for any admirer. Their path to success seems natural, and being a part of their fan journey is a privilege. They are true artists, redefining the essence of musical passion. They deserve far greater recognition and popularity for their immense talent and allure. A global stage is fitting for them to display their remarkable skills.

They are the best girl group for me right now. They're really good. XG and you two girls You guys' reactions were very touching. It comes from the heart. Your smiles, feelings, facial expressions, words really come from the heart, ladies. I love you two.🥰

Any real, authentic, genuine Alphaz would know how well-crafted this music video is, and love it. Thank you both Ozlem and Esosa for your appreciation of this beautiful piece and your reactions. 👍💯🔥💕Hesonoo! 🐺♾️

お元気ですかー😢💖💖私はあなた達が大好き💝

Maya really surprised me with these insane vocals

リアクション待ってました！大好きです😊 ２人のXG愛が、メンバーに届きますように❤

This song is just immaculate Y2K R&B perfection. It's so incredibly rare to be able to say this unironically and be correct, but there really is nobody who does it like XG right now. Nobody else reps this sound nowadays like they do.

reaction動画待ってました🫶 今回も最高のreactionありがとう😭❤

This song makes me cry so much now, after it was released my 7 year old cat passed away, he was my baby my support my everything and I relate so much with this song now. It's so good.

i dont mean to be blunt but i just have to say the fact that this "perfect" song 10+/10 is getting zero radio play in the U.S. and its not charting on Billboard is an absolute travesty. Seriously. And it only has 3.8M views is insane to me. XG, Simon and XGALX created old skool R&B perfection with this song. How it isnt going viral or getting the recognition it so deserves really makes me frustrated and sad for XG. Every reaction ive seen, and there are 100s of them, this song just blows people away.

When the hook is so GOOD!!!! " WHEN PEOPLE PUTTING UP TREES AND LIGHT!!!! " That just hits hard. Knowing you grew up not knowing how Christmas was supposed to be after 30 years later. Parents didn't have much but we make due now we put up trees and lights that its affordable and everyone has a gift to open.

あなた達の素晴らしいリアクションを見て感情が揺さぶられました😢❤ いつもXGを応援してくれてありがとうございます🫶🫶

No one can do it like XG, at this point they're the modern queens of old school rnb.

Its crazy, cause their live performance on this one was even more better.

XG is like a time machine. will take us wherever she wants ♾️

I loved the song and Im glad that you guys liked it too! I hope you guys will check out the behind the scenes of the music video next. It contains some very wholesome footage of the group as well as a little emotional surprise. I think you guys would love to check it out!

reactionしてくれてありがとう🙏 是非,winter withoutyouのBehind the Scene も見てください。 XGのdad,momからのvideo Letterが観れます😭😭😭

Chisa be pulling those off and in reality she is one of the goofiest member in XG... she is everything ❤️🧎

I cried again watching this reaction 🥹❤️

Esosa and Ozlem are the epitome of what it means to be an ALPHAZ. I feel like you both encapsulate the very essence of what we ALPHAZ feel when we experience any XG content. I’d like to add something very important that not many people are talking about when it comes to this song. This time of the year you spend time with loved ones, but as Ozlem said it can also be the most lonely time of the year. Many people are missing someone, parted ways, or even lost a loved one. I myself suffered from a lose this year. But I believe the message our Xtraordinary Girls relay so perfectly is the warmth you find within their music, or in this case the music video shows they still have each other. They give us a sense of comfort within this music video because even they experience loss, hardship, and even loneliness at times. But still remind us there is still something or someone there for you to feel warmth in life. XG gave us a wonderful gift at the end of the year I love them so much. Thank you for always supporting XG, Esosa and Ozlem! Truly my fav reactors!

Don’t cry ~~~🥹🥹🥹 They did it again!!!! Their voices are so amazing♡ Let’s enjoy XG’s progress to the universe together 💟💟💟👽🌏🐺

XGは愛がいっぱい❤あなたたちの動画からも愛をたくさん感じます。ありがとう！心の中であなたたちを抱きしめてます❤

お二人の関係性も素敵で好きです⛄ 良い冬をすごしてください〜

私はXGもあなた達も愛してます🧬🙏💖🇯🇵から応援してます🔥🔥🔥

自分たちの曲を聴いて涙を流してくれる人がいる。XGちゃんたちどんなに嬉しいことか😢歌が寄り添ってくれる。素敵なことですね😭♡

This song is still on repeat for me. I even sleep listening to this song everynight. Something soothing and warm about this song. From the sound, lyrics and ofcourse how XG delivered the song. We used to celebrate Christmas before. I think the last time I've got to experience the joy of Christmas was 12-15 years ago. Life's been tough. And I know not just me but a lot of people all around the world. Through XG somehow I enjoy not just this season but the whole year.

貴女方のこの曲に対するリアクションをお待ちしておりました🎶 m(_ _)m そして… 素敵な涙をありがとうございます… ｡ﾟ(ﾟ´Д｀ﾟ)ﾟ｡｡ﾟ(ﾟ´Д｀ﾟ)ﾟ｡

XG made Esosa emotional again😭❤

もらい泣きしちゃった

すてきなリアクション、ありがとうございます！ つられて私も泣いてしまいました🥹 お二人と共にXGをサポートできて、とても幸せです❤ すてきなホリデーを過ごしましょうね😊

thank you🥰🥹❤🫶

XG is the definition of talent and gold discography

Perfect song to end the year. So stoked to see what 2024 has in store for XG 💜

They all made me cry but Chisa blew my mind!!! She looks so cute to as well!!! These girls are so under appreciated. When is the world gonna get to experience their beautiful voices!!!

XGのリアクション動画を色々観てますが、お二人のリアクションが1番好きです！

oh〜泣かないで😢 behindでは宇宙船のメッセージビデオのシーンが映っているよ。きっとその動画も見たら涙出ちゃうよ😂

it's hard to watch and listen to Winter Without You without crying if you also live away from family 😭

貰い泣きしちゃった😭‎🤍 PVみたらまじで泣けるよね

XG is the most versatile group in the music industry! Every song releases this year has been musically different! From Shooting Star, Left Right, Girl Gang, TGIF, New Dance, Puppet Show to Winter Without You. It takes groups years to master and accomplish something like this, but XG came in boss mode and destroyed it...and every song was a head bopper! Too me XG is that group! Alphaz 🐺

I hope they do a reaction to The First Take live version now. If they thought the studio track was perfection, the live vocals will make them faint. 😂

待ってました😂❤ 僕も号泣しながら聞きました！w behindを見てからだと余計泣けてしまうので家でしか聞けなくなってしまいました😂😂 これからも2人のリアクション動画楽しみにしています！！🥰 THE FIRST TAKEのリアクションもお願いします🙏🙏🙏

You are should watch XG the first take shooting star and winter without you XG really prove it they are can singing live with stable vocals

I am Japanese who love you guys reaction of XG. I think so many people cried after listen this song. Their voice is so clean, powerful and touch our heart.The VIBES… I don’t know how to explain.

XG never fails to impress me but they went far beyond impressing me with this I was so emotional by how good it is, every single one of the girls killed it and I’m so proud of them but maya actually made me cry when I first heard her part. I’m so proud of them

XG 🔥🔥🐺🎄 Best Christmas Song I've Ever Heard!!

Can we just all come together and agree that XG just doesn’t miss. They are extremely versatile and they know how to bring us excellent music in all flavors.

XGのTHE FIRST TAKEも出たのでリアクションお願いします！

お元気ですか❓ 私は元気です‼ Winter without You 最高なXmas🎅songです❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Thank you for the great reaction as always ladies. Once I saw my notification, I jumped out of my seat and watched right away. My kids and I haven't celebrated the holidays, especially Christmas since we lost the ROCK of our family. We lost her 3 years ago and everything is not the same anymore. After hearing this song, it lifted me up and somehow brought back the spirit. She loved Christmas, it was her favorite. Anyway, I just want to say Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to you ladies and your families. I'm so glad to have discovered you ladies this year and every time I see a reactions from you ladies, I feel connected. You guys actually helped a bit with my depression. Stay safe this coming holidays

I don't know how this group hasn't just blown up yet--it's legit crazy to me. They have released quality after quality and have not missed yet!

わー！2人のreactionずっと待ってたよ、🥲‎🤍

いつも いつも いつも どうもありがとう(ᴗ͈ˬᴗ͈)‪‪❤︎

私は2人のリアクションが大好きです🤍 いつも正直にリアクションしてくださりありがとうございます🤍🐺🪐 これからもXGを見守ってください🐺🤍

At the beginning Chisa is recreating a scene from a Japanese movie called Love Letter (1995). The woman in the movie loses her fiancé in a mountain climbing accident. She visits the mountain where he died, she points to the peak at sunrise. She shouts "How Are You?" and she replies "I Am Fine" knowing that she will only hear her own echo.

待ってました😭😭 わたしも泣いちゃいます😭😭

XG Just don't miss, this group does not disappoint, These ladies are superstars they're crazy talented I'm speechless. ❤❤❤

The XG girls and production team need to see this reaction. It would touch them as much as their music touch us.

why u make me cry like that esosa!? 😭😭😭

一緒にずっと素晴らしい時を過ごしましょう！あなたの涙は美しい あなたたちと出会えてよかった 最高のリアクターだよ🎉 毎日XGの曲聴いてますか？ 私は聴いてます！！いつかお会いしたい！XGを好きでいてくれてありがとう！私はあなたたちを全力で応援します

First Takeもチェックしてみてください！ 号泣しちゃいますよ😭😭😭

Every song they put out, Chisa and Maya reaffirm their Bias position ❤

The First Take version of this song is out. RIP Differently Alike. :)

First Take Winter without you is a must! Just when you think they couldn't get better.. This planets need XG's healing.🙂

Debut date: March 18th, 2022 彼女たち一人一人のスキルがとても高いのはもちろん、プロデュース力も唯一無二。どちらが欠けていても出来上がらないXG。デビューまもないのにここまで凄いと、今後どこまでいくのか楽しみしかない。

I CAN’T STOP PLAYING THIS SONG IT’S SO GOOD !!!

Thanks for the love❤XG

Happy Birthday! →o tan jou bi omedetou! →お誕生日おめでとう！😊

Best reaction ever, gracias por apoyar a XG

泣いちゃうのめっちゃわかる😭 素敵なリアクションありがとうございます❤

今までで一番好きなクリスマスソングはこれだな〜。

I mean I've already cried many times watching the MV, but when I saw you tear up, I got all choked up all over again😭

I was looking forward to your reactions 🥹 Thank you 🥹 And I cried with you 😭😭😭 I love you ❤️‍🔥♾️

I love your reactions🫶🫶　　　　　 📣📣XGeeeeeeeeeee🔥👽😭🔥

待ってました🎵 いつも、応援してます！

いつもXGのリアクションを楽しませて頂いています。ありがとうございます😊 日本人の私が見ると最後に出てくるイルミネーションツリーは桜(Cherry blossom)🌸に見えます。桜は大昔から日本人に1番愛されている木だと思います。

言葉は全然わかんないんですが、もらい泣きしました😭 何かを思い出したのかな…？ 良いリアクションをありがとう！！