ZEP - Minister will not make a. decision alone!

  Рет қаралды 7,658

Cde Ngqabutho Mabhena Talkshow

15 күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 133
@bhekinkosi2602
@bhekinkosi2602 15 күн бұрын
The minister will also consider the moods of the South African when its come to outsiders
@user-nx2zd3yj9l
@user-nx2zd3yj9l 15 күн бұрын
The way you not prepared to build and fight for your freedom in your country is embarasment in our country and our political parties we voted won't allow that knowing that South Africans are not working schools are full hospitals as well are full
@louisaringani3333
@louisaringani3333 15 күн бұрын
We are over populated. Even a general worker / domestic workers. Labour laws are also suppose to be INVOLVE. This was temporary. It was only ANC with zanu-pf. There are so many GNU parties who were in disagreement with this. Why only Zimbabweans & Lesotho 's. This SPECIAL NONSENSE SHOULD STOP. IS ILLEGAL & DISCRIMINATES OTHER FOREIGHNERS. WE ARE WATCHING HIM.
@kwenajohnnysepheka9744
@kwenajohnnysepheka9744 15 күн бұрын
Granting permanent residence would show other foreigners that its easy to bend south African law. Everyone will want dual citizenship here and also where they come from
@InkundlatheDATOS01
@InkundlatheDATOS01 15 күн бұрын
It's not bending.actually that's what the constitution of SA says.tgus why Aaron Motsoaledi always was told he is unconstitutional
@thabanindlovu2334
@thabanindlovu2334 14 күн бұрын
He will using his powers as a minister entitled on the constitution as Aaron did when Ngungubele announced that error from Aaron😂
@bence8642
@bence8642 15 күн бұрын
This is draining if I were Zimbabwean i would pack n go back home😅
@CuthbertGore
@CuthbertGore 13 күн бұрын
You said they were gonna go in June but now it's july and in 2939 they will still be in SA dominating and Wena you will be busy fighting them and still in poverty God works in mysterious ways Zimbabweans will have what God want them to have in Southern Africa
@MS-cq6dh
@MS-cq6dh 12 күн бұрын
Narcissists are exhausting in nature
@stanleytshwale1263
@stanleytshwale1263 15 күн бұрын
South Africa should follow example of Germany. Immigrants whether legal or illegal are destroying other countries. UK rejected Islamic visa because they are dangerous. Zimbabweans destroyed their country and now they want to do as they wish here. Mabhena please fix your president in Zimbabweans. Leave our government alone sir. May God bless South Africa more for showing merciless Zimbabweans mercy.
@siyabonganxumalo4574
@siyabonganxumalo4574 15 күн бұрын
So now you gonna at be the mercy of the same government you've been taking to courts and telling them they are incompetent, and they have spent millions of Rands in court battles with you, goodluck with that. Your ego and arrogance is coming back to bite you.
@dumontuliki855
@dumontuliki855 13 күн бұрын
Mabhena has never been part of any court action against the south African government infact he opposed it from my view unless if you have evidence to prove otherwise
@LorraineDememar
@LorraineDememar 14 күн бұрын
It is high time that you must go back to Zimbabwe and fix what belongs to you this country is for our children and future generations please
@user-nc4jp9xe1e
@user-nc4jp9xe1e 13 күн бұрын
How do zimbabweans contribute to the economy of South Africa
@MrChrisCJ
@MrChrisCJ 15 күн бұрын
1. He Said he wants to be satisfied that those on ZEP are actually contributing to the Economy 2. He said everything should be done according to the law 3. The outcomes of this might be worse than what the former Minister had proposed
@CuthbertGore
@CuthbertGore 13 күн бұрын
It will not be worse it's your brains playing with you because you always think negative
@JimmyMaphanga-xv5md
@JimmyMaphanga-xv5md 15 күн бұрын
Is going to be bad for people who taking our government to court.who practice law in our country because we are mumu
@bence8642
@bence8642 15 күн бұрын
Lets discuss Zimbabweans kidnapping SA Portuguese butchery owners
@MarlonNHex
@MarlonNHex 15 күн бұрын
Don't worry yourselves too much. Zimbabweans heed the call. They are tired of being the blame for your own incompetence. The truth of the matter is 90% of Zimbabweans in S.A are either planing to go back home, already establishing something or they are in the process of going to a second country, some European countries have opened their hands for them. Drivers, nurses, care givers, warehouse workers, cruise ship workers. They are leaving in large numbers. The only reason some are still around is because they are still looking for that opportunity. If you don't agree: ask your next Uber driver or maid. If you are a Zimbabwean and you are not thinking of leaving then you are a problem yourself.
@limpopoRiver
@limpopoRiver 12 күн бұрын
​@@MarlonNHexbye bye
@bettymokgobu688
@bettymokgobu688 15 күн бұрын
Mabahambe mabahambe makwerekwere
@brytonmasaire5542
@brytonmasaire5542 14 күн бұрын
Bayephi mntakwethu🤔
@bettymokgobu688
@bettymokgobu688 14 күн бұрын
@@brytonmasaire5542 makubo la ba vela khona or Zimbabwe gray area
@user-nx2zd3yj9l
@user-nx2zd3yj9l 15 күн бұрын
Mabhena the Zimbabweans are excited because they don't want to go build Zimbabwe to be like South Africa there is no way that the political parties won't allowed to give Zimbabweans domestic work,gardening and teaching yet there are South Africans who are not working
@domingosmakuntima1537
@domingosmakuntima1537 15 күн бұрын
Zimbo people's you became boring fighting in other country for permanent resident , when you can't fight your own government for better condition leaving, why you can't learn for young from Kenyan
@tigeletemateme521
@tigeletemateme521 14 күн бұрын
Thank you Mr Mabhena on your hard work and commitment to help your fellow citizens. I suggest that always mention to us that we should not forget to invest at home, like building our houses or homes. Thank you.
@mumsyzulu6775
@mumsyzulu6775 15 күн бұрын
In your dreams no permanent resident will be granted we as the country won't allow that rubbish
@CuthbertGore
@CuthbertGore 13 күн бұрын
You said that many years ago you even joined amadudula thinking it will work,well dololo you will die in poverty with your arrogance sdhidhi
@bhadisabookermashiga6083
@bhadisabookermashiga6083 14 күн бұрын
If u get it , we will do what is done by Kenyans??
@CuthbertGore
@CuthbertGore 13 күн бұрын
So what just do it jail's are open especially for you since the new government is with white people and white people don't play boy
@user-zl8gb3rb5l
@user-zl8gb3rb5l 14 күн бұрын
Minister of home affairs yes he did play or give hope to Zimbabweans he did that because he thought home affairs its going to run according to his will bt nop instead every Minister is run by the lows of the country of which that lows is drown and agree by the citizens of SA through lows,white paper, and other written documents not by Minister, what ur are telling Zimbabweans Mabhena is what ur heared the Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo communicated to say don't be confuse by any Minister who will came and say i will do this and this in SA we dont do as we wish different fro Zim.
@kckc121
@kckc121 15 күн бұрын
😂😂 Ulimenemene wena Comrade Mabhena. You and your constituency were here lambasting Motsoaledi as if the decision was his. You have never articulated the situation as you are right now. Nibona umlungu ngoku niyayicacisa. 😂. You are correct he will follow the same method as Motsoaledi. We will be waiting for all the court cases.
@EdsonBhasera
@EdsonBhasera 15 күн бұрын
This is very loud and clear comrade Mabhena. We have been subjected to many varied processes and procedures and some have been very expensive especially applying for actual work visa. May God have mercy on us.
@CosterSibanda-d5e
@CosterSibanda-d5e 15 күн бұрын
Absolutely correct Mr Mabhena,and we hear you clearly.
@owenmasukume6658
@owenmasukume6658 14 күн бұрын
Thanks comrade Mabhena for clarifying some of these indistinct issues.We also thank the South African government for having kept us this far.We hope that one day things will be okay in Zim as they were in the early to the late 2000s until the Zim gvt started their chaotic land reform which collapsed the economy
@user-tc1hy4oj1j
@user-tc1hy4oj1j 15 күн бұрын
Mara wa bora wena madala u think ur so clever an u think u know SAfrican politics whereas Zimbabweans a all over our country u count even fix yo kwerekwere country fotsek leave our country alone julle moet almal fotsek ons is gatvol ke lona I'm sure u all dream of being South Africans makwerekwere ke lona. On the other hand South Africans a struggling bcoz of u. This time u get away with this nonsensical of yours.
@briandube442
@briandube442 15 күн бұрын
Well said and articulated Cde Ngqabutho Mabhena👏.It's the collective decision of the cabinet etc
@user-gq7id7vn4h
@user-gq7id7vn4h 15 күн бұрын
You keep changing scenarios to fit your situation but you don't make consideration to go to Zim if things don't go your way my advice is start planning now....
@user-zl8gb3rb5l
@user-zl8gb3rb5l 14 күн бұрын
Im exposing Mabhena cos always he portray himself as a person who know Palarment issues of SA before the issues of SA is communicatied to th SA citizens, Mabhena heard everything from news wen Minister Khumbudzo communicating with SA citizens its not that Mabhena is told before nothing like that.
@sibonakalisompofu6106
@sibonakalisompofu6106 15 күн бұрын
Well understood, thank you for the clarification Mntungwa.
@user-nx2zd3yj9l
@user-nx2zd3yj9l 15 күн бұрын
The way you not prepared to build and fight for your country your country are embarasment zimbos
@freddiefazbear3106
@freddiefazbear3106 14 күн бұрын
Mr Mabhena go to the minister in the president's office ,she said disagreements will not stop changes within the cabinet
@reviewdlamini8784
@reviewdlamini8784 15 күн бұрын
Well articulated Mr Mabhena. Siyabonga.
@nomsandlovu1107
@nomsandlovu1107 15 күн бұрын
Thanks u for the explanation
@CosterSibanda-d5e
@CosterSibanda-d5e 15 күн бұрын
Absolutely correct Mr Mabhena and we understand you clearly.
@johnnyamande3354
@johnnyamande3354 15 күн бұрын
Thank you Mr
@siphiwengwenya1606
@siphiwengwenya1606 14 күн бұрын
Evening Mabhena. Myself l don't mind what they can give to me as long l am going to be Legal in the country.whar l don't want is to stay in fear running away from police .At my age to be being illegal in the country it is embarrassing
@blessedboora3372
@blessedboora3372 15 күн бұрын
Thanks so much cde it's clear
@nkosiyazindlovu7835
@nkosiyazindlovu7835 15 күн бұрын
We are in a foreign country. We are at the mercy of the politicians. BUT LET THE PROCESS BE FAIR AND RATIONAL AND CONSTITUTIONAL.
@thabangtladi8057
@thabangtladi8057 15 күн бұрын
you want them to be fair for who in who's country?
@phemelomogatusi8495
@phemelomogatusi8495 15 күн бұрын
​@@thabangtladi8057whereas their own government is unfair to them.
@siyabonganxumalo4574
@siyabonganxumalo4574 15 күн бұрын
We have spent millions of Rands fighting court battles with you and now you want us to take you into our country?
@jonathan8084-y1s
@jonathan8084-y1s 15 күн бұрын
It's very true Mr Mabhena,It's not that clear cut,only time will tell.
@MultiTaffie
@MultiTaffie 15 күн бұрын
That is true Sir. They are are going to decide based on the parties they represent. Some South Africans do not understand why Zimbabweans on ZEP are fighting to stay in SA when they can build Zim instead. That is true and right but on the other hand the fact that ZEP holders have over 12 years living in SA with no criminal record and working fairly warrants for permanent residence to be considered. I pray the cabinet considers it.
@WNdaba
@WNdaba 15 күн бұрын
But it was clear that ZEP doesn't lead to PR no matter how many years you have stayed in SA. Why bend the rules when it suits you. Why should PR be issues to domestic workers and drivers and former fraudster. Remember most ZEP holders are former fraudsters
@prano550
@prano550 15 күн бұрын
those permits were favors and they clearly state that these permits can't be changed ,for PR, and citizenship zimbos are people not to be helped again 🚮
@noreenm5018
@noreenm5018 15 күн бұрын
@MultiTaffie. Are you trying to say, SA must give permanent residence to all foreign nationals that has lived in the country for more than 12 years without criminal record? Unfortunately SA doesn't have such policy. Does Zimbabwe have such policy? ** Remember only Zimbabweans where given "EP" status, there are more countries and their expiration dates are coming.
@MultiTaffie
@MultiTaffie 15 күн бұрын
@@noreenm5018 Yes, SA already has such a law in place, along with Zim, the UK and the US. Its the naturalisation policy whereby foreigners can become citizens if they have stayed a certain number of years in the country. In Zimbabwe you need only 10 years. In America its 5yrs and 3yrs if you marry/get married to a US citizen. In the UK, it might be 5yrs, i stand to be corrected but I know there are many Zimbabweans and even South Africans who are now British citizen. I pray you dont respond to argue but rather do research. Actually if a foreigner is from the commonwealth, they only need to have stayed only 2 years to get British citizenship. Africa we are fueled by hatred hence the reason why most people have no idea that people can become citizens by naturalisation or by birth in some countries. We make it hard for each other. Kudos to Namibia for putting visas for European countries but removed for SADC.
@WNdaba
@WNdaba 15 күн бұрын
@@MultiTaffie I will reiterate again that ZEP came with a clause that the actual permit is not a pathway to citizenship. Did you research since you know everything and every country's laws
@xahumbayuzaxahumba4366
@xahumbayuzaxahumba4366 15 күн бұрын
Like mina im rejection every about you foreigners
@godfreyncube929
@godfreyncube929 14 күн бұрын
Dankie Mabhena , smtmz omkhaya si dooom bacabanga kuba minister wenza desicions yedwa
@bernardsayi4256
@bernardsayi4256 15 күн бұрын
Well explained Mabhena.
@MduMpofu023
@MduMpofu023 15 күн бұрын
Obvious Cde Mabhena we are excited that Aaron is now longer the Home Affairs Minister for a change. Whether it's the cabinet that makes a decision is another story.
@bonifaccematiza7087
@bonifaccematiza7087 15 күн бұрын
Maybe Aaron was better how do you know?
@xahumbayuzaxahumba4366
@xahumbayuzaxahumba4366 15 күн бұрын
​@@bonifaccematiza7087he was better
@blessedblessed3474
@blessedblessed3474 15 күн бұрын
He is back in the ministry of health and you going to see woto woto. Watch the space.
@tumiledimo2248
@tumiledimo2248 15 күн бұрын
I voted for the ANC coz of Dr Motsoaledi I now regret it voting was a waste of time
@blessedblessed3474
@blessedblessed3474 15 күн бұрын
@@tumiledimo2248 a sign God is telling you not to hate your other African race. One thing people must know is, SA is not an Ireland that lives on its own it's a country in an African countries and it's an African country just like other African countries, it will never survive on its own. It needs other countries as well. This thing of foreigners people you just wasting your time no leader will ever do as people think even if he wants to it will forever be a back and forth without clear response to questions about the so called African foreigners . Those praying a wrong prayer for Zimbos just better relax otherwise you will send yourself to an early grave. You will be shocked by the decision that will be taken by the cabinet , watch the space. Better find something profitable better and healthy to talk about than this issue of Zimbabweans it's just increasing the blood pressure, which is detrimental to your healthy, after all we are all poor suffering black people, who are on their own, maybe we staying in a mukhukhu without proper sanitation, then we hate on another poor black person who is also in the same position as you are. What will you gain by hating a fellow poor black person who is working as a maid and gardener, there are better things to do than this, things more profitable Choose to stay healthy, that's it.
@patiencemapungwana7273
@patiencemapungwana7273 15 күн бұрын
Well said
@PatriciaNkosi-lo9iq
@PatriciaNkosi-lo9iq 15 күн бұрын
The cabinet and the paliment took the decision to terminate the zep the new minister has to implement the court recommendations by consulting the zep holders thereafter proceeds with termination of this permit the ex minister advised the zep holders to apply for other visas and permits no new proposals will be entertained
@greatafricanone
@greatafricanone 15 күн бұрын
but where does Parliament come in as it was a cabinet decision only?? When has cabinet all of a sudden became Parliament
@Thokozani1787
@Thokozani1787 14 күн бұрын
Actually Zimbos should be excited for the termination of ZEP so they can apply for other Visas but no they want to be given PR based on ZEP of which will not happen.
@kennethmoyo2391
@kennethmoyo2391 9 күн бұрын
Well clarified my Cmd
@memorymoyo1183
@memorymoyo1183 13 күн бұрын
Thank you Sir
@DavidWhitey21
@DavidWhitey21 11 күн бұрын
Good day Mr Mabhena.I lost my passport with my ZEP. What can I do to get something which confirms that I have valid status in SA until 2025? Is it wise to apply for a new ZEP to put in my passport? I have already applied for a waiver.If I apply for a new exemption permit will I be barred from applying for a general work permit.please help.
@MercyMushininga
@MercyMushininga 15 күн бұрын
Is there a way l cannot communicate with you sir but not publicly its abt zep
@loycemukandi5447
@loycemukandi5447 14 күн бұрын
Thanks Mr Mabhena but I apply my waiver March 2023 until now how long can it take
@nathanielncube7593
@nathanielncube7593 15 күн бұрын
Very true my brother
@richmutsena9709
@richmutsena9709 15 күн бұрын
Thank u
@MthandazoNgwenya-ut3yh
@MthandazoNgwenya-ut3yh 15 күн бұрын
Clearly Less continue praying that any decisions they make should be in favor of us
@prano550
@prano550 15 күн бұрын
go fix your country busy praying for favors from a foreign government that has it's own people to look after ,what nonsense is this.
@thabangtladi8057
@thabangtladi8057 15 күн бұрын
you are praying for wrong things in a wrong country
@user-di9vz2xl6x
@user-di9vz2xl6x 15 күн бұрын
😂😂 Shame.
@whitewitch2511
@whitewitch2511 15 күн бұрын
Sad case of being an international orphan. Go and fight for your rights in Zimbabwe
@WitneyMokatse-ng6ok
@WitneyMokatse-ng6ok 15 күн бұрын
Zimbabwes have no shame and don't put your hopes high citizens have made clear in the white paper how to handle this immigration chaos
@Letstalk747
@Letstalk747 15 күн бұрын
This issue is a difficult one. Let us remember that there are people who are now waiting for the outcomes of their waivers and ZEP applications.Others have recieved their outcomes and are already moving on as usual. All those things must be taken into account in order to reach a sound, fair and justifiable decision
@nokuthulaxaba698
@nokuthulaxaba698 15 күн бұрын
Stop deceiving yourself ZEPs are valid till 2025 November get this into your thick skull
@user-sd1ii2zu8v
@user-sd1ii2zu8v 14 күн бұрын
Well understood
@siphiwengwenya1606
@siphiwengwenya1606 14 күн бұрын
We were given DZP cause we don't qualify cause we don't critical skills. It is clear that the only solution to give us PR.cause it is the only solution if they are willing. After 2025 the number of illegal people will increase coz l don't see my self going back to Zimbabwe after 23 yrs.Here it has become my home that l know
@Thokozani1787
@Thokozani1787 14 күн бұрын
ZEP permits do not entitle holders to apply for permanent residence, irrespective of the period of stay in South Africa’,
@bettymokgobu688
@bettymokgobu688 12 күн бұрын
Don't worry we are going to toil toil for him to be removed, he's lying to you wait and see how solve our problem, we are not running away like you, there's no review go home
@arnoldmanyengawana879
@arnoldmanyengawana879 15 күн бұрын
Well explained thanks Mr Mabhena 🙏
@user-zl8gb3rb5l
@user-zl8gb3rb5l 14 күн бұрын
Mabhena is not lahutla bt is lehutla
@collenelvis7121
@collenelvis7121 15 күн бұрын
I need help brother I have zep but I want to apply for the one can expy 2025, November, please help
@ThomasTadesse-xw7ql
@ThomasTadesse-xw7ql 14 күн бұрын
How are you 0:39
@washingtondzikiti6668
@washingtondzikiti6668 15 күн бұрын
True that
@user-di9vz2xl6x
@user-di9vz2xl6x 15 күн бұрын
True
@weziweandrade6261
@weziweandrade6261 15 күн бұрын
Yes zep holders and Lesotho’s will be given permanent residence. Their kids, spouses and also their relatives will be included. When it comes to all foreigners who have been here in South Africa more than 5 years whether legal or illegal will also be given permanent residence including their kids, spouses and all their relatives. No one will be left behind.
@laurencemakgabo1766
@laurencemakgabo1766 15 күн бұрын
😂😂😂😂
@jabulanisithole9608
@jabulanisithole9608 15 күн бұрын
you are dreaming
@napogadisheli5862
@napogadisheli5862 15 күн бұрын
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂kill me again
@nokuthulaxaba698
@nokuthulaxaba698 15 күн бұрын
Wena that is your wish list
@whitewitch2511
@whitewitch2511 15 күн бұрын
The zimbo madness😂 showing its self. Our parents fought hard for this country no1 will be granted permanent residency based on temporary initiatives by the SA government. Be a good citizen in Zimbabwe 😊
100❤️
00:19
MY💝No War🤝
Рет қаралды 23 МЛН