Both bands are awesome

best version of Radio is Alkaline Trio

NOFX plays Rancid songs better than Rancid, and Rancid plays NOFX songs better than NOFX.... That split album is 100% SOLID GOLD.

They’re both great but I gotta go with the original

Funny, You don't belong may well be my least favorite on that record 😂

All AFI albums are great 🖤🔥🔥🔥

The Rancid/NOFX album was genius and is punk rock gold!!!! There is no right answer.

1:51 Suffer came out in 198, not nt 1998.

The only punk girl at the time that you believed was actually punk!? Damn were you missing out! I grew up on babes in Toyland, L7, lunachicks, bikini kill, 7 year bitch, the Gits there were so many I thought far surpassed the distillers

More bs

AFI 🔥🔥🔥🔥

I love Nofx doing Ska. Its just so much fun, however Let's Go by Rancid is a super kickass album

NOFX

YES. thats my answer.

Both are brill bc of the difference in punk & ska, which makes it unique in each iteration.

The Decline truly is a 30-minute masterpiece. Incredible that they managed to condense 30 minutes of music into a single 18-minute track. Anyway, Herojuana and Bottles to the Ground are the true standouts on Pump Up the Valuum.

Facts! 🎉

Nofx

Pump up the Valuum June 13, 2000

Well, it wasn’t NoFx

I love both but rancid for sure. NOFX is fucking great too though

I don't know much about the Distillers, but I did see them open for Garbage and No Doubt around 2002 or 2003 in Denver. Distillers handed out a promotional DVD with 2 videos which I still have. They performed well but of course Garbage and No Doubt were incredible. I feel lucky to have been front row at that show!!!

NOFX had more layers to it, loved the split album

The Rancid cover of Bob led to me listening to the NOFX cover of Radio. I'm going with Rancid on this.

Blue Skies and this album, End Is Forever, are the great moment from Ataris miss this time, melodic hardcore totally from End Is Forever, my fav song is IOU!! regards from Brazil

NOFX , rancid is kind of a joke

Few people in the scene can stand Fat Mike. He is a toxic drama queen always talking bs about the others. It is normal that Blink and many other bands try to stay away from him

I'm pretty new to Descendants, i always heard about how legendary "Milo Goes To College" was as an album so that kinda made me hesitant to listen to them for fear of not getting it or thinking it was over hyped. it wasn't, it's an amazing album that deserves all the praise it has gotten. as for my song choice of theirs it would be Myage, I'm Not A Loser, or most probably Good Good Things.

Feels like NOFX did exactly what Rancid might've done. Not better/ worse, but I can hear that both these bands could've done it either way

Greatest band of all times and yes They invented pop punk …period

Listening to the debut, it's clear Lars joining the band was the best thing that ever happened to them.

I like NOFX better but rancid is the creators so credit to RANCID sorry El Heffe you know I love you guys 🤘🏼

You roll in that video what I realized in so many years. It's so obvious. But well . I got old. And I cry Tony every now and then.

Rancid, but both are great.

Mine is Hope

What tittle in a 1st song sir?

Rancid

This split album is fucking brilliant

Rancid of course, but really we’re all the winners here for having 2 great versions.

The Art of Drowning is AFI's magnum opus, HOWEVER... DECEMBERUNDERGROUND was a good album.

For me, it would be Days of Blood off Enjoy, that song is excellent

Mine is “I’m not a loser”

Rancid mil veces mejor

Punk by definition isn't mainstream.

I love NOFX but this song is hands down Rancid

Awesome channel! What would it take for you to review my bands album?

I like the Aqua version

Remember when afi use to be punk

great choice. i think id go with Coolidge or Hope

I Like i faster, so Rancid.