Honestly this feels like a perfect ending. Maybe it was the music at the end making me think that, but everyone gets into the island because [REDACTED FOR SPOILERS] won it. Considering BFDIA continued after Ep. 6 after Announcer stopped funding it, who knows, maybe there will be a part 2 to this. And even better, Leafy wouldn't have been vilified and could actually join Season 2. But who knows. Its just speculation.

DD = Donut (is) Dead

Yay!!!

3:30 this proof is that the number 13 is unlucky, as tennis ball was eliminated with exactly 13 points.

Whose out (Donut is fucked)

Blocky: “But I’m the STAR of the show!”

Day 2 of asking for shorter videos 🙏

This is just an interesting idea for an object show in general

A final 5 full of the aggressive players and Leafy? Sign me up dawg.

As both a pin and a premiere watcher, i can't wait to see what happens!

Weird thing at the end there butter. You sure that wasnt an error?

Niceee

Like this comment to avoid spoilers

Eraser would be in the danger zone other than bubble but that wouldn’t have changed anything from the elimination because I think eraser would have used his win token

A bfdia continuation of this would be really cool because Snowball and Blocky would surely get in.

As for the tiebreaker, i think since the cliff jump tiebreaker never happens, it would happen in the final 6 vote. Not that it would change anything, since Firey's afraid of heights...

Banana (chain) [idk why but this was my first thought]

Snowball and Blocky making final 3 is a fever dream…

I have cool idea for this channel What if there was never a rule 4 in bfdia which allowed switching teams

THIS WAS SO FAST

How this man can do long videos without a break?

I NO JOKE TRIED THIS YESTERDAY BRO YES

i DO think eraser wouldve used the win token the second time around, AND match would've gone out sooner, but all in all great video also W SNOWBALL YIPPEEEEE

The match and pencil glazing is kinda crazy, how does she survive over spongy when pencil lost to spongy

YES, FINALLY, SNOWBALL DOES DECENTLY IN A WHAT IF! 15TH TO 3RD!

Pencil not getting the win tokens for winning like 4 challenges in merge is crazy(marbles, barf bag, frisbee, and staring)

33:55 Flower is probably selvish enough in season 1 to try to steal dream island for herself

21:08 I actually think Leafy could be eliminated here. Considering Firey is in the alliance, alliance fans would likely dogpile onto Leafy. Maybe not as much as they would to other characters, given that Leafy is pretty nice, but I think it'd be barely enough for Match's win token to beat, and Leafy would be eliminated. Also, Bubble didn't fall the most ranks. It was Rocky, who dropped 9 ranks from 6th to 15th.

You should make a part two for BFDIA with all 20 most voted newbies (plus gelatin) in the game. And let your viewers vote for the 22nd contestant two!

snowbill

W sb

IM FROM THEE PREMIERE

It seems this is my most controversial What If to date Also, I was NOT biased for Snowball. Snowball in season one was one of my least favorite characters. I just wrote stuff and he happened to stumble into the finale

Damn. Good games. I'm honestly surprised Snowball got as far as he did, it really goes to show how much he got screwed over in his initial elimination and just how well he can do in the points phase, plus him being in the finale was a nice change of pace. Blocky had a great game too, and him making it to the finale with SB was amazing. Rocky and TB being the first merge boots is kinda sad, but hey they've had great runs in the past and Tennis Ball has already won three of these.

Leafy was an underdog this entire what if.🎉🎉🎉

Fun fact: if leafy were to win, BFDIA wouldn't exist because leafy wouldnt buy the island, IDFB wouldn't exist because BFDIA wouldn't either, BFB wouldn't exist because they wouldn't be on the island in the first place, and TPOT wouldn't exist because the split would never happen.