This song is heartbreaking but at the same time I have never once heard her say her ex husband is a bad Father to their kids . So yes, it’s sad that they’re divorced and went through a bitter a through battle.- Both can still be good parents, regardless

Did Kelly write this I can see pain in her face heartbroken well done gw yh rough this song

I relate to this song

God your vocals were good kelly with this song brought tear to my eye you can feel your pain took guts and courage to sing this well done to you

Is Kelly the author of this song?

My dad kept me and my disabled brother when I was 7 months and he was 2. I didn't see him again until I was 9 years old. He had gotten married to the woman that broke up my mom and dad's marriage and they had 2 kids. He didn't come to my high school graduation or my military graduation bit He was there for his other 2 kids in everything they did. I played sports and he never came to any of my games. He wasn't there for me when I had to go through chemotherapy for breast cancer, my motorcycle wreck that I almost died. My car wreck in 2021where I had to have shoulder surgery from it and 6 months rehab. I had a bad fall and ended up with a tbi and he wasn't there. He hadn't rung my phone in 3 years. I'm ill from lupus and he doesn't care. I was in the hospital last June with Covid, double pneumonia, fluid on my lungs, etc. I about died then because when they found me, my O2 level was 78. I try and make our relationship work but he just doesn't seem interested. I'm fixing to be 54 on the 22nd and I'm pretty much giving up on him. The hurt is still there and as long as I try and make it work, I get shot down. Maybe he'll realize what ges missing but I doubt it. Some men aren't meant to be fathers. 😢

Yeah... Im sorry.... but I hate this. Piece by piece we have all been turned into marshmallow. Before you judge my response, you know nothing about me. And I plan on keeping it that way. We need to stop applauding this emotional crap. Look at her at the end, she thoroughly enjoyed it. All the while everyone was sad and depressed. Enough is enough. Grow up people. Life is hard.

She’s an amazing woman and a beautiful voice 🌹💖🎵🎶

😢 Hat's off to Kieth Urban show the heart of a Man 💟

She really screwed up the piano player. Very inconsiderate

I need My Buddy To READ. For Me At Libra...!!!Bye for now!!!!

All Can't Top That???maybe JESUS !!!!!!!!❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉😮😮😮😅😅😅😅😅😊😊😊😊😂😂😂😂I'm Balling!!!!!! Stuck my Pencil Almost in Mys Eyes while crying over the DEATH of my COOKIE !!!❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉

You Go Go Classics Clarkson

This is what music is all about 😢🙌🙌

I cannot see what makes her special. Voice is not that great.

I LOVE this woman, she has earnt every single success, not a dry eye in the house

❤🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈🇱🇷💕⚘⚘⚘⚘ it doesn't matter if you're gay or lesbian and bisexual and gender hate crime out there there's not enough love love is very powerful and Hate show a stranger how much you love them and how much you care love one another be kind to one another secrets in did you be kind to one another and respect for one another give each other boundaries positive and focuses on the positive things in life foxes on positive not negative when you have a friend it's very toxic lights drama in kidnap people and also not tell the truth do not hang out with that friend at all because that friends up to no good very toxic love is very powerful and Hate that's why we all need is love show each other the kindness and love in Rohnert Park California show another guy you love them a guy shot a guy bring Summit joint in their hearts we need everybody need to come together and I'll pay eclipse in Rohnert Park California Sarah gay and lesbian and bisexual by Ginger give me all the time and celebrate the love we need another Secret in Rohnert Park we we need secrets in Rohnert Park California like they do in Santa Rosa Avenue the weather in Santa Rosa Avenue is really sensible in all kinds of wonderful men go there thank you for your passion and your love❤❤❤ thank you for your support and first secrets Santa Rosa Avenue❤❤❤❤ Santa Rosa and Santa Rosa Avenue Santa Rosa California the name of the person that is secret for men❤❤❤❤

😓

Kelly is awesome.

Seriously now the point here is if the piano player is the best ever or not? y'all who wrote shit about that you need to grow up, Jessssssus get a life.

She's a Phoenix

Damn son 🥺

This has got to be my favorite song of her's. Because I can relate so much to it and feel it deep in my soul. What kills me is that like her father her husband didn't deserve her either.

The best storyteller through music without indulgence. Which is why she is the original Idol, the best Idol, the most original Idol. I love Carrie Underwood, but I’m sorry Kelly Clarkson takes it to the finish.

I can't count the times I've watched Kelly sing this song. When I see Keith's face of raw feelings it shows what he is made of. What a big heart he has. And Kelly is undescribable while she gets through this masterpiece. She lays her heart out on that stage. We love you Kelly.

I Never Knew My Father 💔❤️‍🩹😥 God Bless You Kelly Clarkson 🙏🏼♥️🙏🏼 I Needed This 🎶♥️🌹 So Many of Us Abandoned Need This Beautiful Song 🥰♥️ I Love You Kelly Clarkson ♥️🌹 Forever Now 🙏🏼🌹♥️ I’ve Been Married 23 Years And I’m Doing It Right Despite What Happened 🙏🏼 My Family Is Blessed 😇 ♥️🥰🙏🏼

My God that gave me goosies So emotional. W o W. . Great Great performance Kelly

Kelly clarkson keith urban

She has such a beautiful, powerful voice just like the rest of her!

Beautiful song from a beautiful lady, only up from here, your ex’s loss…

Keith if rich entitled people with so much support can tear you up then us poor not entitled people with zero money or support should make you sob. 🙄

Omg if she is so fat with all her money and fame what hope does struggling poor hardworking me have?

Kelly best song..❤

A very rare catching lightening in a bottle moment. In this type of show which is usually so chock full of fake manipulation - the rawness of this performance is astonishing.

Damn! Kelly is a powerhouse! Like another commentor said, it's a shame her husband gave her that gift then divorced her after this beautiful song! Hopefully he's still a present dad at least.

She was super obese here.

Gosh, I wish Kelly would take on the opening of the judge on Idol.

A lit of pain in that performance.

This one didn't age so well. Great performance tho, love Kelly always <3

this song didnt age well😬

Kelly you look amazing these days!

This is not Kelly Clarkson 😬

I have found that most men use the fact that a woman didn't have a father against her.

Shes so beautiful inside and out!! Love her!! ❤ this song moved me to tears!

You're amazing Kelly 💖

I love her voice. She is so talented. Glad she kicked the ex to the curb. Hopefully he's still in his kids lives and didn't walk away like her Dad did

Beautiful Kelly!

Thank u candy. Beautiful

Her Ex is the best extra weight she's ever lost!! So proud of this beautiful human! Keep on moving forward baby!

Need fathers in homes.