Thank you for your detailed exterior comparison. We have a 2016 Aliner Scout. It’s a stripped down version because that’s what we wanted. It fits our needs, the AC is still working, and virtually no problems in the 8 years we’ve had it. We like to set it up as a base camp in an area of interest. We have a Clam shelter that works like an outside kitchen, that has been a game changer for inclimate weather so we aren’t trapped inside the Aliner. I can’t really imagine moving across the country in our Aliner and having to set up and take down everyday. Your review challenged my perception on the Rockwood as a heavier, and therefore sturdier, camper. Thank you again.
@capturereeladventure16 күн бұрын
Thank you for your comment. I also have the clam shelter and agree it’s very handy. Keep that Aliner! Cheers.
@jasonwooden18 күн бұрын
I was filling the fresh water tank on my Palomino A-frame and it fell out! The anti-rotation bolts weren't installed on the hangers, and there aren't any safety straps. Tons of other issues too. I've owned over 20 RVs over the years and never had one I liked. They are all junk. I recently built a Wedge Camper for my truck and am quite happy with it. Looking forward to a van build in the future. Thanks for confirming my bias.
@capturereeladventure16 күн бұрын
Thanks for commenting. The good ones are few and far between. Too bad less expensive has to always mean not just less quality but also far less reliability. Even the low end models still cost too much for the life they have in them before costly repairs start kicking in.
@lefty546319 күн бұрын
I just traded my 1991 Mazda mx-5 for a 1998 Aline July 16,2024. Yeah! I can't wait to get started making it to fit me. I heard all the stories on KZfaq about leaks and cracks. I have a plan to fix all that. There's so many fixer upper repair stuff you can buy these days.
@capturereeladventure18 күн бұрын
Good luck! You picked the right brand that’s for sure.
@donklaing20 күн бұрын
After watching and reading all these damage stories I've decided to rent a trailer when the urge gets me.
@capturereeladventure20 күн бұрын
Good idea. The cost of owning and maintaining a trailer is hard to justify if you only use it a few times a year as most do. This is especially true on new trailer purchases and the fast depreciation they go through. When you factor in total cost of ownership after a trailer is sold and you divide that by how many times it’s been used, the daily cost of using that trailer is shockingly high in many cases. If you only plan on going out a handful of times a year then renting is by far the better option.
@Brough111122 күн бұрын
There is nothing😢 like the safty of a hard sided camper when a 1200 grizzly is sniffing your door knob 😅
@capturereeladventure22 күн бұрын
I had a black bear and her two cubs sniffing around one night on a remote lake in northwest British Columbia. They could break in easy enough as the aframe campers are just over an inch thick compared to a larger travel trailer. Makes for good stories though. 😵💫👍.
@SergioRodriguez-wh5lk28 күн бұрын
Did you end up removing the storage boxes that are under the seats?
@capturereeladventure28 күн бұрын
I kept the storage boxes as this isn’t permanent for me. Putting the seats back in soon.
@randiescott29 күн бұрын
What a great idea.
@capturereeladventure29 күн бұрын
Thanks!👍
@rdsmith4982Ай бұрын
Great tour thanks!
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
😁👍
@GavinSwickАй бұрын
It's unfortunate that QC/build quality seems to be such an issue with these models, the newer A213 model is one my wife and I have our sights set on because of its sleeping arrangement not being offered in the higher quality A-Liner brand (dual twins that can convert into a large king). While these Rockwood/Flagstaff models are clearly a much lower-tier in quality to A-Liner, they are also substantially lower in price (in the $15k/40% cheaper range for comparable models). Do you think a proactive initial investment in some of these remedies from the outset might have changed your opinion of the camper? If I "save" $15k on the Rockwood model, but also make a ~$2k additional investment in fixing most of these weak points before they become problems, do you think it becomes a worthwhile product at that point?
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
You bring up an interesting point. Whether you make additional proactive improvements I would machine that it depends on where and how often you plan on taking your trailer out. I’m no expert on these units, I’ve only been able to share my experiences. The many other comments on this video clearly shows it is a lesser build quality than the Aliner, hence the increase in price. I suggest posting the same question to the various Aframe Facebook groups. This is where I believe you’ll get much more insight into whether your suggestion may be the right way to go. Good luck with your purchase. I hope the trailer serves you well. Thanks also for the comment. It’s really appreciated. 👍
@Crfreak757Ай бұрын
I have one of these campers it's a 2015 Forest River A122 I love it I take care of mine and keep it covered when not in use - the windows on yours are really jerry-rigged! Someone has run self tapping screws through the windows into the camper that's not factory no wonder it leaks - The lift support looks bad/stuck thats why it ripped out the side you can see all the corrosion on it + it's not fully extended - The hinge is just a big piano hinge that's such a easy fix don't keep cutting it as it comes out - also the door seals are not factory
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
I clearly bought the wrong unit. Glad I sold it. Hope yours continues to give you years of enjoyment. Thanks for the comment!
@donklaingАй бұрын
Novus is used in aerospace.
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
Good to know. Thanks!
@bigdogkroppАй бұрын
P.O.S. - this thing is gonna be fully depreciated after about 8 years.
@donklaingАй бұрын
I love the "A: frame concept. What you've pointed out makes me question this brands quality and integrity.
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
I thought it was the best option for me at the time. Rockwood Aframe campers are the worst in the industry according to so many comments on this channel. And I agree given my experiences.
@donklaingАй бұрын
Thermostat works the stove too?
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
Thermostat works both the heat pump and furnace. Cheap touch sensitive controls makes this a guaranteed failure point early on.
@ProdigiousReturnАй бұрын
Did you ever make a video comparing the inside?
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
I only had about a minute inside the Aliner and unfortunately didn’t get a video of it. Adding more trailer comparisons this year as the opportunities arise. Cheers.
@ProdigiousReturnАй бұрын
Did you look in to trail manor ? They seem like they would have been a perfect fit too
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
I have not looked into them. Thanks for the tip!
@peterpiper487Ай бұрын
I don't trust these not to leak but it doesn't matter because I'd buy a large tarp to throw over the top when set up at a campsite.
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
I tried that once. Took quite awhile to put one on by myself and figure out the easiest way to do this. I put it on when the camper was in the down position before setting up the roof. Securing it down with bungee cords and creating an overhang on the front that I used as a place to sit out of the rain. I had three poles and ropes to hold that part in place. Took me a half hour to set up. Not something you want to do regularly but it did work.
@gradycooper475Ай бұрын
What year was your camper? I have a Rockwood A-Frame and have had great luck with it except for the skylights which I replaced with Lexan Formed exactly like the originals and they were all bedded in butyl rubber and then taped with Ethernabond. It's a great camper!
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
Mine was a 2018. The skylights on Rockwoods are screwed in compared to the Aliner which is glued on and no screws. The holes drilled to allow the screws to hold down the bubble windows develop stress fractures which cause it to leak. They should do away with the bubble windows and not even have any in that location. There is plenty enough light coming in from the main windows anyway. Everyone who owns a Rockwood Aframe camper will develop leaks in these locations. Good luck with your camper and thanks for your comment! 👍
@user-uo5kp8nr7pАй бұрын
I love my Rockwood A122S... It's a pretty solid unit and very comfortable heated mattress ... I have the heat pump and gas furnace, factory solar and the storage area is so handy... I would of loved to have an Original Aliner but for what they cost, I am very satisfied with Rockwoods version. I bought mine on closeout saved $8,000...
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
Glad it’s working out for you! It wasn’t a good fit for me unfortunately. I sold mine and am sticking to lodges and hotels for the foreseeable future on longer trips. But when I go fishing or photographing in the backcountry I will just go truck camping on those occasions. No more trailers for me. Thanks for your comments. Cheers!👍
@user-tj1gp3cp1bАй бұрын
Soy based wiring insulation is the attraction for mice and as I just learned, porcupine eats it as well.
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
I think it’s built in obsolescence. Let’s build it low quality so we constantly have to bring it in for servicing. Reminds me of Microsoft, build an operating system full of holes that hackers can exploit. Then charge everyone to learn how to stop the hackers with additional software and training courses. That’s my rant for the day. 😁
@CatherineFogarty-qh1dbАй бұрын
I don,nt like A frame trailers.
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
Great!
@lylestavast7652Ай бұрын
you sound Albertan... am I close ?
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
Fraser Valley BC!
@robertloftis5413Ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing. We stayed at that campsite twice last summer - on our way north on the Dempster to Tuk, and on our return. Great place to refresh. We have a 2016 A-Liner Classic mounted on an Expedition frame, so a bit bigger than the Ranger you showed and we have a storage box in front with lots of room. Our A-Liner did great on all those dirt roads, but our friends had a smaller model without the beefier frame and had more difficulties. Highly recommend the larger wheels and "Off Road" if you are going to spend any time on rough roads.
@capturereeladventureАй бұрын
Interesting campsite but not the most private. Wall to wall without any trees. Big parking lot really. Dawson City is such a great town though. We didn’t spend much time at our campsite as there was so much to do in town. I wouldn’t recommend any trailers on the Dempster. Saw many truck campers and class B types though. Thanks for sharing!
@michaelgerardcondon85312 ай бұрын
I knew this jewish American carsten kid growing up in the new york area . Beautiful scenery but i left the usa on my ancestral irish passport for Europe. Currently relocating to iceland's capital from.north east England Interesting but way way way to remote for me . But very well done video. If it does not have high functioning quality public transport or its very walkable no thanks .
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the comment! It’s a very unusual name for sure. I’ve been to Iceland, stunningly beautiful country.
@wk70602 ай бұрын
I really like the Aliner much more than the Rockwood. Looks to be built better.
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Wish I would have bought the Aliner. Would probably still have it as I’ve thankfully sold the Rockwood.
@randiescott2 ай бұрын
These clips transported me back to many past fishing trips to Cache Creek, Englishman River, Deadman’s Creek, Nechako River, Columbia River, Lilloet River, Texas Creek, Tweed River, etc. It is a wonderful series of memories to recall standing in pristine streams with rushing, rippling water about … the sounds and views are unforgettable…whether or not I even got a fish on my line.
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Fished many of these as well. Fishing is a state of mind for me. I get lost in the joy of standing in a river and knowing the best places where the fish will be. Even the slightest nibble lets me know they are there, adding to the enjoyment of the day. It’s never about the catching but rather the pursuit and just being there that makes it so worthwhile. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Cheers!
@randiescott2 ай бұрын
I I would be curious to know which flies you are using, hook size, line weights, etc. everything is so very pristine. This transported me back to reading of the adventures of Roderick Haig-Brown with his fishing odysseys. Very enjoyable.
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Thanks! Will implement this in episode 4.
@VERY_VARIOUS_VIDEOS2 ай бұрын
Wonderful water streams and water sounds. Video like 👍
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Thank you 👍
@nancyp15682 ай бұрын
My goodness! I have a 5 year old Aliner Scout and have had zero problems with any of it...unless I don't level it right. By reading the comments this isn't just a one off for you. Hope you can find something else that you can actually enjoy time in.
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Aliners have a much better build quality. Glad you’re not having g the same issues. Will be using the bed of my truck with the cap on the back for my backcountry roughing it trips, watch for those videos of amazing places and experiences coming this year! I’m also glad to be staying in lodges and hotels when I want some luxury. Cheers!
@darryldickson43602 ай бұрын
After buffing at the windows spray clear coat automotive on them
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Great idea. Thanks!
@darryldickson43602 ай бұрын
Have someone else lift up and down on the wall while you push the hinge pin back in
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the suggestion! I've already sold the trailer so no longer able to try it. Will recommend it next time this comes up. Cheers.
@darryldickson43602 ай бұрын
Why didn't you remove the skylights and sealed them correctly?
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
There were multiple layers of repairs done to these windows and would have taken a huge amount of time and effort. I decided a year after buying it that I would only own it only long enough to take me on a 14,000km/9000 mile journey up to the Yukon, NWT, and Alaska. Did the necessary repairs and recently sold it. Glad to get rid of it, just way too many issues. In fact it has sworn me off of rvs for the forerseeable future. Will go truckbed camping when I want to rough it. Cheers.
@gailroberts38422 ай бұрын
I'm considering an A-frame style of trailer. Your videos have been extremely helpful! Thank you!
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Glad it was helpful!
@richardbas29482 ай бұрын
Why don't you go back to the firm where you bought it? I would! They should change this electric mess; it's dangerous! After all: electric + water.....
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
I bought it in a city 2days drive away so wasn’t going to deal with them again. I sold the trailer two months ago so never need to worry about it again thank goodness. 👍
@joncothranphotography93752 ай бұрын
Agreed!
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
👍
@bratworx2 ай бұрын
Great video! I feel a bit triggered by the grouse part though😂
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Thanks! You’ll get your chance one day! Promise. 🤥
@joncothranphotography93752 ай бұрын
I had rented an A-Liner Ranger a couple of years back and it seems to be made a bit better. I went all over it making sure that I didn't damage it and I didn't see any exposed wires. I don't know if the rental company had taken steps to eliminate issues or not, but it is the only experience that I have had with one of those campers. I would buy the A-Liner Ranger should I purchase one. Thanks for your review and thoughts.
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Appreciate the comment. The ALiner has overwhelmingly more support than the Rockwood. I hope Forest River is paying attention to all the negative reviews.
@A_World_Full_of_Lies2 ай бұрын
Not too long ago, I was reading that Rockwood A Frame campers have poor build quality and not to buy them because you will have multiple issues. The Aliner brand are the original A Frame campers, they are well built and last for decades. I think you just bought the wrong brand. Glad you sold it!
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the comment. I wish I would have known about the Aliner quality difference before I bought mine. Very happy I sold it for more than I paid for it.
@larryparson96092 ай бұрын
Thanks 🙏🏼 Happy Trails
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
😁
@JKUadventures2 ай бұрын
What's gonna replace it?
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Will be truck camping for the foreseeable future. Creating a whole series of videos on that starting this summer.
@kennethjinkins89672 ай бұрын
looks like all campers are junk , no quality control
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Many of them are. There are exceptions from what I’m seeing online. More to come on that in the form of new videos reviewing better brands.
@chargerknite2362 ай бұрын
i say a most of the issues are more quality of manufacturing issue than design similar issue you'll may see any other rvs possibly more on the lower end rvs. Though other issues are the issue you see in all collapsible trailers which i expect and experienced myself.
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Many RVs are slapped together in record time on the assembly line. Especially the lower priced units as you mentioned. That doesn’t forgive the manufacturers from producing something that falls apart easily after only a few short years. Better engineering and parts should be standard on items that must not fail, ever. Leaks should be a thing of the past!
@philipgelsheimer57052 ай бұрын
I just watched your video a little too late as I take delivery of a 2024 A213HW next week. I had to chuckle as I wanted an a-frame so I wouldn't have to repair another lift system failure. "What could go wrong with a hinged wall?" I thought naively. We'll see how it goes. I'm retired and reasonably handy so I think in 3 years it will look like a homebuilt after all the repairs🙄
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the comment! My recommendation with your trailer is to baby it or else you’ll have issues in short order like most who own one of these. Don’t take it on dirt roads if you can help it. They are cozy and practical for short trips. I did a 10 week, 9000 mile trip with mine last summer, way too long for such a small unit. Check out the video series on my channel! Episode three coming out soon. Best of luck with your new unit!
@gideonporter5372 ай бұрын
Do these have a warranty? Have you raised your concerns with the manufacturer? Did they respond? I really like the design, but if they haven't fixed the "flimsy" at the very least , that's a deal-breaker.
@capturereeladventure2 ай бұрын
I bought it used with no warranty and didn’t contact the manufacturer. I could have but knew that this unit was purchased for a 10 week trip up to the Yukon, Northwest Territories and Alaska. I did that and sold the trailer earlier this year after repairing most of what I could. The trip videos are on the channel and am in production of episode 3 at the moment.