Seminar | India's Green Transition
1:05:58
Пікірлер
@prakashtiwari8003
@prakashtiwari8003 22 сағат бұрын
It's always pleasure to listen to Ambassador Menon.🙏
@666raki
@666raki Күн бұрын
like in Vietnam, allowing investment from China will only increase more investment from the west
@joshua_ch
@joshua_ch Күн бұрын
Most of the talk was very good and interesting but the trade stuff was tired cliches. I am sorry but to make a case for RCEP at a time when Indonesia , Malaysia and Vietnam are talking of imposing tariffs on Chinese goods is just silly. The US and EU are raising tariffs !! Yes ofcourse we need trade but we are not in the 60s, our tariffs are nowhere near those high levels. This silly political point scoring about "Atmanirbhar Bharat" by just harking back to socialist era "import substitution" needs to stop. The policy of raising/lowering tariffs selectively has worked in mobiles and is now working on telecom, laptops, ACs etc. We need to grapple with the complexities as they exist right now. I do think we should look at joining CPTPP some day but all the social justice/democracy wallahs won't like what it will mean for our pharma and agri based industries. All the "informal" sector manufacturing that is so loved by JNU wallahs will also have to go if you wish to sign on to copyright, IP protections of CPTPP standards. Trade deals are very difficult for large countries, as US is also now finding out, and especially so when you are very poor and uncompetitive like India. PS : Sorry for the rant, but i so deeply respect Mr.Menon as a deep thinker who grapples with complexity .I was really very disappointed with his simplistic take on trade that frankly sounded like we are in 2006 and he is some new world bank representative recruited just out of college. I would highly recommend all Indians interested in economic policy read the writings of Michael Pettis on China/global trade and a recent book by Nikhil gupta on problem of growth for the indian economy.
@srinivasanpr1112
@srinivasanpr1112 Күн бұрын
will trade block are doing favour why are those economies not doing well incuding china
@biggpicture2930
@biggpicture2930 Күн бұрын
You think they are not doing well, but you are not worry you are worse off?
@srinivasanpr1112
@srinivasanpr1112 Күн бұрын
he wants to talk only after the 100 mn people brought out from 2001 to 2011 during upa ; but is very sceptic about the current establishment which has survived three tenure ; probably left out syndrome of educated unskilled left intellectual
@sanjeev00123
@sanjeev00123 Күн бұрын
He is right that we are doing only trade with China but we are not talking to Chinese leadership
@sanjeev00123
@sanjeev00123 Күн бұрын
Ambassador Menon gave thought provoking ideas for Indian government to work on.India can't avoid being part of groupings like ASEAN,RCEP etc.BJP should look into it and try not to be in a Silo
@joshua_ch
@joshua_ch Күн бұрын
China, Malaysia or Brazil are not our 'peer' economies. Their per capita incomes are 3-4 times higher and their rates of urbanization are almost double or more. Instead of trying to just blindly follow something WHO says or what richer countries have done in terms of "universal" health care , we need a more first principles approach to look at our challenges. The first question we should try to answer is how are health care costs distributed. If a very small percentage of households at some socio economic level suffering from specific ailments bear a disproportionate part of the overall healthcare expenditure ,say like the cardiac surgery issue of Andhra was brought up or something chronic like tuberculosis, then it might actually be the right approach to focus on those specific ailments and reduce those costs through tertiary or primary care investments . Clear data on what ailments actually burden the population and where interventions with more bang for the buck are possible would be more useful than pie-in-the-sky goals of 'universal' health care or some silly 5% health spending. Our neighbors are China and Pakistan not Switzerland and US where we can eliminate defense expenditure. Our infrastructure needs are going to be pretty high for the next two decades if we have to compete in global export markets so yeah health will never be a big enough priority to justify 5% spending and it should not be. Sorry for being blunt. PS : Srilanka is to some extent a peer economy and it shows the perils of public spending going beyond your means on health and education. You will get kudos from WHO and possibly even world bank will praise you but then one day your economy will go kaput and people will blame some silly organic farming and not persistent government over-spending which was the real cause and common people will suffer .
@jackblack2548
@jackblack2548 Күн бұрын
This is a channel owned and run by leftists who have no interest in a strong and totally independent India. Not recommended at all.
@paulhall1612
@paulhall1612 Күн бұрын
kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jMmWis2ct5bNnWg.htmlsi=jA387SX6m2obfZFz
@ananthkrishna2338
@ananthkrishna2338 2 күн бұрын
Thanks Dr. Surjit for highlighting the RBI's admission of a broken inflation model. Gives inspiration to find an alternative.
@sourabhbhattacharya3411
@sourabhbhattacharya3411 2 күн бұрын
Over taxed??? But who pays taxes in India...only salaried class, businesses get every options etc etc to avoid and evade taxes. Don't ask for states and local municipalities which are even worse and lazy.
@shashwattripathi4559
@shashwattripathi4559 2 күн бұрын
The first question from the audience highlights what is wrong with the Indian bureaucratic system.. The question assumes that the job of a civil servant is to tax the people through the nose.. He assumes that the system is doing fine since we are over-taxing the people. He does not understand that the goal of taxing is to generate revenue to pay for the services that the country gives its citizens & not to exploit the productive parts of the society. This buffoon, marinating in perks paid for from the tax payer's pockets of course does not feel the pinch. I wonder if this is hangover from a colonial mindset where the so-called practitioner, generalist, civil 'servant' was rewarded for exploiting the citizens.
@user-cn2lk7vy5s
@user-cn2lk7vy5s 3 күн бұрын
Greatness of her is acceptness of both positive and negative things remains in every society
@ravisankarnarayanamurthy1011
@ravisankarnarayanamurthy1011 7 күн бұрын
Persons have SUVs with party flags.. how much tax they pay? Any data... ? Salaried class have 30% which is more than corporates taxation . That is shit
@ravisankarnarayanamurthy1011
@ravisankarnarayanamurthy1011 7 күн бұрын
This was nonsense presentation. In India, tax evation is like ganga river and govt is only trying to scoop some tax collection from same obedient class. Govt did not take any serious effect in black money generation because the so called governing mechanism of minisrtry+officials are corruput. Legal courts sleep for decades. e.g 2g scam, looting of minerals in TN, Jarkhan. Then why all these discussions ... eye-wash to substantiate govt policies.
@rishitdesai8539
@rishitdesai8539 8 күн бұрын
My god, when I listened to Mr Arvind I realised, how little first principles thinking our babus like Mr Arvind apply. All arguments are IMF has told us some random potential and we are significantly below that. This is so theoretical. Complete dereliction of all thinking skills - laughable. I hope better sense prevails and better thinking people prevail. Mr Aravind is very knowledgeable but has left thinking behind decades back.
@srinidhirao1620
@srinidhirao1620 8 күн бұрын
Why exactly does this expert thinks that raise in corporate taxes are good for the economy. Corporate tax will only diminish the expansion, curtail the scale & increase the informal economy.
@GuzzarAwan
@GuzzarAwan 9 күн бұрын
Lets not raise tax futher please. Instead increase the investment to GDP ratio, which china has 47% With time as fomralisation of Jobs happen tax base will broaden automatically
@devyanilimaye8560
@devyanilimaye8560 9 күн бұрын
What about richest farmers? Just because they are 1% of farmers doesnt mean they don't earn at least one crore per year
@muditjain8784
@muditjain8784 9 күн бұрын
It’s not low but unproductive government expenditure is too high
@_rohit97
@_rohit97 10 күн бұрын
Surjit is too smart for those dumb baboos in the audience and one on the panel! India is heavily taxed and the only way govt can earn more revenue is by lowering the tax. Its called the laffer curve and it was named after the guy who made Ronal Regan's economy the fastest growing at that time.
@TapanSarkar100
@TapanSarkar100 10 күн бұрын
This is a learning session for a common man to have some idea on tax policies who has little idea on economic theories.
@kaushlendratripathi7984
@kaushlendratripathi7984 10 күн бұрын
Expansion of personal income tax is an absolute must. Of the 8 odd crore that file return less than 2.5 crore actually pay tax ( CBDT data). There is no analysis of these tax payers - what percentage are salaried, how many govt employees, how many shop and commercial establishment owners, how many industrialists etc - regionwise , state wise . Its a sad state of affairs - and Surjit Bhalla's defence is vacuous.
@kbmehta4208
@kbmehta4208 10 күн бұрын
Good insights
@srinidhirao1620
@srinidhirao1620 11 күн бұрын
It's scary that our Baby's think Taxing is their birth right. They don't realize that every tax is a penalty on some one doing some thing productive & that taxing too much will bring down the productivity, innovation & risk taking abilities of the society.
@gsnprasad
@gsnprasad 7 күн бұрын
⁶6⁶⁶⁶ť
@Zethuzzz
@Zethuzzz 11 күн бұрын
Is India’s Olympic medals to population ratio too high or too low?
@saravananc7121
@saravananc7121 11 күн бұрын
Not even 0.0000001%
@GuzzarAwan
@GuzzarAwan 9 күн бұрын
😂😂😂 too high
@julioduan7130
@julioduan7130 11 күн бұрын
This Miss Wong needs more knowledge about China before attending this seminar.
@sudhakaraluri550
@sudhakaraluri550 11 күн бұрын
Interesting discussion!
@srinivasanpr1112
@srinivasanpr1112 12 күн бұрын
how must is the agricultural income total that is shown by various assessee for an assessment year ; why is govt afraid to tell that number
@srinivasanpr1112
@srinivasanpr1112 12 күн бұрын
we must have more conversation like this
@guharup
@guharup 12 күн бұрын
As the rich farmers. Nonsense
@mappaji
@mappaji 12 күн бұрын
Good review of the Budget 2024
@tavishiSoni
@tavishiSoni 12 күн бұрын
❤❤❤ Divya
@sushmanagpal7051
@sushmanagpal7051 13 күн бұрын
Amazing discussion👌
@sushmanagpal7051
@sushmanagpal7051 13 күн бұрын
Great anaysis👍👍
@evanishapathaw7064
@evanishapathaw7064 17 күн бұрын
Kong Patricia Mukhim she’s just awesome 🙌 I mean she is right we need to be different as she said I do agreed 👍
@rakadus
@rakadus Ай бұрын
GST is a "Free Trade Agreement" between States of India.
@muditjain8784
@muditjain8784 Ай бұрын
Certainly the central government gained and the Indian citizens lost and lost badly.
@joshua_ch
@joshua_ch Ай бұрын
They keep saying states have given up fiscal sovereignty but so has the center. The idea behind gst is that both will give up sovereignty to improve efficiency, coordination and share the benefits of turning the country in to a real single market. Unlike Arvind i think the GST council can and will get to three rates structure eventually, it may take 5 years or more but it will happen.
@gvnrgopal2251
@gvnrgopal2251 Ай бұрын
Finally some sane words from someone .... Our people feel like govta have magic Wands .... N can overturn everything within no time.
@samridhup
@samridhup 2 ай бұрын
Audio is not clear
@Souptik35
@Souptik35 2 ай бұрын
Very articulately & intricately explained 👏🏻
@theknowlwdgebar
@theknowlwdgebar 2 ай бұрын
Doctors will become unemployed very soon....
@gokul7403
@gokul7403 3 ай бұрын
Good discussion 👏
@user-sx4mq6zn9o
@user-sx4mq6zn9o 4 ай бұрын
Subject is great. Appreciated from Kolkata.
@ravindraharsoor3460
@ravindraharsoor3460 4 ай бұрын
Bunch of losers with intellectual bankruptcy and woolly headed shortsightedness coupled with financial corruption and anti national mindset. History has amply demonstrated that these guys are wrong, malicious and prevaricating here
@douglaswong6975
@douglaswong6975 4 ай бұрын
Jacob, China doesn't care if you think China is communist, because China is communist. China is not going to change India's democracy, keep it to yourself.
@douglaswong6975
@douglaswong6975 4 ай бұрын
Tanvi madan talk 🦜🦜🐦🐦🐦 and talk , no point, one sided. Wake Up India GDP is 1/5 of China, hurry up and do something stop talking
@douglaswong6975
@douglaswong6975 4 ай бұрын
Wake Up Indians 70% of electronic products are import from China A baby step is start somewhere that you can do, definitely not high technology CHIPS
@basusri1120
@basusri1120 4 ай бұрын
Excellent discussion on the book by Dr Bajpai. But I am very pessimistic about our relationship with China. They have illegally occupied large tracts of our territory, which we can never recover considering the huge disparity of our military strength compared to China. And they still lay claim to the entire state of Arunachal Pradesh, and have changed the names of a number of places in our territory. These are ominous signs and portend serious trouble in the near future.