2:25 as a pansexual, Starkid always delivers on making me panic 😭

5:38 note to self i want pants/jeans like this

4:56 i am convinced her whole solo is definitely a reference to covid lockdown

I seriously can’t WAIT for the soundtrack to appear on streaming platforms I love it so much😍

2:27 the bi pride flag overlaying dirty girl especially during the harmony, bestie you are SO right for that

NOT THE 2000 DISNEY ORIGINAL MOVIE (now I can’t unsee it tbh)❤

Jon matteson looks absolutely UNHINGED in the summoning

* I'm so glad that someone specifically pulled out the way they sing "T'noooyyy Keraxissss" cause that literally makes me feel so dfgdjhhgkdg

I thought we all knew that the vocals were so crisps because we weren't hearing the live vocals? But damn this show was so good - I've watched it several times already. Its such a iconic Starkid show.

I don’t think Jon’s voice got better, I just think this show shows off his vocal ability better. Where in tgwdlm he only sang one song that was right on his break.

also Angela absolutely kills me throughout this show she's so fucking amazing at literally everything she does

also thE ACTING IN IF I LOVED YOU IS OTHERWORDKLY OMG

The way joey sings "one of us is in love," BREAKS MEEEEE ITS SO TENDER AND SAD! FUCK!

i swear the choreo in rhis show is so overwhelmingly good. it's prbably the best starkid has done since fitebringer

i need to hear more commotion for the choreography in this show, it's so effective and fun, i love it

There's so many underrated actors in Starkid, I agree. Corey, Jon, Bryce, even Joey are all such good singers and I think this musical is the first time they got solos/their own individual parts. :p

amgelas range as an actor is so amazing i just UGH 🫶

Grace's outfit is so cute during dirty girl song.

Have not seen anything about how grace chastity starts to swear EXACTLY the way max does even just halfway through the show

OH MY GOD I DIDN'T EVEN RECONIZE THE MELODY IN THE BACKROUND OF RUTHS SONG THANK YOU FOR POINTING THAT OUT FUCK THATS COOL

6:13 SAME!!!!

Jon has grown so much😭😭😭😭😭 I need him to be a protagonist again in a future musical, give this man his own song!!!

This musical gave me so much stellar Jon Matteson vocal moments I am so SO SATISFIED. The way his voice is so controlled in the opening number? HOOO MY GOD

Skipping i am dan reynolds!?!??

Jon's 'spre-ead' and 'I'm not a loser' is so good!

The lords in black song gave me chills it was so good

Listen, I know it's off topic but for the "darkness will spare my soul" part - the staging is set up EXACTLY like Let It Out in TGWDLM. Intentionally feels very "this is the moment that we officially lose Grace/Paul to the Lords in Black"

THE MELODY FROM THE LYRICS ™️ BEING IN JUST FOR ONCE MAKES IT EVEN SADDER AAAA

Nothing captures Grace being the genuinely scariest character more than Dirty Dudes Must Die and Bury the Body (but especially her delivery of "Run you little bitch" and "Who will pray for you")

I can’t believe Starkid invented harmonies with this show

I might sound a little "English teacher finding meaning from the meaningless" here but notice how in NPMD the repeated lyrics from Cool as I think I am don't contain the breaking the rules line, because Max is already a rulebreaker, whilst in DDMD, the break the rules line is sung, because Grace is finally turning against her morals, getting into sexual encounters and dealing with Satanic Gods that aren't connected to Christianity.

there's something so haunting about someone whose defining character trait is having strong religious faith singing "who will pray for you?"

7:38 I definitely wasn't literally sobbing alone at 11 at night watching this when it premiered. Definitely not.

9:33 nice to know everyone else had the same nostalgia with the finale song as I did.

I genuinely want to get a tattoo that says I'm not a loser. This show is incredible.

You and I must be the same person because i had the exact same experience as you watching NPMD

1:17 IM ASCENDING ❤️

starkid really heard that i’d gotten over my crush on joey and decided to have him play a nerd in love with Mariah, who i also have a crush on lmao. also yes their voices together sound better than i could have imagined.