Where are the bronze items. Where is tin source. Where is the iron source. How did they forge the bronze.
@cameronfielder4955Ай бұрын
It’s not entirely clear what his theory is. I think both the brevity of the video and the substance leave the viewer with more questions than answers. Most experts think we came out of Africa and the fossil record supports that conclusion. It’s possible that Homo sapiens evolved from homo erectus in Asia and then moved back into Africa but I think it’s highly unlikely given our fossil evidence. Whenever someone pushed that line of thinking I have to wonder about motivations. Racists have long fought against the African origins theory. He talks about PIE like it’s a culture. Languages and cultures are two different things. PIE is a reconstructed proto language that was probably spoken 2-6 kya, long after Homo sapiens had spread across all of Europe and Asia. Cultural evidence doesn’t do anything in proving a language’s longevity (unless it’s written on artifacts). Frequently a prestige language would replace the former but a culture would remain largely unchanged. This is true for DNA also; DNA cannot track a languages because the two things are not inextricably linked. I could just be misunderstanding what he is saying in some respects, but this whole presentation is full of bs in my opinion. The history of languages going back that far is certainly very messy and complex. It is not so cut and dry.
@Viktor_JohanssonАй бұрын
I make axes from nephrite for fun; alpine jade axes, one boat axe, two axes from the bronze age Borodino hoard. My dream would be to get some jadeite type material from Mt Viso or Syros and make a traditional 'alpine jade axe' from.
@JacquesMare2 ай бұрын
Θράκη....... (E) Truskos?
@forestdweller55813 ай бұрын
Thank you, that was interesting stuff. I'm wondering about the first people arriving during the Paleolithic....is there any evidence of them arriving by boats, exploiting marine resources and gradually settling more inland? That is what happened in Sweden or Norway so it would seem likely for this area as well perhaps?
@lugo_99693 ай бұрын
Old irish and Latin having much vocabulary in common. Anatolian farmer roots. Also the curious links between celtic grammar and semitic languages. The med and atlantic coasts being habitable while most of europe was frozen and empty.
@uiimairgrandchildrenofivar58943 ай бұрын
All of my mother's surnames come from the Scottish Highlands and the Hebrides (MacGilleMhoire / MacIver / MacLeod / Campbell) with three of them having a Viking progenitor. All of my father's surnames come from Ulster in Northern Ireland (MacGofraid / McCosker / MacLochlainn / MacManus) and all of them are Gaelic versions of Norse names. And after taking multiple ancestry and DNA tests and doing a whole lot of research, I've come to find out that I'm on average, 36% Irish, 28% Scottish, and 29%.........Norwegian??? Must of been all those Vikings from Laithlind 😄 🇮🇪 🏴 🇳🇴
@Davod21394 ай бұрын
A lot of shitty rhetoric and invective in this talk.
@forestdweller55814 ай бұрын
I had not come across this site yet so thank you for your presentation. Although i can't agree with your hypothesis and conclusions but that' s fine. i' m curious if any Solutrean items were found? Most of that stuff got " stolen " already by the Magdalenians and later people of course but i like to keep track of where the odd shouldered or leaf shaped points pop up. They would more than likely have known and used such quarry areas as well.
The words for wheel are not loan words, as they show regular sound shifts. For example, if Tocharian borrowed its word for wagon from Indo-Iranian, it would not be "Kukal" but "Cakra." Because Indo-Iranian has a regular L > R sound shift. So "Kukal" cannot have been borrowed into Tocharian by any neighboring Indo-European language family that we know of. And if this is news to you, then you didn't really read David Anthony's book.
@stevejohnstone13116 ай бұрын
David Anthony has repeatedly said wagons came from non-steppe peoples he says they brought togather thouse innovations to invent pastoral nomadism you talk about people being defensive this guy littlerly couldnt have read the book with understanding of the language he read it in.
@stevejohnstone13116 ай бұрын
And he say if you can't track every info on a language movement you can't talk (greek) then says he knows how prehistoric words came from Africa all the way through Siberia.....OK thats just crazy talk.
@deborahziska29167 ай бұрын
Outstanding and groundbreaking work is being done by HeMo in Ukraine that will ultimately benefit societies even beyond Ukraine who face the same challenges of preserving cultural heritage in a conflict or war zone.
@ian_b8 ай бұрын
Being able to watch something like this instead of a rubbish low-content TV documentary is why I love KZfaq existing.
@torbjrnlund9038 ай бұрын
I think the tapestry depictcs the gathering before the legendary Battle of Brávellir (Bråvalla), which is said to have taken place aboyt year 770. Maybe it depicts celebration in aftermath. It is the greatest battle in nordic folklore. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Br%C3%A1vellir
@STICKlaPISSSE8 ай бұрын
If its Southern Iberian Peninsula why the title refers to SOUTH WESTERN SPAIN?!? Don't you people know geography?
@ThatLadyBird8 ай бұрын
That last site isnt in NI though 😂
@Sheepdog13148 ай бұрын
How about monitoring the Cultural Heritage of Germany - it's about to get flushed down the muslim drain
@Boneshaker1389 ай бұрын
Sap Nuno de Santa Maria
@abishemui82789 ай бұрын
Much LOVE from AMERICA!!
@alexgabriel542310 ай бұрын
Satem languages differ from Kentum languages...Tocharian is kentum.and Armenian is kentum based on the verb system and not on.the many words borrowed from Persian...that made the superficial British linguists classify it as Satem. The French linguists straightened that out. Eurocentrism is a must for a career in academia and for grants isnt it ?? ....even if it is not the emergent information from honest research....
@silvergalaxie10 ай бұрын
wowsers
@beforeoriondotcom10 ай бұрын
Thank you for the well organized conference.
@MustafaSav-cb2cp10 ай бұрын
Finally we get to hear the real history.
@MustafaSav-cb2cp10 ай бұрын
Danke Dr. Zangger die Wirklichkeit heraus zu fordern. Es ist wirklich eine Schweinerei die Geschichte zu verändern, wegen den Fall von Constantinople bei den Türken.
@radovanwolf59311 ай бұрын
I do wish the recording wasnt so silent :(
@laterisaferondii143511 ай бұрын
Im a closed head injury 🤕 survivor 8 years now. And new things continue to develop.
@romansukac427111 ай бұрын
Thank you, Alwin.
@youngsugaryoungsugarkim782611 ай бұрын
😊💓
@youngsugaryoungsugarkim782611 ай бұрын
😊💓
@youngsugaryoungsugarkim782611 ай бұрын
😊💓
@andreabeverari193 Жыл бұрын
Buongiorno, complimenti per il video conferenza e il vostro studio , qui dove abito a Verona città , e provincia è stata trovata i frammenti di una situla " la situla di Rivoli Veronese VR , e l' Elmo di Oppeano Veronese VR, opere dei Veneti Antichi.
@MonikaEscobar1965 Жыл бұрын
It´s the today´s WELSH people, Cymry! That was a great lecture, thank you!!
@pinkpink-7699 Жыл бұрын
ماهي التي تدرس في قسم تاريخ فن What are you studying in the art history department?
@dodoyaman8411 Жыл бұрын
Iam vallahades 3 generation from naslic send greek muslims send to turkey. My grandfathers they didnt even speak word turkish.they were banned ffrom greeks and send to tukey. Can speak still greek language some. Big pain for us(
@YianniS2002_4 ай бұрын
You speak Greek or Turkish ?
@erdoganyaman4 ай бұрын
I can speak both langusge but my greek is getting poor cause of less using
@NRoosterАй бұрын
Hocam merhabalar. Eğer görürseniz yorumumu, bir yerden konuşma şansımız var mı?
@aviaxis6261 Жыл бұрын
this was a culture surviving throughout the whole Mesolithic basically
@tankej Жыл бұрын
Great talk. I find myself wanting to know what it is about the letter forms on the Daskyleion sherds that marks them out as Lydian? It would also be nice to see an image of the 7c. Etruscan evidence for Aeneas: in what script is it?
@missbutter7621 Жыл бұрын
very good talk, makes a lot of sense.
@iamgodswife1339 Жыл бұрын
Atlantis, America. The Amarna letters are a lie. Akhenaten was actually Ramses. SETI was kadashman enill and horemheb. It’s America! 😀
@iamgodswife1339 Жыл бұрын
Wilusa where Troy is, is Volusia county Florida.
@SkyForgeVideos Жыл бұрын
The height of stone age technology.
@CmacKw Жыл бұрын
Interesting. Do the feature clusters represent individual residential loci that collectively form a larger aggregated sub-urban community? In the southern American Southwest, this type of late prehistoric settlement is called a rancheria.
@infini_ryu9461 Жыл бұрын
Explains why Medieval People weren't actually that short as previously believed. They were getting a decent amount of protein from animal foods.
@Michael-yx5qx Жыл бұрын
The wheel was invented in the east by Eurasian people period this isn't up for debate
@hermanmunster714 Жыл бұрын
West Slavs and Norse are blood Brothers. Not Rus not German not Brits. Thank you Professor.
@kryptonsonАй бұрын
The Norse Vikings were decendants of Germanic tribes, they were very much northern German as well as Slavic.
@hermanmunster714 Жыл бұрын
Well well well. Considering at its closest northern Poland Baltic region is about a stones throw from Jutland it makes sense that Poles were more Viking than so called Rus or even Germans. Face facts Polish warrior history was always whitewashed to deny its very existence. Thank you Professor. Polish warriors sit in Valhalla not German or Rus.
@nestoraspapoutsas4639 Жыл бұрын
I am an amateur geologist and i also come from Syros. I've been researching both geologic and archeologic sites. If you need any information about any topic i would be glad to help out.
@josephwarra5043 Жыл бұрын
A wonderful discovery, maybe Jazdzewski and his team can comment.