Пікірлер
@bengoodwin2141
@bengoodwin2141 5 сағат бұрын
I think it might be relevant to consider that the sides of the cup expand by unfolding, so they might act differently than just being a rotating curved... plane?
@MathCuriousity
@MathCuriousity 5 сағат бұрын
Why did you change the axis of rotation?! By the way: your channel is AMAZING!!! Absolutely hats off to your level of both creativity and commitment to service and educating self learners!
@blocksy6772
@blocksy6772 6 сағат бұрын
Awesome idea for a channel, you definitely deserve to get more views! Wondering if you're thinking about adding some dynamic/recursive models as well? I remember we used to have a course in my economics program that started out with a silly question like 'What's the best way to eat a cake', given that you can either eat it now or save some for later, and it ended up covering some interesting models with regards to what the best balance was for consumption/saving, given that any consumption today makes you happier right now, but saving allows you to consume more at a later time. So you get really neat models that take time into account and get dependent on past actions/future considerations.
@PeaBrain87
@PeaBrain87 8 сағат бұрын
My sleep deprived brain is telling me that there's an easier way of finding this out with way less math Just bring a little scale w u to Arby's and get a bunch of those little cups and open them to various capacities, full them up then get an empty cup to zero out the scale and and measure the cups The heaviest contains the prime sauce (I'm writing this before I finish the video- if he talks ab doing it this way I'll retract my statement :D)
@nicholasreyna2164
@nicholasreyna2164 15 сағат бұрын
0:53 you misunderstand, acceleration as a stat isn’t that important, it’s mini turbo that is important. Mini turbo is a hidden stat that usually corresponds with acceleration, and changes how long your drift boosts last
@wavebreakerr142
@wavebreakerr142 17 сағат бұрын
I optimized my sauce cups by blowing into the top and inflating the cup like a balloon. If I keep the rim intact, I'll end up with a highly optimized shape. Unfolding the rim expands the shape slightly, but the math starts to look like differential geometry and dynamical systems, which I'm not ready to mess with yet
@trynoobs1119
@trynoobs1119 20 сағат бұрын
Please there has been a problem that has been atuck on my mind for 1 year. Draw 1 right isosceles triangle. Draw a line in the middle of it, splitting it into 2 triangles. If we keep splitting all the triangle, then how much triangle would it produce? And what is the pattern to it?
@zenotheomni-king_br7448
@zenotheomni-king_br7448 20 сағат бұрын
And then u get reminded about the surface tension of the sauce and realize how useless highschool math is
@scott2427
@scott2427 Күн бұрын
I wonder if you could ever do anything with signal analysis it would make for a cool video in my eyes
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
Can you tell me more about what you are thinking about signal analysis? Do you have particular situations in mind?
@reaperplayz3569
@reaperplayz3569 Күн бұрын
Love the video 😂, though normally mario cart players max their mini boost stat! ❤
@orbry
@orbry Күн бұрын
"I've scaled the court so that units are feet" - my rage meter jumps from 0 to high. "But we will put the metrics measurements on the screen as well" - my rage meter drops from high to 0.
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
Ha! Yeah, we have been yelled at a lot when we did not use any metric units. We try to use metric or both now.
@maxmyzer9172
@maxmyzer9172 Күн бұрын
I care.
@alastairhewitt380
@alastairhewitt380 Күн бұрын
Would have love if same analysis was applied to sports with weight classes like wrestling to see if there are body types that excel even when weight is controlled
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
That would be interesting. I'll do some thinking and see if I can find out how to get good data on one of these sports.
@quinn1096
@quinn1096 Күн бұрын
Please consider cropping out the flashing text in the bottom right. It’s all I can focus on when in shot
@cryptostorm3489
@cryptostorm3489 Күн бұрын
42 is the answer
@cryptostorm3489
@cryptostorm3489 Күн бұрын
Tldw:41 degré
@vorey4206
@vorey4206 Күн бұрын
U could do better video about integration.
@FunctionallyLiteratePerson
@FunctionallyLiteratePerson Күн бұрын
It should be mentioned for the multivariate version that it is possible that the partials are both 0 are a local extrema and not global. You also want to check the edges of the domain, as partials might not equal 0 there due to domain restrictions but you still might have a greater value. One might argue you can ignore this if you know roughly where the maximum is and the edges of the domain are definitely nowhere near, but that only works in certain cases and not for everything.
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
The once you bring up our valid. I debated how much to get into these, but since we had a good visual of the situation once we restricted the domain to the context we were working with, I thought it might be a bit much to emphasize those things ( or saddle points) since we could see from the surface what we were dealing with. I certainly could have hurt viewers thinking that finding the maximum on a 3D surface was always this easy.
@Charliewebbwins
@Charliewebbwins Күн бұрын
Couldn't you just treat this as a 2D problem and solve for maximum area?
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
Good question. We take this up in the follow up video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/oLmCYLSDl622oYU.html But the short answer is no. The volume is not proportional to the area. Because areas that are further away from the axis generate more volume. If you do the math for both, they don't come out to be the same (except for maybe one special case).
@raptokvortex
@raptokvortex Күн бұрын
For those interested, the optimum shape of bowl like containers for liquids is a truncated hemisphere.
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
There might be a situation where that is optimal, but if you're trying to make a bowl with the minimal amount of material that holds the most volume, it isn't quite a truncated hemisphere. We're going to get as close as we can to that in our next video.
@peteralaadin9851
@peteralaadin9851 Күн бұрын
I think the speed climbing route is similarly arbitrary, although I think technique can conteract that more than it can in hurdles
@sixtenpettersson3814
@sixtenpettersson3814 Күн бұрын
The hidden stat called mini-turbo is arguably the most important stat in the game
@cuwej8338
@cuwej8338 2 күн бұрын
As an european who has never been to arbies, I’m glad that these videos exist. Definitely need more of Math Overkill
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld Күн бұрын
Thank you! Just wait, we have another one coming soon on toilet paper!
@mujtabaalam5907
@mujtabaalam5907 2 күн бұрын
There's no reason for the cup to be limited to a frustum-type shape; you can use variational calculus to find the optimal curve with the constraint of surface area.
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld Күн бұрын
Yes exactly! That will be part 3!
@BCDLB
@BCDLB 2 күн бұрын
just discovered your videos , you are one of the small bunch that can make math fun !!!
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld Күн бұрын
Thank you so much!
@darkskinnedpimp
@darkskinnedpimp 2 күн бұрын
Wholesome and intelligent, thank you
@siddharth_desai
@siddharth_desai 2 күн бұрын
If you're allowed to change where the flat region of the cup ends, then surely, you're not limited to a flat region and a angled region. The angle of the walls could vary continuously to make a rounded bowl shape that could hold even more sauce. Anyone up for some calculus of variations?
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld Күн бұрын
Yes that is the plan for part 3!
@tttITA10
@tttITA10 2 күн бұрын
For people who were not too happy about the explanation as to why maximizing the cross sectional area isn't the same problem here, by the Theorems of Pappus-Gulding, the revolution volume IS actually proportional to the cross-sectional area, the problem being it is also proportional to the average distance of the points of the object (or, in this case, one half of it) to your axis of rotation, so, since changing the shape of the object (as if to maximize the area) may also change the average distance of the object's points to the axis, the problem is more subtle then just maxizing the cross-sectional area. His example got confusing because he changed the axis of rotation (instead of showing the equivalent change in shape), while, in the paper cup problem, the axis of rotation is determined.
@FunctionallyLiteratePerson
@FunctionallyLiteratePerson Күн бұрын
Thank you for this! I was thinking along the same line but couldn't remember exactly the reason why
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
Thanks for bringing in Pappus. Making that connection it's a good way to understand why maximizing the 2D area is not the same as maximizing the volume.
@drxyd
@drxyd 2 күн бұрын
"Adding up tiny bits" seemed like the most realistic interpretation, infinitesimals notwithstanding.
@jcorey333
@jcorey333 2 күн бұрын
This is fun to watch! I definitely wish I really understood multivariable calculus, but it wasn't too bad seeing the graphical solution to this problem. Of course, now I'm feeling hungry for some Arby's.
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld 10 сағат бұрын
Maybe you could audit my class. (If I ever teach it.) Although you know my office neighbor is better than me.
@EdbertWeisly
@EdbertWeisly 2 күн бұрын
Next: instead of Math Overkill, its Math Slaughterhouse
@brodymiller9299
@brodymiller9299 2 күн бұрын
One thing to point out is that the term "Viscosity" is not accurate for how high a sauce can extend beyond the rim. In this case, if the sauce is a Newtonian fluid, the fluid will always overflow the edges (though it may take a long time, such as the material "Pitch"). Ketchup is not a Newtonian fluid, but rather a Bingham Plastic. Bingham plastics do not flow when under a certain shear stress, known as the "Critical Stress" or "Yield Stress". While it can be correlated between similar fluids with viscosity, it is not the same, and a Bingham plastic can have a low viscosity. As an example, Coal slurry has a lower viscosity than printing ink, but a higher critical stress. For ketchup, I have seen critical stresses in the range of 15-30 Pa, which would give a support angle of 35 - 45 degrees at a 1.5cm radius. I'll try and make a longer write up once I do some additional math.
@chain3519
@chain3519 2 күн бұрын
I haven't gotten to that part of the video yet, but wouldn't viscosity not even apply here? I thought viscosity whether that be Newtonian or otherwise was a mapping of fluid velocity gradient across a surface. In this case the sauce should have zero velocity and therefore the gradient velocity of the ketchup should be zero everywhere. The mechanism that allows sauce to exceed its volume I believe is what you are describing which I think means the sauce continuum is able to generate some internal shear stress along the skin to resist body forces
@brodymiller9299
@brodymiller9299 2 күн бұрын
@@chain3519 Yea, I did the math and it ends up being a sqrt curve from the outside in. I got a total volume of 97.4022cm^3 after all was said and done, with a bottom radius of 2.22cm top radius of 3.802cm, and an angle of 62.8 degrees. I used a 21.8 Pa critical stress since I found that in a google search.
@bengoodwin2141
@bengoodwin2141 5 сағат бұрын
I'm no expert here, but isn't surface tension involved here? Or is that a different phenomenon
@rrrrmrmr
@rrrrmrmr 2 күн бұрын
But would it actually be possible to fold the cup to have that radius without cutting it?
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld Күн бұрын
Yes, you don't have to cut it to get a different sized base. The folds are approximately triangles with the vertex starting on the edge of the base. So you can fold the triangles and have that vertex any distance away from the center. Well, up until physical limitations of folding the paper into an extremely small fold.
@S0ggyW3tW4t4r
@S0ggyW3tW4t4r 2 күн бұрын
7:45 gambling mb?
@xavimourelo
@xavimourelo 2 күн бұрын
Another problem that might be worth explore is to see how toilet paper decreases in size, because when you do a 360º turn at the beginning the volume decreases very little, but as you approach the end each new turn reduces dramatically the amount of paper left, not being able to properly guess when is it gonna finish
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld Күн бұрын
We have this one in the works!
@ExzaktVid
@ExzaktVid 2 күн бұрын
This is how our teachers expect us to use math
@dakerbal
@dakerbal 2 күн бұрын
Excellent video. Something I did find a little unsatisfying in the previous video is that you went straight into the numbers/graphing instead of trying an analytical approach. Here you end up (unfortunately) with a cubic, which isn't very nice, but it does show (albeit this is already pretty obvious) that the optimum angle θ only depends on the ratio of the base radius to the slant length (r/l = a): sin³ θ + 2a sin² θ + (a² − 2/3) sin θ - a = 0 Sometimes an analytical approach gives better insights into how the solution would change as you change the parameters (although here it may not be as useful). Of course graphing is still super nice as a visualization.
@MathTheWorld
@MathTheWorld Күн бұрын
That is really nice. Yes, I should have emphasized that more. But on the bright side, you can use the general form you've created to solve the challenge problem at the end of the video!
@VeteranVandal
@VeteranVandal 2 күн бұрын
More like math oversauce.
@VeteranVandal
@VeteranVandal 2 күн бұрын
When you said "i thought I was the only person" i was like, "no shot, mate".
@Starwort
@Starwort 2 күн бұрын
I'm pretty sure the cross-sectional area is proportional to the volume of the solid of revolution iff you square the magnitude of the coordinates on the cross axis (e.g., the x axis when revolving around x = 0) before calculating the area, but that's a non-linear transformation so might be harder to optimise for than just working through the problem in 3d (e.g. a straight-line side would be transformed into a quadratic curve for area determination)
@johnacetable7201
@johnacetable7201 2 күн бұрын
Are you going to account for the different positions of fingers? Also will we account for the way he is transporting the sauce? I think moving sauce from side to side can help some sauce remain permanently in motion, never falling.
@ecMathGeek
@ecMathGeek Күн бұрын
If you vibrate the sauce fast enough, can you counter the viscous flow of the liquid? Seems like we need the science-guys of KZfaq to investigate this absurd proposition.
@ecMathGeek
@ecMathGeek Күн бұрын
Alternative solution: send the sauce into freefall and there won't be a technical limit to how much sauce the container can "hold."
@aiham_awd
@aiham_awd 2 күн бұрын
I wish I saw this on Sunday, could have helped me with my final exam
@josephdouglas5242
@josephdouglas5242 2 күн бұрын
This is a lesson in how good math can lead to wrong conclusions due to missing variables. There is a hidden stat that influences how fast a mini turbo charges up, and low speed/high acceleration carts usually have a better turbo stat than fast carts. Counterintuitively this means that slow carts in practice are actually faster when nothing is going wrong. It's the low acceleration carts that are better at catching up because their high speed gets multiplied by power ups (mushrooms, stars, etc) that are only available when you're losing.
@alex.g7317
@alex.g7317 2 күн бұрын
When you love ketchup but too cheap to get an extra paper cup:
@BTheFuck
@BTheFuck 2 күн бұрын
I personally think that you're trying to gaslight us into thinking you get laid when this whole video is an obviously testament to how you clearly don't.
@thebeardman7533
@thebeardman7533 2 күн бұрын
The next problem sounds like a physics problem
@NotKnafo
@NotKnafo 2 күн бұрын
all you need to to figure it out is to have as many glasses as there are folds, then pour water to the cup then empty it into one of the glasses and unfold one fold repeat that until you got all of them the fullest glass will correspond to the the optimized cup
@Jesusisnumberone5740
@Jesusisnumberone5740 2 күн бұрын
Homie did calculus to find out yoshi teddy was op
@JuegosLasTazas
@JuegosLasTazas 2 күн бұрын
Now remember the uneven ketchup and the ketchup that is put on top of another
@cadenbappy7408
@cadenbappy7408 2 күн бұрын
You should also make a video about the fastest a person could theoretically run.