From the F5 onwards, Anette has more power and colour than Amy Lee, for a simple reason: Anette is a soprano and Amy Lee is a mezzo-soprano. Amy Lee's F#5 is difficult for her and Anette is as if nothing had happened, the same goes for G#5... both are very good but they are different ranges........For those who say that Anette is not good live, Anette sang non-stop in many concerts, especially on the DDP tour, that was one of the reasons that Tuomas and Tarja clashed, the number of concerts they wanted to sing and those who could, Tarja, taking care of her voice, refused, Anette, who was the new one, accepted and that was the result of many terrible performances, but when her voice was rested it was spectacular.
@Ender_Bird_2 күн бұрын
What is the point? It's 2 different people, so it is clear that their voices will have their own strengths and weaknesses. You can't expect someone that sings different genres of music to have the same voice! Their belt won't be the same lol. Amy Lee will always be my favourite singer for her versatality and her style. 2:03 -> this is one of my favourite songs: Never Go Back (english is not my first language)
@mrallsundayy2 күн бұрын
Yeah their difference makes it beautiful. they are two good musicians i like them both. no bad intentions
@Ender_Bird_2 күн бұрын
@@mrallsundayy I totally agree. : ) It is not you making the video, but the comments being really mean that triggers me.
@feridedogan76533 күн бұрын
I still dont understand why she never sings in her head voice in the 2023 and 24 tours only in weight of the world.
@mrallsundayy2 күн бұрын
@@feridedogan7653 same 😢. It's a shame she doesn't use it often she is so good at it. She uses it on the end of the dream as well lately but i guess she is now more interested in more Rocky sound i like her more artistic and classic side too atm i would like to hear more stuff like that from her and this opening is very good it takes this song to another magical place 😭
@feridedogan76532 күн бұрын
@@mrallsundayy yes i know but they cut it even shorter the head voice part in end of the dream. I like her 2018 Version. She uses now more falsetto register than head voice because they newer music is very Rock. So she belts everything out. She still sounds amazing i just miss the softer parts as Lithium , sweet sacrifice some head voice or at least falsetto little bit lighter vocals than only belting. Is not healthy too.
@mrallsundayy2 күн бұрын
@feridedogan7653 yeah exactly i feel the same. She also had very good belts to during synthesis era in the end of the dream she managed to hit Eb5s and shatter me she hit high e5 belts so good also very good high head voice notes. i would like her to User her full potential on her voice 😁. And ı really like synthesis version of the weight of the world it's a shame we didnt get the studio version it would be better if they added that one rather then secret door it's a good song to but wotw is Just flawless
@heartolog3 күн бұрын
O M G 😮
@mrallsundayy6 күн бұрын
You can Watch the Full Remastered Video in my channel
@Dachikuna6 күн бұрын
საუკეთესო შესრულება ❤❤
@JmguyN86 күн бұрын
I really enjoyed this video I think it’s a fair comparison of both singers.
@mrallsundayy6 күн бұрын
@@JmguyN8 thank you so much 🥺💕
@leytonandrei8 күн бұрын
She's perfect!!
@LeslieLili8 күн бұрын
I remember this haunting opening . She did it in anywhere but home . Too bad she doesn't do it anymore....
@mrallsundayy8 күн бұрын
Me too! She absolutely needs to do this again it's just so beautiful
@willhunt27628 күн бұрын
I have never heard of this version before 😍
@cyrusjulian18710 күн бұрын
I’m so old I actually remember seeing this when it first showed on Conan. Time flies
@williamadkins217010 күн бұрын
Looks like a problem with heels & metal grating
@willhunt276210 күн бұрын
I love this song
@Bman202411 күн бұрын
I love this goddess so much!!! She can literally sing anything in any style. Her head voice always sends chills down my spine. 🖤🖤🖤
@luvkpopw11 күн бұрын
apenas amor por essa banda ❤❤🖤🖤
@ericrobertson202415 күн бұрын
Listen to these tracks .. Ghost + Reaper (Dark Element) , Beguile By Night ( Ultima Grace) , and Catcher Of My Dreams ( Anette Olzon Solo) ...Anette is superbly talented and her performances from 2007-24 are consistently phenomenal.
@shaynemckimber186915 күн бұрын
Anette is a much better belter than Amy. I can't believe this is even a comparison.
@ericrobertson202415 күн бұрын
Waiting on the comparison between Micheal Kiske and Billie Armstrong next...I don't understand this either, odd.
@larrylindgren948415 күн бұрын
No.
@shaynemckimber186914 күн бұрын
@@larrylindgren9484 Oh yes. Listen to The Escapist or To Whatever End and ask yourself if Amy can belt like that. The question isnt which singer do you prefer, but which one is the better belter. They are not even in the same class when it comes to belting in chest voice.
@Textand4414 күн бұрын
@@shaynemckimber1869watch the live performances and Come here again
@ericrobertson202413 күн бұрын
@@Textand44 You think the poster has some grudge against Amy Lee and did this just to ridicule her vocal and/or belting abilities ?? Comparing her to Olzon is utterly ridiculous...pregnant,toured to death,kidney stone suffering,ill Anette from June - Sept.2012 was still capable of belting that made Lee sound like Roger Waters LMAO
@ericrobertson202415 күн бұрын
Anette has released excellent albums with 7 different bands this century,she's phenomenal...I think of Amy in a much different manner but I don't know what the point of this was,it isn't flattering at all for her.
@shaynemckimber186915 күн бұрын
Anette can belt Amy out of the room. I can't believe this is a real comparison. 😂
@Textand4414 күн бұрын
I doesn't matter how much albums she does
@Textand4414 күн бұрын
@@shaynemckimber1869 and in what planet that is right lol
@ericrobertson202413 күн бұрын
@@shaynemckimber1869 Out of the earth lol....Its a silly comparison,,, I thought it was some joke but she/he actually posted clips and well it comes off as ridiculing Amy,, idk the actual purpose but that is the defacto result..
@lluiscadena279516 күн бұрын
Amy lee 100% esa voz que parece sacada de un mundo mágico y de fantasia tenebrosa que al mismo tiempo transmite esa paz no la tiene nadie del mundo, podria estar horas con evanescence a diferencia de otros grupos del estilo
@van363816 күн бұрын
😂😂😂😂 por dios es una ofensa a Amy Lee esta comparación 😂
@ericrobertson202415 күн бұрын
Yes if you actually listen,it really is an insult to Lee....I actually thought it was a parody or something...
@sonicandtoadettefan652316 күн бұрын
Pretty cool. Floor is non operatic, but rather a swing/jazz singer with some black metal and death metal growling and snarling vocals, wh8ch is how i headcanon Sonic the Hedgehog's vocals to be. (Im a sonic and mario fan)
@MetalRock316 күн бұрын
He didnt say sex and rock he said "seksenler rock" which means 80s rock.
@pyrathonia418516 күн бұрын
Anette is actually very good but Amy is much better imo
@andyp753917 күн бұрын
He was taking the piss
@Soturi9219 күн бұрын
What’s :23?
@mrallsundayy19 күн бұрын
@@Soturi92 romanticide
@Gamerbay201720 күн бұрын
What song is 20:05 and 21:07?
@mrallsundayy20 күн бұрын
@Gamerbay2017 20:05 is Break in. It's from the band Halestorm 21:07 is called I'll never be Ready from the band Veridia. both are duet versions with Amy Lee
@annelisunden48420 күн бұрын
Tarja from the start to the end🌟❤️
@jonf56621 күн бұрын
Best acoustic performance of this song! Soo good. I forgot what session this was from?
@mrallsundayy21 күн бұрын
Metal hammer 2020 live acoustic. I Just realized its been 4 years wow
@jonf56621 күн бұрын
@@mrallsundayy oh that’s right. The home pandemic session!
@angelcallejon820021 күн бұрын
The first one was out of tune. Too mich strength. The others perfect
@jmm510622 күн бұрын
Floor is very mature and positive towards each singer of nightwish. I greatly respect that of her! All three singers are fabulous in their own way
@evagomes159025 күн бұрын
She and Whitney houston have taught me how to sing in head voice.
@m8jesticc29 күн бұрын
woww
@mrallsundayy29 күн бұрын
Amen
@Alexander-mk4qf29 күн бұрын
Cringe fk
@Textand4429 күн бұрын
She sounds very good and brave in her after forever years ❤
@van3638Ай бұрын
Poder 🙄🙄🙄🤣🤣🤣
@kyungseokdo7339Ай бұрын
Floor é a patroa!
@nicolasacosta7185Ай бұрын
The ''yamate kudasai'' caught me off guard.
@rukpackАй бұрын
Wow
@ENB_OFFICIAL.Ай бұрын
That last "out" sound personal Like that came from deep inside of him
@Mars-is4unАй бұрын
🤗🍒🤘🏻 Great !
@mrallsundayyАй бұрын
@@Mars-is4un thanks 😁
@canditakerАй бұрын
The true queen of Metal..
@guilermepaesАй бұрын
What song at 26:32? 😅
@mrallsundayyАй бұрын
@@guilermepaes it's weight of the world but that version is synthesis exclusive
@belzorahollow3888Ай бұрын
The Scooby doo episodes are very important to her. I admire that in a WOMan