Well, there's a reason why noeul didn't make it as a kpop idol...

You have to admit that Sheesh song was soooo bad and embarrassing for James

First of all, Noeul can sing. He did a great job singing with the guy from The Masked Singer Thailand. Maybe that particular song wasn’t the best fit, but he's bilingual and sings beautifully in both Korean and Chinese. When he and Boss perform acoustic versions, they sound amazing. Noeul can definitely sing, though I'm not sure about the other two.

Why do BL actors have to have concerts, why all the concerts? Can't we have a fan meet without the concerts? Is it necessary for the BL actors to dance, act and sing? the series or films do not require dancing and singing but acting, I am sure the flier or advertising did not ask for singing or dancing unless it's a dancing or musical film. It must be tiring and frustrating for the actors to be on stage constantly.

Come on, Bright he is a good actor but not so great singer, i show u one 10 year old boy,he sing 100 time powerful than Bright, Sorry 🎉Asia Industry 🎉anyway ❤Thailand ❤Love from Austria

Honestly,the only bl actor that is talanted in both dancing and singing and is capable to become an idol is Barcode,go and watch his recent performances,its super amazing,its sad how underrated he is. If you need proof check his performance of Deja vu,Standing next to you and SIREN by Riize, or if you want to see him singing check any performance of his song No more dream,which he wrote himself. Hopefully more to come. Still wishing all of them success!

They were hating gun for kissing tay while me shipping them hard.. come on guys, they has good chemistry... I really love how tay treats gun... I too like offgun but, I like taygun more

Everyone is free to go for whatever career choice they want and attacking them for shifting is not ok. That said, this forced idol things every BL actor is doing now is tired, Kpop already gets the criticism of picking people based on looks that can't sing constantly and there's no nice way to say this, a lot of them cannot sing or dance better than the average person. My thing is, if the actor was just a regular person, you couldn't see what they look like, would anyone actually listen to 99% of these BL idol songs? Absolutely not, and everyone knows it's true, the few of them that actually sing at a level to be a professional singer are as rare as a literal unicorn. So for me I don't like it because I think the person should have the skills to qualify for the job without their looks, like the majority of them are good enough at acting to not get this criticism there but so few of them are trained in singing and dancing and it badly shows. I wish these companies stopped forcing it. Only make them an idol if they actually have the skills to sing and/or dance at that level. Loads of people are passionate about music or acting or whatever and never get the chance even if they have the skills so I don't think it's unfair for people to say "Oof, this sounds bad, are you sure this is a good idea?", sometimes the truth hurts. I don't think they shouldn't get the same criticism any regular upcoming singer would get. I'm sure Bright was embarrassed but that happened because he wasn't qualified to be up there yet, the others are trained. The pretty privilege is hard to feel bad for.

At first when i saw bl series and see their fan service i thought they were real... bcz i wasn't recognised with fan service... but when i knew about fan service than i just enjoy their series bcz i know they're just co actors

I am a huge huge hugeee Jeff fan but I disagree with what he said, that cannot be taken as an excuse for "SINGERS" not being about to SING! The fans paid a lot of money not to hear that kind of singing and instead of criticizing the fans they should work on themselves, Jeff is such a great singer, I understand that he is just trying to support Bright but those mistakes cannot be done in front of fans who spent lots of money to hear you sing! Maybe a little more no I mean a lot more practice is appreciated ☺️

Please remember for all of us and I mean all of us .. everything we do - all our work related experiences and some life experiences are stepping stones for future work roles - these guys are no different - they are young and searching and experimenting .. what do you expect him to at the age of 60 having lead roles in bl drama with his current bl partner .. please!!!!

With no hate at all at any of them, I'd say, Bright needs better vocal training and so does James and a numberrrr of BL stars that sing. A vocal coach once said everyone can sing if trained, honestly she stated that one might not be as talented as the gifted singers but they would at least sound better. For me though,most BL idols can't sing. Only Nunew, Jeff , Blikin, and Maybe Banky or Fort can sing naturally. Also not every artist is a performer. Jimin BTS had trouble performing and singing,he had to work on that because he kept losing his breath. Those comments are quite harsh but there's truth in all of them. I will support them if they decide to be idols, it is never too late to archive one's dreams but they need a lot of work if they are going to make it.

I that he’s with Tu

באיזה דרמה הם שיחקו?

honestly Brights biggest mistake was together. us thirsty ass beeches were simping over it and never realised he clearly never wanted to be there.

The singing was horrendous but the backlash was undeserved. People can let their unsatisfaction be known without trying to tear a person down

Sorry, I have to say I agree. All three mentioned in the video could use more training before going out to perform. Get a better team of trainers. Sometimes just because our passion is there doesn't mean the talent is.

Fourth is amazing singer

People, actors are humans too! They are not toys made for your entertainment. Stop with this whole shipping crap. It's abuse!

GULF ?

In simple prose, we've heard that Art imitates life and vice-versa. KWILLs MV comeback song its 12-yr gap, a continuation frm 2012 PD to the 2024 'infamous' NoSadSongformyBrokenHeart are both double-blow, a cruel twists infamy! MV and beautiful ballad with its deep, meaningful, sad lyrics gotten moi completely breakdwn, sobbing till eyes swollen!😭. Why? Song and its mv evoke a somewhat similar memory of 15 yrs ago. KWills PD and NSSFMBH are in reality in terms of its core story, its gist is not only relatable but in real-life events, it happened. Both MVs and songs narrated own personal queer lovestory of not knowing, naive(?) or too young to know how to handle, to respond to one's bestie's, own version of SeoInguks mv character. When your bestie expressed and show love suddenly, though own feelings unaware, unconscious buried deep, brewing inside only to suddenly be awakened realising he's the one and only except 15 yrs too late, too little and can't be undone to regain that one true lost love! Immatured and scared, confused to handle an unfamiliar first love? But then there's a 3rd party to divert one's attention to the heart's true love feeling. Ahn Jaehhyun admitted he's quite aware of SIGs feelings but probably chose to ignore or not taken seriously or like moi didn't know how to respond, but only 12 yrs later, it became a big emo-regret mistake. That AJHs last tunnel scene depicts a slow but sudden realisation (his eyes reveal the realisation). It's so relatable except will it be too late for him??? Time-loop and multiuniverse/ dimensions might be the solution for Pt3. OJeez, dont have such advantage of time loop jump in real life or else I would scour thru all multiuniverse in search of own lost-love and confessed and apologise for being such a love fool fearing to rush in where angels fear to tread cuz i aint no angel just a mortal! KWills MV haunts and hounds me by evoking painful, hurtful memories of once being in love yet denying the feeling as 'Stupid is as stupid does!' - ForrestGump. A proof, KWills mv it's not its director/producer mere created lovestory fantasy from a lyrical ballady narratives. In real life, it happens whether or perhaps a similar lovestory ending or nuances of it. Let's wait for KWills MV Pt3, though in actual life, quite wishful thoughts lostlove can be love regained, though one can wish upon the star to be reconnected!🌟🌟🌟😞

if im not mistaken dont you have to go through training to become an idol with a legit company. and it takes a while, how did they jump a head. did we miss a step. didnt santa try that and had to bring his happy butt right back to acting. it kinda a slap in the face to others who have given up everything to put in the work, an still might not even debut. i dont want to see james anymore, im on the fence with him. he caused problems with bailing out of a movie. wasnt it almost done. i honestly think there was more to it that hes not saying as to why his not with net. and whats wrong with gmmtv's staff. isnt there someone in these rehearsals that notice that the song is not working with the artist. are they tone deaf as well. they should be fired for letting their artist even go out on stage embarrassing themselves like that. seems these companies are that hard up for money.

Bright 💔Win

I feel so sad when i think of yizhan. The way their ship was put to an end is just heartbreaking. I truly hope they are still great friends off cam.

😂but come one grown ass man don't kiss eachother on the lips...Or DO THEY?

Im American, and at no point in our fandom would we presume to dictate who our stars date or not. It's astronomically mind blowing that international "fans" think they have a right to dictate a performers private life! HELLO PEOPLE! *PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT* These men are *ACTORS* !! Hence the definition of the word is to "Pretend to embody the behavior and attitudes of the character that someone else has created"!! Get your heads out of your asses, get lives, and just sit back and enjoy the *entertainment* that has been presented for your viewing pleasure. Also, if you can't differentiate between reality and fiction please seek a mental health professional before you do any real harm.

not my Noeul...😭😭😭 At least he can sing better than the two.. and his rap is not bad..

NJ break my heart 💔 Until now I still can’t move on from NJ ❤️‍🩹

People need to stay out of their fucking business you are just a fan you are not a part of the personal lives so stay out of it people being butt hurt about the situation between mew and tay is so disgusting you are not their friend you don't know them let them be and they're not real life couples this is ridiculous and people need to stay out of their fucking business

I don't like actors lying to their fans, and fan service is lying. There is no reason any actors should act like they are dating their costars "in real life", and far too many of them do it. Think of TharnType - talk about over the top fan service. Even I was starting to believe it, and I never believe any of these guys are even gay, much less interested in their costars. Most BL actors are heterosexual and many use the BL industry to launch other careers. That's ok up to a point, but I think it also means that there isn't an interest in many of these actors to bring BL characters to life to tell wonderful love stories. It's just getting a foot in the door for other stuff. Actors who over-promote their "love" for their costars get the most attention & money, but are they really the best people to tell these stories? Do they even care about the parts they are playing? This causes a lot of these so-called ships to fall apart, then it's always the fans fault. Sorry but no. It's the actor's fault along with their managers who take advantage of the desire for LGBTQ audiences to see their world represented on screen. I have a big problem with most of it.

Some of these fans dy craze!!!

Waiting for new poohpavel edit❤

Ohmnanon broke me like no other couple can fix me😢

When i saw Noeul and James boyband line up, i kinda have some hope with Tung thatkawin for the vocal because he's a good singer when he was under starhunter ent. But for the rest i think most of them are dancer. I saw james and noeul dance and thats not bad. But this is boyband and all of them must be sing 😭 I still confuse why DMD let James left the project and focus in the boyband. But at the same time i understand why dmd only debuting Nunew and Tommy. Both of them are the most talented singer under DMD and didnt give the other any debuting. For Bright, i think most of the actor must be understand like i know he sang 2gether ost and has a lot of view. But not everyone listen to this song because of the singer but i can be someone only has nostalgia with the series or maybe just like the song. Its just my opinion and sorry for bad english 🙏🏻

Pooh my baby ❤️❤️❤️❤️

I find it crazy that acting is where Thai BL actors make the least of their money as they are paid so badly. Random BL industry questions: Do BL actors from different production companies every mingle? Which actor has the best management team?

Well to be honest they might not sing well but they can act well and Jeff is right they are not singing machines its not that i want bright ,noeul or any other bl actors to sing perfectly i just need to hear the clarity and stable voices and of course on key that's important to singing

If Bright's records a single, he should leave it in the trashcan of the studio.

Yo pienso que ellos deben ser consientes y darse cuenta si realmente tienen la voz y talento para cantar , el publico merece respeto . Jef Satur actua y canta hermoso . No solo es cantar por cantar .

Time will tell if they can succeed as singers i agree that some cant sing and naybe they stick to what theyre good at

You, are right on the money! They can’t sing .

But why can't their close friends and family tell them,ISTG,i know them friends feel embarrassed like we do...

Most of them can't even sing.

Chile we all know they love a good white wash kpop esk theme plastered on all their talent so its no surprise that they'll throw talemt on a stsge sounding like nails on a chalk board by way of two cats mounting each other 😂

Bright comes from an exceptionally wealthy family and is so bland and uninteresting as a human being! Jeff Satur is the only true singer/composer of note!

I'm not into contemporary music that much, but even I can hear that when NuNew, Satang, Jeff, Billkin, Gawin sing, it hits me differently. These are my just my preferences, but maybe people love Bright and that's okay too.

SOME ACTORS CAN NOT SING

Gosh I was there at The Kingdom concert my favourite song was kinda ruin and tbh. I could not get that sentence he sings out of my head it keep hunting me it was the peek part and should be most important part of the song but it was ruined. and cmon Jeff can't talk shit about other in public you know he is too nice to talk shit I mean no one (in industry)did talk about that coz if they did talk shit about singing off key stuff ya all know what will happen next.

I really love James but I think he doesn’t have a good vocal 😢I think he needs more vocal training before he can be debut. And yes GMMTV,I think that company need to stop forcing their actors to sing 🎤 because most of them really have a bad voice 🥱and let them focused on their acting