Comparing carr with winston and dalton is just plain stupid at this point, if those were drafted by the raiders they wouldnt have lasted more than 3 years in the league. The bucs were a sb roster and that defense wouldve been number 1 in the league if not for winston giving away 35+ turnovers, brady went there and won easy. Dalton also had great teams that were xonstantly in the playoffs and he was the weak link nd got exponed every single time

Carr best version is a mvp candidate andes shown múltiple times, in 2016 he was the mvp favorite before breaking his leg, in 2020 he was in the conversatiom before their defense imploded and he still broke the recird of wins when a defense allows 30ppg (even outplaying mahomes at arrowhead), and in 2021 he was the early mvp favorite beating mahomes and Allen for offensive player of the month before losing gruden, ruggs and another 7 starters on offense. What those seasons had in common is that he had a good o line, a speedster and a good contested catcher along with defenses not being historically bad, he doesnt have that in nola

Good to hear you two talking Saints again. Congrats to y'all on the podcast

I'll address your 2 concerns or problems with Carr. The first one being inconsistency. Where does consistency start on a team, especially for a quarterback? Coaching, pass protection, and a balanced offense. Even in Oakland/LV, Carr rarely had any of the above. Yet, he still put up franchise record setting numbers and is on the all-time NFL qb lists in multiple categories. Look no further than Stafford and Baker. Stafford was called a stat-padder, and he only had those stats because he was throwing to Megatron. Then, he goes to a team with better coaching, a top 10 offensive line, and a better rushing attack, and he wins a Super Bowl. Baker Mayfield was on his 4th team in 4 years, but they had a top 10 offensive line, a good coach, and a legit running game. Suddenly, he's everyone's favorite. Conversely, look at when Mahomes' line was struggling November 20th to December 25th. They lost 4 out of 6 games, and he looked terrible. Against the Raiders, he had a fumble 6 and a pick 6 within 5 seconds of each other. So, even he struggled to be consistent despite a top 5 defense and a future Hall of Fame coach. The 2nd thing you mentioned was leadership. This one really blows me away. Was he not supposed to yell at a receiver for jogging multiple times? Was he not supposed to say something to his line that blew their protection and were directly responsible for him getting injured more than he has his entire career? On that particular play, he called out the mike linebacker correctly, and Ruiz whiffed on the block. Sure, he messed up protection calls on occasion, but what quarterback doesn't? Saying he has to win a Super Bowl or be a top 10 quarterback to "earn that right" is utterly ridiculous. When Will Levis yelled at DeAndre Hopkins last year, he was immediately praised for his leadership.

Raider fan and i can say that no qb would've succeeded with a clown of a. Owner one of the worst roster in the nfl during his time with us drama all the time is he prime Brady no but if you run the ball and protect him great things will happen im rooting for you guy's give dc a ring

I came to simply laugh at the title of this video.

He has to win the division

I do need DA to say confidently that we will sweep the falcons or something sly to get some strength/confidence back with players and fans. If you gonna be soft you gotta be hard, it's a balance. At least say confidently that we should win the division or I need to go.

I can't believe I'm about to say this but I do hope he succeeds. I actually think this team will be really good. Kubiak has a bunch of solid football players which will cause defensive coordinators fits. You really have to game plan around taysom now.

All the hype has been on Rattler but Jake Haener is the future. The Saints gave up two 4th round picks and a 7th round pick to draft Jake but didn't give up shit for Rattler. In fact, they had 4 5th round picks so if they were so high on Rattler why didn't they trade up when he dropped all the way to the 5th. They could have traded up to the 3rd or the 4th or to the top of the 5th but they didn't. Jake is smarter (goes through his progressions much faster than Rattler) and is much more accurate!

#TeamHaener

I am going for Jake he was there last year he needs to be 2nd string,but he should be starting QB that make better choices in Carr dose.

you forgot about J.T. Gray on this list

Pay AK41

And the day this premiered, Saints waived one of the DB's, Faion Hicks!

I believe he’s the future of our TE room. Maybe I am reaching, but I see a poor mans Shockey here. He’s not a WR so I don’t need him to run 4.3. Can he make the tough catches over the middle? Does he run with a lot of attitude behind those pads when he does decide to run after catch? He’ll be just fine.

With the Juwan Johnson injury, Holker has a much better chance of making the final 53 man roster!

I’m in a wait and see with Fosky. But he does seem more mature now.

My experience of being a Saints fan for 58 years warns me to be doubtful, but my intuition tells me that the Saints are going to have a very good year, WHO DAT!!!

"ACCOUNTABILITY" ........

What team did this ol coach come from?

Wow a real line coach . He was referring to the injuries for sure . He was behind last yr

As a very longtime Saints fan, I refuse to drink the Koolaid because the O-lines and the D-lines are comparatively weak. Until those areas prove themselves to be consistently good, the Saints will be average at best.

I know we have an easy strength of schedule, but we play some really good teams this year especially at the beginning of the season.

Derek Carr and Dennis Allen bring carrer loosers gives me pause as well but I have heard all of the same podcasts you have, I love this new offensive coaching staff so far.

I am of the same mind frame as you, but I have been burnt the last 3 off-seasons so, I will need to see it ti truly believe it.

I forget to set this video as a premiere, so no live chat tonight! Definitely user error on my part & apologies for being a dumb*ss 😁

DA still coach?

I am happy about the offensive changes the only thing that bothers me is DA.. 😊

Man I can’t wait to see Taysom Hill, Alvin Kamara, Jamaal Williams and Kendre Miller in this new offense we implementing, but it’s all predicated on the o-line getting their blocks and making those creases in the line because we know if you give AK a crease he’s gone, now some excitement in the offense since Drew Brees retired.

I like how you broke everything down I think has going to put his twist on it and some input from his daddy

I definitely agree with the match up as a group..i will even give us the edge..😮😮

I think Kubiak is a high level offensive coach. Will be a head coach soon. Saints could have a huge tear. Carr is perfect for this offense. Olave , Hill, Miller and shaheed should love this

It’s just nice to see change and implementing a scheme that puts the skill guys in the best spot to succeed, I can’t wait. After hearing olave say that klints calling plays that makes him open is awesome. We’re finally moving on!

It's something very different, but in my opinion, it's more believable to bring success. It almost feels like we have arrived from the Stone Age to the new way of winning football culture on offense.

Let’s go Tim! Great Take Brother! Who Dat!

Support your boy saints fan, give the man a like and a comment. We need more intelligent fan perspectives. Otherwise we hear either sunshine or neg from the media. It’s hard to determine what is real

This is something I wrote on Saintsreport. (Comments) We lost to all of the good teams that we played. Jax, Det, GB, Tx. were all close games. Which showed we were a good team. But we got smoked vs the Shannan tree in Minn and the Rams. This told us, we need a new OC period, if we want to be a GREAT team. We showed heart at the end beating TB and ATL. TB was our most impressive win becaue they advanced in the playoffs. But they were technically 8-8 at the time. Which makes the above cherry picked statement, that we didn’t beat a winning team, true. Regardless of the past, this team brilliantly realized what it needed to do, and did exactly that. They hired the Godfathers Son and his henchmen of the system that has been repetitively rocking us for years. One thing you have to give them credit for, when they realize that they have a need, they go out and fill that need ASAP with quality. I truly have hope in the Saints this year. My only concern is how fast can our offense absorb this new system into their DNA.

What’s up Tim. KK is the Godfathers son and his coaches he brought in are his henchmen

Facts

So AT Perry 40 yard dash is 4.47. Alvin Kamara had a 4.56 40 yard dash time. Kendre Miller's last 40 yard dash was a 4.58. Chris Olave ran a 4.39 official 40 yard dash the combine. Bub Means ran a 4.42 40 yard dash. Just to give you guys an idea.

In 2021 Jon Gruden started out as the coach but had to step down Rich Bisashi took over. DC threw for 4800 yards and 23 TDs. Made the playoffs and he played but lost the game.

It was 2014 when DC had 3900 yards 32 TDS and broke his leg before there playoff game. He didn't play in the playoff game and they lost. That was the year he was looked at as a possible MVP. Jake Del Rio was the coach.

Was looking forward to a vid like this one especially after JW said “we’re bringing Sf offense here”. I’m excited about it. Kyle probably adds tweaks to it annually and like you said builds upon it. I know that we can’t be where they are with it in year one. But I’m hoping we can put together something successful together quickly. We do seem ti have the players, so that’s a great start

PENNING WILL STEP UP THIS YEAR ⚜️

Offensive lineman only has problems when they don’t have no direction nor taught discipline sounds like coaching.

Thanks for a more perspicacious interpretation on what John Bolton means in this interview- I’ve seen other videos that included this same &A but lacked any insightful reasoning about why it could work for the personnel we have - especially Trevor- it fits with what I’ve heard from Kubiak and I think you interpreted what they are thinking much better than Matt, Ross etc. What you are saying makes sense to me and makes hope for an interesting productive season seem reasonable.

Taysom Hill is a baller...period...Klint is having wet dreams with the ways he can use Hill, Kamara, Olave as well as Jimmy Graham (if he re-signs)

As long as they learn the learning curve 😂

Ruiz was a center in College n never should’ve been expected to change his position without some hang ups..All this negativity towards Penning is sad..Give him a chance..Bad luck as injuries