TB hitting animations are way better, more realistic, just need to fix player movement and gameplay and will be perfect!

I have a question. I don't know when to press and hold the button until it turns green. Can you explain when is the optimal time to press the shot button so the ball lands near the line? Even when I hit it on green, the ball doesn't land near the line. TOP spin 2k25 its my first tennis game thats why i have so simple question.

Topspin looks better, especially courts, however the roster needs 20 more players added with custom animations

Tiebreak is the best

Alcaraz in Topspin looks like Pete Sampras hahahha

Call me crazy but I think the ball movement in Tiebreak is too fast. Topspin is slow but the player movement is realistic as opposed to hurky jurky movement of Tiebreak trying to keep up with ball speed. It might not be sexy to the eye showing down ball movement but maybe the only way it can work right.

Volleys are not allowed?

In the last few days, i cannot get myself into playing TS as i have been more invested in TB, due to rosters, faster gameplay, player models and details... (tiny things, like Nadal touching his forehead with sweatbands a thousand times before serving) Also TS feels very unbalanced playing online, unless you manage a perfect shot right on the line, you cannot win a point it seems, maybe in TB winners do feel more rewarding? The only thing i dont like about TB are the ball physics and court graphics, the only point that keeps me from actually buying the game. Also maybe player movement. However, if TB is going to get the attention TS so desperately needs and should it get some fixed and corrections, we are up for the best tennis game out there.

Both games are fun, but neither are great. Still, for attention to the right details, I prefer Tiebreak. When you're not abusing slices, it feels like the game rewards actual tennis strategy a little more than TK. It also looks better - good player design, and I think it's HUGE that they include the players' real stroke animations - especially serve. I do prefer the serving mechanics in TK though, and the timing meter was fun, but I think the timing meter might be why it feels like the players are standing still a little too long before they hit the ball. TK got old after a few weeks for me, but if TB improved the AI difficulty, the game would go from a C- to A+

Looks like the meter is deciding your timing. I see a lot of reds which means it wasn’t timed perfectly. Think we need to keep it under the green

Awesome video. You might find that I’m crazy but my favourite is tennis elbow 4

I am really curious where these games creators are getting their feed back from. All Big Ant Studios had to do was fine tune AO tennis 2 and they could have created a great game. Instead they have again tried to change things that didn’t need changing and didn’t fix the glitches that occur in the game. The double trigger was not needed. Could have easily had one trigger do both sides, return to the serving and shot timing similar to tennis World tour, and they could have made a game that would have blown TopSpin simply because of its roster. it’s frustrating.

Well, its still TS2k25. Animation movement of Tiebreak are really off. It looks just a game instead of real tennis. Tiebreak movement is not smooth. If you cannot see the abrupt movement of players of Tiebreak, you have problem with your eyes. Topspin movements are well captured, smooth and simply realistic. Stadium, well only blind can say that Tiebreak is better than Topspin, hahaha. Gameplay, it obvious, TS is better. Ball movement of Tiebreak is floaty while Topspin is more realistic. Player graphics during play are similar to both TS and Tiebreak. Bet somebody will disagree, but thats the reality. The only good player graphics of Tiebreak is when not in game. Somebody may say the Topspin court in video is washout but I think its in the recording perhaps, in actual game its just ok. I bet Tiebreak will never put a goood cloth and hair animations. And more Topspin clay surface is more realistic with its very realistic foot marks during play.

Bro this game is horrible movement serve return involves no skill Still top spin 5 is a great game

Su topspin manca solo la modalità torneo e il numero di tennisti disponibili ..altrimenti sarebbe il numero uno in assoluto

Tiebreak is almost the perfect tennis game if only they could fix the movement and the AI

I think both have some better qualities than the other but overall it looks like Topspin2k25 is still better. For me, I feel like topspin could improve its flaws quicker and more easily than Tiebreaks. Some sort of amalgamation of both games would be perfect. I thought Tiebreak would have been better or a much closer rival as the graphics and first look videos looked pretty decent, but seeing them like this Topspin2k25 appears much better in its Gameplay. 2k really have an opportunity to make this the best and are failing miserably by not listening to past and present fan base. Thanks for the video, great to see them side by side for an honest comparison ❤

Topspin is the same game from 2014, with poor roaster. I think the problem of ts is, this game doenst make me want to play.. its too repetitive, especially because all players and matches appears the same. Just pushing balls, no challenge, and no ID player. I will try Tiebreak, we need to admit that they are doing a very good job.. if we have continued upgrades, can be a very nice game.

its like players are slipping through the court in TB, Topsin has better animations but more arcade, if TB corrects the gameplay and animations is going to be the best tennis game ever

It's funny to me that TopSpin had Federer motion capturing his groundstrokes and serve yet the animation of his serve in Tiebreak feels much more accurate. The gameplay like the movement, and ball physics and stuff, everything during the point feel better in TopSpin, but there's a lot to be said for the players themselves feeling truer to life in Tiebreak. Like Alcaraz feels much more like Alcaraz based on his animations and physicality in Tiebreak than TopSpin. Very annoying that for some reason no tennis game seems capable of having the best of both of these games in one, like how hard can it be really.

Easy: The tenniscourts and crowd look way better in Top Spin. Generally I think the playermodels do look better in Tiebreak. Especially the hitting animations are way better. They are more true to life. The sounds are also easy to place. The grunts in Top Spin are horrible and not realistic. Cartoonish at best. In Tiebreak they are better. The sound of the ball being hit is also a bit better in Tiebreak. Gameplaywise cant say anthing about Tiebreak because I havent played it but I think Top Spin is only OK and nothing to rave about. There have been better Top Spin games in the series than the new one.

I've now played both and I prefer tiebreak on my initial impressions. It's just a much more immersive tennis experience, all the animations, and realistic player movements are so nice. I prefer TS for career mode due to the grand slam licensing, but TB for general play

Where are the ball boys and umpires

Tiebreak con gli Sprite é decisamente meglio top spin 2k molto meglio come grafica

They need to merge these games and add the ball physics from TE4 or Full Ace, then we’d be sorted

Tiebreak 🔥👏🏽 It needs some fixes here and there but it's clearly superior

It’s honestly hard to pick a standout between the two games right now because one has what the other needs 😅 Great vid!

Tiebreak is eventually going to be the best tennis game out there with long support and corrections.

Topsin becomes more arcade with each update, while TieBreak becomes more simulation.

It’s no contest. TB has beautiful player models, best roster ever & nice graphics but gameplay is so broken. TS miles better. TB animations, movement, serve & flat shot all messed up. TS gameplay is very good but player models are pretty bad. They need to merge lol. Nice videos.

Hey reef I love your vids I had to sub and I think the tiebreak gameplay is way better topspin isn’t it anymore great vid!

We're getting closer to 1000 subs! Sub if you're new (please :)!

I know the gameplay is slower than topspin but this is actually closer to what real would be. Especially on slow red clay.

I have to to get it . wait until September 3 to get it . I traded in topspin 252k for the fact that the physics of the ball changed when they did the update . Horrible update and career mode BS . Getting tiebreak though need my tennis fix 😮

this game is the same old crap of tennis world tour and ao tennis, just making same shitty tennis games with different title names but same crap.

is crappy big ant studios on this game, because that company is shit.

I’m enjoying it thus far. I liked the AO Tennis series also. There’s going to be the usual haters in the comments section but if I had listened to those bed wetters in the past, I would have missed out on some amazing games throughout my lifetime. Moral to the story, form your own opinions. #IgnoreTheNegativityOfShills

This game is retarded. The logic of the game makes no sense. What is the point of using topspin in a game called TOPSPIN when it does nothing for your game. All the AI are broken and the net play is atrocious.

Looks terrible. Playing like half speed of a real tennis match. Full ace tennis simulator is almost half the price of this one and definetely superior game.

How do you get prime nada and Federer?

Based on this release of Tiebreak, I can say that animation in Topspin is more realistic. In Topspin, I can see the real movement of a tennis player and the gameplay is still better for me. In Tiebreak, clay footmarks and grass marks should be there where the longer the time of play the more the marks will be and clothes physics is not yet there.

The ball lands the same spots on each direction, all shots

question from a starter: i see u doing almost powershots only.......what about controlled shots? do u use them? and when?

First impressions. I dislike left and right triggers. I like the tennis serve animations but when you try to speed the game up between points you automatically trigger the serve and then have to wait until it completes and start again. Its just little things that can be tweaked. The game isn't terrible and I love the roster and likenesses.

It would be so great if both games could come together and take parts of each and finally give us a great game. They are both on the right track, but both games need some tweeking.

As for me I really like it, looks real in rallies, besides a complete roster. I'm gonna buy it

ruud better than nadal

Game looks half decent tbf.. roster, player models and AI... beats Top Spin 👀

No Rybakina is criminal

Trash