If you take Shelter From The Storm, she rescued him. Here, she has sent him back out into the rain.

The Rock and Roll Circus was something The Rolling Stones put together and invited a lot of the big bands at the time. At the end you see Brian Jones whistling. Brian was one of the original Rolling Stones who, unfortunately, died from an OD and drowned in a pool, probably shortly after this was made.

Listen to the studio version. This was a live, looser version on the road..

Bob is the original proponent of MLM. That's Multi Layered Messaging...

Do you know that you say "literature" just like Bob? Are you from the same neck of the woods as him?

No it's Bob, end of.

Also, belly-laced?

Did he just completely miss that at the most basic level, the narrator is walking in the woods and came upon some ruins?

The ''windmill'' was Pete's thing. But he did say that he would often rip off his thumbnail doing it.

Ah so you left the single most rational and intellectual system of thought without learning almost any real philosophy to become an edge lord. Great.

I have vivid memories of my 21st Birthday party listening in to a very drunk good friend explaining to my dad (in confidence, thinking that nobody else could hear) that he had fallen in love with a prostitute in Marseille whilst travelling on a student trip around Europe and she would be the love of his life for ever and a day. Guess it happens

This isn't just about a break up between girl and boy -- it's a nasty divorce involving 5 children. An emotionally crippling event for anyone.

Nothing "in-depth" about this when you're just stating your baseless opinions. You've unintentionally displayed your utter lack of understanding of what a cult is, and how it differs from religion, and it's extremely apparent that you have a very minute grasp of true Catholicism, and you spout of nonsense you've heard else where from others who also don't have a clue what they're even talking about.

no matter how noble it may appear or holy, anyone who dares identify as catholic but is not in communion with the successor of st. peter, or is in denial of his legitimacy, and obstinately disobedient of the magisterium, will find himself out of the barque of st. peter and drowning in the chaos of heresy and schism. his piety become meaningless

I learned about REAL church history when I stopped listening to other atheists tell me about it.

Drink the Atheist Kool Aid for the Atheist cult.

How's that atheist LGBTQ cult working out for you? Your problem isn't the Catholics...it's in the mirror.

SSPX is not traditional Catholicism.

Kirk, your interview style feels incredibly disingenuous. You're talking to someone who agrees with you, but you're so self centered that you will not let him finish a thought. You're like a poorly written marvel movie with how many quips you use. If you want to conduct a proper discussion, you should let your guest advance their ideas in a fruitful manner without interruption.

Oh nice, a jew and an apostate LMAO

My objections: 2:42 If you use that definition, can't anything be a cult? Can't schools be a cult because kids having a "difference of their own reasoning mind towards the authority of another" like a teacher? The word "cult" is hard to use. Many think it is this bad word or word for crazy. Like Connor says, when people say "cult" one things of jones town. But many can use the term like "Taylor swift has a cult following". I think the most simplest definition of cult for the topic of this video is the elevation of a singular person to a God like status. This person indulges on ego and claims they are the top. Excellent examples are Hitler. People hailed his name as a greeting. People called him the leader. People did not think twice to his orders and all viewed him as a God. Even better is the dynasty in N.Korea. He is their God. Based on this definition it is hard to claim people like the Pope are cult leaders because they don't fit the narrative. The Pope doesn't claim to be God, rather the "Vicar". Like Christ, he humbles himself by washing the feet of those who view him as master. So one can't even say Christ is cult leader. There was no earthly glory. People questioned his teachings and disobeyed. People killed him. It's like saying is MLK a cult leader? He led many. Of course not, because just like the pope or Christ and unlike the definition of a cult, he didn't seek to escalate his status and glory. All i can say is without much reason (and i say that because this video is so full of many topics) is he's basing the reality of an idea (christianity) off the failures and dark areas of individuals. Kinda a "i didn't like how this person did it so im making it invalid". I mean if i wanted to learn science, am i going to look deep into why it teaches what it teaches, or look into the personal life of scientists? I rather look into how the man split the atom and not how he had a love affair.

are we sure that's Bob Dylan singing? (sounds different...

Thanks for putting this together. I do have to say, the flow of the interview was all over the place. Earlier on, you were pushing a lot against the religion(s). While he was just trying to setup his background and get to his time at the "cult" and how he got out, you interrupted a lot. Then you tried to rush him because it was taking too long (which you contributed a lot to).

Shane McGowan said he just wanted to write a song with the word pissky in it. I think he's laughing at our attempt to try and understand lol

Really interesting conversation! Thanks Kirk and Connor. And I feel like I need to validate Connor's perspective that homeschooling is absolutely widely used as a vehicle for "parent's neuroses", as you said, and a lot of parents go down a kind of radicalization slope that gets worse when they begin homeschooling. They become more enmeshed in their ideology because usually that's where they are getting their homeschooling materials, support, and community, so it is directly related to their choice to homeschool. Unfortunately, the children get the brunt of the negative impact when that happens. However - I also agree that those are ultimately parenting issues rather than schooling issues. Most parents do want their kids to get a good education, and I think as more good materials and support communities become available radicalization becomes less of a problem (fortunately it's not the 90's/early 00's anymore out here).

You don't have to be a good singer to sing. If you enjoy it, sing!

Pete Townshend saw the Rolling Stones doing a soundcheck once and saw Keith Richards doing the windmill move with his arm and thought he played guitar like that. It turns out Keith was just limbering up and Pete mistook it for a playing technique. It became his signature from then on.

MANET OR MONNET OR BOTH PAINTERS

I have a simple request Lupe fiasco released a new album by the name of samurai. The concept is a lyrical portrait of Amy winehouse if she lived to be a rapper. I think you’d be pleasantly surprised at the level of artistry.

I request you play PAINT IT BLACK by The Rolling Stones

Noice

This is the composer’s (guitarist Pete Townshend) early attempts at writing a long form piece (the term now known as rock opera). One of the band’s mangers at the time was the son of classical conductor and quire familiar with classical music and opera. Pete was becoming less interested in composing standard pop tunes and didn’t know how to write a seven minute song that told a singular story. That band manager (Kit Lambert) told Pete that if he couldn’t write a seven minute song just write a few songs that were 2:50 in length and stitch them together. That’s how this particular song came to be….

Great conversation!

I don't think it's jerald is it? I used to hear jello, but apparently it's something else that I can't quite remember yet.

ps: there is NO comparison to Bob Dylan .. one of a kind. #theMaster

My favorite rock lyricist is Bruce Springsteen. Probably the greatest illustration of his genius is the song Jungleland.

Best reaction I’ve heard.👍

Irish American wake where a car is being stolen outside inside everyone is getting ready to send the body back to Ireland and then the story of big jim

interesting version - not the blood on the tracks take.

It is really beautiful

I knew at the chapter "the whiteness of the whale" that the story was one of misotheistic rebellion. The freaks who denounce it as proto-Fascism are closer than they think. Ahab is, in a sense, the Eren Jaeger of his time

The fun of Dylan is allowing yourself to join him in this exploration of not only what the words mean literally but what they conjure up in your mind. Olajohansson touches it for me or maybe his wife's comment that it is brings up the inability to connect just based on a simple twist of fate. The spark starts the connection but then it falls apart-is not that the risk of any relationship? Enjoy the search!

where do you get vaultz trappers from ?

There’s a great version, which may have been included in the Biograph set, where his dogs bark as if on cue. And just as every grain of sand was planned and numbered in the universe of this song, so too must those barks been intended. At least it feels that way to me.

So many good Dylan songs for you to dive into

If that's the first time you listened to it then you missed half the song

You are so distracted and distracting

Now do his song Blind Willie McTell

the only thing more annoying than someone who stops the song every couple of sec.s , is someone who insists on talking during the song . i know it's your vid., but show some class cause it's bobs song. try playing the song uninterrupted, then go back and replay it stopping it as much as you want to point out whatever you want , sounds like a win/win. the songs are not that long so length shouldn't be a problem, this particular vid. is 19.25 min.s the songs only 3 maybe 4 min.s , how much you got to say?.

And its crazy people try to say Pac wasnt a lyricist smh 🔥🔥🔥🔥