Save Cantonese

Пікірлер

@士雪 2 ай бұрын

我係香港人，支持守護粵語。但🤔, 你總得要/會講純正的粵語啊!

@Jacky-zt5ch 2 ай бұрын

聽完條片感覺好似係想守護譚仔阿姐粵語咁XD

@InspirLang 2 ай бұрын

Congratulations!! This is so cool!! 多謝你哋守護粵語！

@rolav3 2 ай бұрын

信息好官方，好不自然的，你可以講得更口語化。我感覺廣東話的精華比較普及大眾，不是文雅高探。你可以選擇再做多一次錄音拍攝，再看看效果。

@kiwifruitkl 2 ай бұрын

Another big myth that non-Chinese people have about Chinese people is that Mandarin is all but one language. Linguistically, Mandarin is a huge branch, and the official language of China is a subset of the Mandarin language, called Putonghua, meaning 'common language' or Guoyu meaning 'national language'. 官方語言 means 'official language'. And in China, the official language is 漢語 meaning 'language(s) of the Han people(s)'. It may also be called 華語. 官話 refers to the Mandarin Chinese language, linguistically, referring to the whole language branch and subsets. 北京話 refers to Beijing dialect or Pekingnese. 武漢話 refers to Wuhanese. 四川話 refers to Sichuanese or maybe Szechwanese. Socially, people will just take the place name and add a 話 after it, then say the language of the place. This language has no linguistic connotation in the English sense, when people mark a difference between dialect or language. It is not based on mutual intelligibility, or lack thereof. It is just based on the place name and the language of the natives. Personally, I would say Hong Kong language is a subset of Yue Chinese language. I might also say 廣東話 with 廣東 referring to the province and 話 referring to the provincial language and all provincial dialects within the province. The Hong Kong dialect 香港話 is a bit different from the Yue Chinese dialects of Mainland China, though, because of the European colonialism. But it is similar enough to be included in the same language family called Yue Chinese language. If I ever find myself having to relocate to Hong Kong or the Guangdong province, then I would take the opportunity to learn Cantonese by language immersion rather than by app or textbooks. It's the best way to learn a language. Seriously, though, I have been to Hong Kong in a layover flight and I have picked up on quite a few vocabulary terms there. It ain't hard, especially since I can speak Putonghua. I think it also occurs with native Chinese people in China as well. My own mother was born and raised in China, but in the early years, she spent time in her grandmother's house speaking her grandmother's language. When she moved to another province in China for school, people didn't understand what she was saying or where she was from. So, my mother is a heritage speaker of a specific dialect of Northern Wu Chinese language. That's why she can understand Shanghainese to a degree, and the amount of Shanghainese she knows is based on the similarity of Shanghai dialect and her own grandmother's dialect, from a preschooler's point of view. I believe that native Chinese people who have never been overseas will behave the same way: they may NOT be able to speak their ancestral mother tongues anymore, but they understand the way the older generation talks. They may not be able to replicate the older generation's way of speaking anymore.

@su6a12m3lon 2 ай бұрын

San Francisco has 3 elementary schools offering Cantonese immersion program. These schools are very popular amongst non-native speakers as well as ABC parents who want their children to be more proficient in the language than they are.

@williewong3563 2 ай бұрын

D. I signed the petition for saving Cantonese at Stanford, glad to see some fruit. Cantonese is spoken during the Han Dynasty, we must spread the knowledge.

@MrChileung 3 ай бұрын

❤❤❤加油👏

@lifewalker808 3 ай бұрын

粵語本身就唔係瀕危語言，用「守護」來講不貼切。我建議可以用弘揚、推廣、宣傳。另外抱歉講句，成條片第一句就係唔咸唔淡既粵語，不免令人懷疑究竟你「守護」緊既係咩？再者係「傳承」，唔係存成。想推廣粵語似乎要由對粵語及中文有充份認識理解既人做。

@Fei-D 3 ай бұрын

1. 點解要等瀕危先守護？ 2. 佢哋呢個組織好似係美國果邊既N代移民果班後生發起既，本意係想維護當地既粵語環境。 3. 做粵語警察除咗滿足咗你既自我優越感之外，對佢哋呢啲ABC或者任何想學粵語既都只會起到打擊同反作用。 4. 一班咁樣響英文環境下長大既後生都盡緊佢哋最大努力響國外學習同維護父輩傳承落嚟既語言，請問你對粵語既弘揚，推廣，宣傳做過乜嘢？

@lifewalker808 3 ай бұрын

@@Fei-D 1. 因為常識。你有無見人走去守護英語／普通話? 2. Noted with thanks 3. 粵語警察？難道保育過程不可以交流及指出錯處？咁要以訛傳訛喇喎？語言傳播及進化過程不需要討論及進步？曾幾何時中大有教授提倡粵語正音運動，用廣韻作為藍本。但因為古音太舊而不被接納。知唔知何為和而不同既社會？咩叫討論？你想傾可以以事論事，唔好一下扣人帽子話人「粵語警察」。 4. 顯而易見，一個良好既語言承傳方法就係用。我會用會親身講會教下一代講，會參與呢度既討論提出意見，係咪唔夠弘揚、推廣、宣傳？咁你又做左啲咩呢？你都唔係第一日上網，擺得出來自然有討論有意見。唔洗因為我唔同意某啲野咁offended既，坦白講我都係就住件事提出意見，你覺得我講得唔岩咪大家傾下交流下。你一來就扣我帽子問我做過咩野就唔係太友善囉。

@Fei-D 3 ай бұрын

我係覺得你話佢哋最後果兩句對佢哋呢班細路太苛刻所以先復你，話你做緊粵語警察。因為你講到好似要做到語言學家咁先有資格去學同傳播。明明有更好既表達方式去鼓勵佢哋點樣正確表述同用正字。至於你舉例既英語同普通話，佢哋人口基數太大喇，而且普通話果班甚至唔覺得粵語係語言。你覺得問你對粵語做過乜就係扣帽子，我只係覺得佢哋係真係盡力並且認真咁做緊佢哋力所能及既嘢，你咁樣打擊佢哋既積極性，我睇唔過眼，所以我出聲。我並無對粵語做出幾大貢獻，起碼無佢哋呢班響美國上街舉牌甚至上網呼籲大家一齊學粵語既細路做得多。我只係對所有過嚟問或者想學粵語既朋友，同事，網友都盡量提供我所知道既信息。最後講多句，真係唔好覺得粵語大把人講緊唔會瀕危。比較大感觸既係今年年初係5年嚟我第一次翻香港同廣州探親，眼見所及，香港多咗好多講普通話既，廣州連啲靚仔靚妹都係滿口普通話唔識講粵語。我甚至響廣州市舊城區用粵語問路俾人用普通話復我 “說國語！我聽不懂你的鳥語！” 對呢啲肯推廣粵語既人群多啲鼓勵啦，或者起碼可以用友善啲既方式話佢哋知正字係乜，又或者正確讀音係乜，而唔係一開波就話佢唔鹹唔淡，同質疑佢哋既出發點。對好多非粵語人群嚟講，佢哋開口講粵語就已經要用好大既勇氣。

@lifewalker808 3 ай бұрын

@@Fei-D 你有你的道理。不過我本身的批評同時係有個實際建議，我唔係純粹想話人。例如主持可以搵個粵語流利正腔。當然網媒有唔同玩法，講到一舊舊都可以訪問native speakers，咁呢個睇佢地自己點做。其實而家做KZfaq 好大競爭，撇除度稿剪片等，啲硬野都要有料，例如教煮食既隨時係大廚，同理推廣粵語講得流利啲就更有說服力。你講到粵語被邊緣化，呢個絕對係觀察得到。面對強大既同化洪流我認為無太多野可以做，正如當初廣東話係香港滅絕左圍頭話同令客家話被小眾化一樣。能做得最好就係自己繼續用同教下一代講。此外只能順其自然，呢個只係我個人睇法。

@andesapple 3 ай бұрын

因為中共政治問題令到粵語變成瀕危語言, 用「守護」點解唔得? 而呢個行動要由啲講唔咸唔淡既粵語嘅人去做, 而你就走出嚟批評??? 你冇出過手幫手就算啦~

@jimlee2664 4 ай бұрын

Cantonese per se is almost as old as Jesus Christ. People with no culture would opt for something less historical

@G8666yu-qs9ww 10 ай бұрын

評委有個好似蜜蜂翁

@user-lq7sj3jl3n Жыл бұрын

speaking up for the cantonese community!

@user-hl9iu7oi1i Жыл бұрын

It makes me so happy to see that there are people advocating for Cantonese out in SF!

@finehtfly9521 Жыл бұрын

wow 你地channel 好勁，支持！

@rickyhohk Жыл бұрын

support !

@user-wk1ri3wd6e Жыл бұрын

好撚正

@hvuu1628 Жыл бұрын

canthetto.🤣

@kenchoi6709 Жыл бұрын

I really like watching music reaction video especially about foreigner react to Hong Kong Hip Hop music. And thx for making this video to promote Hong Kong Hip Hop. I really glad to watch this video. Please keep it up!