bmarshy2303

Пікірлер

@ariesstorm9577 4 күн бұрын

Another thing to consider when trying to gauge the timeline and if it all takes place in 9 ABY is Nevarro and the changes it goes through under the leadership of Greef Karga. How long would it take to source the materials, the funds, the planning, the labour. How long would that take on a world not supported by the galactic government? I highly doubt it went from how we saw it in season 1 to how we see it in season 3 in less than a couple of months.

@bmarshy 3 күн бұрын

That's a good point, however don't forget that until season 3 Navarro was a hub for criminal activity - a bit like Mos Eisley it was a 'wretched hive of scum and villainy' including pirates, bounty hunters, smugglers, etc. Those enterprises likely brought in a lot of illegal funds, and with Greef Karga at the top of that pyramid then he was the one to benefit most and therefore he could direct the funds however he deemed appropriate.

@ariesstorm9577 12 күн бұрын

I’m not sure how it affects the timeline but in the first episode of Ahsoka, the guy played by Clancy Brown that it has been several years to the day that the Empire was defeated. Was he talking about their defeat at the battle of Endor, or when Empire was driven off of Lothal in Rebels?

@bmarshy 8 күн бұрын

@@ariesstorm9577 good catch! I think I overlooked that. Luckily he only says “several years ago” and not a specific number, and The Mandalorian seasons 1 & 2 (+ Ahsoka in this timeline) take place 5 years after Return of the Jedi and the defeat of the empire so that line fortunately doesn’t affect the continuity, but great catch!

@bloodred255 27 күн бұрын

To be fair, smiley was no sith.

@zacguapo7391 Ай бұрын

It could be just not him and some other conehead, but also it literally isn't a sith.

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

Firstly, he’s listed in the credits as Ki Adi Mundi which means it was an intentional decision by the writers. Secondly, Qimir literally says he’s a Sith. And although they’re only watching a hologram of Mae - who isn’t a Sith - they suspect she was trained by someone much more powerful in the dark side than her, as they say in the episode. I question your motives for trying to defend this show…

@stoney7041 Ай бұрын

I’m wondering when is Disney+ going to expand Darth Vader timeline???? They keep trying to introduce new characters and content when we really don’t have satisfaction story of Aniken Skywalker

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

Well, the entire 6 movies are the story of Anakin Skywalker so...

@stoney7041 Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy true but it ends with his transformation into Vader no enlightenment into his violent sad life during the empire

@bmarshy 8 күн бұрын

@@stoney7041ah I see what you mean, you’d like a story that explores anakin’s descent into the dark side after he becomes Darth Vader and how he becomes such a cold and merciless killing machine that we see in Rogue One and The empire strikes back?

@XavierAway Ай бұрын

At what point did he say he suspected it was a Sith Lord in the acolyte?

@user-sm6gn3nl6o 26 күн бұрын

At none. But fanatics must find something to spark a fire of hatred towards Disney and modern Star Wars.

@ei3170 Ай бұрын

There is no hope. Back to your cells

@DarthSaggezza Ай бұрын

At the 8:43 mark I thought the same thing you did when I went back and re-watched that episode. When Grogu’s head and hands came up to the cockpit glass, I thought that he was connecting with Asoka and not the space whales.

@zufalllx Ай бұрын

I don't like Luke and Ahsoka both being alive at the same time. Especially this far after Jedi.

@omarbaba9892 Ай бұрын

Why

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@zufalllx Why not? Ahsoka is only 14 years old at the beginning of the clone wars and 17 by the time of Episode III when Luke is born. By A New Hope Luke is 19 years old and about 22 or 23 in Return of the Jedi. And The Mandalorian takes place roughly 5 years after ROTJ, which means Luke is 27/28 and Ahsoka is only about 45, so they would certainly be around at the same time, unless you mean you don’t think Ahsoka should have survived until that point in the timeline?

@zufalllx Ай бұрын

There is no mandoverse. There is only Star Wars.

@AzerbaijanOficial Ай бұрын

This gives credibility to the theory that the are trying to retcon the prequels

@finnsimpson5253 Ай бұрын

In this scene he literally assumes it’s a rogue jedi, not a sith. Are you guys deliberately stupid or what

@Sagu1712 Ай бұрын

Damn crazy how by the end of the show the jedi are unaware of any sith dealings and only Vernastra is aware of Qimir and simply thinks hes a fallen jedi. But no questions must not be asked and we must only be shown answers because thats how good stories are writtrn 🙄

@abelarmstrong8054 Ай бұрын

These shows are always creating plot holes

@Blockxolotl Ай бұрын

This plot hole was explained in the show’s finale though

@abelarmstrong8054 Ай бұрын

@@Blockxolotl oh. I haven’t really watched the show and I don’t feel like it. Not to be rude

@Blockxolotl Ай бұрын

@@abelarmstrong8054 i didn’t like the show either, only watched it because my little sister was really liking it

@chancellorpalpatine4035 Ай бұрын

Bro they literally explained this in the show.

@popcrazyfishProductions Ай бұрын

hahaha when you pull out ki adi mundis obscure age only establised in legends and Forget NO ONE in the acolyte told him SITH

@natem9080 Ай бұрын

I get the complaints about this show, but I don't know why people bring this up. At this point there was no confirmation that anyone was a Sith. Just because there's a "bad guy" with the force doesn't mean they're Sith.

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@natem9080 that is like a person being attacked by an alligator in a river and screaming “AGH! CROCODILE!” and then someone saying “wELL aCtUaLLy tHaTs aN aLLigAtOr”. And there is plenty of confirmation that they are Sith. For one, Qimir literally says he’s a Sith. Secondly, Darth Plagueis is in the final episode which means that either Qimir is a Sith or he’s at least pretending to be one and caught the attention of the real Sith. Either way it is illogical writing.

@natem9080 Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy I said "At this point there was no confirmation" meaning at the point that Ki-Adi was involved. Yes, confirmation of a Sith is obvious later, but all Mundi knows is that someone with the force was killing Jedi. Which, funny enough, lines up with Mundi's reaction in the phantom menace too. Qui-Gon gets attacked by Maul, but he's still in denial about it being a Sith.

@natem9080 Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy Your points about Qimir and Plagueis are totally irrelevant to the conversation. Those scenes confirm to us the viewers that there's a sith (duh), and to the Jedi that were actually there. Need I remind you that Mundi was NOT THERE for either of those two things.

@austindeivert1198 Ай бұрын

Actually as far as he knows master sol went rouge and killed the jedi at khofar cause venestra covered everything up perhaps you should wait for the story to play out before you condemn it and by the say ki adi mundis birthday was never cannon it was listed in a non cannon 2001 cd and a non cannon 2013 magazine he had no cannon birthday so your not making a big deal out of something little your making a big deal out of nothing

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@austindeivert1198 dude chill out it’s just a meme over a fictional TV show, it’s not like we’re debating 20th century politics

@GeertHolz Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy Are you telling other people to chill out meanwhile you upload a stupid video thats supposed to make fun of an allegedly mistake, creating a toxic comment section in the process, just because you kids have nothing better to do than hating on a tv show for basically no reason? How thin-skinned are you?

@mattheweaton9111 Ай бұрын

Doesn’t sound like him. And it’s 100 years later not 75 years later

@хуй_залупа_пизда Ай бұрын

he meant centennial, not millenium, he's just a little dumb

@shamanspointofview8083 Ай бұрын

You do realize there was no proof andara ever contacted the council, this is further backed by the fact the green skin chick didn’t know about Mae, it would help if you anti fans actually payed attention or watched it

@transformersfan500okane3 Ай бұрын

My theory: his name in the credits was a mistake

@kibathefang6022 Ай бұрын

Now all of you who couldn't wait for the rest of the series. Memeing about amnesia. If you just think about it there would be some explanation as to why. And we got it. All Jedi who faced the Sith are dead. The potential apprentice memory wiped. And the one Jedi who learned about the truth through force echoes covered up the story as it was her former Padawan who was behind.

@colremy Ай бұрын

Bravo!!!!!!!

@LightningYtpl Ай бұрын

@alvinobege7307 Ай бұрын

The purrgil connection was genius and makes such a small detail in the mandalorian mean so much more

@alvinobege7307 Ай бұрын

2:09 what the actual fuck is going on here on the disney+ page??

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@alvinobege7307 i did a little movie magic for the video 😉

@alvinobege7307 Ай бұрын

Nobody seems to wanna mention that at this point, nobody in this scene knows that they're sith. You guys are literally making up reasons to hate this show. Ki Adi Mundi's age is a stupid retcon I agree, but he never discovers these siths existence

@darthlucasfuu Ай бұрын

And that's one of the many reasons why the OG canon will always fit better with the 6 movies.

@douglaswright4019 Ай бұрын

The timing is perfect for me. Rewatched Mando 1 and 2, then took a break. This a good excuse to start again.

@a_literal_brick Ай бұрын

Haven't been watching the show because I don't hate myself, but I'm guessing they're going to reveal that Smilo isn't a true Sith for the sake of consistency. But then again, maybe I'm giving them way too much credit here.

@mRibbons Ай бұрын

Da power of maaaany dead brain cells.

@antodiyo7523 Ай бұрын

May the 4th be with you too 🎉

@sergioandrescontreras5251 Ай бұрын

Listen I have a suggestion for another video: Talking about Star Wars characters whose stories need a continuation and conclusion. For example, Rotta the Hutt, Jabba’s son aka Stinky as Ahsoka called him. Anyway we need this Hutt to make a return in Star Wars. Perhaps as the adoptive son of Boba Fett. Which is very far fetched but it’s fun to think about. So please think about it.

@sergioandrescontreras5251 Ай бұрын

This is actually very accurate. Thank you for this. I love the Mandoverse, especially The Mandalorian. That show is definitely better than the entire sequel trilogy. Thank you so much and may the force be with you.

@zufalllx Ай бұрын

There is no mandoverse. There is only Star Wars.

@VictorDiGiovanni Ай бұрын

I call for a moratorium on the "It's like poetry..." clip. A more clever way to present it would be to start showing it, and then cut it off at "It's--", showing that it's such an overused trope at this point that we don't even need to see the rest of it to get the joke.

@shpaghettishpaghetti6219 Ай бұрын

His voice acting in the acolyte is awful.

@badangpatang Ай бұрын

First, Ki Adi Mundi's age was only confirmed in a Legends story and is not canon so that squashes that complaint. Second we do not know if Qimir is even a Sith.

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@badangpatang dude people keep saying this but episode 5 came out TWOOO WEEKS AGO and he literally says he’s a Sith

@badangpatang Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy Qimir doesn't even claim that he is a Sith. He says he is not anything, but the Jedi may call him a Sith.

@sean.m. Ай бұрын

And he using Trakata, a Lightsaber style which is forbidden by the sith too

@NiggletFarm Ай бұрын

First, this show is awful and shouldn’t be taken seriously

@FowlManor Ай бұрын

Very interesting 🤔 I've wanted to give these shows another watch, and now you have given me a reason to do so with this new viewing order. Thank you for your work, and I'm looking forward to see how it works.

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@FowlManor thanks for your support it means a lot! When I watched the shows like this for the first time it honestly felt like a whole new show so I’m glad that you find it interesting. If you watch the episodes in this order be sure to come back to this video and let me know what you think!

@FowlManor Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy It's a similar situation with The Clone Wars; If you watch the episodes in order of release you'll have clones in Phase I and Phase II armor in episodes right after one another and story lines will be picked up and then dropped for almost an entire season before being picked up again. If you watch The Clone Wars in the correct order, the long story lines are much better, and the end hits harder than you can ever imagine. 😭

@gunslinger2566 Ай бұрын

Star Wars officially died the moment KK wore that idiotic "The Force Is Female" shirt. With that one act, she let fans know that the franchise is dead and she'll just be playing with the corpse.

@BARTENT Ай бұрын

Very intresting

@Zanjutsu Ай бұрын

Although this is problematic, I will withhold judgment until all episodes have been released.

@wizlb Ай бұрын

The original Star Wars fans left before any of Rey’s movies… the fans leaving now are the animation fans

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@wizlb I’m not sure that’s entirely accurate. I know a lot of “original” fans who are still fans to this day, even after all the mess Disney has made. I think people were just happy to see a Star Wars project that felt like George Lucas’ creation again when the Mandalorian came out in 2019. It’s not perfect, and I know a lot of fans have dropped out, but a lot of people are still rooting for Star Wars to be good again and at the moment the only light guiding the way seems to be projects like The Mandoverse and Andor/Rogue One (and the animation as you mentioned).

@metro25production Ай бұрын

Andor is still good tho

@wizlb Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy .. I’m not too sure of any franchise that didn’t have issues, James Bond, Indiana Jones, fast and the furious, mission, impossible, and the list goes on

@wizlb Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy Star Wars fans need to take a damn deep breath, it’s only entertainment, it’s not real life

@wizlb Ай бұрын

@@bmarshy.. However, as I mentioned earlier, the majority of fans who enjoyed the first three Star Wars films tend not to watch any of the animated films or series

@officialmonarchmusic Ай бұрын

The timeline of the Mandoverse is completely broken. Literally the only way to rationalize it is to imagine that Morgan Elsbeth was getting transferred for 2 years. The line that completely broke the story was Captain Teva barging into the court marshal mentioning "the conflict on Mandalore" which happened 2 years after season 2

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

I completely agree. That’s why I started looking for a way to fix it when I was showing my partner The Mandoverse for the first time. A friend of mine came up with the idea to put the episodes in a different order when we were watching the first couple of episodes of Ahsoka together, so after a few weeks I came up with this episode order. If you feel like the Mandoverse is broken, try watching the shows again in this order and see how the entire story changes and feels much more thought-out. Try it out and let me know what you think!

@officialmonarchmusic Ай бұрын

@@bmarshyEven with your fixes, it’s still technically broken. And you can rearrange all the broken pieces you want, and I think you’ve done it well, but they’re still broken pieces at the end of the day, just in a different arrangement.

@zufalllx Ай бұрын

There is no mandoverse. There is only Star Wars.

@MbaeacFIlms Ай бұрын

They don't know that it's a Sith there what are you talking about?? They never mentioned anything about the Sith people just be creating problems for nothing.

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

Someone hasn’t seen episode 5 and 6…

@MbaeacFIlms Ай бұрын

@@bmarshyI watched them and he's not in those episodes though, it doesn't say anything about him in them, what are u talking about. The show isn't even done yet its already starting to explain it.

@JonBaldock Ай бұрын

Its just he default result when you hand over anything to Liberals who want to push their Woke agenda.

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

How has this comment got anything to do with the video???

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

Thanks for watching! Stay tuned for more Star Wars related videos coming soon! Full episode order: 1. Chapter 1: The Mandalorian 2. Chapter 2: The Child 3. Chapter 3: The Sin 4. Chapter 4: Sanctuary 5. Chapter 5: The Gunslinger 6. Chapter 6: The Prisoner 7. Chapter 7: The Reckoning 8. Chapter 8: Redemption 9. Chapter 9: The Marshal 10. Chapter 10: The Passenger 11. Chapter 11: The Heiress 12. Chapter 12: The Siege 13. Chapter 13: The Jedi 14. Chapter 14: The Tragedy 15. Chapter 15: The Believer 16. Chapter 16: The Rescue 17. Part One: Master and Apprentice 18. Chapter 1: Stranger in a Strange Land 19. Chapter 2: The Tribes of Tatooine 20. Part Two: Toil and Trouble 21. Chapter 3: The Streets of Mos Espa 22. Chapter 4: The Gathering Storm 23. Chapter 5: Return of The Mandalorian 24. Chapter 6: From the Desert Comes a Stranger 25. Part Three: Time to Fly 26. Chapter 7: In the Name of Honor 27. Part Four: Fallen Jedi 28. Part Five: Shadow Warrior 29. Chapter 17: The Apostate 30. Chapter 18: The Mines of Mandalore 31. Chapter 19: The Convert 32. Part Six: Far, Far Away 33. Chapter 20: The Foundling 34. Chapter 21: The Pirate 35. Chapter 22: Guns for Hire 36. Chapter 23: The Spies 37. Part Seven: Dreams and Madness 38. Chapter 24: The Return 39. Part Eight: The Jedi, the Witch, and the Warlord

@johnthemachine Ай бұрын

Please consider having this edited into a fanedit film, or several. Reach out to Hal9000. It would work well as two long movies that would setup the “third” official theatrical release in 26

@jasenbertrand Ай бұрын

I think people forget that multiple episodes could be 1 day, or 1 episode could be days long(hyperspace travel parts) I like Mando 1-16, Boba 1-4, Insert Skeleton Crew, Boba 5-6, Ahsoka 1-3, Boba 7, Ahsoka 4-5, Mando 17-19, Ahsoka 6, Mando 20-24, Ahsoka 7-8

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@johnthemachineI think it would be far too long to have as a fan edit. Each episode of the Mandalorian is anywhere from 30-50 minutes long, and there are 39 episodes in total. I had considered making a fan edit out of the last 4 episodes (Chapter 23 Mando, Part 7 Ahsoka, Chapter 24 Mando, and Part 8 Ahsoka) because those episodes would definitely work well as a movie. Perhaps Chapter 16 of Mando, Part 1 of Ahsoka, and Chapter 1 of boba would work well too. Maybe I’ll give it a go 🤷‍♂️

@bmarshy Ай бұрын

@@jasenbertrandthat’s an interesting order, the only issue is that the trailer for Skeleton Crew shows that Vane - the pirate from Season 3 of The Mandalorian - is going to have some kind of role which means the show is likely set after S3 because otherwise he would still be working for the pirate captain. Also, the reason I put Ahsoka Part 1 directly following Chapter 16 was one because if you wait until after Chapter 6 of Boba - or even after Season 3 like the official order - then what was Ahsoka doing for all that time? After she finds out what she wants from Morgan Elsbeth, there’s no reason she wouldn’t start her mission as soon as possible - and that also helps keep her story flowing by having it continue only a few episodes after she appears in Mando. Also, I feel like watching boba directly after Mando is a bit jarring, because you see the post credit scene where he takes over Jabba’s palace twice within two episodes. And the entire series was almost created just to bring Mando and grogu back together, which means you’d be going from them separating in chapter 16 to them coming back together almost instantly. Anyway, I like your order too it’s interesting. Maybe I’ll check it out one day 👍

@sirdoomer7927 Ай бұрын

Disney is all fanfic as far as I’m concerned

@TheBitingBat Ай бұрын

Dementia from being apparently far over a hundred years old

@The_mahayana_legend Ай бұрын

Maybe the Ki adi mundi Was a different one than in Phantom menace

Ең жақсы KZfaq

Пікірлер