Are you suggesting he should be out for the season, just like the poor guy that got hit? The rest of the comments are agreeing with the rest of the World not just you South Africans
@AndySmith-lq2di17 күн бұрын
No I'm suggesting whose idea , a woman ref
@paulnicholls479122 күн бұрын
Typical south Africa complaining, should be ban
@jonathantepairi266422 күн бұрын
Sam cane 2023 ,we had to suck it up yet kolisis tackle is very dimilar to this one. "hmmmmm"
@reniervanheerden683024 күн бұрын
There was no head contact. Jose Lima is not, test rugby material. That was the only fact that came out of that incident.
@liamfriel874924 күн бұрын
I believe the Boks have prided themselves on practicing lower tackles to avoid head contact. Clearly, Esterhuizen missed that class! However this is a clear red any day of the week imho. 🤔
@brianseage545225 күн бұрын
Red all day, every day. Very careless and dangerous.
@reniervanheerden683025 күн бұрын
The only head contact was; Jose Lima's head hitting the grass. Why was André Esterhuizen fine after the tackle, if there was head to head contact.?
@user-dd7ls9el7h25 күн бұрын
Why you comment only the possitive reactions towords, Esterhuizen, he is a dirty player, he wants to heard his opponents, he should be banned from playing any rugby for a year ,and you should get off the internet with your one sided comments
@trevoryoung270025 күн бұрын
The laws of the games have evolved in recent years to protect players from life-changing injuries (e.g. concussions, as endured by Pat Lambie). The officials in this case followed the protocol and came to the correct decision (Nigel Owen).
@maurichiohill260825 күн бұрын
Our country is a good sport nation. individuals must practice good professionalism on+of the sports field.
@maurichiohill260825 күн бұрын
How can they believe in this era not been caught for drugs using...?
@user-il1fv7iv8m26 күн бұрын
Justified..... END OF DISCUSSION
@rogermccallum446627 күн бұрын
Red card =5points lost Yellow= 3points lost Player 3 red cards 5 match Penalty, = clean games
@user-lg9ls8jq4n28 күн бұрын
Love Esterhuizen but head on head a definite card and his opponent lights out so yea maybe not such a long suspension. 💚BOKKE💚
@beetle632328 күн бұрын
Clear and obvious for all to see but not the officials..wonder why.
@beatrixstrydom132328 күн бұрын
I do believe this is all part of Rassie plan for going forward preparing for next World Cup and just a reminder Rassie has earned himself a Doctorate and not only does he look at wherever improvement in his book as close to perfection any player can get Springbok Team has winning outlook and Rassie is Bold enough to be real and totally honest with his whole operation...God Bless Rassie 🙌 Beatrix Strydom
@ryanlawlor786228 күн бұрын
Win, lose or draw saffas are always gonna whine and be the victims
@JohnKelly-oi1xz28 күн бұрын
He needs to learn proper tackle technique!!!
@garethmoore859329 күн бұрын
What the duck, are females reffing men for????😮
@Stephno8629 күн бұрын
Clear red dont know what your talking about controversial...and to say there was attack on Marxe`s life is laughable ..your such a clown
@mitakon2129 күн бұрын
Zero red card, tackle shoulder/chest height, dipping in the tackle, no head contact. TMOs phckn blind.
@booey2829 күн бұрын
Females should not ref a mens match
@brendangamble508829 күн бұрын
Clear red card no debate
@beatrixstrydom132329 күн бұрын
We all have own opinions on things in life ...however Our Springboks are then free to play rugby 🏉 and use their talents to best 👌 of their capabilities is it not about Winning... Rassie Rassie Rassie...keep being a step ahead don't worry 😉 about the rest Beatrix Strydom
@douglasherron753429 күн бұрын
High speed; plenty of time to adjust but no attempt to dip by the tackler; no significant change of direction and height by the player tackled; obvious head-on-head contact = high degree of danger = red card.... where is the controversy? Trying to compare the decision to another one in another game is pointless. The referee, assistant referees & TMO are looking at the incident they officiating on, they are not comparing it to other incidents (there is no such thing as precedent in the laws of the game).
@rarbuthnotc29 күн бұрын
A basic tenet of Rugby is that the referees' decision is final. Accept it and get on with the game! Glad nothing said about the gender of the referee and that, somehow, had an impact. Incidentally there was clearly head on head contact and anyone saying otherwise needs their eyes testing!
@gerhardpistorius520729 күн бұрын
Where was this TMO when Owen Farrell shoulder charged Esterhuizen back in November 2018? It's most defiantly a penalty - but NEVER a red card.
@conormarren77729 күн бұрын
controversial??? no no no no - 100%red card no doubt
@martinduggan407729 күн бұрын
Red card simple
@chiva250729 күн бұрын
More "Rugby" BULLSHITT ! Rugby is now the shittest sport on this planet. Was a plain simple tackle.!!
@ianvenables130429 күн бұрын
The 4 week ban was a bit harsh I think
@conormarren77729 күн бұрын
what would you give him?
@beatrixstrydom132329 күн бұрын
Springboks are a breed of their own ...not fake ....the real deal ...I remember one debate I got into concerning Jockeys 🏇 horse racing that I want to repeat because if you good you good however bad things happen to the best as well ...not winning is hard to accept however never quitting is what Champions 🏆 are made of ....Rassie Rassie Rassie is in our heads.... Beatrix Strydom
@jmo8934Ай бұрын
Yeah shows you what they know. Ireland won the second test. Crowley also missed a few kicks in that game.
@Bradford1ableАй бұрын
Rassie is just trying mind games, Andy has responded in a great professional way. Not taking notice of his goading but getting his own opinions and words in there. No need for any extra spice in a game like this.
@izakcelliers7307Ай бұрын
shame....manbaby....
@maurichiohill2608Ай бұрын
If a great coach should've uses plans B or C....we misses Snorman.Remember Wellington(N.Z) a plan B or C beat All Blacks that day.
@maurichiohill2608Ай бұрын
Analysis must stop putting pressure on coaches.When they were there it wasn't so clearly that way...Pls.
@JimmieCooper-le6vjАй бұрын
Mallet is not wrong !!
@v.9876Ай бұрын
From what I saw world rugby set this up as two match series with the four southern hemisphere teams
@maurichiohill2608Ай бұрын
Makes it competitive.Should be 2-0 as Aussies & All Blacks did?Even world champ performance like that?A lots of short mornings...Fly Half must decide, Pollard, still proceeds
@kenarbuckle7531Ай бұрын
RG was in the middle of the tackle, his head facing the other way. He couldn't see, how was supposed to stop. It happens a lot of time I don't believe it was intentional. 2 Broken legs, 2 bloodied faces, 1 concussion. I wonder what was intentional???? 😡
@celticloftsАй бұрын
If South Africans think so little of Irish rugby then why do they spend so much time talking about them?
@peterrowlands6406Ай бұрын
Why could'nt we hear Farell speak, rather than hear you?
@CoffeeKing-vr1fm10 күн бұрын
probably copyright rules
@ChazzyWSАй бұрын
We see far worse in virtually every game, this one is hardly controversial. Move on...
@aidanmasterson50Ай бұрын
Players come in from the side and clear beyond the ruck all the time. The result was accidental though. What I think was missing was that he didn’t go check on him as a former teammate. Not a good look either in front of most of your future teammates.
@tpkorea6cАй бұрын
High tackles are difficult to judge. How can a tall guy, when he did bend his body to go for a tackle be accused of a high tackle when the opposition is upright, or when both players god down? Sorry, this is a contact sport and if World rugby wants to stop head injuries, let all players wear head gear.
@beetle6323Ай бұрын
If you can't take the heat fuck out the kitchen.
@harveygould6543Ай бұрын
Rugby has gone soft.
@trevoryoung2700Ай бұрын
As rugby fans, we need to stop justifying, or worse praising, reckless actions on the pitch that can lead to life changing injuries - watch Pat Lambie’s interview with Bryan Habana.
@beatrixstrydom1323Ай бұрын
Rassie can spell win and earned a Doctorate specialty being Rugby 🏉....Beatrix Strydom
@donnachamcgowanАй бұрын
S. A rugby is about Brawn and not much Ability thats why they are Called the BOMB SQUAD 😂
@GG-tc8crАй бұрын
It is what it is Play to your strengths Boks are best team in world Im Irish