Thank you @matthewgrandison8794, means a lot. I am currently working on my next one :)

Hello, must admit I play by ear, but I will have a think about sheet music and how to do it. Adding sheet music may be something I add as the channel grows, good idea thankyou.

Hello,. there is a bit of a balance getting the info across and making videos more mobile friendly. I will have a think about this whilst I'm creating the next video as I don't want to exclude viewers. Thankyou for the feedback.

@@scaledtuna that circle is fascinating and I am sure it will be extremely useful (if I could understand it). I tried screenshotting it but it was incomprehensible.

There is a video I have created explaining how the circle of fifths is built.. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html .. I hope it will help you understand how it works and the important information should be viewable on a mobile device. The video also has info cards, that can be zoomed into, although I appreciate the keyboards showing the chords may too small beside the wheel, as they were really designed for desktop/tablet use. What you say though is valid as I have had another comment saying the info is too small. have to keep that in mind in future videos or even create mobile specific or supplementary content. Thanks for taking the time to comment as it gives me good feedback for future videos.

Hi @dr.koupop880 this video has been remade to make it easier to follow thanks to the constructive feedback from this video. see link to new video: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html .. I hope you like it and see the improvements. Thanks for watching and commenting.

Je t'en prie, @lawrencetaylor4101 thanks for letting me know.

I suppose it makes sense in retrospect, a tritone (or six semitones) is half way between an octave eg c-f#-c. Thanks for watching and feedback.

I am glad you found this helpful, please feel free to add links to your own songs.

Thanks for that @geoffwatson :).

Thanks for commenting means a lot, hope you find the videos useful.

Thanks @billhasty5197, much appreciated.

Thanks for that, I will keep that in mind for the next video. Were you watching on a mobile device and did you mean the keyboard at the bottom or at the sides?

Thankyou for the feedback, glad you found it helpful.

Thanks for commenting. I am currently working on a remake of the unlocking creativity with the cof video which should be arriving soon, its been a tad time consuming. Have a few more already planned after that. Hope you stick around.

@@scaledtuna i am going nowhere. :) thanks for replying. i can imagine this videos being time consuming with all the animations

@@jakobmusic9187 thanks appreciated :)

Hi @vocalchords3609, Thank you very much for the feedback and for subscribing to the channel. Great to hear you like the video.

Appreciate the comment, thanks :)

Thankyou very much for the feedback. I have a few more videos in the pipeline with a remake of the cof video coming soon. Hope you stay around.

Thankyou for taking the time to comment. :)

Thankyou for subbing and taking time to comment, I need honest feedback to make better videos.. I really need to do a "remake" of this video as it was my first tutorial video and have learnt a bit since creating it. Please take a look at my newer videos as a lot of feedback from this has gone into the newer videos. I hope you like them, any feedback is welcome.

I hope you might like the remake of this video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html - thank you for the suggestion to make it more user friendly!

Hello @Juan_M1, thankyou very much! All the best.

Hi, thankyou very much for the feedback. Glad you found it useful.

Thankyou, glad you found it interesting.

Thanks for watching.

@@scaledtuna I am late fourties and only starting to believe in the power of music (and other abstract subjects) but i appreciate very much, tx you tx you

Thankyou :)

Thanks for watching, I'll post the correction in the notes. Hope you liked the video otherwise.

Thank you for your feedback @geoffwatson, this video is the first attempt before feedback :) . Please take a look at the newer videos I have posted titled (Adding color/colour to music part 1 and 2) where a lot of feedback from this video has gone into creating them, I really hope you like them and see the improvements. I spent a fair amount of time in the newer videos writing software from scratch to display the COF and highlight the chords as I am playing them as there was not a product out there I liked. I am currently writing my next video about passing chords thanks to @jorgeellesmenmusic for the suggestion, where I plan to make further enhancements to visualisations. I do plan to remake this video at some point in the future, there are quite a few changes I want to make and will take some time between the day job. Shame I cant just overwrite this video, I will need to upload a new video so want to get a bit more content in first.. I hope you stay around and see the improvements.

@@scaledtuna Thank you - keep up the good work 👍🎹

I hope you might like the remake of this video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html - I think you may find it easier to follow. Thank you for the feedback.

Thankyou for your comment! I hope to make even greater circles in the future :)

Hi @chequemiel, its called MIDITrail and is available for Windows and MacOS. Thanks for watching.

Hello, thank you for taking the time to comment, sorry to hear that you didn't get much from the video due to the pace. I have taken many of the comments on board from this video, to help with the newer videos I have just released. More time has been spent visualising and highlighting the chords as I am playing them and making the audio more clear. Speed wise, Its hard to find the balance between keeping interest for some and going to quickly for others. I think moving forward I will try to make the illustrations as clear as I can.. All feedback is very much appreciated as this is a bit of a learning curve for me also :).

@@scaledtuna 👍

I hope you might like the remake of this video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html - thank you for the suggestion of making it easier to follow.

Thanks for that :)

Hi, that is a great suggestion maybe with using inversions. I will put it on the list of videos, thank you.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hrVmm7Of29y7dHk.html <- thank you for the suggestion. I have credited you in the description if that is ok by you?

Hi, thanks for noticing this was time consuming :). I wrote it myself in javascript using the SVG library to draw the circle of fifths and to highlight the chord along with the table generation. All the slides are generated through a web browser. I would like to make this public domain in the future when it is ready, or to allow an interface through a website to generate the COF diagram.

@@scaledtuna Woow fantastic work . Congratulations

Oops :D well spotted. Thanks for watching.

Hi, appreciate the feedback. Thankyou!

Thankyou! glad you liked it.

Hi, I record my piano into logic pro and feed the midi input into a piece of software called MidiTrail to produce the nice looking 3d keyboard which is green screened onto the presentation slides. I quite like it but agree the red lines are a bit annoying something for me to think about , do you have any suggestions? As regards to your other comment about indicating what I am playing, it seems to be a common thread of feedback and something I will add to videos moving forward. Thankyou for taking the time to comment, it will help me to make better videos in the future.

Hi thanks for the feed back, just to let you know I addressed this in the newest videos. I may remake this video when I get time.

I hope you might like the remake of this video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html - Where I have tried to indicate what I am playing more clearly and have shown the chords in keyboard form beside the circle to help as well (sorry about the red lines, I do think subliminally they help to show how long a note is pressed but I am looking for a better solution, I may end up writing my own software for it). Info cards have also been added so video can be paused at specific points.. Thanks again for your feed back as its help to improve this.

I am glad you liked the ideas, apologies about the high frequency noise which I only noticed after publishing, a bit of a learning curve on that one. Adding the chords seems to be a common thread in the comments, useful feedback. Thanks for commenting.

I hope you might like the remake of this video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html - I have made it easier to follow, added more content and improved the audio. Thankyou for the feedback.

Thankyou for commenting, I will take those comments on board for any subsequent videos. It is hard to find that balance between slowing down and keeping interest. Speaking the chord names is a good idea.

I hope you might like the remake of this video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html - thank you for the suggestions!

Thankyou for the feedback, good point!

@@scaledtuna Yes, I was going to suggest the same thing. Otherwise I really like how you're giving a visual/auditory view so I can begin using the circle of fifths in a similar manner for songwriting. Which is why I subscribed.

Hello @robm3569. Thanks for taking the time to comment and subscribing. I am in the process of remaking this video which I am hoping to be able to post up soon as a new video. I have improved the audio, adapted the content and am currently in the process of remaking the visuals with animations.

@@scaledtuna Pro move, you da man :)

@@scaledtuna Awesome 🙏

Glad you found it helpful!. I get your point about the levels, thankyou for the feedback it helps improve future videos.

Thanks for the comment about the audio, I made a remake video with this comment in mind kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q7lxoNGqu5_XXXU.html - thank you for the suggestion

Thanks for that, appreciated.

Thanks Terry means a lot. Just checked out your channel, great cover of "The Man Who Sold The World" by the way.

Thanks for the comment! Thinking this one might be on the edam side of cheese, so I am thinking of getting a few more videos together before posting next to try and up the quality.

Thank you for the feedback @foulmercy8095 thats nice to hear, please let me know if you have any suggestions for future content.

Thanks, glad you like let me know if there is any content you would like.

@@scaledtuna It's a bit leftfield, but I'd like to see you cover 'Tes Yeux Noirs' by Indochine.

ça a l'air très intéressant ! Je vais essayer et si cela semble bon, je le publierai. Je pourrai peut-être pratiquer mon Français. Mangetout!

Thank you

Thankyou :)

Thanks for that

Nice job. Is that Ben I see staring at me in the avatar above?!

@@orchestralcinematiceducation Thank you for that

@@orchestralcinematiceducation Yep, hows things pat?

@@brekerr Doing good! Hope you are too.