They challenged the United States for their number one economic spot in the world. So guess what you're not going to get, exactly.

Ok

This is your misperception

Shah Wali Ullah on economy?

@@abrarahmad1495 kia matlab

You don't want to read history and see things in a superficial way

@@RisingStarViews My family lived through this history, Sir. During it's rise and lucky after it has fallen. Some died. We we robbed, we fought terrible war. We can compare it practically. And on more than one case - looking as I said on PolPot, Mao, Kims, Stalin, Kastro. We know all the flaws of Marxism. My parents had formal TOP grade for Marxism Theory in University. Do you have such a grade? Do you? And after all we know - Hammer and sickle = death and famine. Deep down you know that you are power-hungry monster that wants to abuse working class much harder than any capitalist (read about Cotton Collection in Uzbekistan. Educate yourself - it's the same level of abuse as black slavery in USA 19th century ). You have proven your nature directly by removing me genuine comments.

@@Calvrack This is very personal argument though I feel sympathy for you and your family. Also recall the population of red Indian was around 124 million, according to Roy Casandra of Austin School, over the several decades it was reduced to 25 million only. Howard Zinn said it was 59 million and 0ver 90 percent perished, 12 million slaves were brought, 4 million perished in the Middle Passage, according to Christopher Clark Cambridge historian, Zinn claims 55 million slaves were brought, one million Irish perished because of the British imposed famines while 35 million Indian also faced the same fate, over 40 percent British trade consisted of opium sale in the early 19th century, France killed millions in North Africa and other parts of the world, British introduced concentration camps in Kenya and other parts of the world, Germany played havoc with the lives of African colonies, Leopold killed over ten million , amputating over a million, Portugal and Spain looted silver and gold from South and Central America, Japan ruthlessly killed Chinese and people of other colonies. By the way modern research claims one million were killed in the USSR. I am not justifying the brutality of Stalin and others but you tend to forget the oppression of western colonial powers---the genocides, massacres, plundering, imposition of opium, destruction of Indian and Chinese economy that would contribute over 40 percent to global economy. Your ancestors suffered and I feel sorry but more than 35 million Indians were killed in famines imposed by the British colonial governments. Please read a complete history, one way of reading would not help.

@@Calvrackyour parents may have had such a grade, you yourself do not. Your lived experience notwithstanding, what you didn’t experience was actually existing socialism. You see only the flaws of “Marxism” because you cannot fathom how what you saw wasn’t Marxism, ergo everything fits, seems clear, and yet you’re just a confused puppet. You can’t answer to the crimes of capitalism because that would negate your ideological argument.

Kindly subscribe

please subscribe and share

You should check within a day. I guess this "creator" would just silently delete your critical comment. As all of them Marxists do.

Slavery continued until 1832. Primitive accumulation of wealth was possible because of colonization and ruthless plundering. Until the 19th century over 40 percent British trade consisted of opium sale. If the free market were a recipe for prosperity then why are only a few countries prosperous. The story of Hong Kong and Singapor is a totally different story. From 1949 to 1979 the average Chinese GDP growth was 5 percent and a bit over 9 percent after 1979. But from 1949 to 1979 China had been under ruthless sanctions. Socialist countries got destroyed because of sanctions

@@RisingStarViews Or dear I see. You are still deleting critics. So you understand, your Marxist friends "deleted" my grandfather in 1930s, just for being Kulak - owning cows. So I will not stop fighting your backward anti-human ideas.

This is very personal argument though I feel sympathy for you and your family. Also recall the population of red Indian was around 124 million, according to Roy Casandra of Austin School, over the several decades it was reduced to 25 million only. Howard Zinn said it was 59 million and 0ver 90 percent perished, 12 million slaves were brought, 4 million perished in the Middle Passage, according to Christopher Clark Cambridge historian, Zinn claims 55 million slaves were brought, one million Irish perished because of the British imposed famines while 35 million Indian also faced the same fate, over 40 percent British trade consisted of opium sale in the early 19th century, France killed millions in North Africa and other parts of the world, British introduced concentration camps in Kenya and other parts of the world, Germany played havoc with the lives of African colonies, Leopold killed over ten million , amputating over a million, Portugal and Spain looted silver and gold from South and Central America, Japan ruthlessly killed Chinese and people of other colonies. By the way modern research claims one million were killed in the USSR. I am not justifying the brutality of Stalin and others but you tend to forget the oppression of western colonial powers---the genocides, massacres, plundering, imposition of opium, destruction of Indian and Chinese economy that would contribute over 40 percent to global economy. Your ancestors suffered and I feel sorry but more than 35 million Indians were killed in famines imposed by the British colonial governments. Please read a complete history, one way of reading would not help.

Nice