The Best Idea

pls

This would be so perfect.

That's impossible Josh only knows how to be extra.

Yep I second (or 6th or 7th) this. doesn't matter, it's a good idea.

I’m not wearing my glasses, so when i first clicked i though this was a Lobster Roll video lol

@@faisalaldahlawi6560 lol same

They're New England Hot Dog Rolls. They're for hot dogs. They work well for lobster rolls too.

@@mackal and as somebody from New England now in the midwest, its nice to see a simple recipe for them because I can't buy them here and well..... there is no substitution lol

@@larryarcher8533 Try near the seafood. I was discussing them with someone that lives outside of NE when I learned about this being a thing and he said they sell them with the seafood where he lives :P

the real but cheaper is to get the hotdogs at Costco and then make your own toppings lol

Imagine doing this in a batch and freezing.... It's fine where it is. Work smarter, not harder. Also consider hotdogs are made by the billion already and so are buns there's. Absolutely fuck all stopping them not filling it up with chemical bullshit. Using spices like he does here, they just don't because capitalists are greedy c**ts

So make your own channel doing a proper but cheaper then

@@ericingham3343 Or... (and hear me out on this one) OR, you *could* let people leave constructive criticism and feedback in an open comment forum on the channel who's owner actually takes comments like this into consideration. Instead of expecting everyone who suggests a change do it themselves.

and the cost of the energy

he said its 1.50 per serving, i hope you've become more coherent over the last 2 years

@@whipwalka That's still more than 1 dollar.

@@thesomethingandsomething9823 bro if you cant spare 50 cents for a hotdog idk how you are alive in this economy

@@whipwalkaHey, I never said I couldn't do that.

Wrap your head around this… it’s for the algorithm/views! No way! Crazy right? He rounded down so that he would (via the video) be more successful! I know this is hard for some people to come to on their own, but someday I believe you will be able to. ​@@thesomethingandsomething9823

Pondering glizzy Contemplating hot dog Etc.

Jesus Christ loves you

@@MFCSteele Jesus Christ loves you

I was just about to comment this exact same thing but you beat me to it, so you get a like.

He’s looking back on his life and regretting not putting mayo on every hotdog he’s ever eaten. While also having the best dog of his life. It’s beautiful

Kendrick was looking like he was having an existential crisis over that dog at the end and like he wasn’t even mad about it. Hey, you might get drug onscreen, but there’s free food, and it’s incredible.

I mean Josh gives the people what they want.... More Kendrick.

wait my name is Kendrick wth

"So first you want to incubate your chicken egg for 20 to 21 days"

”Im serious about this. This isnt something you skip”

No you idiot! You just killed the last of the breeding stock!!!! Funny stuff man!

Lol. This video drove me nuts. Who has hours and hours to make a hot dog? Absolutely ridiculous and Im saying this as a fan.

So much this! Just even the time investment. Lets take two days to make a hotdog.

It's only "But Cheaper" if you compare it to super inflated prices at a sports stadium.

And he didn't even make his own mayo, ketchup, and mustard. I mean after all that effort... lol.

And it's only cheaper if you are making an industrial quantity of hot dogs. The video was fun and interesting to watch but no one's going to make this.

Man has jokes 😂

Geezuz wept

i can’t tell if this is sarcastic or not and because of that this is hilarious

How'd they turn out?

😂😂😂😂😂

quality of his videos is getting worse lately

Good point. While fun to watch these are no longer remotely practical for the average home cook.

When he messes with something so industrialized as hot dogs it's hard to have everything you need to imitate them, sadly :(.

Yeah I came here to see if they would save money but this is definitely not for the time cruncher or penny pincher. I’m about to unsubscribe here in a minute if it doesn’t improve and actually does what the title suggest.

@@venom74799 He's making hotdogs...what could he possibly do to speed up the sausage-making process? Same with the buns. Just buy hotdogs from the store of you're that bothered, they're not that expensive.

I completely agree, Josh does get a little overboard with these, but hey! That's why we watch him, isn't it? I mean, if you have access to a good bakery and butchers (or are fine with whatever your local store has), you can cut down the prep time by like 90%.

@@xyrthor 💯 I love these because I trust Josh's judgment and while some things I will never make myself, I like knowing what the premium standard is so I can make informed choices when I buy things like sausages or bread in the store.

Hey he said cheap not quick! Gotta put in some work to make up for the money saved.

* + the membership fees

@@Real28 you don't need a membership to go in and buy from the food stand area. At least not in Canada

It's not that expensive really. It's $400.... like... how much is your iPhone or android smart phone? How much is your car? How much is your mortgage? Or rent payment? Like... honestly, put into perspective of all of the things we buy, it isn't that much money. Especially considering that it's a one time purchase, not like a car or a phone or laptop or iPad etc. That is VERY expensive and we all pay extra in interest for all of these things. And your complaining about a kitchenaid that's a little less than a flat screen TV? That most of us have multiple of.... I mean... I do understand, it's NOT cheap. But, considering everything else out for sale on thr market right now, I mean the God dang thing is cheaper an an xbox!!! Come on people. It's not thay expensive!!! You pay more for a PS5! Etc. For reals.... like.... perspective! That is all.

@@fuzyfuzfuz2 true but who eats 80+ hot dogs

@@alexblanco7494 you don't. You freeze them and then eat a few at a time :) though, I will say, even over a year I do NOT eat 80+ hot dogs a year. So, point well made!

@@fuzyfuzfuz2 I eat at least four dogs in one meal

oh wow you just understood how every single artisan profession makes their money

Josh did say you could buy store bought instead of making your own. It is still way cheaper

that's half of his vids lately, his recipes are becoming even less practical over time. it's why i go to other creators for actual recipes I plan on making

@@josephporcelli2302 can you tell me some?

@@1958jacco Ethan Chlebowski is good. Mike Green from Pro Home Cooks are both good

@@ShayanGivehchian Ethan is great, been watching him for a while. Made quite a few of his recipes.

J Kenji Lopez Alt, during the pandemic he started posting almost daily gopro videos of what he cooked for his family. An absolute treasure trove of cooking knowledge

Hi, if you like cooking, feel free to check out my easy recipes ;-)

facts

Or money, to be honest. Dude used the most expensive methods for a series called "but cheaper". what a fucking sham

I mean.... You spend a couple of hours, and you get, easily, a few months, to a year's worth of hot dogs... Or a few summer party's worth. Being realistic, if you've already got the grinder out, you could, feasibly, take a day, and have all the cased, meaty goodness you could ever need, for that same span...

@@andrewamann2821 cool 👍 thanks for the advice.

From my one and only experience with their coffee, I think a more accurate statement would have been "What do you expect from Aramark?"

I regularly get hot dogs from Sheetz. They’re $1 each for 2. They’re a little small, but damn if they don’t hit the “I want fast food hotdogs and pay very little” feeling.

@@johnbuscher unfortunately some people don't have a Sheetz or even know what that is. I'm sad for those people because Sheetz prices really can't be beat 🙏🙏

I don’t expect good quality food for $1 but I do expect *edible* food when it’s being served in a public place

You have a point, but nobody is going to serve you anything good for a dollar. I’m sorry lmfao. But they shouldn’t sell mostly and rotten food.

It isn't even a hard recipe. Maybe the sausages are, but you can just buy sausage and make everything else to save money.

come to san francisco that’s how much they are here 😩

murrica, if it were up to me, id triple the charge

boss man

I just downloaded it for free :-??

@@borg4098 I paid for it because I support Josh and everybody that put in hard work to make the book. But cool

You are eating like a king 👑

@@Balo657 it's a process you invest in lil by lil Here's a decent starting point. 1. Buy Multiple sizes airtight canisters & lots of them 2. Buy every oil and vinegar and cooking wine you can 3. Buy up every spice or herb or dried fruit you can 4. Buy empty uniform glass ware for oils and spices 5. Appliances. They can be expensive they can be cheap. 6. Cooking utensils and measuring spoons and cups. 7. Buy a Label maker. (walmart) $40.00 Figure out which kitchen appliances you need and will actually use on a daily basis

I mean, what people living in a dorm even have a cutting board and a knife? And if for some reason you do, you have to awkwardly cut on your desk. You don’t have spices, and you don’t have room for much of a pantry or condiments. And based on how Josh does videos, you’ll be given recipes with ingredients you’ll use once or twice before you hit the expiration date. And do you want those things crowding your fridge or pantry space when you have so little in the first place? I support the idea out of pure absurdity and how much it will crush Josh’s soul to have a microwave and mini fridge as his only appliance options. But if we’re being realistic, just eat your food court and your ramen and be happy.

@@seanmatthewking Yeah um…we didn't have a food court either so there goes that. My school owned a "cafe" that didn't serve full meals and it was a train ride away. And to answer your questions, yes actually. You do awkwardly make your food at your desk. Maybe not the microwave as his only appliance but to use things that someone would have in a dorm. Hell, I even used an iron and tin foil to make a quesadilla before and it was probably one of the best cheap meals I've had. No, I didn't have a cutting board but I did have a knife and a plate to cut things with. As far as space, I had my bed lofted for the majority of my time living there so storage wasn't really an issue as far as things like spices and ingredients that don't expire fast. As for other things, I got everything in 1-3 serving sizes so nothing ever went bad. Again, about space, you can make it work. I dormed with 3 people and shared a bedroom. You can find ways to maximize space. You get really crafty with how you do things in college when you don't have any other options. Nothing stopped me from being able to make full meals with what little I had to work with. It's all about creativity. Edit: also, to your comment about ramen, yeah, no. I tried that along with a lot of other instant food my freshman year then ended up with high cholesterol and heart problems fairly fast. I didn't have a choice but to eat full and healthier meals. Again, when there's no option, you make it work. 2nd Edit: last thing, when I transferred schools to one that had a kitchen (still no food court) for the people in the dorm to use, it was two refrigerators for ~450 people to use so… yeah

@ I have learned to make S O many things in the microwave, and while I do prefer full kitchens, you just can't help but make do. Or... "Settle" and be happy 👀 have nothing and be happy... Sounds familiar. Ew.

He wouldn't be able to do it bc he's so out of touch with broke people. The prices in his But Cheaper videos are always kinda sketchy and he makes recipes for people with loads of free time.

Damn that college sounds like a shit hole.

@Jacko Sargs They're the best I've ever had that's for sure.

And makes his own hot dogs😂

Hi, if you like cooking, feel free to check out my easy recipes ;-)

That while for me might be the entire life though. Videos like these are a reminder why i'm not into cooking that much, lol. No one has time for this unless cooking is a hobby.

@@DoctorStrange01 Very true! I can only even attempt his recipes on a Friday afternoon when I know I'm going to have a weekend where I can have the time to finish these recipes XD

Then...don’t put “but cheaper” on his titles? His “but better” videos seem just fine, people do walk in there to be entertained and it’s alright if he uses wacky machines or ingredients if the goal is to improve on the original. But you’re gonna get peeps bothered if you do the same thing and slap the title of being “accessible” especially during times with covid.

@@Cyprimm Again, what exactly could he do make this more cost and time effective other than just buying hotdogs from the store? Other than making the hotdogs from scratch, nothing in this video was especially difficult or costly anyway tbh.

@@Alidwee1 Any serious home cook has a kitchen aid. I bought mine in my second year of college and used to bake all the time. You don't need a fancy pellet smoker like him, use a $20 weber kettle. The meat attachments are cheap but I'd spring for the all stainless one from another company. Thats really it as the meat grinder and mixer will pay for themselves if you make your own sausage, ground meat, bread etc yourself. The grill is something that can be used as often as you like for various things and you don't have to heat up your house. The main issue I have with making some things like relish is the shorter shelf life. The people complaining are not serious cooks and are too lazy or time inefficient to actually do meal prep en masse like this.

@@jahcreatorPeople do not think this way nowadays. It has nothing to do with money, it is because they are lazy. It is cheaper and much better to cook from home. If you invest in doing that all the time, the amount you save on groceries will as you said, easily make up for the equipment you buy to achieve it. Sadly though, people do not want to take the time to do it, which is their problem, not Josh's

Hey! That was unnecessary kind of you. Thanks! You too!

Thanks demon you too