Literally crying at Tiffany mouthing Jessica's "really really Good goodbye" part...

Tiffany looks really devastated this past two days. The way she acts is so not her usual self. When they performed last Sep. 30 she wasn't really into the dance. She's almost not smiling at all. She barely sang Jessica's lines to cover for her parts. When she's about to sing them, she either stops or she sings them almost like a whisper. You can see it in her eyes that she's sad. The glow of her eyesmile is not there. She was not cheerful yesterday. Also at the airport yesterday she looked like a total mess. Her clothes aren't the usual fashionable airport clothes she used to always wear. She seems to be hiding her face with her hood and by keeping her head bowed down. Probably because she's been crying. We know Tiffany is one of those who really cherish SNSD the most. She's the overprotective one of the group. She always expresses how important SNSD is to her. They're her family. I just hope for everything to be cleared out and fixed soon. I still hope and believe that this is not the end of OT9. Jessica, I hope for your success in everything. I hope you win your fight against SME. I hope you and your 8 sisters could fix this. We'll support you no matter what happens. We love you our SNSD! I still have faith in SoShi bond and that you guys will find your way back to each other. Hwaiting! #StayStrongJessica #StayStrongSNSD #OT9

i just wanna hug her and tell her that everything is gonna be ok

I don't know but seeing Tiff in this way is really sad :( She's my bias in GG I DON'T CARE SONES OUT THERE, PLEASE GROW THE HELL UP SUPPORT OR NOT IS YOUR CHOICE BUT YOU DON'T GOING AROUND AND CALLING THESE S8 FAKE AND STOP CURSING AT THEM. DON'T WORRY FANY, REAL FANS STAY!!!

Tiffany look exhausted and her eyes look kind of puffy. I think it was from crying. What surprises me is Tiffany always smile no matter what, even if she is truly hurt on the inside and to see her like this really hurts me... She seem so incomplete....

She seriously looks like she doesn't know what to do with herself :( Its so sad to hear Jessica's voice in the back

Tiffany's trying her best to stay strong.. i won't turn my backs on you 9. i still believe in soshi bond. jeti

she closed her eyes very often just to restrain herself from crying :(

tiffany singing along to jessica part @ 1:59. She must be very sad by jessica's news. Because for a FACT , all SONES should KNOW that tiffany is always a cheerful person. Even on stage while singing, she waves hi & interact with the fans but in this video we saw none of that & not her beautiful smile :(

Who knows SNSD and It's Sone know this is not normal, Tiffany is a person with bright personality and just seeing her makes you smile. See her face in this presentation makes me feel so sad because it shows her devastation. I simply I can not help but have my heart broken by nine of them, yet I continue to support the all no matter what.

Damn going through the comment section in 2021...seeing people hate on either the 8 members or Jessica is really heartbreaking 🥺 I'm a new sone, ot9 and it hurts to even think that the fandom has sides where people are blaming the 8 on Jessica's departure or hating on Jessica...damn I can't can't imagine what havoc would it have been 6 years ago...anyways...love them all!

The song's title and that one key repetitive word, 'Goodbye', no wonder Fany can't control her sadness anymore and let out tears. I've never seen her that sad in a performance and I don't even know that these girls can affect me so much. For that, I'm supporting these girls all the way. #staystrongsnsd #staystrongsica #staystrongsones True SONES, let's stay strong together.

I really feel like.. our fandom was cut in half. Some sones do think snsd kicked jess out. But please understand both sides.. cause, we fans really do not know what happened. We have no clue.. to the people who got angry to the remaining members and said they did not stood for her and let her out, well people it's SM. They can destroy SNSD in whatever they want. I don't want a JYJ part 2, no. Just.. no. We fans are devastated to that news but imagine you spent half of your life with a friend that was gone like a bubble. They are friends since trainee days plus 8 years. Snsd are also human. If we are devastated they are worst. I always believe in their bond, Until now. I also think Jessica is happy now. She made her fashion line came true. And she did her best as a singer so she became succesful and I think she thought of stepping forward and explore new things. As a friend you would want her to pursue it. I think Jess did her part as a singer. And now proving to be a designer. As Sones we must suppport both of them. Cause rants and all this theory or guesses, none of this is true. We can do nothing but to support them. SNSD HWAITING!!!! P.S. PPANYANGG SO SAD HERE I KENAT

you know shit went too far when Tiffany Hwang is unable to fucking smile!

Just cry......please don't hold it back.....we are sad too, but sadder, seeing you try holding back tear...

Her eyes told everything... hmmm...

SNSD cry = theyre not professional "theyre not supposed to cry blabla.." SNSD did not cry = they kicked out jess. "so what? taeyeon kicked jess out of snsd blabla.." think before you comment guys.. wth were you try to comment about. theyre humans. they might be felt lost jess too.. theyre together since trainee, more than sones. they know each other, they shared things in dorm, they lived together, they help each other.. you guys still want to blame them? bz. as a SONE we have to continue support SNSD with or without Jessica on stage and support Jessica as well, just like when she still a part of SNSD. #nohate

Please do not assume anything. We do not know anything and therefore we should not create a fandom civil war. Try to not pick a side but continue to love and support all 9 GIRLS, the SAME way we have done before this mess happened. We should unite and go thru this difficult time TOGETHER as GG fans, as a real SONEs family.

If the members feel sad, how much more would Jessica feel? She's all alone and feels betrayed.

we used to see her in her cheerful side happy side and then seeing her in this situation makes my heart hurt so much.. she looked so tired, so sad and frustrated..

She's in so much pain I can see it through her eyes.

The more you watch the other girls reactions and performances since Jessica was forced out it looks more like they had no choice in the decision. Their hearts are broken just like ours and some of them just can't hide it.

the girls should had talked more about their situation but it seems like no one wants to listen to each other & have an agreement. i believe that they didn't want her gone, they just had an argument which lead to kicking jessica out.

she looks so exhausted and sad :( thanks for the upload, by the way!

The eye-smile we know and love was definitely not there because it was full of pain and sadness. JeTi was one of my favourite ships and to see it sink like that was so heartbreaking. I miss our American duo so much.

This is very heartbreaking,fany trying soo hard to hold back her tears!! 😭😭😭 her only dream from the start is to b a singer coz she really love to sing & love music so much,seeing her like this really break my heart! I just want to hug her sooo freakin much!!! Stay strong baby aaah!

I know you so sad! Your eyes told me! I will support you and other members forever! ♥ #StayStrongSNSD #TIFFANY Thanks! ♥

Tiffany is so lovely. You can see that she is very sad and I know she will have that terrible lonely and empty feeling like having to bear the death of a beloved family member. Being a professional she is trying to be strong and manages a smile. But that smile hides the hurt and deep pain and heartache she feels from losing Jessica. We are all hurting too but imagine what it must be like for the members. They have basically grown up together and in a way are closer than sisters having faced such hardship and adversity in their rocky road to becoming the icons of kpop and global megastars. They must feel like they have losta part of themselves. They have brought so much joy and happiness to millions of ppl and have sacrificed their youth, their family life and freedom all for us fans. They have paid their dues - they have given all they have and more- they owe us nothing any more. The least we can do is give them are total love and support - god knows they deserve it. We all have bought into this fandom so we have to stay strong for Soshi nomatter what may come. I don't even care anymore what happened to cause this situation. All i know is that my love for Soshi overrides these concerns. Look at Tiffany here - she is grieving, look at Seohyun grieving and in tears and all the other members the same. Now tell me they are all not absolutely gutted and devastated by these cruel events. Deep in their hearts this is not what they wanted. LET ALL US SONES GIVE THE NINE GIRLS OUR LOVE AND SUPPORT. THEY NEED US TO BE THERE FOR THEM NOW!!

I'm Jessica biased, but I least have too eyes to see the both sides of this situation, not like the narrow minded people in the comments ugh. You think the 8 others are happy with all this? Of course NOT they are hurting just like Jessica.......

i'm crying when i see this video. It's so hurt when i see my bias like this. It's okay fany just let it out your tears. I will never leave this fandom. I love you

never seen Tiffany like this before

tiffany onni..dont hold the tears..let it out... i hv never seen a non-energetic Tiffany.... staystrong!!!

Tiffany is always known for her bright and energetic personality that shines through her performances. Fellow Snsd members have said numerous times that they have trouble keeping up with her energy. Watching this is so sad

This is so heartbreaking.. i have never seen fany like that before. All 9 of them must be crying and feeling hurt. I hope all 9 of them will stay strong and things will get better.

:( OT9 will be restored. It should. I hope it will.

awww tiffany :( OT9 forever!

Damn why SM's groups always got someone leaving or kicked out .. :,( never thought something like this would happen to snsd.

Seeing Tiffany so sad makes me sad too. We all know the pain and suffering Tiffany! SONES will always stay by your side

never seen Tiffany look this sad and depressed before

This was one of my favorite songs because the parts were well distributed. Jessica and Taeyon had the whole chorus to themselves while the rest had the smaller lines and it was pretty even since Jessica and Taeyon were the main vocalists. Now it's basically sunny who gets the most lines here...

This hurt so much I can't hold the tears :(

My heart breaks again seeing this. First time seeing Fany like this. Cant bear to see the girls in this state.

Her face is really sad. Like she was really tired back then, also they had a problem between them, and it looked like she really holding back her emotion and it just made her so tired:( thank God she's back with her eyesmile now:)

Babyfany I'm on your's side...See u being like this is so heartbreaking. I dunno what happened but you're my one and only girl that I'll always love. when the storm passed the sunrise is coming.

my poor fany :'( and I believe she was especially sad when she had to sing the lyrics "really really good good bye". Just gonna support my favourite girls forever no matter what others think, we all don't know what really happened and so I give them 1000000 benefits of doubt 'cause i love them

If you are able to perform and being hurt. Think how much worse jessica are having right now all ALONE! but you have 8 others members backing you up anyway. Never going to beleive in soshi bond ever again, everything is fake! #staystrongjessica #asoneheartbroken

This is not Tiffany Hwang. If tiffany can break down like this it is mean that they are really said n hurt. They are not fake n I believe in shoshi bond.

they prob thought jessica's need to branch off was like a betrayal to their sisterhood or some shit so i'm pretty sure the sadness comes from how shitty the situation is like "everything was going so well until jessica couldnt 100% commit to the group anymore and now we had to kick out one of our best friends for the sake of the group" or whatever. not really blaming anyone i just feel like it's a bunch of petty girly drama that turned into legal drama and now everyone's salty solely because they can't communicate properly.

StayStrong....... Fany, just holler. Let the bad emotion out~~~ Never say goodbye

i will always love and support you whatever happen. My Fany fighting~~

damn, ii cried ......

She has never been like that before... I'm crying

10년동안 소녀시대하면서 이때가 가~장 노래하기 힘들었을 것 같다. 얼마나 힘든 시간이었을까..

Everybody lies, even your bias... it hurts but it's the truth. Music industry is always like that, what matters here it's the business. I'm not saying that everyone is fake but when you expirience hard circumstances you have to make a decision, we run our lives basing on the choices we make, and we shouldn't be trying to find someone as culprit, at some point you reach your limit. These girls have been together since they were kids, living as a family, I seriously doubt they are not feeling good after loosing a member.. it must be hard after all, I know how it feels to loose a member and have to make a difficult decision but there's no other option, I'm part of a kpop dance cover group.. I know it's not the same because we're not idols or something but those kind of situations are always happenning u.u even if we have the same prupose, each one has different interests, we cant's expect to agree in everything. Please stop fighting.

All the sad emotions. 😢 Fighting unnies! OT9 Forever!

i don't think it's right to put negative feedback on the remaining 8 girls because we for sure do not have any idea on who is telling the truth here. We only heard an official statement from Jessica but not for Taeyeon, Sunny, TIffany, Yuri, Hyoyeon, Sooyoung, Yoona and Seohyun!

I think SM found a way to shut the rest of the SNSD members up.... It's sad, but I think many K-POP stars don't publicize their contracts for a reason. What I think is 1.SNSD members legit all agreed to disband Jessica and is acting in front of cameras and the press or 2. SM decided to disband Jessica and keep the situation under control since it's the cheapest solution available. SM clearly made a huge mistake here. Doesn't SNSD know better? They have the largest fanbase in the industry. I think every member should post their side of the story on their SNS accounts. This is unacceptable. Large companies are never to be trusted, especially in the entertainment business. SONES, stop supporting SNSD as of now. I'm not a SONE, but I think SM needs to see where their income comes from. Stop buying their albums, stop voting, stop going to their concerts. Also, don't forget to sign this petition and share it with others. We can do this SONES. www.change.org/p/sm-entertainment-keep-jessica-in-snsd#share #StayStrongSNSD

seem like she is trying to hold her tears :'(

Like this song was sung for Jessica in this context. Never thought this song would be interpreted this way..

I believe one day jessica will come back to snsd but for now let just continue support snsd and jessica, and stop bashing each other if you are really a sone

I'm very sad about Jessica... I don't know the truth, but I think that girls have no guilt, at least not all. Kick a member out, that's unbelievable! They know that we love all of them together, and do something like this is stupid... I hope that girls talk about this, and even Jessica. They have to clear this out... #staystrongjessica

And you call yourselves true SONES ???? U're a shame on the fandom , why are U assuming things from ur own head without knowing the facts ?????? When did ever SM made an actual statement about what happens with their groups ???? this is telling you to just stop what you're doing or saying , because she's not coming back PERIOD . please shup up , no one needs more bashing we're already in pain , just accept the facts and move on with your lives , be more mature please !!!!!

let's just wait the truth. we don't know the truth guys. the truth will be revealed.. let the time decide

With everything that's been going on, you can tell that SNSD still has a lot of haters and a lot of people who want to see them disappear. I didn't know about K-Pop back then, but I can understand now what they went through at the time of the black ocean...

Tiffany, better go home and sleep.

U can say it just seeing her eyes,,her acts that time wasn't really her you can say that time all of them can't focus performing and their smile fade away you can say if you watch the performance, they all look down,and all of them are holding back their tears 😭💔||2020 anyone??||

Those eyes ......full of sadness.... can't say no more.

Up until today i still blame the company for not taking good care of their artist growth career and mental health. The company should know the value of SNSD. They are like gems. I'm sorry if you had different opinion than me but that how i felt.

People who listen to one side of the story and simply decide that's the complete and absolute truth are just too dumb.

tiffany is crying

喜歡少時這麼多年從來沒看過阿黃這種表情 努力把眼淚往肚裡吞的樣子 好心痛........

My Tiffany😢

ได้แต่มองพี่เจ็บปวดโดยที่ฉันทำอะไรไม่ได้นี่มัน..โคตรเจ็บ!!! T_T

Even though it was the members kicked out Jessica, why do people assume that the decision was unanimous? Maybe Tiffany was against kicking out Jessica, but was outnumbered?? This is logic, don't just assume things and think that's the only true answer...

My heart.... ;_______;

Only true SONEs gonna stay with SNSD, because true SONEs gonna support the 8 members, and Jessica no matter what. If you were sone and now you think that they are "fake".. is so embarrassing, we have to wait to members, they have to say their position about this news.

baby don 't be sad we are always here

I can see her mouth is like forcing herself not to sob. I'm not used at seeing this bubbly girl being devastated.

no jessica, no snsd. that may be much better. one quit, all of them quit the better.

this hurts so much

don't cry baby we all got your back =(

Why are you sad? You guys chose to kicked her out on you own.

โอ๊ยๆๆ ที่รัก เป็ห่วงนะ

not a good goodbye :'( sad

I fcking cried T___T

It must be so hard to even pull out a smile /: and I feel sorry to those ppl that believe in everything they read and take sides.. it's like they know the whole story lol how pathetic

There's a clear pattern here: whenever K-Pop fans (those who are seemingly frustrated with their lives) realize their idols are actual human beings with feelings and emotions ==> HATE, DELUSION, ANGER. ("OMG How they dare those SNSD girls have an argument? Let's stop supporting these fake bitches! They're not sisters." etc.)

I still believe in you SNSD. I know you girls can talk it out with each other and solve all this non-sense. Your all mature enough to know what is right and wrong. I believe you SNSD always :) I always be a SONE no matter what the situation is. This situation needs to time and alot of thinking, once the girls figure it out, everything will turn out okay. nothing is impossible. We love you SNSD, SONES are always there for you! It hurts me as much as it hurts the girls and other SONES around the world but we can get through this together. We all make mistakes in this world and we should learn from them, and I think the girls and Jessica had some misunderstand or made a mistake on either part. We shouldn't blame it on the 8 girls or Jessica. They have always been together and said before they always be SNSD forever. #SNSD #TTS #StayStrongSNSD #StayStrongJessica

she honestly looks done with the whole concert like if she could she'd walk off. im no sone but from what they say shes the most professional one in the group so for her to look like this obviously speaks levels the situation

I can feel the sadness. T_T OT9 in my heart forever! JETI

this is such a sad video

watch this then watch their fancam of the same song but at Sketchbook... feels totally different :(

i sill believe in OT9

Do not hurt My Fany !! Go AWAYYYYY !!!!

I'm glad a lot are mature and not believing that girls can do such a thing

she looks so sad here.....her eyes are not shining.....she's smiling but i can't see it in her eyes......i am sad too cause i can't hear sica's angelic voice....and i think fany's feel the same way too.....

Qe triste, quisas esta asi por la partida de jessica, ademas la cancion habla de un adios, y tiffany es muy cercana a todas esta claro que esto la deja vulnerable.

Holy crap, this is the song where someone made a mix of taeyeon and Jessica's vocals together and omg crying

Always love you all T___T