Both Sunny and Seohyun covered it

​@@francismarasiganiii4549But Sunny was given the lines that were more challenging. I'm assuming that's why many of us are applauding Sunny.

@@iKETOURAGE She did an amazing job. She did not try to sound like Jessica.

@@francismarasiganiii4549 Right! I agree!

​@@iKETOURAGESunny is criminally underrated.

That's why I think she's the best to cover for Sica because unlike the others she doesn't try to be Sica but herself. She spice up the part to her liking while still giving justice to Sica. Love her personal touch to the lines/verses she cover for Sica. She Rocks all the covers...

Lifu Xie Yes not someone replace someone and Sunny try to be herself,i love Sunny

Variety Drug House People really need to understand that Sunny doesn't know know how to be anyone but Sunny and that's why when she does cover Jessica's lines it's more acceptable because she doesn't try to be something she's not. She's true to herself & feelings plus she's blunt enough to tell you as it is.

I’m crying 😭

써니 목소리 들을 때마다 너무 슬퍼요😢

Yes thats true 😂 everyone just to obsessed with jessicas voice. Because only jess can keep up with taeyeon, without jess this song becomes a little bit gap 😓

TimelessGap2 agree with that I love how Sunny make the lines like own her

TimelessGap2 cállate

OMG EXACTLY

No.

because they have the same vocal style. Its just Sunny has lower vocal range than Sica's

Andrea Bagamano Thats because sunny’s voice is rather similar to sica’s. She sometimes sound like sica when she sings and the best thing is she can hit high notes easily and effortlessly.

They don't need to try to be Jessica because they have their own qualities. I like Sunny singing it, but I think Seo would be the best choice due to her color of voice. It's elegant.

bae seul No one has to sing it like how sica does, they are not her and you can't expect the girls to replace her just because she is no longer in snsd. Sunny sung sica's part in her own way and she nailed it despite being in pain from sica's departure. You can still support sica by purchasing her albums and her fashion items, she's still doing well, hope you are able to move on after 3 years.

Ps. Hyoyeon and Yoona supported Sunny~

Tri Buana Sica has released her own music, if you still miss her you can check them out. Summer storm is really nice. Sunny and seo sounded amazing here despite trying to hold their tears.

but sunny and seohyun did it. well yeah no one did her adlib. i saw tiffany tried but gave up

Actually it's Taeyeon but in most of the songs that they performed, they left Jessica's part so that the fans could sing it.

Ayo gg i dont know but sunny and seohyun clearly did it (the last chorus) and on sica high note 'really2 good goodbye' tiffany tried to sing it but just like gave up. and taeyeon yeah. this is just sad isnt it

Sunny did it very well. Better than Taeyeon.

Dafi Hale she is talking about the final part. Jessica really has the hightest range in the group... Sunny and Seo singing her part was good, but not perfect as her, 'cause Sica has a strong voice like Taeyeon...

Eight will never be nine, and this fact is thr, no matter you want to face it or nt

sam but 8 are still friends and refused to disband.they continued and fighting lol thats a fact

yes,i agree with u this just a clon

Aryana BTS wifeu funny until now 2020 they are still snsd and theyre proud of it ahahaha

????

surprisingly?

Because that's her part. And Fany realized that and she takes the part.

@@yoora_kim she didnt say that she hear sica's voice. She obviously talked about the lyric tho. Sounds like "sica, really really good goodbye"

@@fadelengelen2217 dude, its been 2 yrs and u reply it now?

@@yoora_kim just telling you what she meant

私も

Then the song wouldn't have sound this smooth or soothing. Tiffany voice was never meant to cover for Jessica. Shes not as skilled vocally and her registery is too low. This is why she mostly scream or sound forced when doing high notes. Her voice is straining.

tui hiều nè :))) mà sự thật sunny với Seo hát ko hay bằng jess đoạn điệp khúc mà bạn. họ nói cũng đúng thôi

ZZZZZzzzz...

***** But SNSD is going on a downward spiral

Christy Cheung. Lmao. They had a massive comeback in 2015 and they ended up dominating charts for most of that year. Non title tracks from their albums were competing with title tracks from other groups. Additionally, they're having another comeback this year. So Soshi fighting.

9-1=8 Snsd now has 8 members whether you like it or not, they are doing perfectly well and being richer than ever. Sica has her fashion line and her albums are amazing. She's happier now and hope y'all golden stars will too.

Oof this math...

Gmna mw improv,smuany sdih

ใคร

Go out hater. Go wash your ass. I can smell from here.

Chris Moon No need to hate anyone....they do their best to sing the song....

You obviously don't know anything about singing if you think Sunny nor Sooyoung can't sing. Sunny skills are more developed than everyone in her group. Her headvoice is topnotch. Every vocal analysts said that when using her headvoice no one else can ckmpare to her in the group. Sunny just doesn't display her vocal techniques in her group as the other members. Especially not on title tracks. You need to go watch SNSD tours or Sunny's solo projects. Even performances where it's only the vocal line singing. She gives the main vocalists a run for their money everytime.

@@TimelessGap2 Sorry maybe i blamed them because I just want Jessica back and make 9soshi and nobody can cover her. I was such a idiot that time

@@Jjanggusone That's no result to be bitter to the girls. Jessica left the group on her own accord. If she wanted to remain I'm sure there were ways to go about that being that she was an artist under contract. Both parties had to have resched an agreement for it to go over that smoothly. Jessica also mentioned in an interview following her departure that stating "that she left Snsd and being that she can do things she wasn't able to accomplish as Jessica of Snsd." Moreover if you are picking on Sunny and Sooyoung for what happened then you are barking up the wrong tree. Sunny and Sooyoung were two of the girls that Jessica was closest. Jessica never had anything but praised for these two the only ones of the group. Both her and Sooyoung were schoolmates and best friends. Sunny ahe got to know and love as a member and sister. I believe in my heart that these two were on Jessica's side through whatever went down.

@@TimelessGap2 You are right. I was compeletely wrong. Now all of 9 members are precious to me. I blame myself for writing like that. I was stupid. I want 9 girls back together and have a concert someday. I miss them so much.