No video

3 ecocritical ideas in Macbeth | Top grade Shakespeare analysis

  Рет қаралды 1,357

Jen Chan

Jen Chan

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 14
@bakirathethirukumaran
@bakirathethirukumaran Жыл бұрын
Hi Jen! This was so fascinating and you've introduced so many compelling ideas that I would have never thought about. But, I was wondering that perhaps the notion of the witches being physical embodiments of air pollution may not extend to them 'creating' it as such, but they are instead left marginalised into an atmosphere of 'fog' and 'filthy air' since they do not conform to 'healthy' or 'natural' societal gender expectations. Maybe it is this forcible ostracisation that has left them feeling bitterly vindictive, causing them to take part in perverse acts of environmental destruction which we can see when they chant 'fire burn and cauldron bubble'. So, when Macbeth says 'Infected be the air where on they ride', he may not be explicitly claiming that the witches 'infect' the air themselves, but their name and actions are synonymous with such infection, and so use it as a tool in their pursuit of revenge (they only 'ride' on the 'infected air', they don't seem to necessarily 'create' it). So, in other words, maybe they don't cause the air pollution, they are simply associated with it (and rather unjustly, if I might add). Or, perhaps, if we focus on what quantifies 'fog' in itself, that being condensed water vapour, I believe that it paints an image of the gender expectations on Jacobean women to be powerless and submissive - something 'gaseous' and inherently expected to fuel all women - condensing and liquifying into these transgressive women who reject these aforementioned gender norms. If we take it a step further, 'fog' obscures and hides, but at its core, the water vapour and therein, the initial water molecule, will always be there (it is only in a different state), just like the true 'essence' of women will always be there in these witches, despite their admirable efforts to hide and transform it into 'filthy air'. 'Air' also invades and penetrates through everything in its grasp, and so does 'fog' which envelops everything in its clutches, which could draw to your own interpretation that the air pollution that the witches' ostensibly embody, penetrate the confines of Macbeth's ego, completely distorting his perception of morality, but also his id, bringing forth desires in his subconscious that should preferably be left untouched. Furthermore, the 'filthy air' and 'fog' can cause undeniable harm for sure, but air pollution is mitigable and is ephemeral, which could suppose that the witches' power and evil essence is temporary - just like air pollution, it can be reverted back to its healthy state which is achieved through Macbeth's demise, and therein the dissolution of 'fog' and cleaning of the 'filthy air'. Thank you so much for your interpretations and as a GCSE student, they've really made me enjoy literature and open my mind to how engaging archaic texts can be :)
@JenChan
@JenChan Жыл бұрын
This is fantastic stuff, Bakirathe! I love your interpretation. Yes, your point about the witches being marginalised by the moral 'fogginess' of the broader environment - and being triggered into creating environmental destruction through 'fire burn' etc. makes total sense. Also insightful of you to pick up on the association air pollution and the witches' power, although perhaps I'd suspect a more hardline ecocritic may challenge your view that (the impact of) air pollution is ephemeral...! Thank you for engaging with my interpretation so thoughtfully, though - you're most definitely a literary scholar in the making 🤩
@bakirathethirukumaran
@bakirathethirukumaran Жыл бұрын
@@JenChan Thank you so much! 😊I honestly wouldn't have been able to ruminate about criticism in this way without your help. Even if it is only behind a screen, you've done so much for students immersing themselves in literature (which initially does seem really intimidating), so thank you :)
@hamnaali4977
@hamnaali4977 Жыл бұрын
Wow, I'm mind-blown by your perceptive and exploratory interpretation!
@bakirathethirukumaran
@bakirathethirukumaran Жыл бұрын
@@hamnaali4977 Thank you :)
@nicholasshmicholas2637
@nicholasshmicholas2637 2 жыл бұрын
Perhaps an example of Macbeth's own destruction towards nature, could be after he murders Duncan. Where thee natural order tear itself down. "Darkness in Daytime" "And Duncan's horses- Turn'd wild in nature, broke their stalls, flung out"
@JenChan
@JenChan 2 жыл бұрын
Oh yes, love this! Thanks for suggesting :)
@floraleuphoria241
@floraleuphoria241 2 жыл бұрын
thank you so much for this! have my exam tomorrow and i’m hoping i can mention some of this :))
@JenChan
@JenChan 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for watching! And all the best with your exams xxx
@christiangirltalk070
@christiangirltalk070 3 ай бұрын
how did it go
@lamlamco275
@lamlamco275 2 жыл бұрын
Become your fan rn :DD!! interesting vid !
@JenChan
@JenChan 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks :) I appreciate you!
@srr7674
@srr7674 2 жыл бұрын
Amazing video
@JenChan
@JenChan 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for watching!
Prank vs Prank #shorts
00:28
Mr DegrEE
Рет қаралды 11 МЛН
Just Give me my Money!
00:18
GL Show Russian
Рет қаралды 585 М.
Paradigm Shifts: "The Ecological Turn in Literary Studies": Prof. Kate Rigby
26:43
Freiburg Institute for Advanced Studies (FRIAS)
Рет қаралды 14 М.
Supernatural Macbeth in 9 Quotations
25:26
Mr Salles Teaches English
Рет қаралды 34 М.
3 reasons why you should do a literature degree
14:35
Jen Chan
Рет қаралды 913
100 Films That Changed My Life
20:26
Bruce Tetsuya
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН
"I Think Therefore I Am" Explained
23:45
Alex O'Connor
Рет қаралды 638 М.
How to Read Shakespeare: Five Easy to Use Strategies
5:18
Oxford Comma
Рет қаралды 24 М.
Analysis of the poker game symbol in A Streetcar Named Desire
17:06
Prank vs Prank #shorts
00:28
Mr DegrEE
Рет қаралды 11 МЛН