That first story could have ended so much worse than what it did. That was actually so scary I’m glad they got out of there in time.

Story 1 reminds me of a horror film. A rural town, and weird, creepy people living in it. The Church and gas station, and the end of the story just gave me Children Of The Corn vibes. Couldn't imagine how scary that would have been.

the fact that the 8 yr old in the 4th story was actually aware of creeps means he has actually decent parents

Story 3 reminds me of a time I walked in on what I'm pretty sure was a mob meeting at this deli in Toronto. There was a pizzeria attached to it that never seemed to be open but one day when I went to the deli to get a sandwich, saw people in it and figured - what the hell, maybe I'll try a slice. The door from the deli area was unlocked so I go in, see a bunch of dudes sitting around a table, nobody at the register and nothing apparently being cooked, no 'pizza smell', everything looked brand new and never used. I just remember these guys at the table suddenly got real quiet and were all staring at me when I walked in. I took the hint and got the fug outta dodge. There was a murder at that deli some years later that was allegedly a hit by the Russian mob.

started watching you when I was 12 ish, now I'm 19, time sure does fly. I always made it a habit to check your channel every 6 months or so and you'd have a mountain of vids posted that I could binge for a solid day or two. thank you for providing this content.

I went to the Notre-Dame cathedral in Paris about 10 years ago, and on the day we went it was very rainy and there was lightning right overhead. I almost thought it was going to strike the building. It wasn’t necessarily scary but it definitely helped set the depressing gothic mood that such a cathedral is known for.

For anyone thinking about the thumbnail - it's an abandoned church in Czech Rebuplic named St.George's Church. It was left behind after the roof fell during a funeral. The ghosts are statues made by Jakub Hadrava, and because local belived it was haunted or cursed - he decided to play into this idea. The city failed to repair and renovate it due to low funds but now tourists have donated a lot of money for the roof to be reapiered. There were some tourists that didn't go in due to feeling uneasy because of the ghosts. I personally would go in as I find it hauntingly beautiful.

Listening to Story 1, I kept thinking, "Don't follow that man's directions! What are you doing?!" I was convinced the man was leading them into a trap. Thankfully, the path really did lead to the highway, but they got seriously lucky!

As a Georgia resident who's heard and seen things in rural Georgia, the Warren County Georgia case sounds less like a cult meeting and more like a daytime Klan meeting.

Both the 1st and 3rd stories are both eerily similar, I'm getting cult-like vibes from them

Story 4 really creeped me out… it’s honestly a lot like what happened to my church about a year ago. A staff member of the church, someone who I knew since I was a little kid, someone who was in charge of Youth activities and games, had turned out to be some kind of child predator. It makes it really creepy and weird to me because although he never tried anything on me, I always saw him as such a cool and fun guy. He talked to me a lot and had a nickname for me. It makes me uncomfortable thinking about it now because I don’t know if he was just trying to act nice, or had some, fucked up interest in me or not. I’m very glad I only ever met him in public areas, as it’s horrifying thinking of me and him in a room together. Obviously the church has cut him out, and I’m pretty sure he’s been arrested, or something like that.

Stories 1 and 3 feel like very similar experiences despite being in completely different states. I think it's safe to assume there are a lot more churches like that in the south where if you walk in you might get similar reactions from the people inside.

1 and 3 are reasons why you shouldn't walk right into a church that is currently going on. They walked into some crazy cult that doesn't like outsiders, could get dangerous.

Story number three gave me the creeps. I grew up in Atlanta, but I’m very familiar with towns in areas like what was described. It would not surprise me one bit if there was a cult going on, and that the police were even somehow involved, or knew about it. Small towns, and rural areas in the south of the United States… All sorts of weird stuff goes on. I’d never want to live in one

When I was a kid, I used to visit Alley Springs, Arkansas with my dad. There is an old mill and a school/church building, both are well over 150 years old. It was always eerie being there but I never had any experiences of any kind. When my wife and I were just dating, I brought her and our dog to alley springs to show her around and it immediately felt different than when I was young. Walking through the trails that I’ve been on dozens of times and it felt like being in someone else’s house without permission. Hair standing up, constantly feeling that we just should not be here. We toured the paper mill and then walked toward the church/school and that’s when our dog planted himself to the ground. He was staring directly at the church with his back hair sticking straight up and growling. And he WOULD NOT go any further. After the day we had, we looked at each other and nodded because we were both ready the gtfo and never come back. I have no idea what he saw and I think I’m fine with that.

I'm surprised this wasn't a topic before. Crazy things have happened in places of worship, both true crime and supernatural

It’s getting to the point where I feel that Mr Nightmare has read so many of these stories that he is just immune to fear

Story 1 is definitely my all time favorite Mr. Nightmare story of all time now.

I had a similar experience with a cult at an abandoned church. Honestly, telling the story is the best way to handle the weird vibe one gets from being present. I wrote a story with some truth mixed into the fiction, as I feared the worst if the actual truth were revealed. I published that story years ago... Broken Wing Dragon. Please forgive me for the mention of the book, but it can easily relate to two of the stories in this video. I enjoyed listening.

I’m excited for all Mr.Nightmare videos but this one seems extra thrilling

Mr. Nightmare always delivers the quality videos, and has done so consistently for years. He deserves all the praise and thanks for the great content!

Churches have been a theme for creepy stories for a long time. In Finnish folklore there is a concept of "Kalman väki" (lit. translated "people of death", specifically "decaying" death), of undead people who hold their own strange masses in churches at nights. "Kalma" is also a name of an ancient female death deity that was worshipped by some pre-Christian Finnic tribes as a goddess of death and decay, which adds another layer of creepiness.

There is absolutely nothing creepier than being alone in a church building at night! I had to clean a church at night and once and had to go into the attic! Talk about being freaked out!!

I’m surprised this has never been a theme for a video before. Mr. Nightmare, always breaking new ground.

Old abandoned churches are the creepiest. They always seem demonic since Gods word is no longer spoken in them.

Wow, how strange is the thumbnail?! That is exactly one of the first nightmares I ever had as a child! In a church my parents were speaking to a priest. Behind us, the doors flew open and leaves rushed in. When I turned back, my parents and brother were gone. I walked up the steps to of the inside of the church and saw beds in the darkness and ghosts covered in sheets were floating above them.

The first story was really eerie. As explained the supposing loving church wasn’t so loving and friendly to the young men and it’s a good thing they left that area before it got dark because they could have been victims of a human sacrifice. Thanks Mr. Nightmare for narrating another intriguing story you have an incredible imagination.

This reminds me of the Hills Have Eyes movie. It’s not surprising to me knowing all the weird things that go on that no one knows about unless they listen to Mr. Nightmare. I appreciate Mr. Nightmare because he has warned me of what not to do when I I am thinking everything is normal but suddenly unexpected things happen when I least expect it.

Mr. Nightmare's material is always so engrossing! He has easily one of the best narration based channels on the platform. His content is truly thrilling!

can we all just appreciate that Mr. Nightmare has such awesome stories!

First story is actually so crazy. Especially the cop telling em about some crazy witch folks. Extremely cool vibe though. Ominous town with many secrets.

I recently moved south from New England. So the whole religion thing down here has taken a little getting use to. Around my new home, it’s common for strangers to ask you to be a guest at church. I met a woman and her husband and they were seriously so nice and although I’m neither here nor there about religion I took them up on the offer. I honestly just wanted to form a connection with them since I felt so lonely here at first. After the service they were insistent I go back to their house for lunch. And I mean of course I did. But no more than half an hour of being there they get in there car and just drive away. Like I was sitting in the outdoor area and they had gone inside for a minute. But then I see there truck going down the dirt road away from the house. Never said anything to me. Never saw them again. And I’ve driven by the house but it’s a long driveway so I don’t see anything really. I never even got creepy vibes or anything. But like who does that?

Thank you for the stories. Gets me through housecleaning 😅

Mr. Nightmare's videos feels almost nostalgic, by far my favorite horror story teller on YT.

After hearing the cult stories in here, you should really do a cult horror stories video. Like stories from either people's run in's with a cult or stories from when they were in one

The fourth story sounds like a creepy churchwarden. Churchwardens were both security and maintained the grounds while living on site. They are rare these days but some churches do keep the tradition going.

I remember wanting to hear church stories from Mr. Nightmare for a while now, it’s so cool to see this notification! Thank you!

I have been listening to Mr. Nightmare every single day during lunch time at work but when I say this video gave me the actual chills, omg *goosebumps* The first story was so so scary, I was picturing the scenes in my mind as he was reading them, it gave me Wrong Turn vibes where the old man would give travelers the wrong directions, I was screaming inside my head to not listen to the old man! God!

Man Ive been checking your channel every week for the past 6 years to see if you had a new upload bro. I remember watching all your lockdown horror stories those where the best. I love watching your videos man and I can always count on you to keep me up at night, wondering if I'm being watched, or if I'm not alone in my room. Keep doing what your doing bro 🖤

That last story was absolutely disgusting! I felt like throwing up after hearing that! It sickens me knowing how many people like that exist in this world😡😡😡😡🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

Yooo, Mr. Nightmare, Idk if you'll see this, but I just wanna say that I seriously appreciate your work. You've always put a ton of effort into all your videos, from the audio to your tone of voice, and I've always enjoyed your content. Thanks for uploading more frequently lately, ive had a lot of fun binging your vids!

You know it's a good day when Mr. Nightmare drops a new video ‼️‼️🙏

Mr. Nightmare definitely has the voice for such and perfect timing

I love Mr Nightmare's narration & His videos. This new one by far was very creepy as hell. I sometimes turn on his channel to fall asleep, his voice is soothing.

i love your stories so much. I can't explain how excited I get everytime I see that Mr nightmare posted. I especially love hearing his stories during late night car rides with my friends.

This one I really enjoyed! Always look forward to new content from this channel!

8:00 I just imagine some person coming out of the darkness when the boys after they run out saying "kids these days are so dumb, oh look they play this stupid game"

I love to listen to these while doing homework! You never disapoint me with your content!

These were some great stories, would love a part 2!

I wish you would come out with more weekly material because I love your channel!!!

Short but scary if you think about it, true story. In high school I was doing a internship with my chiropractor as soon I was done with my hours for the day I walked home, not to far from my place but as soon I passed a old church 2 old ladies ran out of the church. Something I honestly didn’t expect, they kept saying no on repeat. The hood instincts kicked in and ran with them. To this day I still have my wits about that church. Stay safe everyone.

This is the first time Mr Nightmare tells a horror story about Church! Story 3 - that was not a mass they attended, they almost went inside _the Cult_ !

The first story reminds me of Corspe Husband's story on the church, where people were also singing.

Im so happy to see you posted a video.. i absolutely love your channel.

Yay!!! Thank you, Mr. Nightmare! I've been hoping for scary church stories!!

Been listening to these for nearly 5 years can’t get enough of mr nightmare!

I love your content/channel!!! Please upload more often Mr. Nightmare

the background audios in this one were simply terrifying 😳 damn mr. nightmare’s just getting better and better

Listening to this alone on a night shift. Loving it.

This is seriously the best day of my week. I look forward to your new stories after school to sleep to.

I've been dying for a church video, and it's finally here!🙌

I love you Mr. Nightmare. I couldn’t get through my workday without your videos. Thanks for the awesome stories. ♥️♥️♥️

More Horror Stories Ideas: Valentine's Day St. Patrick's Day 10 True Horror Stories Volume 9 and 10 Insane Asylum Picnic/Park McDonald's Burger King Garden/Gardening Library Trading School Funeral Home Nursing Home Concert

My day just got better. Thanks for posting.

Dear Mr Nightmare , I recently tuned into your channel and the first video I have seen from you was the crawl space . it was so scarey and than I I kept watching more of your videos and man I tell you them videos sends chills down my spine. I will continue to watch them . I really think that your videos are great and can also help many to watch their surrounding's .Thank you Mr. Nightmare.

Great quality video like always. Keep up the good work!

1. They probably stumbled on a Satanic church 2. Could be or could be not a man trying to scare them or something else 3. Cults could held a meeting from anywhere including an abandoned church 4. Okay I have a story for this as well. I'm a servant for the church so, in simple terms, I'm a Roman Catholic. I remember one-time where I was serving from scheduled serve, and while the mass is still on going, a church goer comes to me and said, "Have you seen my purse?" "No, ma'am." And I could tell from the tone of her voice that she was in a panic, and then when I was finished on my scheduled serve and was already leaving, I saw a police officer is on the patio doing his job, asking questions and stuff. And then, the next day where I was on my scheduled serve, and the mass was almsot done and was already in the announcements. As usual, our parish priest will say something important to the church goers related to the announcements, but this time, he reported, "Last night, our cctv camera's picked up a man who is roaming around inside the church grounds. And it took someone's purse." I was shocked, and I asked the woman who asked me where her purse were, "Excuse me, ma'am. May I know what's inside of your purse." She said, "Everything. Credit cards. ID's and other stuff." This goes to show that be attentive to your personal belongings, all places are considered not safe even churches. You never know when an individual would take the most important belongings from you.

Thank you Mr. Nightmare I really needed this ❤

Mr. Nightmare, I’ve been watching/listening to you for the last 8 years. I’m so proud of your progress and I’m sincerely happy for you! You don’t realize how much these stories help me clean the house and cook!!!

I love this channel ❤ thank you!!!! Love scary stories😊

And my family tells me nothing bad happens in a church. Hmph

Glad you finally did this topic!

Your timing is impeccable. Truly.

I’ve been watching you after a year of you starting your channel it’s always great to bing story’s after forgetting you and then finding you again

Some of these horrific church stories honestly gave me the chills, especially stories 1, 2 and 4...

Always got new and good topics I love it!!! Been a fan for years and u never disappoint ❤❤

Great stories..thanks Mr.Nightmare❤😊

This is easily one of the best Mr. Nightmare videos. These stories are great

Love the consistency with mr nightmare ❤

Oh man church horror stories! I bet the list is endless for this topic. Mr. Nightmare you are the best storyteller on KZfaq. No matter what I'm doing, when I get notified I drop what I'm doing and click on it. Thank you Mr. Nightmare! 💜

I live close to Warren county Georgia, so hearing the story literally hits close to home!! Thanks for your amazing content!

Mr. Nightmare, I really love and enjoy listening to your stories. Your voice is calming yet, scary and the right tone of suspense. Thank you. 😊

I’ve been watching for 5 years and I love your content keep up the good work

Mr. Nightmare always comes up with new amazing video ideas. His channel is amazing!

I’ve been watching all your videos since 2015/2016 and this one has got to be in the top 10 scariest. Very well done.

love seeing mr nightmare upload give me joy love your videos been watching for awhile

I’m always on time for your videos

One thing to know about rural America, and I mean really rural....like "300 people in a town rural"....is that there are a LOT of small churches and cult communities out there. The sort of places where literally the whole town is related to each other in some way, shape, or form. And everyone attends the local church. They are, generally speaking, not welcoming to outsiders.

Nothing like blazing up on 4/20 listening to some scary stories🔥🌳

Am I only one that turns on mr. Nightmare stories and listen into oblivion like staring at a wall with posters, just listen and when the story starts to unravel in your mind, it is so vivid by the end.☺️ I love how he tells the story.😌

been watching mr nightmare for 6 and a half years, never get tired of these stories

Always a fabulous day when Mr. Nightmare posts a new video!

I’m happy with these consistent uploads, you’re like a cure to boredom.

Dude ur channel is awesome I love it

I just want say thank you for your videos I watch while cleaning, playing video games, sleeping, etc, I absolutely love your videos ❤

I love these sm tyyy!

Always a treat when Mr.Nightmare post

Amazing story’s Mr. Nightmare love your content

Terrific thumbnail. I watch these during the day sometimes, because they're too creepy at night. 😱 Thanks for being the Creepy Stories Champion. I thank everyone who submits their stories.

Holy crap that first video where they realised there were no crosses that gave me chills lmao