BAP IS 3RD GEN

@@tooth9420 no theyre not, they made their debut in 2012 and thats still 2nd gen

How about SISTAR

So good to know people know about 9muses

OMG BAP 😭😭😭

This wasn't their peak at all! Their last two releases did incredibly well

10000000% AGREEE *-*

maykissify I completely disagree...

wileymerkage you can't disagree with the fact that What's Your Name was one of the best charting songs of 2013. It's a fact

I was leaning towards Whatcha Doing Today....

YOO❤

Me

Meeee

들켰네. 잘 숨어 다녔는데. 😂😂😂

me too

Totally agree! Listen to it almost everyday!

이 노래가 이제 11살이 됐네요 맙소사 😭😭😭😭😮😮😮

I wish we go bk to this era

Alex Rosewood its kpop, they used the most advanced and most expensive in 2012.

Because 2012 is not that far back rofl. You thought this would be in black and white or what?

This is one of the sharpest and timeless video concept

2012.. you make it seem like this was made in the 90s haha

@@taompons what he's saying is the quality of the video. It looks 8k. 8k reso only launched in other countries lately. Yet some countries are stilk in 4k. And the idea of costumes looks ahead of time. Sometimes it takes common sense to understand.

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

Starting a 4M discography marathon while crying on this terrible news.

It's official that they're disbanding 😭😭😭😭😭😭

+Dan and phil Sugg I know, it's a real shame.😔

i really think crazy and hate were better than this song o-o

I was 8 years old when this came out. I still come back to this from time to time

Well Im a mother now and still come back to the golden age of kpop. Kpop now stresses me but yeah I miss those days

me

Here. Is nostalgic ❤💔

I was finishing school when this came out. I'm literally old school in kpop 😭

Same happened to me...

I feel you, it's the same for me ;;

same xD

Listen to Hyuna's solo songs, good place to start: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/n8iPZKSFy9icp4E.html

Disband or not it doesnt matter i still listen to them

Yeah, that's right

Yes! To this day I still can't find a kpop MV with a special effect as good as Volume Up's 'Turning into black smoke' special effect

Agree! Their best song imo

This was hella expensive as well

Agreed. Song is hype and video is gorgeous

4th and 3rd gen idols can sing too lmao

@@brennathecatlover4360 lol

@@aespaforever1034 lol I’m right and K-pop always cared about looks too but you’re just in denial. New K-pop idols still can sing stay mad you’re wrong

Vocals do seem to have had more variety in the 2nd gen compared to now. Mostly cutesy voices indeed and an absence of powerful voice like in this video

Look at you ! Record yourself when traveling the God or Internet you set your eyes on. Look at how long you stared in dumb mode. They creat d.u.m.b.s. extracting your retinal scanned look. If you can read behavior, imagine what has been kept from you as far as the advancement of what they do. Understand mental slavery and the control to keep your eyes off Life and in reality. Truman show people. And I'm not Jim Carrey Liar Liar. Don't be a dumb E , dummy.

Kira Shin please stop bringing down other gg’s.

Ithinkchildrentastegoodsendhelp they are not bringing anyon down.. it’s a fact

I like mature concept❤ have experience😄 but fact.. more likes young.,😂we like all about kpop so 'dnt worry'✌

@@rae6075 please be respectful of someone's opinions and try not to be butthurt about it, it's all free speech and the best thing we could do is respect it ❤️

4minute always had a unique feel.

same 😭💕

I met you in 2018 and I still here

omggg soumaya jp has _T A S T E S_

I consider "Volume Up" to be the first Girlcrush MV.

It isn’t the first girl crush MV but it is great. This song still goes so hard today

11 YEARS LATER 🤧

@@yinyinn03 Still ate any rookie up with one song. C.V.N.T on the silver plate.

the cuntiness shooked the rookies@@itsflowerbitch3321

Hae 3 ikr this song never gets old

i never feels so old

It's been 8 years old now

This is so sad

I’m late... ;-;

Lol..

actually this mv is one of the most expensive ones (if not the most, not sure) in the kpop industry

Well Gayoon is the stylist and she has very expensive taste that happens to be absolutely perfect. I actually don't know if she's always been the stylist or if it started later on.

+IRENE GALLARDO T-ARA's Cry Cry was the most expensive, I believe

I agree the fashion is ON POINT

Fucking facts...they all had own uniqueness.. they all the same now I really don't understand the hype :( I miss the goldens

indeed. I'm a big fan of 2nd generation

Debuted in a wrong time ? I don't think so they can debuted any time and still op af

During 2nd Gen, kpop wasn't as known internationally as it is right now. But all 2nd Gen artists are considered legends at this point.

@@Duma2011 to me popularity isn't where it is at. It is where the good music lies

I mean...Oh my god by Idle is a close comparison~

I hope so too. I really miss it

It's a classic!

😂❤

It's originally from sunrise Inc mysterious girl

Kenny G

@@kedskies sunrise inc released the mv of mysterious girl on April 24th, 2012- 4minute’s mv was released on April 8th, 2012.

True

@@kedskies fact: They both bought the melody from a third party musician, so no one is copying anyone.

Same here

Yeah. Me too!

Anh Vuong same

same

Same here 😢

And both were treated badly by their companies...

Yes. Miss them so much 😭

@@kay_7701 I love you isn't sexy though

@@Nick-ue1kg It is. A classy kind of sexy.

Golden age.

Yipz :'( It's both great & terrible that it's no longer just a nice genre :'( A unique & beautiful lil niche genre :'(

what i was thinking too lol

@@GermanGDragon i find it funny how back then nobody even called themselves k-pop fans, it was all just music to us. i feel like now k-pop has a much stronger identity and is proudly korean and confident about itself. i like how now it is more respected and influential

I was 2 years old at that time

Bro this is my first k-pop song…. I found it through a Levi x Reader K-pop idol pov 🙃🙃🙃 Not the highlight of my childhood but it lead me to 4minute and k-pop, so its cool lol

Ikr

Cause they disbanded im so sad😭

Hi Merries!

nope😓

nope :(

I'm ok.

Am not okay 😢

WE ARE NOT😭

Their*

This was one of the first Kpop videos I saw. It's still one of my all time songs and videos. So fierce. They were so unique. Strong and fierce like 2ne1 but had that sexy aspect too they stayed. 😭

+Joseph O'Sullivan "So fierce" is right! This is a damn good, unique kpop video! And they had other good songs, too; hard to believe they disbanded... There are so many other groups that'll never achieve anything like this; what becomes of them now?

Joseph O'Sullivan

same 😢😢😢

Yeah, 2nd gen was kpop's golden age honestly. Now it's very uninspired.

Also they could pull off perfectly this kind of songs which requires a huge talent, huge power. It's really not given to anyone to make a song in this style, so powerful with club dance elements, powerful vocals and make a masterpiece that sounds just right.

Check out dreamcatcher they have some dark fantasy vibes :D

@@ashley_smith yess I was about to say that

i recommend wjsn if u like fantasy/dreamy

Here

🙁

hii

🙋🏽‍♀️

뀨~

ㄹㅇ 싼티안나고 딱 섹시한 그 느낌...

this is still my favourite

I love them now. "Crazy" was just... amazing.

Look at their new song.

May Lee Agreed

May Lee Did you like Crazy? I think that is their best album to date!

same

same & i agree

2021 still addicted ❤️

Hi miyeon unnie:)❤

Yes this is true. Many netizens have voted this song as their best song. Even for me.

I Hate You and Crazy are pretty GREAT, too...

@@aewinteroutsoldaekarina2631 chvu

❤️

It's just a shame they aren't together and most are not singing anymore 😐

yo brader

Good

Agree

+Luuh Soares they disbanded 😭

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO WHY GIRLS WHY?!!!!!!!!!!!!!

😭😭

+Caitlin Swain Why? 😅

Lilium Power why what😂? they broke up 😟

:)

The 2 best voices in the group

I just want

Siang Hmung xx

No need to shade blackpink. Some of us actually like 4minute, 2ne1 and blackpink. Not for the same reason though.

dxyx mltifndom 2ne1 was the baddest then 4minute

IKR like compare as if it’s your last by Blackpink with crazy or hate or volume up or any of 4minute’s songs. Like I love cute concepts the most and am not a fan of girl crush or badass but in my opinion only 4minute and a couple other second generation girl groups, they’re the only ones who can pull it off naturally and I love them for that reason even though it’s my leats favourite concept I can’t deny 4minute’s power and I love all of their songs

@@elainegalloway4287 Actually i like blackpink too. I dont hate them. Im just so sick of their fans (new kpop listeners maybe) claiming BP is the most baddast girl group ever.. Like duh.

They never saw how badass 4Minute and 2ne1 were... 😂

Emily Rose lol wtf did you expect

Caleb Hughes shut up

Ikr TT

Caleb Hughes stfu bitch they were legendary they didn’t deserve to be disbanded us 4nias were in pain after hearing that you would feel the same way

Why did they disband?

Hyuna will be really tired ...

poor Hyuna, now I know how she can be that slim :))))

PLEASE TELL ME YOU'RE NOT LYING TORUBLEMAKER?!?!! IM ACTUALLY CRYING READING THAT OMFG OMOMOMOBDJSJAJSJWHAHHS😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 pls god pls ill be good forever

Me...

..Me.

me

me =(

me :(

cant believe its been 10 years omg

오... 이 음악에도 세로 드립이...!

volume upup!!

agreed! not to mention, the vocals and jazzy feeling 💅🏽

Jeremy A I TOTALLY AGREE

Most K-pop songs back in the late 2000s and early 2010s were really good and unique. Now? I'd say K-pop = rotten

@@jasons4045 couldn't agree more.

@@jasons4045 K-pop has become complacent. Nowadays they just stick to the same formula.

Hi

What about hyunah?

@@areyoudeadI think They didn't think they had to explain HyunA she's didn't leave cube she continued making music with them

Jiyoon and Gayoon are both incredibly talented, and deserve more credit and attention, than they get.

Yesss. Hyuna is the main one in the group. She's really talented sure but the other members are really talented as well. No one sees that.

Same 😭 Jiyoon was my first bias

+Blackjack 4nia agree

It was JUST announced that Jiyoon got signed to another label!!! Get excited!!!!!!!!!

She is Jiyoon .. She's also my bae 😍 ahahaha .. jkjk

she is Jiyoon my bias 😍

+iey lumagod jiyoon

Jiyoonie 😍😍😍

@@the-viewer yeah! And also I forgot to add the part where ppl have said "blackpink is better because their English is better" like.... K-Pop IS Americanized now and comments like that prove my point. K-Pop was so unique back in the day.

@@the-viewer ikr??!! Nothing wrong with Selena Gomez but it just doesn't even feel like K-Pop when they feature American artists.

The Viewer As a person who loves Kpop since 2nd gen and loves many newer Kpop groups, I disagree. Especially the “cheap copy of American pop” part is exaggerated to me imo. Kpop still has its uniqueness of talent, choreography, vocals, and rap that makes American pop look bland in comparison. Even the sound in Kpop music still sounds way better than American music today. Also idk about the Kpop being “Americanized” part considering that Kpop has always been influenced by American music since the start. Western producers/songwriters have always helped in making songs for Kpop bc they find that the Kpop industry allows for more creativity than the Western one. As for those type of “Kpop fans” that only like some groups bc their English is better or some stupid reason, they aren’t real Kpop fans (and a minority bc I barely run into them at all in my experience). It’s unfortunate they exist, but they really are a minority in comparison to Kpop fans that love Kpop bc of the talent and amazing music in it. I do understand your viewpoint since I used to view it that way a few years ago tho. But I say that you should also give newer Kpop artists a chance as well and have an open mind ^^ (Sidenote: I also love how Kpop nowadays have members participating more in song writing and choreography. And as much as I love 2nd gen, rapping and choreography in Kpop has improved so much since then)

Someone had to say it. 👌

Why do y'all think rapping and certain music is ONLY AMERICAN lol.. I love both old and new groups.. Kpop is still very unique. But that's just your opinion and I understand.

ikrrr she's a *QUEEN* btw she just released a new single !!! kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q9OeftNz38yYn30.html

+exol4ever! 4minute is like Beast, they don't have an specific music genre so they always try anything new with their comebacks :3

+b2st__paradise but recently theyre sticking with the fierce concept

Chrysline Lim yes but even tho they still make different music gerne although you can feel the fierce concept.

+b2st__paradise I agree. They're strong and fierce in this even though it's not the obvious upfront concept. I love this song and this video. STILL!

+Chrysline Lim Jiyoon has always been fierce ;D. Even in Volume up, with that powerful voice and her dance moves.

Cool

Well im one of those new generation lmao 😅😅😅 but well i do like bts and blackpink but i also love 4MIBUTE, this is a badass masterpiece

And twice man

@@goldendragon7853 twice has not one single song that is a tenth as good as this one.

馬君 are you actually serious fancy, special, signal, tt. Mann get out of here with that

+woogyu trash Time flies doesn't it?

+woogyu trash 4 years ago and I still think this is one of their best songs lol

+omg liy who do you think i am....

+omg liy omg lol

and i fucking loved it

Golden age.

It's definitely a memorable one for me!!

Same 😭

Saeko Kuga дуььшамэрэрд

Mine too

same :D

Hara nama I'll die of happiness if there is a 4minute reunion.

exactly! :(

i like 2ne1 and them

+Au Sisloenn same!

Au Sisloenn And now they are officially disband. 2NE1 and 4minute

😭😭😭 i know...

Lol awesome right :)

Woojong, have you been exploring more like Love Tension, HUH, First, Mirror Mirror, I Me Mine, and Muzik. So many more I could name from the early years. Their new song CRAZY just brought them back to top.

thanks ^_^

BITCH YASSSS💎🖐️😌

@@johnNcupCaKES 😏💫✨🔥

I'm in love with these girls

+Omega SONE Hahaha Yeah.

+Omega SONE red eyes doesnt mean vampiric style. somehow their music and dance style seems to resemble the late singer U;Nee. OK thats my opinion only

walker ten well, a vampire theme was their concept for this song, not only the red eyes, but, them appearing with a black mist is another sign, bats as well

+)

+Алекс Дыбов прив

+polina ship хай

yeah actually not them also I mean by GIDLE

Yes what?

Aidana Tractenberg True True True

Crystal Velvet cube mistreated g idle too the only reason they are having proper combecks is that they make their music by them selves they weren't making their own music they would have been clc 2.0 even lion MV was made by their own money that they made from queendom So stop spreading misinformation soyeon and other g idle members are working hard all the time and they make most of the money for cube but cube don't speak for them when someone steals their hardworking they don't even try to protect them so stop saying that cube only cares for g idle bc its not true

Nevie excuse me but (G) I-die gets proper promotion and proper stage outfits. Have you seen CLC’s devil stage outfits ? They don’t get the right promotion and don’t even have a lightstick, because CUBE doesn’t care about them even though they could’ve been as big as Blackpink. CLC pays their own plane tickets and oversea promotions and Sorn does her best in promoting CLC in Thailand so please. EVERY idol works hard and Yeeun does write some of her raps and helps in composing the songs. CLC’s comeback single “La Vien Rose” which was already recorded was just sold to Iz*one when it could’ve been CLC’s Second breakthrough hit. They even started to post hints on Instagram and had a choreography. CUBE cares more for (G) I-dle than they do for CLC and that is a fact and I didn’t even list ALL of their mismanagement