I, personally, believe that Tigerheart is what Tigerclaw could have been. Ambitious but only has good intentions for his Clan

I like tiger heart as a flawed good guy. I hope he doesn’t turn into a villain.

They better not do that because I swear I dumped every single warriors books because I had it with them recycling their freaking characters

4rcane bringing some light onto TigerHeart once again, I’m not gonna lie the title scared me since I am a huge fan of TigerHeart and haven’t read A Starless Clan but I’m relieved that the title wasn’t the case. Really interesting video in general though with comparing the two, I think the fandom needed something like this.

I do not think he was right to take over RiverClan and nothing can change my mind on that, They did not want him there, and he would not listen until he was pressured by other clans, BUT at the same time, i don't think he was doing it out of evilness

I think Tigerheart has one thing that Tigerclaw didn't have, empathy. That's what makes Tigerheart different, Tigerheart is a genuinely good cat that just does bad things in good faith. Imo he is a bad leader, but mostly because he does a lot of things without thinking of the overall consequences. But he's not nearly as horrible as his grandfather. Also technically Tigerheart could be considered half clan himself. Tawnypelt was born in Thunderclan to Thunderclan parents (since Golden and Tigerstar both are born Thunderclan cats). So if Tigerheart's kits are considered half clan bc Dovewing is originally from Thunderclan, technically Tigerheart would also be considered half clan. Right? Please let that make sense.

Tiger (nothing else to say )

I personally think tigerheartstar is one of the best leader

The art in this video is SUPER AWESOME!!!

I despise Tigerheartstar but saying he's anywhere near Tigerclawstar's level is ridiculous

As Tigerheart's biggest fan on this planet, I have no idea how I haven't seen this video before I agree with most of what you've said, though I don't agree with a few things, like Tigerheartstar taking over RiverClan for revenge. He himself says Rowankit's death had absolutely nothing to do with it, in the book, and saying he did do it out of revenge is like implying he lied to his whole Clan while keeping a straight face, lol... Minor nitpick, but it bothers me how easily it was accepted as... Canon? But overall, I agree with the message. Tigerheart is not turning into Tigerclaw and people saying he is, is just kind of dumb. There's nothing about his behavior that would imply he means anything bad, even if what he's doing is not always the smartest thing, especially considering how shocked and upset he is when compared to his grandfather. And I'll say what I once said here. I think Tigerheartstar doing many of the same things as Tigerclaw but doing those things with the best intentions is really poetic, some people would say Tigerheart's writing is bad, but it's the opposite, it's really good for warrior cats standards, Tigerheart actually feels like a person (cat?) not just words on a page, and it fascinates me Tigerheartstar is the better Tigerstar, he's what Tawnypelt wanted, for Tigerheart to be remembered as The Tigerstar, and not her father.

I want to say yes, but i know that is just my heavy dislike for tigerheartstar, he really isn't as bad as Tigerclaw, he seems like he can actually learn from his actions.

Are you using Clip Studio?

So was tiger star the yes grandfather, I mean. Did he have a good relationship with his mother?

if tigerheart became tigerstar.. atleast he is going to be a lot more interesting.. personally i hate tigerheartstar.. DONT ATTACK ME

Not sure who that is but hehe hi ah the (it’s a joke in my house)

Morally gray characters are always welcome imo. More interesting that way! I still don't forgive Tawnypelt for naming her kit Tigerkit though. What is wrong with you?!

I resently rewached Lion king and, well, ITS WORRIOR CATS !!! If you tinck aboute it Lion king has the same sort of plot! There is Skare who is Tigerstar, Simba who is Firestar and Nala is Sandstorme - and lots of charecters that will give you Worrior cats vibe. Also thay have STAR CLANE!!! Simba actualy sed that " those ae the ANSESTER kings." So.... yah.... if you are a worrior cats fan, rewach Lion king. 🙀

No!!!!!

I do think tawny was pretty spot on with her name choice for tigerheart, he is very much like his grandpa just subtracting all the murderous tendencies and retcon innate evilness