This was a very cool challenge, Ryan, thanks for inviting me! I had such a great time listening to the other tracks - awesome work, guys! I was hoping for wildly different but great variations, and that's what we got. ❤
@LiamRaitorComposerАй бұрын
You nailed it, man! Congrats, it's always a pleasure and inspiring to hear what you do!
@LiamRaitorComposerАй бұрын
Oh, I love your takes on the theme so much, guys! 😃 I'm so happy to have been part of this video! Thank you so much, Ryan and your team, for the invite! ❤ Every time I participate in a contest or project with Ryan, I have the opportunity to learn and experiment in uncharted territory. I'm so grateful every time! A big thanks to my sibling for helping me out with the drums and percussion, which made the music 10 times better than it was before ! 😉
@douglasbradley7244Ай бұрын
Amazing project! So cool to see how the different composers approached the theme. Bravo!
@lulcy789Ай бұрын
Jeff hilkema’s is so good
@gamedevmanti4578Ай бұрын
yeah, definitely my favourite using fragments from the melody to extend the piece, then have the main thing at the climax is such a powerful composition approach!
@@victorxue7088 Yeah, you killed it! Your piece is so much fun! 😃
@johnhill762Ай бұрын
Yours was the best. Didn’t like any of the others.
@alexchristodoulouАй бұрын
@@johnhill762 thanks 😊
@GautierSeguinMusic27 күн бұрын
Hey, i think my favorite one is the Jeff's composition :D But really nice work for everyone ! And i love the rythm for Victor Xue :D
@ajilanthemusicalАй бұрын
Great idea for a video! I really enjoyed hearing all these different styles--it's a toss-up between Jeff's and Liam's for my favorite. Well done, all!
@XXIII_89Ай бұрын
Links been hitting the spice again.. now they need to do the spirit temple in that dune style!!!
@MoryBuxnerАй бұрын
I feel that in Arild Wanvik's version, the melody is completely drowned out by Dune, to the point where you could remove the Song of Time completely and not notice much difference.
@arildwtvАй бұрын
Thanks for the feedback! It's all about striking the right balance, I guess. I was very intrigued by translating the SoT melody into the more exotic modes that HZ utilizes in Dune (which you can check out in my full breakdown), but maybe that was ultimately at the expense of the recognizability of the theme. Anyways, it was a fun project! 🤘
@SDSMOfficialАй бұрын
Now this is inspiring me to make one! Thank you.
@avivshukerАй бұрын
Enjoyed that one a lot. Interesting challenge and very great execution from everyone. Well done!
@lulcy789Ай бұрын
Just commenting for the algorithm
@NinghuiYu-vg3lbАй бұрын
Awesome, thanks for sharing! Learned a lot.
@ZayaMillisАй бұрын
This was an amazing video! Thanks for sharing
@MinurielLaiАй бұрын
This is incredible, such good work!
@droidknight847Ай бұрын
Just really awesome! Loved them all.
@zoedoesmusic4520Ай бұрын
that Dune version is amazing !!!
@sergiojoelmusica2514Ай бұрын
I wonder if Liam Raitor (at minute 18:00) is intentionally trying to bring the vibes of the Zora band, The Indigo-Go's, from Majora's Mask. I like thinking it is because of the sound of the waves and the set of instruments. Just wow! Congrats, mates!
@LiamRaitorComposerАй бұрын
😉
@IvoryMadness.Ай бұрын
Great video! Liam's version was my favorite!
@cholo2215Ай бұрын
awesome video like always
@Pax30001Ай бұрын
Awesome!
@AmjadAbdullah2Ай бұрын
Omg😮😮 Victor ❤
@darealmvp5737Ай бұрын
awesome!
@ChrisNeuhahnArtАй бұрын
Arild version reminds me of Jack Wall's soundtrack for Myst III: Exile. If you haven't heard it, you should.
@LetsPlayNintendoITA2023Ай бұрын
people: vg music is not music me:
@jwhite1016aolАй бұрын
Not a weak one in the lot.
@PatrickHaeslerMusicАй бұрын
Great video, thanks Ryan & co. Just a a bit of feedback. This format works a lot better as a vieeing experience when the composers all react to each other's works (see: Andre Huang's 4 Producers videos)
@TheFallenmemories2Ай бұрын
@AlexChristodoulu Which VSTs, especially which choir sample did you use? And how were they able to sing some text? Or is this recorded?
@alexchristodoulouАй бұрын
I use two libraries, 8dio Requiem and Strezov sampling choir essentials. The text is sung by 8dio Requiem, which has around a dozen of latin syllables you can use (either legato or staccato)
@TheFallenmemories2Ай бұрын
@@alexchristodoulou Thank you a thousand times for the Answer ❤
@yonico_Ай бұрын
I'm gonna say it until i die. Less is more
@adamconrad1540Ай бұрын
Algorithm comment. Good work
@ComposerRocksАй бұрын
I will be composing a piece where I need the kind of chanting I can hear at about 10:05. Can anyone steer me toward the sample library used? kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Y9eobKmkntKtn4k.htmlsi=cBsSQ1ru3rPrbp2i&t=605
@arildwtvАй бұрын
This is actually several recordings of me and my collaborator, Ingeborg Ekeland, whispering, and then layered with more recordings of us that I processed through Padshop to get a rythmic feel (it chops, reverses, etc). I'm sure there's a bunch of libraries out there that can offer you chanting samples, but I would recommend recording it yourself. It's a lot of fun, and whispering is something that most people are actually decent at. 😄
@THEKHAYYYAMАй бұрын
glorpatron 3000
@mustuploadtoo7543Ай бұрын
beethoven
@richardmaia8732Ай бұрын
6:40 ac origins vsts? 💀
@arildwtvАй бұрын
Are you referring to the female vocal? It's a recording of Ingeborg Ekeland, a talented vocalist (and violinist) that I collaborated with on this piece. But yeah, I can definitely hear the resemblance (although not intentional) to the vocal on AC: Origins. 😊