Some other stuff I had in mind but completely forgot to say in the actual recording because I'm dumb: -Shulk has to say "let's begin the experiment" when trying to reactivate KOS-MOS for the first time -The trailer has to do the thing a lot of modern trailers do where they cut from the climactic stuff and showing the title to a comedic thing to end off, so it goes from "do not fear for me, Shion, I'm coming back" and the title reveal to a scene from early in the game pre-KOS-MOS getting rebuilt where Staff Girl wraps up a fight and KOS-MOS says her classic "my external appearance has decreased by 5%, I need cleaning" line -The title screen has to be a modified version of the original, still with the green field and Mechon wreckage, but instead of the Monado I, the Monado REX is in its place with Staff Girl's staff stuck next to it and on the opposite side of the weapons from the Mechon is KOS-MOS's broken torso

luxin legit just activated a vision 💀

This entire video feels like someone describing a dream they had.

Luxin out here having a Vision apperently

LUXIN WHATTTTT WE NEED TO TALK.

So, this idea is now kinda true after Future Redeemed. I'm really excited about the future of Xenoblade, I still can't believe that Xenoblade 4 will likely be Xenosaga Episode IV. If I remember correctly, the second arc of Xenosaga was supposed to be a remake or retelling of Xenogears, so yeah Xenoblade 4 could not just be Xenosaga Episode IV but with that to some degree also Xenogears.

Luxin: THE NEXT XENOBLADE HAS TO HAVE XENOSAGA STUFF IN IT. LIKE HERE IS THIS AND THAT SO IT MUST BE CONNECTED! FC WILL CONFIRM THIS! Monolith: haha bird lady goes home

Luxin is certainly one kind of Monado boy ain't he?

2:18 BRUH

he called it

Thanks for sharing us with your wild idea, and I am actually down with it too. Also yes, I also want a Xenosaga IV.

So about this idea being dumb... 😅

Dumb ideas are usually the best ones in my experience

My thought with tying all the games together was that after the end of xenosaga 3, kosmos did her dimensional shift and fell onto what would alrest pre-experiment. She's then found, reactivated and the people there tap into her advanced data thats beyond their current time. They then use that data to rapidly advance the world beyond what earth did in the saga/gears universe, found the zohar early and from kosmos's data learnt how to use it, leading to the creation of the world tree's and the artifice technology with klaus as the lead scientist This would explain how and why the world takes a different turn that the repeating universe saga/gears set up, how kosmos had data about how the world tree was constructed (cus she was there) and more importantly, how she was one of the original set of blades in xb2. Remember the blades where the "previous inhabitants of this planet" (not counting dlc as canon myself), since she was one of the original blades then logically she must have been on alrest during the experiment. I also have a smaller theory that the same could be said for jin being the reanimated jin from saga 3 who also dimension shifted with kosmos. He uses the same swordsmanship, same ice based attacks and even had the same scar on his chest. Kosmos had the data about bringing the dead back to life from the saga games so it could be used to connect the games more so So basically the way i see all the xeno game universes connecting so far is saga 3 happens, kosmos uses the zohar to dimension shift and branches into 2 universes. The first carries on in the current timeline taking the zohar, able and feb into xenogears. The second has kosmos (+ maybe jin's body) falling into another universe relatively earlier in the timeline that being alrest pre-experiment, which the branches into xb1/xb2. Xenoblade X is still a total mystery but its still odd that it has nopon that references phrases, locations and events of xb1, yet theres no sign of anything else from xb1. Though i do still think the explosion that destroyed the earth could be the experiment too possibly blasting through the multiverse, even the ganglion didnt seem to know what it was so they didnt cause it

17:20 i feel like after a couple years of research, shulk could (at least) replicate 75% of the effect said crystals have and make an artificial version so that he doesn't have to farm it every few days/weeks.

Well, well, well, what do we have here?

The next Monado is the Monado Ray, which he replaces for Monado Arsenal as a final upgrade

How about we just put her in Smash instead?

The true heir to the Monado was rambling about a radio for an hour solid all along.

I feel like a greater timeskip would make more sense so the people of fantasy world have time to have created their own culture descendant from the great colony on the far side of the mountains. like long enough that Empress Melia is still alive, but in the same age range as Sorean was in XC1, but Vanea’s still young and healthy. The Monado Rex has been passed down by Shulk and Fiora’s heirs: Galea being Shulk and Fiora’s last living first-gen daughter and and old matron, with her grandson Dickson and Reyn/Sharla’s great-granddaughter (haven’t thought of a good name) being the colony’s heroes, dusting off shulk and fiora’s ancient faces Nemesis and Oneiros (a spirit that is the Personifications of a Dream in Greek myth and one of the lesser brothers of Nemesis, goddess of vengeance) for their new odyssey.

What if....the girl... was a Nopon? Huh? Think of the possibilities :>

I do in fact like this video very much at all. It's cool hearing your theories about the future of a series you're passionate about!!

lol

Id wanna see this story split into 2 or 3 parts with a time skip in between where the first game has shulk and fiora are using monado rex and a new mayneth monado replica that shulk makes for fiora. at the point of the first game they have a pair of twins, a boy and a girl named alvis and galea who would be like 10 years old who stay behind with riki's family like you were saying. that would make shulk and fiora probably around their early to mid 30s. theyd be like mid to late game party members. I would probably include the concept of each party unit consisting of 2 paired members who fight in a modified version of the torna combat system, with rear and vanguards. then each pair gets a face mechon to tandem pilot. youd probably see pairs like MC and KOS-MOS, Shulk and Fiora, Kino and Nene, and then maybe you could even bring back Teelan and Tyrea who would fight together but instead of using a Mechon,,, get this,,, they ride a fucking Telethia mount as a result of teelan's research progressing to the point where he can confidently communicate with them. After the first game concludes you get a time skip by about 5 to 8 years. Shulk and Fiora are retired from the party but in exchange their twins Alvis and Galea are now in their late teens and they become a new tandem unit for that game, playing similar to their parents but modified to feel unique enough. Given how long this time skip would be id say the best way to fill that gap is to have a seperate game in between which returns to the XC2 world, and acts as a big set up to how the two worlds will eventually come together. So the Order would be part 1 of the new world of XC1, Return to the XC2 world to start foreshadowing the people of both worlds coming together, then part 2 of the XC1 new world where the time skip takes place, and finally you have the final part of the new world trilogy where the XC2 gang finally makes contact with the XC1 new world. How they do this I could imagine being that when the conduit disappeared in 2, it transported to the XC1 new world, so with Pyra and Mythra returning at the end of 2 they feel the conduit calling out to them as the whole purpose of their birth was the conduit. The conduit existing in the universe of 1 would then serve as an explanation as to why the gnosis are being drawn to this world. This final game where their worlds join could then have some really sick tandem units like Rex and Alvis, using Shulk and Fiors's old Replica Face Nemesis, Juju returns and Fights with Tora in a Poppi buster MKII, Pyra and Mythra using a replica Aion, and then Teelan returns after completing his research and the Telethia mount him and Tyrea used in the first game returns as a High Entia girl who continues to fight along side him after they had already built a strong sense of trust during her time as a telethia. Hell, you could even keep the whole telethia mount thing by saying that teelan discovered a way to allow her to activate and suppress the telethia gene at will, so rather than going into a mech, she transforms herself back into her telethia form momentarily and teelan rides on her back just like they did before.

Lance fighters are always fun. Maybe something that's somehow rocket powered. Also, I think for part of the crossover you're thinking of, maybe think on the concept that Dissidia: Final Fantasy has

Can't wait to see your next video: A Great Idea for a Let's Play with Sigurd in it

This "extended chain attack" sounds like the ad-libs of tokio Mirage sessions

An aside. I used to come up with a lot of fan Game concepts for games and such I loved over the years. But I have started to focus more on coming up with my own original concepts for stories and characters, drawing inspiration from things I love. The long ass Xenoblade post I made in this comment section and past ones is like an exception to this haha. I forgot to include what musicians I'd like to work on the games as leads along side ACE or otherwise in the big comment. But also I'm grateful to your vids for letting me have this fan story/speculation for future aspect back in me. It was a good way or relieving my stress in a sense.

Yeah I definitely feel like shulks Hilbert effect would function exactly like enchant in chronicles and the monado arts used by the replicas in my mind have always worked like light heal which I have always thought was some form of ether circuit that shulk made and later adapted to work with the monado Also there is some stuff in future connected that implies that something happened to Riki and he's not around anymore And my opinion on how mechs should work in this new game should be similar to how skells worked in x where you had different ones but you could put them on different party members as you wanted but also with different levels of compatibility based on different frames that you could find/build over the course of the game and yeah I'm chill with dual pilot mechs but make them stronger in some big way And I have another idea for the name Xenoblade: Die neue Welt

I swear you’re the Nopon Archsage in rl. Also, did your voice get deeper?

I feel like "Xenoblade Chronicles 3: Saga of a New World" would be a good title for this hypothetical game. It would tie together the two series nicely, but I feel like it might be a bit too spoilerific.

...Considering Future Redeemed, this could be possible. I wouldn't be surprised if the next Xeno game crosses into Xenosaga territory.

Kino’s mech is just poppibuster

Of note. The being able to use reserve party members in chain Attacks idea is something I've also thought of. I'd say it's work more fluidly just going in order as choosing the next character may add an extra selection aspect that could middle the flow of gameplay imo. But also could work. I thought of the idea based on how sessions work in Tokyo Mirage Sessions. And how reserve party members will jump in on the combo. And if you have the good luck and such can go on for very long and it's very satisfying.

I have three routes I'd like future Xenoblade to possibly take. Which further divide into an extra one. First: I'd like for monolith to make use of the Xenoblade DE release as a means to even further explore the world of Xenoblade (yes even more than future connected) with a full on DLC addition like XC2. Like one that they could even release stand alone like Torna. With revamped location. This could take the form of two ideas. One: a literal Torna style game looking at the past. With Egil as protagonist. We could follow his earlier days, how mechonis and Bionis were then. A fully populated and explorable Agnaritha, and old Bionis before Homs. We can have a party with Machina, Giants and High Entia. And come to see why the high Entia ancestors decided to dilute their blood after Zanza, Arglas and Egil's relationship. Vanea as well and see how they deal with a semi small threat, before finding peace and ultimately end with Zanza's take over of Arglas and attack on Mechonis for tragic end like Torna. Meyneth could also have a bigger role and make use of her character design a tad more than main game and see what happened to all the other Giants aside from Arglas and Dickson. Two: one I haven't thought as much about, is taking place after main game on the main land. After Future Connected even, as the group explores the new mainland, maybe in a limited manner, and encounters more fog king type enemies and maybe even Rex and crew to confirm the world's did become one after both 1 and 2 ended. And this could possibly set up a more clear idea for the future. Second idea relates to X. I hope they release something like a Xenoblade X CE (Complete Edition). I felt that XCX was almost a Half Game. (Not in terms of content duh, that game huge, but rather in terms of Story and progression with the level caps for characters being well below 100 and the cliff hanger segmentation being done in a way that made me think first of Golden Sun at the time, and FFVIIR more recently. XCXCE would work as both a straight port of the original XCX game, with the addition of a second act. Which would Explore what happened after the end of X, increase level caps for characters and Skells to 99. Add new characters, we see what black knight and Lao are up to. And I've explored some of these ideas with friends and in previous comment sections, but basically for Recap. I have reason to think that the Black knight is the elite member of Blade who fought in the intro but went missing according to characters in the story. So we can explore what they've been up to. And as stated earlier I wouldn't be surprised if the Planet Mira is conscious and X is like an avatar of Mira, hijacked by the planet and hence why you don't remember your name at the start. And so the conflict could end up being with the planet itself, and what it has learnt about humanity. A living planet similar perhaps to like Ego from Marvel where they are a race and perhaps also created by the samaarians. (Which I also talked about how they could possibly relate to Xenosaga un the past) And how the Ghost Faction/Ghostians end up being the new Galactic Federation obstacle while Blade tries to learn about Mira and such. (A friend and I also talked about possibly expanding the world by allowing travel out of Mira to other nearby planets or moons perhaps but that is maybe better off left for later) ultimately the story doesn't need to end with them dealing with the Galactic Federation as a Whole. But perhaps placing them in a stalemate of sorts where the federation isn't likely to beam issue till perhaps later generations. I also want there to be a more developed Mira. With settlements for different Xenospecies having developed into full out areas to explore. A thing I missed from XC1 in XCX at the time were interesting settlements like Frontier Village and Alcamoth. With a small Timeskip the Manon and maybe the other friendly races may have been able to build settlements up in unique manners. Like maybe an underwater one and allowing Skells to travel under water to add new places to explore, etc etc.ultimatelt close off the story of Elma and the crew, and leave it open to future generations to ready up for a fight against the Galactic Federation down the line so we can explore a new Set of characters in a XCX2 perhaps, speaking of which. Third idea revolves around what they could do in a Xenoblade 3 or XCX2. I went a bit over the XCX2 possibilities above so the focus is more on XC3. My ideas for XC3 are also two fold in a sense. One: I would love the game to take place either down the line in the world Shulk and co. And maybe Rex and Co. Are in and it follows a completely new set of characters. Most everyone from the prior games are long dead. Maybe left as legends. With possibly the exception of Melia and Vanea/High Entia and Machina characters. Who could very well have lived till the next huge conflict appears or maybe even have it take place at a point that even (1/3)

You know, if this was ..... Nevermind, as soon as I was typing this comment, you mentioned the party using repurposed face units. I'd like them to be like Skells from X. Although you may need to do something to delay them to mid game at the earliest.

I don’t have a complete grasp of the Xenosaga part of the Xeno series (still working on how best to play in a PAL region), but this sounds like a really nice way to tie things together and give Xenoblade a direction in the future. (Also, considering you’re calls in the past with Xeno stories there’s a non-zero chance they actually head in this direction)

I kinda wonder what your idea of a mech for every Xeno character would be like. How super robot would they be or would they lean towards real robot

Let's leave the writing to Takahashi and Monolith please 😅

That is deep. I've been playing rpgs in the 90s. What you said is closely related to Lunar Silver Star Story 2 but of a goddess that lost her memory founded on earth/planet

One thing they could do is just make Alrest = Fifth Jerusalem, capital of the Galactic Federation of Xenosaga. The flashbacks of Alrest, showing the orbital station, the beanstock, and everything are pretty much ripped right off of the design of Fifth Jerusalem. In fact, when I first finished Xenoblade Chronicles, I thought the scene WAS Fifth Jerusalem. The earth imagery at the end is kind of vague-dreamlike, it doesn't necessarily have to mean Alrest = Earth, only that there is some memory of Earth involved in the Zohar. Samaar Federation = Galactic Federation, although later down the line it is mostly or completely human beings. Xenogears takes place over 10,000 years after the conclusion of Xenosaga; but in order for them to connect, Takahashi would have to decanonize the "Abel's Ark" which wasn't his story, anyway; it seems more like someone trying to design an ending to Xenosaga based on the beginning of Xenogears, but they only read about Xenogears and didn't actually understand the details of what happened. Either way, replace the nonsense ending of Xenosaga with the beginning of Xenogears, which is a far better story.

i like the idea i d like to see some of rex and crew if not some members from x show up

Very cool to hear that you have many german viewers. Here everyone has English as a main subject in school next to German and Math, also Germany has by far the bigest population in Europe.

I think Xenoblade 3 should have a nopon scientist replacing Klaus's character in the 3rd story, thus explaining why the nopon are everywhere... nonsense ensues.

I would like to see this game.

If Monolith watches your video and make a game with almost all your stuff, did you will demand them or will be fangirling?

Maybe use the Xenoblade 2 combat as a base, then replace the blade specials with death blows. Just press A to activate, then press A, B, X, or Y for different attacks & the different levels just power up the specials?

Bro, just call it Xenoblade Saga. It's a sequel to Xenoblade CHRONICLES, but involving xenosaga stuff.

Xenoblade: Saga of a New World? Xenoblade: Dawn of a New Saga? Xenoblade: New Worlds Saga? I think putting Saga in the title might be a little on the nose but it’d also serve as a great teaser for the return of Xenosaga.

at least i'm not the only one who makes fanfic-y xenoblade game concepts lol

i had this crazy theory that what if one universe in the xeno multiverse was the gaogaigar and betterman universe. being betterman is about the animus and anima. and Yuichiro Takeda wrote for gaogaigar and betterman and is writing the manga as the conclusion as we speak He wrote all the xenoblade games too. Erde kaiser is a direct reference to the brave franchise. Even looking strikingly similar to great exkaiser. Which quite possibly all the brave show could also be i the same multiverse

Well, Well, Well

Further idea, have party members be able to team up into Offense and support, like the blades from 2. So you have 3 active fighters, and characters in reserve can support from outside active combat, Like how the Hypothetical new main character has KOS-MOS at the start, KOS-MOS would be exclusively a support character until she is repaired enough, Shulk could be placed in either role, Fiora is exclusively a combat class, the new healer is a support only (avoiding the curse of the dedicated healer being the least desired party member for lack of combat utility, sorry Sharla,)

The replica Monado not being tied to Zanza means that theoretically anyone can use it with no penalties, which means we could have non-Shulk party members that use Monados like normal weapons with personalized arts and everything. It paints a silly image in my head where the entire party is stanced up to fight an enemy, and they're all just prepping up each of their versions of monado buster and absolutely annihilating everything.

I do like this idea for a story, but I still want to include some of the Xenoblade 2 cast in there. Cause I wanna see a real crossover between the main 2 games and get confirmation that Shulk's new world is in the XC2 world. And I wanna see an older Rex dual wielding both Pyra's and Mythra's swords, interact more with the XC1 cast, and I just wanna know how his life with Pyra and Mythra has been after the main game. At most I would have the XC2 characters join be Rex and Tora along with Pyra, Mythra, and Poppi. I chose Tora because someone in this party needs to be the tank, and him sharing his notes about Poppi with Shulk would be fun and could explain how KOS-MOS gets a body again. Maybe being turned into a somewhat artificial blade. I am 100% on the idea that Shulk and Fiora get married and have a kid since they're such a cute couple. Shulk being in the supporting role makes sense since I don't really know where his character can go at this point, but Fiora could really use an arc. While I do love her in XC1, she does feel shafted in that she doesn't have a big character arc. 33:10 Yes this needs to be a scene. Also Faced Genesis is a cool name for Shulk's faced mechon. And it rhymes with Faced Nemesis which I like. It would be really cool if Shulk could plug the Monado REX into Genesis like a control stick kind of like how some Super Sentai/Power Rangers control their Megazords.

I wish one day we get the SIX Xenosaga games we were supposed to get, but... I've lost hope

There's a Xenoblade 3?! Why haven't I heard of it?!

Not bad. Yet I would say have the same universe for both xenoblades and Xenosaga. I would add as I had been thinking this lately that Wilhelm had a hand with what happend with Klaus. An enemy that I think could show up is a fifth testament as a constant foil.

I always imagined that xcx is the universe of end of xc1 and something went wrong that lead to the character go away from the planet and now its the start of xcx. it would be nice if somewhere in that universe is the xc2 world but they new went into a new universe but just traveled far out and with xc1 and xc2 being in different universe thats just not possible. Übrigens Morgenröthe als name eh. Deutsch wäre wohl nichts so absurdes für ein jrpg.

If the game is combining Xenoblade and Xenosaga, maybe just call it Xenoverse. That would also work nicely for an early part of the story that is not obviously Xenoblade.

What’s funny is that this doesn’t sound like a bad idea at all, and there’s a lot to go for here. You could take this idea even FARTHER have it turn out that at the end of Xenosaga, Kos-Mos was sucked through space/time/whatever and sent into Shulk’s world, where her main motivation is getting to be reunited with Shion. Maybe at the end of XC1, where Shulk creates a new world, he ultimately destroyed any notion of other worlds, and now everything is reunited. no one from Saga/XC2 ever existed in THIS universe. Basically you end up discovering this and find out that Shion’s WILL does exist in some capacity because of her nature in the Saga-verse and it turns out the be the girl from the beginning. Maybe they get reunited and we finally get closure to our space opera-lesbian-robosexual-love story! :D

I think Xenoblade x Xenosaga sounds fine but in the logo you'd stylize it as: Xenoblade e n o s a g a

We need daddy shulk and mommy fiora

Did you mean: Xenoblade Chronicles 2

Great fanfic :) if only monolith could buy Saga or Nintendos

brrrrrrrr

Not a bad idea.

Dang dude,you ever play Grandia?

I don't HATE the idea by any means, but I don't really want a game that ties two finished properties together with no real direction either. There is so much meat and potatoes left in the X series, and X is very close to Saga in so many ways anyways (the character designer was the same from Saga 1, the composer was Sawano and also the composer from Saga, story is a high tech world involving the galactic federation and fail safes for universal destruction, Kos Mos and Elma have many parallels), then tell the story that needs to be told. It may only be my opinion though, as X is my favorite game out of the entire Xenoverse, but there's a natural place for X to progress, there is no destination for Blade 1 or Saga to go really.

Well I guess I can pretty confidently say I'm 5th.

You call this dumb, but I actually love the idea, it's not gonna happen most likely but it's and awesome cool Idea

All of Luxins ideas are dumb... but quite entertaining. What will he come up with next?

If Galea really did have silver hair like her namesake, I don't think the Shulk x Melia fans would be able to handle themselves.

What would be this theoretical game's "Xenoblade"? I feel like Monado REX isnt quite Xeno enough to be the Xenoblade

100 emoji

It needs to go back to the stun based turn based xenosaga 1 battle system. You could add death blows to that. Xenoblade battle system isn't very good

Xenoblade Saga: Gears of Dawn

xenoblade chronicles : exodus?

Ah yes. Galea. Why do I smell a big reference. Since i literally wait for my course in game design to begin, writing a second parallouge on xenoblade 1 touching on the bionite order and alvis to present, i really appreciate this. Also, spoilers Am i the only one who noticed the great boss monster in torna's womb to actually be galea? When rex picks up the card found next to its corpse, her face can be spotted on it. Funny when we compare xenoblade 1 and 2's illustrations of galea

Steal xenoverse from dragon Ball xenoverse lol