Thats why the 2nd Amendment in our Constitution is thee most essential and important part of all time. If we fall...so will the rest of the world.

@@juneskywalker5847 What she said. If the first amendment fails, the 2nd needs to be implemented. It's something we don't WANT to do, but will if we have to.

You do know that this is all made up right??? The moive is fake and the book won best FICTION! Just like Ann frank and the book night they are fictional books with zero truth to them

@@davidbarton1806 Firstly not entirely made up, Oskar Schindler did exist and some events and people were real. And secondly, Ann Frank being fiction, what are you smoking?

@@juneskywalker5847 Yes June, that's totally related to the video and is indeed true. The world will fall in agony and darkness when the US no longer has its trigger happy militias, armed secessionist groups, mass shootings and shooters or less of a savior/action hero good guy with a gun fantasy.

Please tell his name

Hiya. Just a thought - it might be worthwhile passing his name and details to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. It has a database of survivors and victims. Stay safe. All the best to you.

If you could, please share his story. There's not many people who are left that were in that time of history and our German class want to hear from a survivor about what happened. I understand if you don't want to however. It's a pretty heavy subject.

I have been to yad vasheem. There are Christians who saw the death camp.they were scarred by the sight for the rest of their life, and that's after fighting through a war zone. Pray for them.

If you would, I would like to at least know his name

All the Catholic and Christian people who saved others are so amazing and literally changed lives of millions of people! ❤️

Your wife sounds beautiful to know and very brave. People like her are the true heroes that the world needs to hold dearly.

@@Kaylaw9 Thank you. Unfortunately, she died a couple of months ago, but she left me with 39 years of wonderful memories. We'll meet again.

@@reddevil3387 I'm very sorry for your loss.

​@@reddevil3387all my condolences, I am sure your wife was fantastic. I am French too ! Oui, un jour vous la retrouverez ❤. Yes, you will meet again someday 🪽🪽🪽

Aww, well please don't ever think that this is how modern Jews see Germans, your country has been so astute with education about this subject rather than sweeping it under the rug so I am very grateful to Germany for that fact!! Thank you for joining me on this tough watch! ❤️

The Russians and Japanese were even worse. Don't act like any war was less gruesome.

You owe no one an apology.....you didn't do it.

Bist du komplett bescheuert? are you completely insane ... This is a completely wrong historical view ... Almost no German was a Nazi during the Nazi era. And it's a tragedy on both sides. Everyone talks about how the Jewish people were murdered, but nobody talks about why and how it happened. After WWI, the German people were hated and treated like shit all over the world. And as you should know, there were no good guys and bad guys in WW1. But the Allied propaganda was so strong that everyone hated the Germans. Everyone always sees it from a single perspective. Shut out from the world for decades, the Germans were left absolutely dead after World War I. The Germans were blamed for everything. They were hated everywhere. The crisis and depression in Germany at the time was three times what it is today. Yes, you heard me right. We can no longer imagine how bad it was for Germans. Proud, strong German soldiers who fought against the whole world in World War I were seen as demons. And World War I broke not the body but the spirit. Of course the hate grew. At the same time, the military was being crushed and reduced to the minimum. Everything you sacrificed yourself and your psyche for was now gone. After the French took over a few factories in Germany and killed 120 Germans in the process, after the war because Germany couldn't pay the trillions in the crisis, it was finally over. Rightly so. And when you have three kids at home, no food, no drink, no job then you'll turn to anyone who promises to undo it. No German knew what Hitler was planning in the background. The Nazis gave them their lives back. And only when it was too late.. did the Germans see the real face. But it was too late. The youth were already being manipulated and if you don't follow Hitler you will be shot. There is a big difference between Nazi, German and Wehrmacht at the time. And people don't understand that. Many high wehrmacht generals hated nazi ideology and brutal ss who didn't listen to them. The Germans followed Hitler because he gave them their lives back and also partly told the truth. And not because they liked the ideology. Of course some people but not all. They even felt sympathy for the jews at the beginning. The Allies created Nazi Germany. With the Versailles "treaty" and do you think it's a good idea to put down such a proud and overly powerful country as Germany a country that fought against 80% of the world, a country with the best thinkers and engineers? And then let it lie...? No hatred will grow. Hitler gave the Germans one victim they could blame for their suffering - the Jews... Many forget that the first country the Nazis conquered was their own. Your ancestors were probably not Nazis. As I said, almost no German was a Nazi. Nazis were Nazis. Do you even know what that stands for? It stands for Hitler's party. That's just like saying every American is a Democrat. My grandma lived in East Prussia and wasn't a Nazi. Like most Germans. They wanted to eat, drink, work and were hated everywhere. They all suffered greatly and it is easy to throw your suffering on someone else. Mainly because hatred of the Jews didn't come out of nowhere. Jews have unfortunately been hated in Europe for hundreds of years because the Jews were often fine, you know ego and it's a different religion. It was not right. But as I said. The Germans also keep the sacrifice. Even very. And the hate would strike back. All because of the Allies. Evil is not born. It is created. And as I said, even many of Hitler's own generals wanted to kill him because they knew he was crazy. The general German soldier had nothing to do with the crimes. These were tough soldiers who ended up fighting for their country. They had to fight. And how they fought.. Against a whole world. In any case, the NAZIS are evil. I'm only concerned that you have presented it as if all Germans were evil. That's wrong. Even the soldiers, at least many of them, were just soldiers. Many forget this in today's world due to the propaganda still going on. Be proud of the Germans who stood up to it. On high Wehrmacht generals like Rommel or Stauffenberg who wanted to kill Hitler. It was a tragedy on both sides. You can think of the Nazis as a natural evil parasite that emerged from the suffering and hatred of the Germans.

@@frontgamet.v1892 Ok ich gehe davon aus, dass ich dir auch auf Deutsch antworten kann. Ja mir ist durchaus bewusst, was nach dem ersten Weltkrieg passiert ist. Das lernt man bereits im Geschichtsunterricht. Ich habe nichts gesagt was falsch ist. Vielleicht waren nicht alle deutschen Bürger zu der Zeit Nazis aber jeder Nazi war damals Deutscher. Das zu leugnen ist ekelhaft auf einem anderen Level, weil man versucht sich als Nachfahre aus der Verantwortung zu ziehen. Und das als Nachfahrer derer, die 6 Mio Juden auf dem Gewissen haben. Ja es ist nicht die Schuld der heutigen Deutschen, was damals passiert ist. Sagt ja auch keiner. Ich muss mich als deutscher Bürger und Nachfahre derer, die diese Gräueltaten begangen haben, allerdings der Verantwortung bewusst werden und dafür sorgen, dass so etwas nie wieder passiert. Auch wenn man den Alliierten eine Teilschuld daran geben kann, wie die Bedingungen in Deutschland zur damaligen Zeit zustande gekommen sind, waren es trotzdem die Deutschen die den Holocaust begangen haben und die Alliierten die Nazideutschland gestoppt haben. Die Tatsache, dass du so verteidigend wirst, wenn ich als Deutscher mir bewusst bin, was für eine Verantwortung ich in diesem Kontext habe und wenn ich Mitleid mit Nachfahren der Opfer zeige sagt vieles über dich aus.

my grandfather say the same, my granpa was young in that time like 15years old, and he always told me that, he left with his sister, to south america chile, his father can only buy 2 tickets, and my grandpa and his sister was the only who survive in the entire family, in 1950 his sister comeback to france looking for his family, and she dont found anyone, my granfather promise in that time he will never come back to that place, and never did, he die in 2010 with 90 years old

@robertmckenna3994 the mayority of veterans didnt want to speak, because they are were criminals. We know what happen, and the history you believe is fake, that is why today xionists are destroying countries today, while you still in the piyama kid propaganda

@@Alexalevins You guys grandpas never spoke about what israel is doing in plstine?. Or why anybody wants to talk, or maybe that hollywood is ruled by those who create this movies while make wars everywhere

My dad also served under Patton right after Normandy. He was in the 3rd Army, 3rd Armored Division as a tank driver.

I had a great uncle that served in the 3rd army never talked about it other than to say it was worse than anything you could imagine. At the same time he also had an interesting story from the occupation of how kind an older German woman was to him. She had lost all of her children in the war.

Thank you so much for your beautiful comment! And yes omg it truly is not that long ago. Whenever I talk to my grandma I realise that it was all within her lifetime it’s truly so recent in human history!

Imagine falling for this antigerman propagandafilm. Svara

@@GratDuForloradeArgumentet I was waiting for a comment like this. Imagine being still brainwashed with n3on4z1 propaganda as "pro german/german nationalist pride". I was a negationist before and thought like you, and you know what? They manipulate very well, and that's awful. This is not anti german propaganda, this is a film about horrors perpetrated by nationalsocialists. See the diference. In fact the Führer wasn't german, so he is to blame for what did to german people, and thus jews and many more people. Blame him, not the "anti german propaganda". He was anti-german because he believed the people were "arians", and if they weren't arians they deserved death, even though being germans... Those germans who believed in him became monsters. That's the "arian race" then, a bunch of filthy monsters, not german people. You need to touch grass and meet people in real life and empathize. Jesus, and I was like you at some point in my life... Pathetic and shame. Get out of there while you can.

@@GaboTheGrey Divide your sentences and learn to write like a normal person, then I can read. Until then I cannot be bothered. I bet it's just a bunch of liberal whining anyway.

​@@GratDuForloradeArgumentetYou mean this film with a German hero which actually downplays the horrors of the Holocaust?

Thank you so much for joining me on this journey! I’m so grateful it was impactful! I’m very lucky my immediate family survived!

Crazy how the 🔯 decided to genocide all Europeans as revenge for Germany trying to become autonomous.

Why are you sorry?

​@@OmarLivesUnderSpaceWhy are you not?

@@mix6809 It's a nasty habit to answer a question with a question. But now that you did, why should I?

So beautifully said! I couldn’t agree more! ❤️💔

He chose this film to submit for his student film requirement when he finally went back to college to finish his film degree. It appears he agrees with you.

it's Spielberg's crowning achievement in propaganda and in altering of history. This movie is based on a book that won the award for fiction. Germans were not even remotely these sadistic devils who crawled from hell. They were never like it not, before 1930-1940s, not after, so why would they be like that in that time. Learn actual history

Imagine falling for this antigerman propagandafilm.

​@@GratDuForloradeArgumentet excuse you. You believe the Holocaust did not happen?

That is actually such an accurate metaphor! You're so right that they wait and stay still as to not provoke the predator!

I felt the same thing, and you worded it so well.

@@mosovanhe thank you

I cannot imagine how they must have felt during filming! Especially those playing the crueler characters!

@@MovieJoob Some of the Schindler Jews were on set as advisors for Spielberg. One said in interviews she almost had a panic attack the first time she saw Fiennes in character as he so embodied Goeth.

@@MovieJoob From what I’ve heard, Robin Williams actually called Steven Spielberg weekly during filming the movie and basically put on a personalized comedy routine just to keep his spirits up.

Couldn't agree more!! So beautifully put!

@@MovieJoob Thank you. Keep up the good work.

I have watched it through once. I don't think I could watch it again. I am just now able to watch reactors, with the selected snippets of the movie. It is so affecting to me at the end when all those people are placing stones on Schilndler's grave, both honoring him and saying 'this happened.'

It is shown in German schools.

Eu também já vi muitas vezes. Inclusive vi essa semana de novo. Está tendo uma mostra sobre o Steven Spielberg aqui no Brasil essa semana e passou novamente no cinema. Foi muito bom rever na tela grande. Eu assisti a primeira vez na estreia em 1993. É o meu filme preferido.

Thank you so much! and I am so sorry to hear that 💔

@@MovieJoob The point of the book, which I didn't think really came through in the film, is that you don't have to be a saintly person to do a really good thing. Oskar Schindler seems to have been a dishonest, womanizing screw-up during most of his life, but during this one brief period, he did something incandescently wonderful. (Just as Hannah Arendt pointed out, 60 years ago, that you didn't have to be a monster to participate in the unspeakably monstrous things that were done during the Holocaust. Ordinary, unremarkable people all over Germany took part in it. The capacity for good acts and evil acts is in each of us, and our "natures" won't save us from them.)

I think it can be dangerous to see those people as monsters. Any human is capable of great cruelty as we have seen all throughout history. Humans can be horrendous to each other and this is just an example of such cruelty.

You are right every human is capable, i agree. But the holocaust was an industrial level of cruelty, they built killing factories, they murdered children, newborns and pregnant women. So that's why i see them as monsters not human. But of course i deeply respect your opinion. Love and hugs.

@@Sicarii86 (sorry for english) i think she’s right, monsters is a just mental creation that we invoke when we just can’t understand anymore or don’t want to admit what human nature really is. It’s reassuring to distinguish them from other humans, to think that we aren’t like them. The thing is, one has to realize is that every human is capable of the worst and of the best, whether it’s them, me or you. The main problem is when you’re taught to see other human beings not as humans anymore. This allows you to do horrible things without feeling guilty. The question of responsibility is also very complex, obviously there are the ones directly working in the camps (yes cruel people etc…) but they are also thousands op people especially in the administration who had a decisive impact on the logistical feasibility of the genocide. Whiteout them it wouldn’t have been possible, so they played a role a in the mass extermination of millions of people… yet these people were just common people doing their jobs as usual… You see it’s really hard to really sort out everything. About your first comment, thank you for pointed out the hypocrisy of most developed countries especially the US who now especially in Hollywood movies play the role of the “Jew liberators” when they refused to let them come first, while they were fleeing Nazism (see Evian Conference of 1938). It’s without mentioning the antisemitism which was widespread in allied countries. That’s also partly why at first GB and the US didn’t want to go into war against Hitler, one reason was not to give credit to german propaganda of « the war of/for the Jews » which had a significant impact on public opinions in allied countries.

@@MovieJoob Journalist and philosopher Hannah Arendt reported from the last trial of one of the main «architects» of the Holocaust, Adolph Eichmann. I think her conclusion perfectly supports what you say. It is reflected in the title of her book: «Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil». Holocaust was not performed by monsters but by conscientious functionaries.

@@pianoman1857 I think I have to agree with your opinion. Well said, thank you!

I think I heard somewhere that at that point he's thinking about the little girl in the red coat, and that if he'd got one more person he might have been able to save her. If I'm remembering right, that sentiment might come from details in the book, Schindler's Ark, which I understand was a precursor to this film being made.

Couldn’t agree more and Omg thank you very much that made me tear up to read! ❤️

Same with Sir Nicolas Winton story, which save our czech jewish children

How can you, considering the history of your people, live in an apartheid state waging genocide against the Palestinians?

@@ComradeHB Simple, cuz the israelis are hypocrites

@@ComradeHB "Palestinians" are the new Nazis. They have the desire but they lack of the capabilities to mass murder Jews.

Thank you so much for watching along with me and sticking through it despite how heart breaking it is! 💔

Imagine falling for this antigerman propagandafilm.

My reaction was that speilberg reopened the camp with this film, nothing more. The rest is about a man success saving few life when the holocaust is not about some heroic but people just disapearing, trully awful movie.

Crazy how the 🔯 decided to genocide all Europeans as revenge for Germany trying to become autonomous......

So beautifully said!! I adore this comment! Thank you so much for your kind words! ❤️❤️❤️

It's one of the most disgusting antiGerman propaganda pieces if anything. Ohhh pooor jews. Never mind the 65 million Europeans who died. But oohh poor jews 200k of them died..

Such a beautiful message!!! Yes I completely agree! I hope this makes everyone feel that their impact can be bigger than they ever expected!

@@MovieJoob I'm kind of an old man now. While raising my children, I took every opportunity I could to let them see me doing good for others, then not expecting anything in return and never mentioning again (wanted them to know I didn't do it for recognition). Now I get to enjoy watching them doing good for others, I hope my examples formed those feelings of service in them. Now I have two grandsons, and they will see Pawpaw trying to be a good person to others. The cycle continues. You have a large platform, and I see you being the example, my hat's off to you. Peace.

That is so kind of you omg thank you very much! ❤️

So beautifully said thank you!! And yes I have watched 12 years a slave (I was crying so hard I had to pause the film cause I couldn’t hear anything over my crying) and hotel Rwanda my mum showed me that!

@@MovieJoob Always good to know history. Plenty of blame to go around. Without the African tribal leaders willingness to hunt down, enslave and sell their neighbors, the African slave trade would've never existed. Seems people always overlook that part of the blame for that terrible time in history.

Hotel Rwanda is another stellar movie depicting real terrible historical events, as is this movie too.

@@lukeball4937 Yes, there will always be criminal individuals, but when these hate crimes become incorporated into a country's values then it becomes something far worse. In the case of WW2 while any murder is appalling genocide is on another level. Many white nationalists cite the same point as you make, in the hope that this will offset the criticism that is justified of their countries for their crimes but it doesn't make such crimes any more acceptable.

@@alana8863 both of them? The bogeyman of the “white nationalist“? Do you know who else speaks like I do? Freedom loving Americans that believe in our Constitution and its amendments. Here’s a little tip for you, if you don’t have the ideological strength to win an argument against a white nationalist over their ideas, whatever your beliefs may be, obviously aren’t worth defending. You get what you deserve. A dead body killed by censorship smells exactly the same as one killed by genocide. Look around today, tens of thousands were murdered in nursing homes through the use of censorship. Open your eyes.

It’s so incredibly moving and hard hitting!! I’ve never seen the Indiana movies sadly but I’ll make sure to watch it with you all I promise!

during the war of 1971 Pakistanis massacred 3 Million Bangladeshis in a period of just 9 months (25th March-16th December)....so I can relate to the massacre of millions of people in WW2 n others...Winston Churchill consciously formed a famine in Bengal of 1943 by holding the food stock n let millions of Bengalis perish, Roosevelt ordered nukes on Japanese civilian populous, Stalin n Mao killed millions in so called cultural reforms n revolutions...n many more examples. its not about German-French-Russian-British-American or Jews-Christian-Hindu-Muslim, politics is politics, and people do this to achieve earthly gains....one death for a murderer of millions doesnt make it justice, hope the Creator burns those in hell for eternity.

Thank you so much for joining me on this journey!! Yes I couldn’t agree more- if I could have one wish come true it would be that there was no such thing as hate !

It is absolutely a must you are correct! It was hard but I’m so glad I watched it!!

Thank you so much for your lovely comment and for joining me on this experience!! ❤️

It will happen again if the maga nuts get their way

my family was German Jew that got away........but i know that relation went to the camps

Oh wow! I’m so grateful your great grandparents made it out beforehand! My grandma on my dads side just left before the war thankfully and my great grandparents on my mums side left a fair bit before the war too! ❤

@@MovieJoob Glad your great grandparents made it out too.

😂

This might be my favourite comment! Nothing in the world is more beautiful than compassion and empathy in my opinion!

"What is an ocean, but a multitude of drops" - Cloud Atlas

WOWW! that is so beautiful!! You grandad did amazing things! On 860 calories a day all I could probably do well is sleep.

I’m so glad your wife’s family made it out safe!! ❤❤ thank you for your comment

I have actually seen that film before! It was great!!

That movie is also a tear jerker

I am so glad they went to America back then! ❤

Aww this is such a beautiful comment thank you so much!! So grateful that you joined me on this journey too! ❤️

That is so beautiful of you! Thank you so much! This is a perfect comment I thank you so deeply!

Ironic, because the Jewish hate Christians.

Diana Reiter, was the architect's name. Elina L, the actress who portrayed her.

Yes this!!! I completely agree! No matter how hard it was this was always on my MUST watch list and I’m so grateful I finally experienced it! It’s so important!

!!!! 1000x yes to this!!

Thank you so very much!!

Holy far out that is a lot less than I thought… can’t say I blame them for not wanting to stay in Poland after such trauma. My grandpa saw Australia on the map and thought it was great because it was as far as possible from Poland. 💔

​​​@@MovieJoobyou mention Poland 3 times, and we are innecent...but not a one time Germany....they should go far away from Germany and Germans....they had good life in Poland, no country in europe had so big juish community in 39

Thank you so much for the beautiful comment! ❤️❤️

Very very true!!! They couldn’t show all the r-pe, torture, experimentations and so on that tragically occurred as well! 💔

Thank you so much for your beautiful words!! It is most definitely worth it! ❤

Oh wow that is so intense!! And so young! Such cruelty at such a young age 💔

@@MovieJoob Most of the hanging after the trials was done by Albert Pierpoint. Who was the hangman for Britain. A very interesting man.

You and your generation have nothing to apologise for! Germans are such lovely and mindful people! Your generation and the ones after are the apology as you are such great people! ❤️

Thank you so much for your kind words!

Holy shit that is so intense and I am so glad he escaped!! So many incredible Polish people who weren't even Jewish risked their lives and their loved ones lives to do the right thing. I am so heartbroken that they were killed for doing such a brave thing. 💔

@@MovieJoob thank you!

Oh wow really! I had no idea!

I totally agree! And thank you so much for joining me on this tough watch! ❤️

I’m Jewish by heritage but atheist by religion 😊

Thank you for the virtual hug!! 😊

Thank you so much!!