Maynard’s voice takes you to another realm.

His Voice moves me like.. The Strength of a father... And the Intention of a mother.

I fucking love this song, this album, this band and most of all: Maynard, such a bloody genius.

Maynard's voice is the only man's voice that gives me chills and I'm man enough to admit it

Peace brothers, lets light one up 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻 and smoke to those we have lost.

Literally brought tears to my eyes...I love Maynard and his voice has been my escape for many years..

"By And Down The River" Moving in and out of the shadow It's no easy mission, holding on to how I picture you Showing only bits and pieces 'Til the light betray you and your empty allocution Searching your eyes for a hint or a trace of humility Searching your eyes for the saint is an act of futility Searching your eyes for a hint or trace of it Searching your eyes for humility Searching your eyes for a hint or a trace I'm still searching, searching Showing only bits and pieces 'Til the tide betrays you and your empty elocution Float the Piper by and down the river Carcass crippled underneath the pounding waves of adoration Pied Piper, float on down the river Bloated carcass crippled me, the weight of adoration Moving in and out of the shadows It's no easy mission, holding on to how I picture you

Love how you can hear Maynard much more in this one. His voice will forever be my favorite. "It's no easy mission holding on to how I picture you" that part in the beginning is just wow. 🖤

This whole album is getting me through my life right now. Thank you.

I am having a perfect circle renaissance in my life now. I love this album. Took me years to listen to it. It's amazing

After learning about the shadow from 46 and 2... the difficulty of crossing through it from the humbling river... this song and Maynard are on another level of self discovery

If this music doesn't touch your soul then we are not the same

Geez Billy is an underestimated guitarist. Deserves way more cake!

My love for rock died a long time ago but maynard and apc has reignited my love for it and i cant thank them enough

If there was ever a song to elaborate the constant inner battle a veteran has to deal with, in finding a reason to keep living..this is it.

Ten second into the vocal performance..... Speechless...

Waves of goosebumps

First heard this running at 3am in the cold . Masterpiece!

i dont think theres enough ppl talking about the mastery of the delivery of the first line of this song. The Moo Oo Oo Oovin inand outofthe shadoooooow. like you can almost see his voicing going in and out of a shadow so to speak. freaking brilliant. I could listen to 0:30-0:36 all day.

This song might be the greatest thing I ever heard 👂

From A Perfect Circle comes...... A Perfect Song.

On my top 50 list ever. Beautiful song. Very powerful

This album is the best thing that could have happened to APC. I love the way the band keeps evolving. What a beautiful journey to be a fan of yours!

This was hard to read, but thank you for sharing it. I lost my 19 year old son to suicide in 2020. Every Tool, APC, Puscifer, and Deftones song makes me think of him. Music is healing, but it’s raw and painful sometimes too. Keep pushing through. Your brother is always with you

How can a song hold so much beauty and heaviness all at once, and how is it that A Perfect Circle continues to somehow use that balance so effectively? There's just nothing quite like this band.

The only song that gets our newborn to stop crying and go to sleep

Cannot play enough of this album

every time without a single exception this song blows me away and gives me chills.

Everyone talking about which version of this song is better, and I just feel lucky that we get to enjoy BOTH.

I get chills down my spine

This album is a Master piece.

I love you all for knowing good music. we love you apc

Yup Maynard still sounds like an angel

I have a feeling this album is going to help me through the next chapter of my life

It’s like TOOL and The Cure collaborated - my heart is so full listening to this! So completely and perfectly what my numbed out soul needs right now. ✨💖💫

The 2 different versions offer 2 different emotions

Can't believe I only ""heard "this today.... BRAVO!!!

Searching your eyes for a hint or a trace of humility, searching searching and still searching... harder to find than i thought..

This album got me through some rather dark moments, thank you APC!

His voice was even better live

This song will forever be my favourite. The last song I heard while my son drove me to work. He died that night. R.I.P son.

I love and appreciate both versions of this great song! Love Maynard!!

One of my favorite songs from this album!

Right when he started singing I got chills. Dam I love the original of this but this is great

One of my favourite songs from their new album!

One of my all time favorites. Wow. What a song. Sneaks up on you.

I'm in love~ I've been feeling really lost without music of late. Rn the songs I do have on list I've worn out completely so it's just bland and monotonous with no heart left to give. I also had a moment when I deleted all of my music having been fed up with certain people and things in my life that I was about ready to kill that part of me for good despite the fact music has always been my life whether listening or creating. I'm really glad I remembered A Perfect Circle and looked up some of their songs to come across this. It's like a dark haze that surrounded me was lifted, and a wave of euphoric nostalgia that only comes in holy reverence of what makes us human inside washed over me to survive in a clock work orange society run by big brother and the machine.

His voice goes through my soul

This song is amazing

This is one of my favorite songs of all time!.... I really wanna see them in concert this next year. I wish they weren't so far away.... Everyone loves Florida!!! why not stop in over here!?!?!

My brother in sorrow, this touches deep within the soul. I understand to step to that edge, to long for the pain to release. So live my friend, live for your brother. Heal and be healed. One day the light will call us all home. God strengthen you.

My favorite on the record! This record is beautiful ❤

Such an Amazing Band Maynard is the G.O.A.T. Hands down best artist on this earth no matter who he makes music with it is always a pleasure to hear it Tool and Pucifer are just as amazing Maynard is just the best

Maynard's voice and Howerdel's guitars are phenomenal

this is one of my more favorite (newish) APC songs.

Best song ever by APC. Been jamming this for years, love the sublte differences here in this version.

Just found this and i love it. I feel like it hits me right in the heart. Definitely a favorite now...

Just change things up. There are a lot of sad references to this song. But there are a lot of good things. This song brings me back to clarity & is a really good song. It shouldn’t get destroyed for any reason

Less pride more humility

Thank you for this MASTERPIECE. It speaks right into my soul.

saw them last year, this song is burned into my brain, 2 hits were kickin in a powerful moment to be sure

This is actually so good, I forgot this album actually slaps

I first heard this as a toddler sitting in a car with my family and hearing it now brings back so many memories

Love the solitude captured with every note he hits and matches lyrics to ecclerate

I love Thirteenth Step with a passion, but when I try to be as objective as possible (it's impossible, I know) I always end up concluding that this is the best song they've made.

Just when he starts singing, what excellent voice control.

He's our best friend. Spirit guide. Has been since day 1. One way best friends are just as important. Don't forget who makes a difference in your life through their work.

one of my fav song from the new album. this song is very addictive...the riff is so catchy stuck on my head.

At first I was a little disappointed I saw this on the tracklist.. but boy did my mind change when I heard this amazing version. Keeps getting better.

This is a band that’s truly evolved with the time!!

Greatest band in the world. Period. See you all next week in all your infinite glory. Counting the days....

Listening to this I get an overwhelming feeling of sorrow and anger from all the friends and family I've lost from drugs addiction, suicide or freak accidents I burst out into tears thinking about it, but the sad reality is there's so many ppl out here hurting and they hide it well, including myself.

Oh hi, I buried my heart here for safekeeping.

I just got this album on vinyl and it's absolutely beautiful.

Gahhhh, Maynard's voice... ❤❤❤

for awhile, I thought of a perfect circle as 'tool-lite,' but this album really is its own sound

My favourite song from this great band. Nice remake.

Best Lyric on the album what a release!!

well I love both versions, this one feels more LIVE, as far as the playing goes, imo. glad it found its way into an album!

2:11 Orestes: "I dont wanna feel this overwhelming HOSTILITYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY"

HOLY SHIT I LOVE THIS VERSION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Between Depeche Mode and all MJK does I'm thankful I got to live in this era. Thank you!

This song has and always will give me chills. So masterfully created and Maynard’s voice shines more than ever in this one

Og version is unmatched

Kinda sounds like when they played it live at Red Rocks. Again the intro 🖤🖤🖤🖤

love him so much and every band hes in.he sounds just as awesome live.

2020 iso. This song is incredible. That intro verse and the feel of counting bodies..... Very very good song

herbert's got a set of pipes on em

Best concert EVER Detroit, MI 11-9-18 we wanted to go again the next day! Absolutely LOVE the new album I listen to it over and over it is so true with what is going on in the world!

for sure, 85,000 of those views are mine. i love this song. moving. epic. phenomenal.

I love this song ❤️ ✌️🕊️🕊️

Simply on replay😊

Why can I not stop listening to this song.

I like this version a LOT. I do like the triplet play between the hats and ride in the last chorus section in the other version, but this one seems cleaner. Love em' both.

How did I pass up this album?! After getting big into Puscifer a few months ago, came back to A Perfect Circle for more Maynard... and boy am I sure glad I did. I've had this song in particular on repeat a lot!

I love this version! It’s more personal I feel. More intimate with his voice🔥

Album of the year.

Glad to see this song get a real place. I remember when it came out being so excited for new APC. Even just this one song.

I listened to this song in some of the better years of my life, falling to rock bottom, it reminds me of how I used to feel, how I used to function, and even tho I’ll never be that way again, this is a somber reminder of how happy I used to be.

Moving in and out of the shadows. It's no easy mission, Holding on to how I picture you. Showing only bits and pieces, Till the tide betrays you, And your empty allocution. Searching your eyes for a hint or a trace of humility. Searching your eyes for the saint is an act of futility. Searching your eyes for a hint or a trace of it. Searching your eyes for humility. Searching your eyes for a hint or a trace, I'm still searching, searching. Showing only bits and pieces, Till the light betrays you, And your empty allocution. Rode the Piper by and down the river. Carcass crippled underneath, The pounding waves of adoration. Pied Piper float on down the river. Bloated carcass, crippled knee, The weight of adoration. Moving in and out of the shadows. It's no easy mission, Holding on to how I picture you.