Abu Dhabi Mandir: Responding to Criticism | مندر کی تعمیر | اعتراضات کی حقیقت

Abu Dhabi Mandir: Responding to Criticism | مندر کی تعمیر | اعتراضات کی حقیقت | Javed Ghamidi |GCIL

Рет қаралды 218,245

2 ай бұрын

Abu Dhabi Mandir: Responding to Criticism | مندر کی تعمیر | اعتراضات کی حقیقت | Javed Ghamidi |GCIL
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: kzfaq.info?s...
▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.org/donate/
🔵 RELATED TO THIS VIDEO:
◽
🔵 RESPONSE TO 23 QUESTIONS:
◽ Meezan Aur Furqan: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ What is Sunnah: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Itmam e Hujjat: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Qiraat Ka Ikhtelaf: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Excommunication (Takfeer): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Singing & Music: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Veil (Pardah): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Beard (Darhi): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ First Revelation: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Halal & Forbidden: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Splitting of the Moon: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Isra-o-Mairaaj: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Return of Jesus: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Arrival of Mahdi: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Interest / Usury (Sood): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Human Nature: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Jannat Ki Hoor: • Response to 23 Questio...
🔵 OTHER TOPICS:
◽ Introduction to Quran: • QURAN Ka TAARUF - Intr...
◽ Hujjiyat-e-Hadith: • Hujjiyat e Hadith - Ja...
◽ Dawat Ka Tariqah: • DAWAT E DEEN SERIES
◽ Ahl-e-Sunnat Ke Aqaid: • عقائد سیریز | Aqaid Se...
◽ ALI (r.a) aur Muawiya (r.a): • Hazrat Ali (ra) aur Am...
◽ Foj Ka Bayaniah: • Bayania Series | Fouj ...
◽ Mishkat Dars on Ramzan: • Nabi Ki Batain - Yasal...
◽ Dallas Lectures: • Dallas Lectures - Coun...
◽ Conversing Islam: • Conversing Islam with ...
◽ Meezan Lectures: / @ghamidicil
◽ Al-Bayan Lectures: / @ghamidicil

Пікірлер: 269

@MuhammadShahid-ig3mm 10 күн бұрын

خدا کی زمین پر پابندی خدا ہی لگا سکتا ہے۔ واہ، کیا کمال جملہ بولا قبلہ غامدی صاحب نے،❤

@user-pl9nh1wp9m Ай бұрын

جاوید احمد غامدی صاحب کی رائے میں بلا کا توازن ہے ۔۔۔۔۔۔جزاک اللہ خیرا

@shafieshamsi8985 6 күн бұрын

دین اسلام کے روح رواں قبلہ جناب غامڈی صاحب مسلمانوں کو دور حاضر میں جس بے بسی اور بے چینی کا سامنا ہے اس سے نکالنے میں بڑی تگ و دو کر رہے ہے خدا انہیں اپنی سلامتی کے سائے میں رکھے

@northernpolestar8645 7 күн бұрын

Almost 1450 years ago, Prophet Muhammad SAW abolished idol worship in Arabian peninsula. All the idols were destroyed during the conquest of Makkah. There should not be any justification for establishing idol worship in any part of Arab peninsula.

@ghanirehman9930 Ай бұрын

Ghamidi Sahab is an intellectual scholar and the General masses must put an effort to understand the logic and interpretations. He is not a story teller but a teacher of high quality.

@QasumAbaloch-yd1md Ай бұрын

غامدی صاحب کو رب العزت عمرِ دراز و صحت و تندرستی عطا فرمائے، آمین یا رب العالمین ثم آمین

@smbadruddoja8442 Ай бұрын

Every thing in this world is dynamic. Only Allah knows what is good for mankind.

@Pashto_guitar 2 ай бұрын

JazakAllah khair

@afzalahmedkhan2796 2 ай бұрын

Very well explained. Jazak allahu khair

@pervaizmir3885 Ай бұрын

Mashallah Great Very informative and Visionary Analysis on all subjects Allah Almighty bless him healthy wealthy happy life Aameen Suma Aameen tk cr

@firdousaziz3792 2 ай бұрын

Salam sir aala tareen wazahaten salamat rahen sir allah ki rehman aap par jari rahen taa qayamat❤🤲from abu dhabi

@shamimakhtardutta674 Ай бұрын

Idol worship in any form or arrangements to do so is strictly prohibited in this sacred land where our prophet (peace be upon him) visited this place and also delivered sermons. Instead this sacred place must convey the teachings of Islam and make sincere efforts to protect Mosques being demolished daily in India and construct temples over it. Not protecting Islam and encouraging idol worship in this sacred land of UAE would bring devastations, sufferings and natural calamity of high magnitude that will bring heavy irreparable losses to this sacred land. It is high time that we must oppose idol worship in this land to earn rewards and paradise from Allah.

@islameducationlovers6033 Ай бұрын

Before this most of the people and friends asked me not to listen to this person..... Now this is the first time.... First I listened carefully , the whole debate regarding this issue..... MashahAllah great..... I'm satisfied. For all listeners please listen carefully.... inshahallah.... you will be satisfied.

@WNAZ-WALA Ай бұрын

Maashaallaah...It's sign of intellectual as well as well educated scholar. ...

@user-dr6br8vm4b 2 ай бұрын

Ghamdi sahib as usual, convincingly argued with clarity & logic defining history & philosophy of Governance of National states in support of his position on the issue.

@badaransari271 2 ай бұрын

Jazak Allah

@user-tt9vb1jl7o 2 ай бұрын

جزاك اللهُ

@nehalahmad6812 Ай бұрын

We express our thanks to Dr. Alghamdi for his highly acuired deemi Ilm. Jazakallah

@zuhakhalid3139 2 ай бұрын

Ghamdi Sahab is an only person who faces all the criticism with courage.

@insafindiafirst8828 2 ай бұрын

Behtreen masha Allah

@shamichauhdary4716 Ай бұрын

wow!! it was worth listening ... it really cleared my concepts about nation states and rights of the citizens

@ihsankhan8799 2 ай бұрын

OIC should be informed about keeping Arab Peninsula clear of Shirk, Allah's decree in The Quran

@robbykiller2323 2 ай бұрын

Clarity and confidence

@sohailsultan8206 2 ай бұрын

ماشاءاللہ

@vickychannel1986 2 ай бұрын

Best answer..... especially last minutes

@7574rocky 2 ай бұрын

18:05 18:11 Really intellectual and logical discussion. Thanks Javed and Hassan Ilyas Ghamdi sb. One question about the concept of nation state that you discussed that the nation belong to the people who has been there for centuries. In that context how do you explain the nation state of US and Canada. In these countries, the indigenous people are not in control and immigrants became leaders and control them. Can you please comment.

@farzanasolangi6017 Ай бұрын

Zabardast

@MdArif-fz8sw 2 ай бұрын

What a brilliant analysis

@mdsadiquekhan6068 2 ай бұрын

Ghamidi sahab is gift of Aallah swt for those who want to know what is haqeeqi deen. Allah swt Ghamidi sahab ko lambi umr ata kare🤲🤲🤲

@homeid6312 Ай бұрын

حسن بھائ زبردست ۔۔۔۔اللہ آپ سے راضی ہو۔آمین❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

@farahrasheed3331 2 ай бұрын

Jazak Allah Khair

@Jane-mh2gx 2 ай бұрын

Mashallah what an intellect

@moazzam2575 Ай бұрын

اللہ تعالی غامدی صاحب کو ان کے اخلاص کا دنیا و اخرت میں اجر عطا فرمائے

@ShaNawaz-xc8zc 2 ай бұрын

ماشاء الله

@imac786 Ай бұрын

Well done Ghamdi sb salute your principled stand.

@islameducationlovers6033 Ай бұрын

Jazakhuml khair

@muhammadwaiz2251 2 ай бұрын

SubhanAllah Muhatram Ghamdi Sahab to Ghamdi Sahab hein, JazakAllah Khairakum

@swdsandhu 2 ай бұрын

Jazakallah khair ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

@saleemkhan12 2 ай бұрын

Ghamidi Sahib is an unbiased intellectual and religious scholar who has a great grip on philosophy too. What a blessing it is to learn from Ghamidi Sahib. Stay blessed!

@fawad750 Ай бұрын

Very well explained. Rulers/ Governments have their own rules to govern which may be different from their religious laws. It is their primary duty to be bound by religious laws, if they choose not to, and their masses don't hold them responsible as well. Then one can't do anything. Muslim history like other national histories are replete with such blundering exceptions. This being one of them!

@shamimarif9812 Ай бұрын

زبردست باتیں کر رہے غامدی صاحب شاباش غامدی صاحب

@nadeembukhari7973 Ай бұрын

Kamdi shahib, please send a strong message to the UMMA about their weaknesses of not keeping the islamic values and orders against what is going on such as allowing and participating in HINDO religion rituals in especially in Middle east. We like our great scholars to speak up loudly.

@zafarzeeshan6325 2 ай бұрын

May ALLAH give you a healthy life you truly are a asset.

@faridahmed9172 2 ай бұрын

Thank you for such concise explanation. But does any one else, notes a bit of weakness in his voice? May Allah grant him health and long life.

@humanadeem6767 Ай бұрын

Thanks

@FareedAhmed-zx8st 2 ай бұрын

Ghamidi sahib ALLAH KAREEM bless you.

@mohammadnematullah9140 2 ай бұрын

مکہ یا امالقرا تک تو بات ہو سکتی ہے، مگر پورا جزیرہ نما کی بات بے تکی لگتی ہے، دوسری بات یہ کہ اگر کوئی کام کرنے کے لئے بھی آیا ہے اور سالوں سال سے رہ رہا ہے، اسکو اپنے طور سے ایک عبادت گاہ بنا کر اس میں عبادت کرنے سے روکنا سوائے ہٹ دھرمی کہ اور کیا ہے؟

@irshadkhan4085 2 ай бұрын

Great intelectual

@shahidafwan1102 2 ай бұрын

Nice question Hassan bhai

@klacontactbackend7710 Ай бұрын

Jazzak Allah ❤

@Learningnfun643 Ай бұрын

America ki government tu nahi bana k dyti mosque but difference here is government has built mandir

@khawarraza8064 Ай бұрын

Mashallah Ghamidi Sb, your way of explanation is an asset for lawyers on such type of international issues.

@amjadkhan6761 Ай бұрын

بحیثیت قومی ریاست اس قوم کا حق ہے کے وہ کسی بات کی اجازت دیں یا نہ دیں مگر یہ حق بھی اس قوم سے زیادہ اسکے زیر تسلط علاقہ سے مشروط یا منحصر ہوتا ہے پس اس ریاست کی مرضی سے وہاں کسی بھی مذہب کی عبادت گاہ بنائی جا سکتی ہے میرے نزدیک ایک مخصوص علاقہ پر خدائی ریاست کا نظریہ غیر حقیقی ہے کیونکہ تمام دنیا خدائی ریاست ہے۔البتہ تاریخی طور پر ثابت شد ہ کسی مذھب کےمقدس مقامات کی زمین پر کسی غیر مذھب کی عبادت گاہ بنانے کی اجازت نہیں ہونی چاہئے لہذا حرم شریف کی حدود میں غیر مسلم یعنی اپنے آپ کو غیر مسلم تسلیم کرنے والوں کو عبادت گاہ کی اجازت نہ ہو گی

@amjadkhan363 2 ай бұрын

Allah ghamdi sb ko lambi zindagi ata farmaye..

@tajakbar5443 Ай бұрын

Very impressive analysis

@jamilmalik6296 2 ай бұрын

The first part of the video did a very good job of explaining evolution to nation state. The second part of the response was unconvincing.

@saliksayyar9793 2 ай бұрын

To oppose Sayyid Maudoodi’s elegant tafsir, Ghamidi Sahib invented the nation state for Muslims. It is a secular parallel yo Maudoodi’s sahib’s aqamat e deen. Now he appears to be tying himself in a knot. He should understand the nation state was a European political compulsion. How did Bangla Desh , Southern Sudan, Israrl etc come about ? Except through violent occupation or great power threat of violence, as used to be in historyz

@asimrehman1566 2 ай бұрын

If you celebrate the opening of mosques in non-Muslim countries the why you have a problem with others religion doing the same, don't they have the rights to practice their religion.

@zahidanwarkamal3055 2 ай бұрын

Ustad just great just great❤❤

@xohaibiqbal4395 2 ай бұрын

کیا اسرائیل جزیرہ نما عرب میں نہیں ہے ؟

@rafiqquadri4588 Ай бұрын

As always, Ghamidi saahab has proper reasoning for his opinions. May Allah bless him.

@homeid6312 Ай бұрын

well done..Ghamdi sahab..well done ❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉

@ihsanullahm.ibrahim3985 2 ай бұрын

Excellent explanation 🎉 Muslims leaders wake up

@otherpointss Ай бұрын

بھت عمدہ طریقہ سے الفاظ کے چناو سے اور تاریخی پہلو کو مدنظر رکھتے ھوے خامدی صاحب نے بات واضع کردی بلکہ اگر یہ کہا جائے کہ راستہ واضع کردیا کہ عرب والے اس بات پر غور کریں کہ، عرب میں ان چیزوں کی گنجایش نہیں یہ اللہ کی منتخب کردہ سر زمین ھے، جزاک اللہ

@syedqammarmohammad6993 2 ай бұрын

If I correctly understood, As Ghamidi sb has said that about a land where the rights of all Muslims are the same. Kindly tell us what the boundaries of that land are. And also inform inform us that the visa restrictions by Saudi Arabia on the Muslims to visit and enter Saudi Arabia are legal?

@ghanirehman9930 12 күн бұрын

Arabian peninsula is being serviced by people of all religions and nations . We have to respect their feeling and maintain good relations and learn from them . The recent Indian election has proved that humans want to live in peace and cooperation and Modi lost inspite of building a massive temple . Most of the Muslim nations continue to fail the societies and jungle laws prevail . Cooperation, goodwill and understanding is the key.

@ikhlaqhussain4527 Ай бұрын

ماشاللہ

@DeenDuniyahandme Ай бұрын

I wish you use simple Urdu words for someone who is not as educated as the hosts. It will be beneficial for all who has basic knowledge in urdu/hindi

@nehalahmad6812 Ай бұрын

Interviewer is skilled.

@tanveerafzal5868 2 ай бұрын

بہت شکریہ ۔ ایک مودبانہ سوال: بہت سے مسلمان دوسرے ممالک سے جزیرہ نما عرب میں کام کی غرض سے گئے اور اب تو ایک سے زیادہ نسل سے آباد ہیں ۔ انہیں وہاں کی شہریت کا حق کیوں حاصل نہیں ہے؟

@user-wh9io2rh1f Ай бұрын

Very nice 👍👍👍👍

@sawahab7642 Ай бұрын

Ghamdi sb great parsons

@idbhandari9952 2 ай бұрын

The state is a well defined entity having Land, Population, Government and Souvreignity.Nation State is European concept where countries were formed on the basis of NATION having common Language, history, ethnicity ete.But after second world war State were defined by more liberal ideas even DEMOCRACY became the basis at least in European countries.

@rubinashamim6641 2 ай бұрын

Excellent expiation..Hazrat Ibrahim broke the idles and Arabs allowed idle worshippers to built a temple to do butt parasti again. How could the Muslim kingdoms break the rules set by Allah through his messengers.

@najamuddin9236 28 күн бұрын

The basic principle is MIGHT IS RIGHT AND THE MIGHT IS ONLY WITH GOD.

@GeopoliticsByKalim 2 ай бұрын

استادِ محترم جاوید احمد غامدی صاحب اللہ تعالیٰ کے صالح بندے ہیں۔ وہ دین اور قرآن پاک کو نہایت عمدہ انداز میں سمجھاتے ہیں۔ انہوں نے دین کا صحیح فہم حاصل کرنے کے لئے یقیناً بہت محنت کی ہے اور قربانیاں دی ہیں۔ اللہ تعالیٰ انکی اس کوشش کو قبول فرمائے! انکو صالحین میں شامل فرما کر دنیا و آخرت کی کامیابیاں عطا فرمائے! اور اللہ تعالیٰ تمام انسانوں کو اسلام کا صحیح فہم حاصل کرنے کی توفیق عطا فرما کر عمل کرنے کی توفیق عطا فرمائے!

@imac786 Ай бұрын

1 question rh gia. Ghamdi sb agar ap arab mai hakim hon zara tafseel sy batain kesy darja ba darja is maamly aur dosry maamlat drust krty hain

@alimmuhammad9275 2 ай бұрын

Live and let live . If we declare the Arab lands as sacred and do not allow others to build their temples or churches India can also declare Bharat a holy place and prohibit mosques

@mh-zq2fm Ай бұрын

English subtitles plse

@sarfarazghani6570 2 ай бұрын

Wonderful

@MalikFaisal-kl3dl 2 ай бұрын

غامدی صاحب درست فرما رہے ہیں

@shahhussain1296 Ай бұрын

Koi Insan aqal kul nahein. Shakhsiat ki bahes NI Musalmano KO HAQ, BATIL Ka ferq aur Islam ki Taleem si dur kerdiS.😢

@kubrab2617 2 ай бұрын

Bahot accha sawal kiya aap ne...bahot zaruri hei ye sawal....but not convinced with answer...har koi agar apne aqide ke mutabiq logo ki deeni azadi par hadbandi karde to phir dunya me wahi jabar ka dowr wapis ajaega...ham hindustan me rehte hei hame samna karna padta hei musalmano ke in dohre naptol ka jab ham apne huquq ya mazhabi azadi ki baat yaha karte hei ...makkah madina tak phir bhi baat logical lagti hei lekin pura arab ?

@mshaikh4879 2 ай бұрын

meaning that it should go on ....final analysis ---- nahi anil munkar out ?

@shahhussain1296 Ай бұрын

Muslim Molvis should wake up, learn the Truth, unite & establish Islamic human society😂

@javidiqbal1931 Ай бұрын

لیکن پھر تو ون نیشن سٹیٹ نہیں بن سکے گا ۔کیونکہ وہاں پر بھی ایسے مسئلے پیدا ہونگے ۔

@ijazbaig5308 Ай бұрын

Duniya ka qadeem treen mazhab Islaam he aur tareekh Muslimano ke he jo ADAM alaihislaam se he.

@voice_against_domestic_vio7489 2 ай бұрын

India was not formulated as a separate nation based on Hindu majority. Rather pakistan was separated based on religion. India always survived on the concept of democracy, not on the basis of religion. However, reverse is happening now but the past was never like that which you have depicted.

@murtazashah2415 Ай бұрын

Ghamdi Sahab ko smjhne ke lye parha likha hona zaruri hai

@Learningnfun643 Ай бұрын

Dubai n saudia is paying 4 times to non Muslims compared to muslim workers…gamidi sahab is right …koe ehsan nahi kiya non Muslims ny

@user-iy2zk2xs9b Ай бұрын

Muslim qualified from the same institutes from the west are paid less than the whites in Saudi Arabia and other Gulf states

@kashifbaby406 Ай бұрын

Mazhab Zameen paar Nafiz Nahee Hota.Mazhab Dil o Demagh Paar Nafiz Hotaa Hai.

@DanishAli-rm2ky 2 ай бұрын

سوال تو یہ بنتا ہے کہ جب خدا نے یہ اعلان کر دیا کہ دین میں کوی جبر نہیں اور ہر کوئی اپنے عمل کا جواب دے ہے تو عرب میں بسنے والے غیر مسلم اقوام کو یہ حق کیوں نہیں۔ جب وہ لوگ جو صدیوں سے اپنے علاقوں میں آباد رہے اور اسلام کے آنے کے بعد ہم انہیں یہ صرف یہ آپشن دے رہے ہیں کہ یا تو مسلمان ہو جاو یا پھر جزیرہ نما عرب سے نکل جاو ورنہ قتل کر دیے جاو گے تو اس میں choice کہاں بچی جس کا دین میں دعوی کیا گیا؟ المیہ یہ کہ آج کے دور میں فاتح اقوام نے اپنے ملکوں میں دیگر مذاہب اور اقوام کے لوگوں کو پناہ دی اور برابر کے حقوق دیےجس طرح آپ کو امریکہ میں حاصل ہے اور لاکھوں کی تعداد میں لوگ ان ممالک میں پناہ لے رہے ہیں لیکن اسلام جو عالمگیریت کا دعوٰی کرتا ہے وہ اپنی طاقت میں کسی دوسرے کا وجود برداشت نہیں کر پارہا۔ شاید یہ سوال ہمیں ایک دو صدیوں پہلے پریشان نا کرتا لیکن اب جب لبرلزم نے فرضی طور سہی، دنیا میں ایک ایسا ماڈل دیا ہے جہاں ہر ایک فرد کو معاشرے میں آذادی سے جینےاور اپنے مذہبی آذادی کا حق ہے ( اس حد تک وہ شخص یا اس کے نظریات کسی دوسرے شخص یا طبقے کو نقصان نے باعث نہ بنے) جو ہر شخص اپنے لیے ڈیمانڈ کرتا ہے وہاں مذہبی فلسفہ ایک بظاہر تنگ نظر اور استحقاق پر مبنی لگتا ہے۔

@komalsur 2 ай бұрын

Even as a long time fan of Janab Ghamdi Sahib, it is still difficult for me to understand his arguments in this case. Somehow it looks Double standard. Sorry.

@AdnanAli-ct8px 2 ай бұрын

Ghamidi sb k kaam ko English mein convert kerna shurroo karein plz

@asifiqbal2776 2 ай бұрын

It appears that the logical fallacy of "equivocation" has repeatedly been committed here. "Equivocation" happens when the same word, -- such as "headache," -- is understood to mean precisely the SAME thing in a sentence like: "Annoying drivers are a real headache," and a sentence like "I took a painkiller to get rid of my headache." The point of giving the preceding example is as follows: The word "state" in its modern parlance, with the central feature of being an impersonal institution, emerged in Europe from the 16th century onwards and eventually passed to the Muslim Middle East by its Arabic name of "dawla." The fallacy consists of equating this modern concept of state with that political alliance which was reportedly created in the 7th century by the Prophet of Islam. Here's how Montgomery Watt (correctly) described this latter entity: "The Islamic state in 632 was a conglomeration of tribes in alliance with Muhammad on varying terms, having as its inner core the people of Medina and perhaps also of Mecca." (Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman, pp. 222-223). In short, the concept and extent of the meanings of a word ("state") in the 20th century do not equal what the same word ("State") meant in the 7th.

@alimansoor6459 2 ай бұрын

i am kind of a liberal but to all those drama queens in the comment section who sit and eat in the west while talking abt palestine and changing DPs, khair coming to the point... why do u fast? why do u pray? why do u stay away from haraam? bz its Allah's decree right? same thing goes for arab peninsyula, Allah has decreed it for muslims, if the west doesnt allow you to make mosques thn its their choice, they can make mandir in pakistan or say indonesia or turkey etc but the arab land is muqaddas, if you believe in Allah, thn u have to accept his decree. simple