Some people complaining abt their vocals being breathy/shaky are the same people that hate on them for not singing live. I think the girls did well and i wld consider their singing quite stable considering they had to do some hard choreos. Well done girls. I hope to see them sing live more

Giselle don’t usually get this much attention but now that they’re actually singing live and in front of a huge crowd, you really see her shining!!!

Coachella really needs to invite AESPA again😤 They were so damn ready by talent back then but now they’re so damn more experienced and could eat the entire stage atp. The live vocals r literally crazyy

If anything this performances did was help people acknowledge Ningning, she killed it. The girls do know how to sing live and now we all know it

This just goes to show that live singing does affect stage presence, they are 10x better here than all of their stages. Hopefully they'll get to do more lives like this for their next comeback

I usually just casually listen to their music but wow, Ningning blew me away with her stage presence, Giselle was so stable, Karina really proved herself as an all rounder, and Winter’s high notes sounded just like the studio version

now aespa has become a big group and can perform at the Tokyo Dome in two days and all tickets are sold out.

im so proud of these girls. it seems like not a lot of people are satisfied with their performance, but for a group who debuted in front of cameras with barely any experience with a live stage and audience, they did really really well. damn, imagine how nervous they were lol. they might not be the "best" but they definitely arent lacking, and im really excited for what they have in store for us in the future. well done girls!

i’m so proud of giselle, you can see how pro she is on hyping the crowd. winning’s vocals are just so amazing and karina’s energy wow.

at first I thought that they wouldn’t have stage presence but tbh them singing live made them have stage presence, they slayed.

Winter's vocals are SO stable! I lovedd herr singing the most of the four! AND ningning's and karina's STAGE PRESENCE are absolutely eye-catching and Giselle's rap is so addictive! Overall, for a group who doesn't sing live often AND are still rookies in the industry, this was SOOO GOOD!!!!!

8:36 winter's voice really sounded so princess-like here. the song suits her so much, along with giselle.

Absolutely love how Winter sounds exactly the same as their studio version and even better. But right here she gave much more life to it. Her voice is golden ❤️

they slayed the stage!! they’re just a 1year old group seeing for the first time a real crowd and they hold this power!! im so proud !! AESPA QUEENS

Giselle is so stable like especially in her rap part in Savage that fabulous. Her stage presence is also shining same for NingNing. They really stand out during Coachella.

Winter has the largest chunk of lines in their songs and she displayed her vocal capabilities the best through stability. No matter what people may say, the western community will still remember them as the kpop group who served vocals in coachella

Ningning's years of training in SM Rookies really paid off in this Coachella performance. They may be a 1-year old group but Ningning as the main vocal really shined and carried the whole thing along with Giselle's confidence. Specially proud with Karina and Winter as well. There's a lot of room for improvement but they still delivered. Kudos!

I’m not shocked they sang live because I’m pretty sure it’s a requirement for Coachella but I’m also sure this is their first live performance. They did pretty good and if they sing live next comeback they will become more experienced!

Most of the time Karina and Winter will take over the stage presence but this time I just cannot take out my eyes on Ningning and Giselle! They really daebakkkkkk

You can see how much being able to perform live changes their stage presence. These girls went to SM to become performers and show off their talent. I’m happy they finally got to do that.

Surprised by Giselle, she ate and enjoyed the perf instead of just dancing around she made it enjoyable

As a Sone, I'm supporting aespa too. Snsd must be proud of them. These girls don't deserve the hate. They are one of the most talented 4th gens out there. They are the overachieving rookie group. Believe me, they are just starting, they will continue to improve talent-wise

We can't deny that their vocals are excellent and stable. Gisselle rap is 🔥

Winter’s power to be able to belt her high notes so perfect. Her stability is insane.

Ningning is shining here ✨ while Giselle proves herself to be someone who's on next level. Karina and Winter are always a total performer. But Giselle & Ningning stole the performance. 👏🏻

their improvement is obvious, they sing live and their vocals are really good, they're on the biggest stage in America, their charisma, and their presence on stage everything is perfect. They did a great job, why should they receive criticism from the online community? they represent the gen4 girl group that's really very, very, very proud. We are always with you, wonderful girls 🤍

I came here to clean my ears after listening to that le sserafim coachella

Who else is here now lol

Finally they are singing LIVE , and they did well , aespa let's go just when i was happy of 2ne1 making a stage comeback , we have aespa slaying their performance 🥳🥳🥳

Im just a casual listener of them but i could say that they improved a lot!! omg i didn’t even expect it to be this banger

Guys , let's see this again

NingNing OWNED Coachella era… can’t tell me otherwise

Given time to develop their live stage these girls will really be the biggest group of the 4th gen, look how good Ningning and Giselle are here now! Imagine in a couple years with more experience under their belt.

Ningning has sang live in front of a big audience before and it shows. Her confidence is beyond!

It’s so good to finally hear them singing live for the first time, and my girl Ning Ning did amazing I love her.

I love Winter's voice omggggg

TBH guys NINGNING killed so much... her live singing I really great like he had been doing live singing for a long time... her VOICE stands out too much and I don't have a hard time listening on her voice because of the POWERFUL VOCALS she has..... she really proved why she is the MAIN VOCALIST of AESPA.

so proud of my girls!! they debuted during the pandemic and hardly had any chance to perform in front of an audience, this being of the firsts for them ofc they have to be nervous and especially because its a large crowd with casual stoppers not hardcore fans. despite all that they performed and delivered while having fun!! YOU DID GREAT AESPA

The fact that they sang live and danced their powerful choreos without a single break makes them the 4th generation k-pop queens

Here again to see my girl❤

*Even non fans and casual listeners keeps praising them. Aespa, you've come this far within less than 2 years. All of you are absolutely amazing, it's not a smooth journey but that's life. I'll always believe in your skills and talents. Keep improving as a performer and a person. We're rooting for the best future ahead. MYs will always supporting AESPA.*

It's really different when they sing live, it brings out the best in them, the confidence and stage presence. I hope SM will let this Queens sing live. Im so proud of them, slay! 😊💕

Can we talk about how much Ning Ning is feeling it and slaying

couldn’t put into words how happy and proud I am seeing Giselle and Ningning shine and enjoy themselves throughout the whole performance✨

aespa singing live is indeed a blessing! The confidence, stage presence, and the amount of support they got from the audience is everything. Thank you for those who went to supports these babies. virtual hugs for yooou 🤍🤍🤍

I'm just amazed at Winter, how she holds herself and feels like being in control and calm throughout the performance with her almost perfect singing most of the time just like the studio version. Karina also the same, the way she did the adlibs for the last song, and the perfect intro to Next Level, she's really the all rounder. Ningning and Giselle did great too! Hope they'll be able to perform for live audience more

Winter really killed it, she's stable and can sing live yo haters. I'm proud of my bias

Honestly Giselle sounds wayyyy better live! She loved the audience and improved a lot! She and NingNing finally shined. Karina and Winter definitely delivered too!

8:00 To the person who said “ZU ZU ZU ZU” so energeticly and Loudly, I love that energy you have there. GO QUEEN AESPA. STAN AESPA, YOU CANT LIVE A LIFE WITHOUT AESPA

Giselle and Ningning queens of stage presece, they improved a lot!

I wish next year they perform again there they're gonna kill it for sure

I don't get why people are surprised about their live vocals: they are SM, OF COURSE THEY CAN SING LIVE. What I'm actually shocked is that they opened with aenergy. I don't hate the song, but not exactly the best to pump up the audience. SM can make breathtaking concerts, so I really don't understand.

rookie group who hasn't had this big of a live crowd before and finally got to sing live and they killed it. wasnt a perfect performance since its completely different from what they've been doing but they did amazing and im so proud of them !!!!!! i cant wait to see them get even better and i hope their company lets them sing live more bc look how hyped they were !!!

I KNEW IT! I KNEW SOON THEY WOULD HAVE SUNG LIVE! And they slayed like they never did! I've always thought that they didn't have a lot of stage presence, but here they were absolutely perfect! They handled such a big stage being just four! Especially Giselle and NingNing, they looked so hyped and excited! With this performance they proved everyone they are perfect, I just hope they will start singing live in Korea too🥺

NINGNING IS KILLING IT SHE LOOKS LIKE SHES HAVING THE TIME OF HER LIFE IM CRYING I WISH I COULD GO

This is way better than any of their other stages when they were lipsyncing. The more practice they'll get the better they'll become. Live vocals don't have to be 100% perfect, but it does bring so much more energy and presence to the stage.

The fact that aespa is just 1.5 years in their career and has 0 experience performing live in front of actual audience like this yet they nailed it 💯💯💯

Ningning is such a performer!! Many ppl were asking about the "blonde girl" Aespa did really really well!! I love to listen to their loud and energetic vocals I wish I was there too 😭😭

Omg there vocals sound so good. I’m so in love with Winter & Ningning powerful vocals !! Giselle vocal color is really good. Karina sound good. People need stop complaining about vocals . They did the best they could, every idol doesn’t always bring the best vocals to table all time . They going have breathy vocals , strained vocals , vocals cracks .

Winter was so stable. And they've did great. I'm so prouuuuud of em

Interesting. I thought Karina and Winter would be the stand outs. But after watching this, I feel like Ning Ning and Giselle really stood out and embodied the “American” vibe: It’s not about being perfect or the best, it’s about having charisma and being raw. It’s strange watching their performances without the typical K-pop production and fast cuts. You really see who stand outs. Karina and winter are amazing always of course, but somethings seemed a bit off or lower energy than usual. Maybe they were just nervous. But also, they were really singing live, so maybe we’re just not used to them conserving their energy and not dancing as full out. Great performance overall though and proud of them!

This is probably the first time I can actually hear them sing live. They're great, don't know what sm's problem is or whoever blasts their backtrack on full volume all the time.

aespa ah, if you see this comment, i just want to say that I'm so proud of you guys, you guys are more than I expected, I love you and will never regret it! Rest well and come back soon!

the fancams are soooo much better than the official broadcast, we can listen to their voices, their vocals are really good

I better not see any MY complaining about Ningning's vocals again. She's hard carrying here. What a Queen.

The girls did not prove me wrong. From the beginning people said they had no stage presence and can’t hype up a crowd but I knew all of that wasn’t true. They sang live and proved that they just as good as any other group. This was their first time and they did amazing. Love you Aespa

a proof that singing live does affect stage presence. PROUD OF AESPA, THEY HAVE A LONG WAY TO COME!!

They did awesome. Coachella is so stressful and hyped I imagine they were extremely nervous

NINGNINGS ENERGY AND STAGE PRESENCE!! My eyes were glued to her the whole time

Damn you can clearly see difference when they actually sing LIVE. They are way more energetic and you can see them enjoying themselves.

And thats why NingNing and Giselle are my bias since day one.....yes scorpio sisters ❤️ Edit: Finally they are singing *live* !!

6:26 THISSSSS FINALLY! AN AUTHENTIC LIVE SHOWCASING OF VOCALS.

Ningning deserves so much more hype! The girl has literally the best presence and her live vocals are the best!

They actually have insane stage presence when they sing live omggg 😩 SM WHY YOU DOING THIS TO THESE QUEENS?!

Ningning seems to be the most comfortable holding the microfone

Aespa stage present is geting more betterr!!! Keep doing the great teamwork aespa, you gurls are doing better!🥰🥰🥰

I never understood why SM never let them sing live. After this performance, it’s pretty obvious that SM needs to have them sing live ALL THE TIME!

SLAYED girls, the first 4th g girl group to go to the biggest stage in America, finally they are singing live, vocals, visuals, charisma, stage presence, everything perfect, *the leaders of the 4th generation*

Their stage presence is sooooooo much better when theyre singing live! They seem happy to share their music and are enjoying themselves.

Winter usually has the least stage presence. But this live singing completely turned it all around. WINTER IS MEANT FOR LIVE PERFORMANCES!!!!

As a blink and a fan of aespa, it hurts to see many people fighting over who was better. Obviously the crowd is more quiet because these r rookies we talking abt. Honestly the fact this is their first time in front of a big crowd and their singing LIVE. Props to the girls. Edit: I think people are confused on why i think the reason for the crowd being quiet is because they are rookies. First of yes, aespa is considered rookies still in the Kpop industry because they only just debuted about a year ago. Second they are rookies when it comes to international stuff, SM hasn't really made their mission to push aespa internationally so this leading to the crowd maybe not knowing them. And third, if people were really bored at the music(which still could be), wouldn't they just leave instead of recording or whatever. So to compare, Blackpink having 3 years in the industry and international push=loud crowd, aespa having 1 year in the industry and no international push=quieter crowd. Facts are facts.

Winter sounds exactly like the studio version... Seriously no different at all

Finally ning getting all the hype she deserves i love her-

Ning Ning carry’s this group and people have the audacity to hate on her

Their live voices are even better than the studio versions bcs you can hear them raw and i like that ✋ specially karinas voice! Like it gives more oomf and it's deeper.

Absolutely loved Ningning and Giselle's energy. Ace Winter and Ace Karina rocked it too! SM please let them perform live in their future stages as well, look how happy and confident they are. Thank you for posting this.

im a blink. i know that i dont to mention this. but i want mys to know that not all blinks or blonks bad mouths other artists. every kpop group deserves to have their shining moments. regardless if their the "1st" or not in anything. everyone has the right to dream, so as me and you🙂 aespa did well in their live stage and most important them and their fans enjoyed this historic moment for their idols. ☺️ by the way, i love their new song, it has a nostalgic vibe to it ❤️

1st ever 4th Gen who performed at Coachella and they slayed it in front of a big crowd. And I can hear the audience singing with them. So proud of yah all. 😘😘😘.

Also shoutout to Giselle, an 11 month training period is crazy. She did so well honestly, her raw talent shines

Them singing live gives them more energy. Looks like they were really enjoying. Hope they would always sing live ❤️

They objectively did amazing. I am just now getting into Aespa and I appreciate this raw performance

Queen winter!? Hello?! Those looks and vocalsss served me welll!!! Omg I really wanna be there😭🤍🤍🤍

I'm kinda surprised by how stable Winter's vocals are while performing live. SM should allow them to sing live once in a while...

They did amazing! Giselle definitely hyped up the crowd! Karina still with the dance moves along with the rap! Winter with her amazing vocals! NingNing with her vocals, and confidence! Definitely wanna see them live again!

I'm so proud of them. I'm a casual listener but I've heard them since their debut and they've really improved a lot.

Ningning and Giselle really killed it

I AM TELLING YOU THIS IN ADVANCE. THEY WILL BE SO FREAKING SUCCESSFUL AND I AM HERE FOR IT.

Damnn NingNing was so goood!!!good!!!! Wow blow. Away by her charisma that showed and her vocals

By watching all of their performance, you could say that they literally improve their facial expressions. This is just the start!

So proud of aespa....they literally blew off the stage.....this shows how professional is aespa