YES!!!

FR (2)

NOT GONNA START THE CHAIN BY ME 😈 But I agree Giselle was the best here .

True

Their visual is really unique

@@human7491 and her socks are soooo meh 🤣

FR

jojiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

buen truco karina

nah karina giselle and winter is 2 lovers and a 3rd wheel😭💀

so true when its Karina + Winter + Giselle lmaoo 😭

100% accurate 🤣

Strawberry time

Ningning+Winter=Chaotic pair

Yea♥️😽

Karina and Giselle is really cute....

It's true they are cute

Yesss

Armyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy💜

Yeeeeeeeess 💜

a r m y y y y y y y y y y 💜💜

😂

@@velveteeensrv5390 yes

@Sehun Oh ofc it's the first one .. they're my girls :( I could never

You mean giselle?

@@GilangD21 while giselle is confident in front of the camera, she doesn’t experiment with her posing like ningning does. models often make awkward and original poses when they have a photo shoot but they also make sure they highlight the product they are selling. for this reason, i said ningning is the most natural at modeling which is expected because she trained the longest. ( one of my cousins is a model so i’m not ignorant on this subject and often do lots of research on this topic myself because modeling has always been brought up to me)

I agree She is both cute and very beautiful too

Yes I agree ! Can't take my eyes off her >

@@GilangD21 damn girl...the shade you trying to throw is only gonna make you look stupid AF

Guess my two biases🤩🤩

Dont forget victoria f(x), she's good leader too :(

@@RafikaSuryaAdhi long list aunt Victoria :(

Nooo where's Victoria xxx she never gave up on her group

I'm so sorry for not including Victoria unnie. What I'm trying to emphasize is their visual relation because those three were really looked alike. Including Winter of Aespa and yup Victoria unnie is indeed such a great leader of F(x). I miss them so much too.

The fact that they all look like they're on the same age

Agree!!!

I noticed it since the teaser photo of her. Her modeling skill is another level for me

I too agree .she is so beautiful

Future Main Covergirl

They have amazing personalities.

Ikrrr

wait time stamp?

@@ryeong4497 1:05

@@ryeong4497 1:04 :)))

😁😂

Same lmao, but looking back at karina's predebut askfm account i'm not so shocked lol

@@xiaothink2820 all she does in her askfm is to flirt lmao

@@spacesoftime she been hiding her true personality all this time lmao

Same

same

Next level: 100M

Yes💙❤

Y E S

Suho is Bvlgari too 👍

Pringles Princess

yesss

U forgot DIOR

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAH HEEEEELP 😭😭

and thats why i stan them lmao

@@JuanCruz-ew2vq .......ok

I love you 😍😘

@@JuanCruz-ew2vq the feeling's not mutual bby

@@aesdive l love you 🤴👸💐

Oof i will never be like that👁👄👁🐑

Yeah she is both cute and beautiful

pleaseeee everyonee. See in 8:57 - 8:58. Hes open camera handphone. And than 9:02. Hes take a picture winter without permission. And im sorry for mu bad english. I just want to say that. Pls protect winter

@@fathanahtriramadhani4587 PROTECT AESPA

🥇⚾️🎏🎄🎏🎁🎫🎁🎫🎄🎐🎁🎖🎋🎖🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🥇🎖🎋🎖🥇⚽️🎆🎖🎗🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁⚾️🎁🎖🎋🎋🎖🎖🎋🎖🎁🎋🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎖🎋🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎫🎄🎐🎁🎏🎋🎏🎏🎄🎫🎁🎖🎊🎫🥇⚽️🏅🎫🎗🎫⚾️🥇⚾️🥇⚽️🎍🎖🎗🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🥇🎖🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎁🎫🎋🎖🎫🎆🎫🎁🎖🎋🎖🎗🎖🎆🎖🎁🎖🎊🎖🥇🎋⚽️🎖🎁🎖🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎄🎁🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎁🎫🎍🎁🎖🎖🎋🎖🎁⚾️🥇🎋⚾️🎖🎁🎁🎖🎋🎖🎖🎁🎋🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎫🎋🎖🎄🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁⚽️⚽️🎁🎫🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁⚽️🎁🎫🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎄🎐🎁⚾️🎗🎐🎄🎖🎐🥇🎐🥇🎖🎗🎖🎍🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎗🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🥇🎖🎁🎖🎄🎖🎗🎖🎆🎖🎍🎖🎆🎐🎆🎐🎐🎄🎫🎁⚽️🥇🎖🎗🎖🎆🎐🎋🎖🎁🎫🥈🎫🎍🎖🎄🎁🎖🎋🎖⚾️🎁🎁⚾️🎍🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎄🎐🎋🎖🎁⚾️🥇⚽️🎍🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎫🎄🎐🎖🥇🎋🎖🎄🎖🎋🎖🎁🎀🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋⚾️⚾️🎋🎖🎋🎖🎋⚾️🎄⚾️🎁⚾️🎁🎖🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎐🎖🥇🎖🎋🎖🎖🎋⚽️🎗🎁🎖🎖🎋⚾️🎗⚽️🎆🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋🎐🎖🎖🎋🎫🎁🎫🎁🎖🎁🎁🎖🎄🎐🎁🎖🎋🎖🎖🎋🎁🎖🎋🎖⚽️🎗⚽️🎋🎫🥇🎖🎁⚾️🥇🎐🎍🎖🎁🎖🎗🎖🎁⚽️🎋🎖🎁🎖🎖🎋🎖🎁🎫🎁🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎈🎏🎗🎫🎆🎏✨🎋✨🥇🎖🥇🎖🎁🎐🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎄🎁🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎫🎍🎫🎫🎋🎖🎁🎖🎁🎖🎗🎖🎄🎖🎗🎖🎋🎖🎍🎖🎐🎄🎖🎁🎖🎍🎁🎖🎋🎖🎄🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🥇⚾️🎋⚾️🥇⚾️🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎋⚾️🥇⚾️🎁⚾️🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎁⚾️🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎋⚾️🎁🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎁⚾️🎄⚾️🎁⚾️🎖🎁🎖🎖🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎖🎖🎖🎖🎋🎖🎁⚾️🎋🎖🎋🎑🎊🎖🎀⚾️🎋🎖🎗🎁🎫🎋🎫🎫🎁🎐🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋⚾️🥈🎖🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎋🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎁⚾️🎗⚾️🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎖🎊🎖🎊🎋🎖🎋🎫🎖🎁🎖🎄🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎖🎋🎖🎋🎖🎗🎫🎍🎐🎍🎐🎗🎖🎊🎐🎗🎖🎖🎁🎖🎊⚾️🎀⚾️🎁⚾️🎗⚾️🎄🎖🎁🎖🎁⚾️🎍⚾️🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎁⚾️🎋🎑🎁🎖🎁⚾️🎗⚾️🎋🎖🎁⚾️🎗🎐🎆🎖🎋⚾️🎋⚾️🎁⚾️🎍🎖🎄🎖🎁🎖🎋🎖🎗⚾️🎆🎖🎁🎖🎋⚽️🎁🎁🎫🎫🎁🎐🎎🎈🎎🎖🎁⚾️🎁⚽️🎗⚽️🎍🎫⚽️🎟🎎🎖🎁🎖🥇⚾️🎗⚾️🎇🎖🎍🎖🎋⚾️🎁⚽️🎇🎖🎍🎍🎖🎊🎖🎁⚾️🎇⚾️🎗⚾️🎁⚾️🥇⚾️🎟🎉🏆🎖🎖🎀🎖🎊🎫🥇🎖🎁⚾️🎃🎖🎁⚾️🎁⚾️⚾️🥈⚾️🎋🎖🥇⚾️🎁⚾️🎍⚾️🎖🎁🏀⚾️🎟⚾️🎆🎖🎁⚽️🥈⚽️⚽️🎟⚾️⚽️🎗⚽️🎟⚽️🎖🎍🎖🎁⚾️🥈⚽️🎎⚾️🎁⚾️⚾️⚾️🎍⚾️⚾️🎋⚽️🎁🥈⚾️⚾️🎍⚽️🎋⚽️🎁⚽️🥇⚽️⚽️🎟⚽️🎍⚽️🎋⚽️🥇⚽️🥈⚽️🎎⚽️🎗⚽️⚽️🥇⚽️🎁⚽️🎋⚽️🥉⚽️🎇⚽️⚽️🎋⚽️🥇⚽️🎗⚽️🎟⚽️⚽️🎋⚽️⚽️🎁⚾️🎟⚾️⚾️🎄⚾️🎁⚾️⚽️⚽️🎄⚽️🎋⚽️⚽️🎃⚽️🥈⚽️🎎🎃🎫🎫🥇⚽️🎟⚽️⚽️🎋⚽️🥇⚽️🥈⚽️🎇⚽️🎄⚽️⚾️🎁⚾️🎗⚾️🎄⚾️⚾️🎀🏀🥇🎗🎐🥇🎖🎗🎖🥇🎖🎍🎖🎋🎖🎖🥇🎖🎗🎖🎍🎖🎋🎖🎁🎖🎗🎍🏆🎋🏆🎋🏆⚾️🥈🏀🎆⚾️🎄🎊🏆🎁🎖🎗

I hope you're not holding on OT2 or somethin like that and I hope you love all the members

who said that stop spreading rumours

Nobody said that.

I wanna know who the mf said that? 😀🔪

Maybe you don’t know but there are lots

Lol, why would they said that. Even if it's true, that's just nonsense because the main owner of givenchy "personally" picked aespa as brand ambassadors of his brand. Are haters saying they know better than the owner of the fashion brand???? Haters can just cry. I hope more endorsement will come to them so they can shut up their haters

They removed this part

​@@melisch8572damn I suddenly remember this when the video was released so I've just checked again and found out they deleted everything. Seriously, I think it's the goddamn power and money play getting involved in this whole situation. I don't trust the industry at all.

ดัน

But why people noticed this only month later?

구라치치 마라

1) the guy in the navy shirt was actually the MAIN PHOTOGRAPHER of the photo shoot 2) winter was wearing long pants, not a dress or shorts 3) there were hundreds of cameras rolling for behind-the-scenes, no one in their right mind would attempt a crime in the middle of that 4) sm confirmed all of this 5) the photographer is publicly suing everyone who falsely accused him of this so check ur facts before spreading this shit so disgusting how fans act these days

@@junb20000 winter is wearing long pants but it has many slits. Next look at 8:56 in slo-mo and you can see hes on camera mode he also tapped his phone once which is most likely to take a video and at 9:00 why did he have to lean in with his phone near winter's bottom.

😍😍😍

I didn't see anything

@@frostyheaven8612 Look at the man behind Winter and Karina he has his phone facing down.

Taking legal actions for an official photographer who has his camera app open 😂😂😂 There will be many legal actions now 🤦🤦🤦

1) the guy in the navy shirt was actually the MAIN PHOTOGRAPHER of the photo shoot 2) winter was wearing long pants, not a dress or shorts 3) there were hundreds of cameras rolling for behind-the-scenes, no one in their right mind would attempt a crime in the middle of that 4) sm confirmed all of this 5) the photographer is publicly suing everyone who falsely accused him of this so check ur facts before spreading this shit so disgusting how fans act these days

The first time I saw this I was angry but I still searching the truth and I came here...that man is the main photographer and if he really took a photo of winter under dress my question is how? How that man took a photo of winter's under dress if winter is wearing a long pants and no revealing part of her underwear or anything..and also don't accuse sm,,sm doing their best and their artist doing great :)..sm isn't the best but always good :]

Yes please 😭❤

Popular opinion** 😭😭

fr

Korean fans are assuming the reason aespa don't do vlive is that SM worries the fact that there are so many haters in Korea. Haters terrified the ratings of aespa's song in melon (korean major music streaming app) and they leave so many bad comments to aespa. so Sm might worry about if aespa do vlive they get attacked by those haters

I assume the same now after reading this Safety comes first

Does anybody check the news sites before they post? SM already debunked this!

@@stephensimpson9289 Will u really just believe anything SM says?

yes and idk what's with sm but you can see it clearly and it's so obvious

the dude it’s so fucking obvious my blood boils to see it and know he would have no repercussion at all

if y’all look closely he turns on the camera app on his phone and then leans in next to her when he gets behind her if you think he didn’t do anything wrong your the problem

I don't have points to prove you wrong, shes amazing!!😽💕

Omgg Indian My!!!! eheheee *noice*

@@godjihyoizmyreligion1501 I'm an Indian MY too ;)

Bruh stop it

I am very strong

No everyone wants their new upbeat song

@@itzyamelia4605 these "popular opinion" comments are copy pasted countless times everywhere that fake stans spam around just for likes, showing how they dont care about the idols and only pretend to be stans for attention

@@itzyamelia4605 its not hurting fans, but many copy them just for likes and we can see that too many do this everywhere, showing how insincere they are about liking the idols, if you didnt know, its fine, just compliment your idols with your own words, so there wont be a missunderstanding again

yeah. you're absolutely right! i've never seen anyone this beautiful before💗💗💗

@@jackmarshmallow2457 yeah ikr her smile 😍😍😍i just can’t get over with that.her smile is so beautiful it’s screams visual

aespa my foreverrrr

My aespaaaa

Everglow’s fan be like : 👁👄👁 (Jk)

@@loonamonster "EVERGLOW FOREVER LET'S GO!" WANG YERIN 2020 HAHAHA BTW "MY" and "FOREVER" here❤️!

Shito

stop witch hunting

@@moozo9061 what?

@@jessicarhee1147 Honestly!!! If he was “checking” the mentor or whatever it’s called. Why would he need the camera open?

​@@cupcakegirlseven don't photoshoot people frequently take photos of monitors? you can see the edge of the monitor on the right edge of the video at 8:57. he looks at the monitor at 8:58, thinks about taking a photo of the monitor at 8:59, goes in for a closer look at 9:01 and then decides he doesn't need to take the photo

trueee

trueee

yes

Favourite part 🥺