If Uncle is 61 in RDR2 then by RDR he is a 73 year old that is able to care for a ranch and take on the military with LUMBAGO.

Let's be honest, I looked good for my age.

The fact lennney was 19 makes even sadder

Charles was 24?! Hella mature for his age, even if he didn't stood so well after the separation until John.

Lenny being only 19 makes his death even more sad 😭

Dutch calls Arthur his son, even though he's only 5 years older.

When you realize that Arthur would be 158 years old by now.

Wow Sadie was only 25?! Jeez her deep voice and dgaf attitude made me think she must have been in her early 30s or sth, just a few year younger than Arthur not 11 🤯🤯

There no way John 26, he sounds like he’s been smoking cigarettes for over 30 years.

Micah: calls Arthur old Micah: is 39 36 year old Arthur: am I a joke to you?

Man Arthur, John, Sean, and Lenny all died so young. I only mention these because they were the best four the bunch

I thought they were all older than this. Like Arthur in his 40s. Dutch is his 50s and Hosea 60s. John 35 at least 😱

Mr.BossFTW would've made this video 10 minutes long

Dutch literally talks to Arthur like he’s 20 years older than him but he’s only like five

I thought Dutch was in his 50’s, Hosea in his 60’s and Abigail in her 30’s.

Arthur Morgan: 36 John Marston: 26 Dutch Van der Linde: 44 Abigail: 22 Jack: 4 Hosea Matthews: 55 Micah Bell: 39 Susan Grimshaw: 42 Molly O’Shea: 25 Sadie Adler: 25 Lenny Summers: 19 Sean Maguire: 21 Bill Williamson: 33 Javier Escuella: 26 Charles Smith: 27 Tilly Jackson: 21 Karen Jones: 25 Simon Pearson: 48 Uncle: 61 Leopold Strauss: 53 Reverendo Swanson: 46 Josiah Trelawny: 45 Kieran: 21 Edgar Ross: 48 Andrew Milton: 42 Colm O’Driscoll: 45 Leviticus Cornwall: 51 Colonel Henry Favours: 63 Eagle Flies: 19 Captain Monroe: 34 Alberto Fussar: 45 Hercule Fontaine: 27 Sheriff Gray: 39 Archibald MacGregor: 35 Joe: 34 Cleet: 32 Jim “Boy” Calloway: 52 Black Belle: 41 Catherine Braithwaite: 54 Penelope Braithwaite: 17 Beau Gray: 17 Anthony Foreman: 32 Mary Linton: 28 Jamie Gillis: 18 Sheriff Curtis Malloy: 48 Archie Downes: 16 Tom Davies: 47 Sheriff Freeman: 38 Angelo Bronte: 55 Mayor Lemieux: 56 David Geddes (1907): 46 Abe (1907): 21 Tom Dickens (1907): 55 Vampire: 452

I feel like most of them should be about 10 years older.

When you see Lenny’s age and it makes you cry more

I get that arthur is in his 30’s and stuff but how the hell is john’s 26

So abigail was barely legal when John & her had jack 😂😬

I'm 27 years old and most characters in their 20s look like they could be my parents.

Charles's age surprised me the most. He acts way older than he is.

00:28 the wisest thing dutch said was TAHITI

Its sad, I never realized how young so many characters died....and got brought into this shit storm. A lot of them could still be in school!! (college ofc)

So nobody is gonna talk about the fact that Bill is younger than Arthur

How is it that Uncle did basically nothing, had a large impact on the story and still outlived everyone else by a good 25 years?

Everyone looks exactly 10 years older than they are claimed to be

If I had to give a more fitting call for what each member should be based on their appearance, I'd say: Arthur (36) - About right ✅ Dutch (41) - Late 40s (47-49) Hosea (55) - Early 60s (60-63) John (26) - Early 30s (30-33) Abigail (22) - Late 20s (27-29) Jack (4) - (6 or 7) Micah 39 - About right ✅ Bill 33 - Mid 30s (34-36) Javier (26) - Early 30s (30-33) Lenny (19) - About right ✅ Stauss (53) - About right ✅ Charles (24) - Late 20s (27-29) Swanson (46) - About right ✅ Sean (21) - About right ✅ Karen (25) - About right ✅ Tilly (21) - About right ✅ Mary-Beth (21) - About right ✅ Pearson (48) - Mid 40s (44-46) Grimshaw (43) - Early 50s (50-53) Uncle (61) - About right ✅ Molly (25) - About right ✅ Sadie (25) - Late 20s (27-29) Pearson is the only one who I think looks younger than he actually is, not much, but I've pinned him a few years younger. Sadie only looks a little older than than she actually is, I think it's her rough voice that makes her seem older. Swanson looks a few years older than his actual age, but I think you chalk it up to his morphine addiction. I'd say Grimshaw looks like she's in her mid-50s even, but similar to Swanson, she's lived a tough life which probably makes her look a lot rougher.

Poor lenny was practically still a kid😭

Lenny's death pisses me off even more now that I know his age

Damn Arthur, John and Abigail, Micah, Bill, Javier, Charles look much older than their ages.

John’s voice is like he has been smoking for 50 years

jack: “did you catch the bad guys” *words of wisdom*

Uncle and Hosea are the only ones who could have served in the civil war

Dutch was dating someone half his age

"I RAISED YOU AS SONS" - Dutch being 5 years older than Oarturd

I’m so handsome.

We need RDR3 with a story about Uncle in his prime and how did he get Lumbago.

The reason i liked and subscribe was because you didn't force us to like and subscribe like literally EVERY OTHER KZfaqR! This made my day! Just the touch of " if you want to" thank you so much (i loved the vid too)

Lenny was 19, and Sean was 21, this makes their deaths even sadder

Sean was 21 and got his head blasted. Lenny was only 19 when he was gunned down.

Abigail looks like a godess in the thumbnail.

Love the video, thank you.

My boi Dutch be pullin at age 41

4:30 "people call me lazy, i'm not lazy, just don't like working, there's a difference" Same uncle.

It's so weird to think about it that Jack could've lived to around 1975 maybe 1985 .The world had changed so much.

Famous quotes: “You miss 100 percent of the shots you don’t take”. “Whether you think you can or you can’t, your right”. “That which does not kill us makes us stronger”. “Did you catch the bad guys”.

Dutch was 5 years older than Arthur Dutch to Arthur : you are my son

Molly O'Shea Age: 25 *"I've seen you lock at her Dotch!"*

Is no one gonna point out how gorgeous Abigail is in thr thumbnail?

Jack is four?? I thought he was like... 6 or 7 but ooooook

Man I wish we could rewind time and get back to the day this masterpiece released and we played it for the first time😕 Wonderful memories

It’s mad crazy that Uncle lived until he was 73 and even then he was still active. Most men in 1911 would’ve died a lot sooner, but I guess it takes a lot to kill the one shot kid.

The first thing Arthur said when he made it to heaven... “Ha, found you Lenny!”

No way bill is younger than arthur i thought he was the same age as dutch

This is a great video

Sadie looks and sounds like she's in her mid-thirties at least. In fact most of them seem older than their actual ages.

Why everyone thinks they are older what they really are? Don't you understand back then living conditions were tough and people looked older (bad food, smoking, alcohol, sicknesses and so on)

I thought dutch's quote would be "I have a plan" or "we just need more money"

Everytime I listen to these songs it makes me sad because it reminds me of Lenny hosea Arthur and everyone who’s fallen and what happen to the gang 😔

4:36 wow looks like I got a new crush🥵

They all look older than they actually are. Must be the rough life they live.

You didn’t have to do us like that with the thumbnail, got damn Abigail is gorgeous and she’s a freaking game character!!!

Hello from Brazil, my lumbago has gone with uncle singing in the end of the video thx

EDIT: As I started to replay RDR2 yesterday i come to one thing, at the beggining of the game arthur says that he rides for about 20 years with the gang, and that he joined them while hew was about 13, so he must be no older than 34 or 35

When you realize Mollys 25 and Dutch is 41 lmao

I can't get enough of that first song it always hits home (:

Damn, that thumbnail though 🔥❤️

GrimShaw is 42 she looks 60

Sean died at the ripe old age of 21

I want RDR3 to continue the trend of going further back in time, and I wanna see the formation of Dutch's gang and play as the younger Hosea.

In Arthur’s tent at camp you can find a newspaper scrap of the gang’s first bank robbery. It occurred in 1887. Lenny was born in 1880. Lenny was SEVEN YEARS OLD while Arthur was robbing banks. That’s kinda crazy.

Arthur Morgan - 36 Dutch Van Der Linde - 41 Hosea Matthews - 55 John Marston - 26 Abigail Roberts/Marston - 22 Jack Marston - 4 Micah Bell - 39 Bill Williamson - 33 Javier Escuella - 26 Lenny Summers - 19 Leopold Strauss - 53 Charles Smith - 24 Reverend Swanson - 46 Sean McGuire - 21 Karen Jones - 25 Tilly Jackson - 21 Mary Beth Gaskill - 21 Simon Pearson - 48 Susan Grimshaw - 42 Uncle - 61 Molly O’Shea - 25 Sadie Adler - 25 Kieran Duffy - 21 Josiah Trewlany - ?

Lenny didn't deserve to die😭

I love the music playing over this slideshow it’s hilarious

damn lenny is so young :(

we gotta have a backstory to Arthur when he’s in his prime, like 21-26

Everyone: badass sentence Jack: did you catch the bad guys?

I'm 19 right now which was the same as Lenny when he died. That just gave me a whole new perspective on life. I can't imagine. RIP Lenny

Bruh, I miss Arthur, Lenny, Sean, Hosea, Grimshaw and the others too. I miss them all

Lenny was only 19 *NNOO* WHY SO YOUNG WHY TAKE MA BOA SO EARLY

No way is Bill Williamson 33 years old, more like 53.

The hell, did hosea fight in the civil war??

What a nice usage of music

I love how Dutch constantly calls Arthur "son" but if fact it is incredibly strange considering that their age gap is only 5 years.

All this time I thought Ms. Grimshaw was well into her 60’s.

Im not surprised that dutch is 41 years old he's my fav

from looking so much for gavin I even forgot my age

Nobody: Tilly: 😳

I loved Charles, and I loved the Native American levels. Best of both worlds when you get to do a mission with Charles

I know that this is an old post but it's just popped up and so I was curious. These ages seem mostly accurate but from various sources I've read up on over the years and especially the wiki, Dutch is placed at 44 years in 1899 (b 1855) and uncle at 50. Even though it's only three more years, it makes more sense to me that Dutch is eight years older than Arthur than five. It also makes sense that he is that bit closer to Hosea's age. Uncle does seem way older than his fifties, but then so to do Hosea and Strauss. Well, the harsh terrain of the wild west will age folk.

“Don’t under estimate an old man man who’s profession is where many young people die in” - Hosea Mathews

Damn.. Most of these folks are 10 years younger than what I thought they were.

*Arthur Morgan* Age: 36 [☆1863] *"LEEEEEENNNNNYYYYYY!"* *Dutch Van Der Linde* Age: 41 [☆1858] *"I had a god damn PLAN!!!"*

Damn most of the Characters are way younger then what I thought, I suppose it does makes sense I mean back in those days life was tough you would have grown up fast and aged fast.

The music, the quotes, and pictures, almost makes this a senior yearbook! I guess Landon Ricketts was right, it was a sort of "high school reunion"! lol

Damn Sean died so young

Man when there quotes are there Arthur Morgan’s should of been OUT OF THE DAMN WAY

If true, nice content!

Uncle was the only gang member to be old enough to have fought in the Civil War