Bumble and the sexual revolution

  Рет қаралды 160,282

Alice Cappelle

Alice Cappelle

14 күн бұрын



Go to www.squarespace.com/alicecapp... to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain and use the code ALICECAPPELLE !
✨You can support the channel on Patreon and you'll get to join our discord chat and livestreams + you will have access to bonus videos
/ alicecappelle
SOURCES/RESSOURCES 📚
Sources can be found throughout the video but here are some books that inspired this essay
Alice Echols, Daring to be bad, 1989 (on radical feminism and the TERF movement)
Michel Foucault, The History of Sexuality, 1976
SOCIALS 👩‍💻
Storygraph: @alicecappelle
Instagram: @alicecappelle_
Twitter: @cappelle_alice
Enquiries: alice.cappelleyt@gmail.com
Video edited by Elfo Editing

Пікірлер: 1 400
@kawaiimombear
@kawaiimombear 12 күн бұрын
Choosing NOT to have sex with just anybody is also sexual empowerment.
@bigbenguitarslinger494
@bigbenguitarslinger494 12 күн бұрын
In a way, the celibate is a person who is the most sexually empowered because they don't have to
@extracrispy9229
@extracrispy9229 12 күн бұрын
CHOOSING is empowerment. Feeling like you need to do either in order to match with some social norm or some cultural value is not empowering. No matter what you choose as long as you chose it and feel like you did so under your own free will and are happy with your choice you won.
@andiralosh2173
@andiralosh2173 12 күн бұрын
Also makes someone a terrible consumer 😂 Think of the economy!
@Kareragirl
@Kareragirl 12 күн бұрын
​@@bigbenguitarslinger494 Thats empowerment in the way being a sober from your addiction is - you'll never be as free as the person who wasn't bad at handling it in the first place.
@sadiemakesmesmile
@sadiemakesmesmile 12 күн бұрын
@@Kareragirl if you never had an addiction in the first place then its not hard to choose celibacy and feel empowered
@cheaxel
@cheaxel 12 күн бұрын
I, as a man, see the retreat of women from the apps as a very good development. I really don't understand why one of the main aspects of a human lifes should be managed by a programm and their algorithms made for profit of a company. We need more third spaces, where people can meet naturally and form romantic relationships again and don't let profit oriented companies have the power and control of those spaces.
@Nyingmaba
@Nyingmaba 12 күн бұрын
To be fair, there are benefits, from the woman's side. Consent is clear. All dating apps provide a space where it is clear what both parties are interested in, as opposed to real life where, even if its not a creep or creepily done, women often don't want to be approached if they are in the process of doing something else in public
@danimariafe
@danimariafe 12 күн бұрын
@@Nyingmaba that should not be the solution, men need to learn how to navigate consent in real life...
@ryn2844
@ryn2844 12 күн бұрын
Hi! Spotted an urbanism nerd :) I recommend Radical Planner's video essay on 'Third place versus Right to the City'. I just watched it and found out there's not much to the 'third place' theory other than an old book by a disgruntled conservative who didn't think women should have third places, because according to him third places were specifically meant for men to collectively escape their wives and objectify women in peace. After watching the video essay, gotta say, to me the concept of 'third place' is dead in the water. 'Right to the City' is much better. I'm not against people meeting organically obviously, or against hangout spots where you don't have to pay to exist, but the concept of 'third place' isn't very well thought out.
@DemosthenesKar
@DemosthenesKar 12 күн бұрын
​@@danimariafe The only way of getting experience is to try but that means that during the trial and error journey you impact a lot of women with your errors. I think a lot of men can do some basic vibe checks but there are a lot that don't have the fundamental experience to do them.
@cheaxel
@cheaxel 12 күн бұрын
@@ryn2844 Interesting perspective, thank you! I was not really speaking about third spaces in an urbanistic manner, but how society and groups of people are structured and ordered. Think more of a spaces people meet in a manner of interests and organizatory manner, like sportclubs, volounteering groups, neighborhood meeting points etc.
@Praisethesunson
@Praisethesunson 12 күн бұрын
It is wild how every single dating site actively commodifies the women they depend on.
@ryerye9019
@ryerye9019 12 күн бұрын
We did it to each other. The technology revealed unpleasant aspects of humanity that quickly arose in frontier spaces: commodification, instantaneous gratification, narcism, prejudice, deception, exploitation, compulsive addiction, etc.
@TheWaross
@TheWaross 12 күн бұрын
I mean, it commodifies both, but it makes the men pay most of it. If that's not commodification of men, idk what is
@victorhugoeh974
@victorhugoeh974 12 күн бұрын
That's capitalism on the move!
@TheWaross
@TheWaross 12 күн бұрын
@roxyortiz8819 look, I understand it might be difficult for you to empathize with others and as such you have difficulties understanding perspective outside your own (so, men in this instance). It's OK, not everyone is great at that. But on dating apps, no one is forced to match with others. Everyone who uses dating apps commodifies themselves, both men and women equally. But due to the disparity in gender ratio, dating apps make men pay the most of the cost associated. But paying doesn't land them a match. They still have to commodify themselves and "sell" themselves to women as much as others. They just have the opportunity to "jump the line". No one has a gun to the head of women forcing her to swipe on the guy that pays. Unless you're telling me you have no agency?
@chrizzlybear5565
@chrizzlybear5565 12 күн бұрын
​@@TheWarossI think you nearly stumbled upon Roxy's point, but barely missed it: As you said, men are mostly the ones paying. They're paying for a commodity, namely women. Therefore, the dating platform commodify women by using them as a product to sell to men. Somewhat independently from that, we're commodifying ourselves, both men and women, by making a dating profile, which is basically an advertisement for us.
@Benjamin_Bratten
@Benjamin_Bratten 12 күн бұрын
Met my girlfriend on tinder two years ago and it feels like we caught the last chopper out of Nam.
@mjr_schneider
@mjr_schneider 12 күн бұрын
I salute your good fortune from the trenches
@kafelematavou
@kafelematavou 12 күн бұрын
guess im no fortunate son
@Bojoschannel
@Bojoschannel 12 күн бұрын
A friend of mine found his current girlfriend 7 months ago on Bumble, surely more luck than anything
@cdw2468
@cdw2468 12 күн бұрын
truly feels like winning the lottery to actually have a meaningful connection with a dating app
@awsambdaman
@awsambdaman 12 күн бұрын
Same, met my wife on bumble. Respect to everyone still in the trenches
@foofieviolet
@foofieviolet 11 күн бұрын
I see a lot of westerners oversimplifying the 4B movement in SKorea. It is not as widespread as Westerners seem to think it is. The reasons for gender inequality and the shrinking population in SKorea are way more complex and rooted in Confucianistic family values and gender roles, recquired military service of all men between ages 18-28, the cut throat SKorean education system that is causing kids to commit s*icide at alarming rates, the cost of education, the housing crisis in Seoul (where half the entire population of the country lives, there just aren't as many professional jobs in other cities), economic marriage cultural recquirements which young people cannot meet even if they want to get married, and the fact the apartment renting system works differently there. In the West if you're renting an apartment you pay month to month and a deposit. In SKorea you pay an unfront sum which is usually a few millions won and that takes years of savings. Then there's the fact that the work culture in East Asia overall is insane. People regularly work 12-16 hours, usually without overtime pay. So parents can't even be at home with their kids. The 4b movement isn't really that popular in SKorea. But the government decided to blame the shrinking population on "crazy extremist feminists" instead of addressing things like the economic and housing and educational issues. And then Western news agencies didn't do their due research and just quoted the SKorean government, and now everyone thinks SKorean women are all femenists refusing to have sex. And that just is NOT the case at all.
@foofieviolet
@foofieviolet 11 күн бұрын
Oh and also it's still legal and very common for companies to fire women when they get pregnant. But families can't afford to live in one income. So then even if they want children, they just cannot afford to. SKorea is also a collectivist culture. Like in the West, shaving your head to become an outward expression of your political beliefs will make you stand out, but you can still work and live. In SKorea they are not accepting of things like that, you could lose your job. You won't get hired. Job applicants recquire head shots. This is why a common graduation present from parents to their kids is plastic surgery, to increase their hireability. Westerners just don't even understand the 4B movement because they do not understand SKorea or East Asian culture, and they don't understand the social forces at work there
@Staenhus
@Staenhus 11 күн бұрын
I might have to watch the video again, but I don't think that its widespread nature is what she was referring to, more the radicality of its rejection of social norms and what that says about the norms themselves. Also, every discussion of specific topics is going to be a bit generalising, she's doing it with Western culture as well. It's difficult to reflect every aspect from every possible angle, you would need to write a book for that. With that said, I agree that the West generally over-romanticise SK, prob for geopolitical reasons. What you're writing about should probably be talked about more and I do feel for your plight. Hopefully the movement grows and there can be a structural manifestation of the frustration you're expressing, so that people can get a better life. That's what all of us want.
@KateeAngel
@KateeAngel 10 күн бұрын
4B may not be that widespread, but it should be more widespread. Worldwide. We women gain very little and lose a lot from engaging with men romantically. And romantic love as a concept is over-rated and often used to convince women to act against our own interests and sacrifice "for love" while men don't get pressured like that.
@badwolf3618
@badwolf3618 10 күн бұрын
​@@KateeAngelI always find statements line your's interesting because it seems to communicate the idea that women are unique in feeling this way. Because I see men saying they feel the exact same way about women. I don't really know how to make heads or tails of it. I am a man, but I have zero loyalty to men as a whole, or women as a whole, and thus my desire ultimately is for reconciliation between the sexes, but when both sexes are claiming that the other is worse, and that they see no benefit in pursuing romantic relationships with the opposite sex, I can't tell which one is right or wrong, or if they are both right in some way. It's very confusing and discouraging.
@CocoaHerBeansness
@CocoaHerBeansness 9 күн бұрын
@@badwolf3618 so there's this thing called the patriarchy. it uses systemic misogyny. this leads to scenarios where men worry about getting their heartbroken on dates and women are worried they'll get raped and murdered. hope this helps.
@misterwachulochulo5262
@misterwachulochulo5262 12 күн бұрын
the soul of everything is destroyed when capitalism touches it, nothing can exist but the quest for money
@jamesl1806
@jamesl1806 12 күн бұрын
Solzhenitsyn: 'Hold by beer'
@DiegoRockLoiro
@DiegoRockLoiro 12 күн бұрын
cap
@Bojoschannel
@Bojoschannel 12 күн бұрын
The internet before 2015 is the perfect proof of this, such an endless stream of creativity and possibility destroyed by a few greedy corporations
@butterkaffee910
@butterkaffee910 11 күн бұрын
It definitely destroyed patriarchy
@Zectifin
@Zectifin 11 күн бұрын
ok cupid was a nice website and I met some nice people on there in the 2000s. I tried the app version when I was single in 2019 and it was much worse. Much better than every other dating app I tried, but still worse. I was thinking, it would be nice if there was a dating app/website that was for the socially awkward, the anxious, the neurodivergent. No overflowing with the adventurous party people looking to hook up. That wouldn't be a good plan businesswise though. You want as many people to join as possible to maximize profits. Capitalism ruins everything. even the internet.
@DKH712
@DKH712 12 күн бұрын
I hope we get a return to internet dating where you're matched with people based on your profile. Like, you fill in a bunch of questions, and then here's 10 or so people who are kinda similar to you. That would be great. The current approach of presenting endless choice - of which 99,9% isn't compatible with you anyway - inevitably leads to dating fatigue. I want a dating app to make dating simpler, not more complicated. I guess that's harder to make money from
@joechip1232
@joechip1232 12 күн бұрын
Yep, they discovered that incorporating the insights of gambling and gacha apps was more profitable than helping people find LTR's. People generally delete their dating apps when they find a partner.
@noot-noot-pingu-noot-noot
@noot-noot-pingu-noot-noot 12 күн бұрын
we should make matchmakers a career again, why have an algorithm do a job that clearly should be done by a person???
@idekblah
@idekblah 12 күн бұрын
Matchmakers do exist still actually! But they are extremely expensive. As in thousands of dollars for services. I wish I was kidding.
@logan3920
@logan3920 12 күн бұрын
Yeah, old okcupid was like that. I miss it 😢
@Alltagundso
@Alltagundso 12 күн бұрын
You mean like OkCupid?
@annaphallactic
@annaphallactic 10 күн бұрын
When I hear the term body count outside of the context of true crime, I feel a crushing sense of despair.
@graeschnahmoffski5716
@graeschnahmoffski5716 8 күн бұрын
But a somewhat funny crushing sense of despair!
@edumazieri
@edumazieri 6 күн бұрын
Was a bit shocked by that one too :D
@graeschnahmoffski5716
@graeschnahmoffski5716 6 күн бұрын
Sorry, just realized, do you mean you're more confortable with bodies being dead than bodies getting hooked up?
@edumazieri
@edumazieri 6 күн бұрын
@@graeschnahmoffski5716 Ok that was even more shocking
@gnomesarerealgnometruther6688
@gnomesarerealgnometruther6688 2 күн бұрын
Yeah I would be too if I looked like that
@PickleJello
@PickleJello 11 күн бұрын
I'm not sure how Bumble came to the conclusion the hated part of Bumble was women sending the message first, not the 24 hour window to send the first message making users feel pressured.
@My1es
@My1es 10 күн бұрын
The 24 hour thing feels like it's to ensure daily use as well. FOMO. I never know when a user doesn't initiate contact because they're not interested or they're not on their bumble ever day - both green flags
@Bleilock1
@Bleilock1 10 күн бұрын
​@@My1esthats some low self esteem
@My1es
@My1es 10 күн бұрын
@@Bleilock1 😸
@Bleilock1
@Bleilock1 10 күн бұрын
@@My1es i think the limit as a concept is fine If one side has no power over action in conversation but has to wait the other side to initiate, a limit is nice tool for knowing the other side isnt really interested, made a mistake or isnt available anymore 2 weeks for that seem to me about right, but 24h is just ridiculous, its literally fomo extortion
@kalliaslands9938
@kalliaslands9938 10 күн бұрын
The 24 hours is annoying but a good idea. Otherwise people are less motivated about each match. Men are more likely to send lazy/sexist first comments and women are more likely to ghost most of the matches they make. FOMO also plays a big part in getting people to overcome the awkwardness and discomfort of in person dating
@silvermica
@silvermica 12 күн бұрын
I tried Bumble once - but there were no humans to talk to on that app - so I deleted the app and joined a band to play in. Now I see and talk to people all the time.
@misskwannie
@misskwannie 11 күн бұрын
Is this your first time on earth
@silvermica
@silvermica 11 күн бұрын
@@misskwannie please tell no one
@Zectifin
@Zectifin 11 күн бұрын
I was single for a bit and I tried bumble, tindr, okcupid, and bbwdate ( think thats what it was called. I like plus size women.) Nobody ever messaged me on bumble, bbwdate sucked because you barely had any swipes in free mode so you could barely see anyone, tindr was all bots and barely had anyone to talk to. Okcupid was pretty nice and I talked to several nice people on there. Ultimately my ex and I got back together and I deleted them all. If we were to ever not work out I would dread dating again. If I had to I might try okcupid again, but its original website form where you filled out questionaires was the better form and I wish it would go back to that. The advice of "just go out and meet people!" is something I hate. I don't like that. I met my current partner through my roommate, he was friends with her and I ended up talking to her through AIM and we had similar interests and were both homebodies. Dating apps used to be good for the awkward stay at home types, but now everyone uses them. I wish there was a dating site for the anxiety ridden, autistic, and introverts to meet on that wasn't filled with the adventerous types looking to go party and whatnot, but that wouldn't be profitable.
@uschurch
@uschurch 11 күн бұрын
@@misskwannie is this your first attempt at a pun?
@godwinyo5206
@godwinyo5206 8 күн бұрын
how do you find a band to play in?
@jonathanmelhuish4530
@jonathanmelhuish4530 12 күн бұрын
20:29 Damn I wish KZfaq would let us say the words that grown-ups use
@Alltagundso
@Alltagundso 12 күн бұрын
The worst thing is that even in real life people now say "cuddling" when they mean sex. 🤦🏽‍♀️
@kelethrailkill
@kelethrailkill 12 күн бұрын
Amen. I watch a lot of KZfaq, and the extreme censorship this platform pushes through it's demonetization policies has made me actively start to seek alternatives. Nothing good can come from a society where the word "s-x" is banned. While it would be bad enough by itself, it's not just the "bad words" list that's the output of these policies either. But much worse, is the massive chilling effect it has on the very topics content creators are even willing to risk taking on. KZfaq has disproportionate impact on how and what society offline thinks it can or can't discuss. I guarantee there has been an noticeable shift in the Overton window of certain important topics due to how difficult it would be to get paid for working on those topics on KZfaq. The idea that we can not choose to enjoy art or ideas without listening to the "radio edit" version is maddening. And the idea that living in a self-imposed "radio edit" society is correct or right, is cancer to a capitalist democracy.
@sadiemakesmesmile
@sadiemakesmesmile 12 күн бұрын
@@kelethrailkill I was just watching and reading comments on a Eugenia Cooney info channel... and apparently Y Toobe (and all platforms) allow her to be online in all her sick glory, but she CANNOT say she has an Eating Disorder (even if she wanted to). So we are allowed to see all the aspects of this disturbing disorder, but not allowed to say or know it is A DISORDER and how to prevent it. Poor kids... thats all i can say. It is setting them up. HUGELY.
@pavelandreev4727
@pavelandreev4727 8 күн бұрын
@@kelethrailkill It is again the capitalism that's at fault. the creators cannot afford to use certain words because they cannot afford to lose the revenue and go starving or " go do something else that's useful". So they have a choice - comply to the algorithms or resign to a tiny audience that will never expand and will never be enough to provide a sustainable living...
@slvrcobra1337
@slvrcobra1337 6 күн бұрын
I died laughing at that part because outta nowhere she was all like "sksksksksksk"
@mahogara
@mahogara 12 күн бұрын
Personally, the thought process behind the ads is the very reason that discourages me from using the dating apps. That very ideal of using the dating apps as a hookup site. Even if you specifically specified that you're not looking for hookups (because you find it repulsive to get it on with someone you barely even know or feel something toward), you would still somehow end up with people who expect you to put out on the very first meet up/date. If not, you're somehow guilted into feeling bad for leading them on. Even though it's not the dating site's fault, it's baffling to see Bumble showcasing the same mindset as some men who view women on dating sites as a catalogue listing of desperate and easy products, looking to get laid.
@vaska00762
@vaska00762 12 күн бұрын
The problem with dating apps (in general) is that they've come to monopolise the way people go about dating and finding people to have relationships with. Many bars/pubs/clubs are either too loud for certain people, not accessible, too far away, or the fact that they're places to drink alcohol discourage a lot of people who don't want to, or cannot drink. Where else do people find relationships? At the workplace? At places of religious gathering?
@awsambdaman
@awsambdaman 12 күн бұрын
vaska00762 Workplace is taboo and people don’t go to church anymore. If I was single I’d try to meet someone at church and I wish we would meet people at work but there’s so many rules and stuff and a lot of people take their drama to work. If everyone was mature it could work
@yveje9720
@yveje9720 11 күн бұрын
I have no skin in the game since I’m not single. But I personally don’t read the line about celibacy to be an endorsement of casual hook ups. In my mind, a vow celibacy is not having sex and not dating romantically / not getting married. I don’t equate having sex with hooking up because a lot of people have sex in a relationship. And this probably speaks to the wider issue of perception because most people falsely believe that sex is predominantly happening casually when the exact opposite is true, most sex is happening in long-term relationships in marriages. The rise in sexlessness for young Americans is due to the fact that more of them are single. Hooking up was never the main way people were having sex even at the height of the sexual revolution. Maybe it’s the movies maybe it’s TV that has us all confused about this.
@Bleilock1
@Bleilock1 10 күн бұрын
​@@yveje9720 i mean then again there is the worlds oldest proffession for casual hookups...
@letzte_maahsname
@letzte_maahsname 10 күн бұрын
​@@yveje9720 It's definitely the age old mindset of "haha, now that you're married, you're not gonna have sex anymore because sex is solely for procreation and our marriage was arranged anyway soooo...". Some myths die hard.
@CaraMarie13
@CaraMarie13 11 күн бұрын
I typically spend a while between relationships. I was single for nearly five years after my previous relationship, and I remember how great I felt even though I had no sex during that time. No shade on my current relationship because it's great the majority of the time. But I really learned to love being alone during those periods, and I truly believe it's why my current relationship is going so well years in. The only thing I hated was the comments from some friends constantly congratulating me for being brave. As if I was doing a cross-country trip on my own. But people really struggle with understanding that I don't just "have a good time" with just anyone. Casual sex has never done it for me and even though it's gotten me labeled as a prude, am more than ok with that. I will say, i tried bumble after my last relationship because everyone was pressuring me to "not be alone". I left after a week because I felt incredibly shallow looking at pictures of man and a little information on their interest and saying to myself, "let me guve this one a try". I could not move past the discomfort of judging a mans potential on that alone so i never developed a curiosity for anyone that would push me to asking to meet in person.
@afruitlesshippo
@afruitlesshippo 11 күн бұрын
There's the one healthy and well adjusted person on the internet. I hope you have a nice day :)
@AlexandarShmex
@AlexandarShmex 38 минут бұрын
God bless you sister, I was happy to read a mature outlook. I hope your boyfriend and you have a very long, happy relationship.
@selena1731
@selena1731 10 күн бұрын
As my mother as always said "mejor sóla que mal acompañada" better to be alone than with bad company
@vaska00762
@vaska00762 12 күн бұрын
Aren't Dating Apps the thing people turn to because of loneliness? Making new friendships as an adult is something that feels next to impossible at times, and it's not because we necessarily lack the spaces - it's our lifestyles. I could meet people at work, but they have their own lives to get back to and chores to do when they get home, not forgetting anyone who has children they prioritise. People seek out relationships because that's the way many people have found as a way to cope with the loneliness, but at the same time, the lack of platonic friendships, and its deprioritisation in adulthood doesn't help either. Especially if you move to a big city, or move to a different country, you have no social safety net there - you have to start your social life from scratch. I know Bumble introduced their subsection for finding friendships, but does it really work? What even are the alternatives?
@Jazzmaster1992
@Jazzmaster1992 12 күн бұрын
It seems for many people, their relationship becomes their entire life. They spend most of their time working, or with their SO. The older you get, the more common this becomes as people settle down, buy houses and start families with their spouse. The advice singles get to expand their social circle almost feels like a slap in the face, when you realize most people who are in relationships basically disappear off the face of the earth for everyone but their partner and their job. I'm not saying it should be that way, but socializing is just so difficult right now and I don't blame people for "cashing out" on a relationship the moment they find one.
@AtheistEve
@AtheistEve 12 күн бұрын
I would join local groups of people doing voluntary or creative work in the community. Just to find like-minded people. And go from there.
@Dave102693
@Dave102693 11 күн бұрын
@@Jazzmaster1992or they find a church or mosque to go to to fill that void
@CatarinaStone
@CatarinaStone 11 күн бұрын
I'm single but mostly not looking to date right now and so I've thought about using the apps to find friends. Bumble friends locks you in to find friends of the same gender. I'm a bi trans woman, this makes so little sense to me I'm actually kind of scared of what kind of people I'd find there
@peznino1
@peznino1 11 күн бұрын
​@@CatarinaStonemost lesbian women are furious about your type on their lesbian dating apps from what i hear...they really get annoyed and frustrated apparently...what do u say to them?
@LiquidDemocracyNH
@LiquidDemocracyNH 8 күн бұрын
Second of all: I can't think of anything more ridiculous than saying "first *they* say don't be a slut. Then *they* say where did you all go?, don't stop using our dating app." *They* are two different groups of people. The group of people slut-shaming, and the group of people who started an app oriented around female-empowerment (debateably) are very different people. If they're contradicting each other it's because they're not the same group of people. When you should actually be concerned is when ONE well-defined group starts saying contradictory things
@kellycowley3535
@kellycowley3535 3 күн бұрын
@LiquidDemocracyNH No many men (not just men but usually men) do both of these things and don't realize the hypocrisy in doing so. They call women sl*ts if they 'sleep around' and claim their 'body count' should be low but then call them 'crazy cat lady' and 'entitled b*tches' if they dare to not be interested in dating. These are the types of men she is talking about when she says *they* .
@czarkusa2018
@czarkusa2018 11 күн бұрын
"Why pressure women into doing something they don't want to do?" That was the whole point of Bumble, to force them to write anything at all, usually "Hey", at an introduction. They always could and never wanted to.
@screew708
@screew708 11 күн бұрын
They never had to because they could always rely on men taking the first step. Pretty sure the majority of men would also prefer not being the one to take the first time either but they don't really have a choice if they are seeking a female partner.
@yeehawneehaw5215
@yeehawneehaw5215 10 күн бұрын
It always rubbed me the wrong way that they decided putting all the work in the woman’s hands is the move. As if that’s gonna stop men from being creepy after we shoot our shot or something
@brianmeen2158
@brianmeen2158 10 күн бұрын
Correct and it gave women a taste of what it’s like to have to initiate all of the conversations. Many found out just how mind numbing and frustrating it is and seem to have complained to get it changed. . There’s not a guy out there actually likes having to initiate on dating apps - we just realize that someone has to do it for the dating process to happen
@AW-uv3cb
@AW-uv3cb 10 күн бұрын
@@brianmeen2158 when I (a woman) was on bumble a few years ago, I actually appreciated that feature. Not because I don't like being approached by men , but because it was a clear rule that everyone knew. Either I initiate, or it doesn't happen at all. And because men also knew that, me initiating wasn't treated as a sign of just wanting to get laid or being desperate or whatever. It was just something that had to happen to have any interaction and there was a pleasant clarity to it. I'd feel the same if there was a rule that only men initiate. When both sides can initiate, both can wait for the other party to do it and it gets frustrating. (One of the reasons why dating apps feel so alien to the way people actually interact in the real world...)
@lonestarr1490
@lonestarr1490 10 күн бұрын
Nah, it has never been anything but a way of getting into the pockets of desperate men. Because of course you can pay for being able to text first.
@TheBoringAddress
@TheBoringAddress 11 күн бұрын
As someone who -after several years dealing with crippling anxiety- finally feels like putting himself out there again on the dating scene... it feels like that scene in Community when Troy returns with the pizzas. I loved Bumble's main feature, more so as someone who is probably on the spectrum and is substantially better at repartee in written form... perhaps that was their biggest blind spot, their tragic hubris: They thought they were revolutionizing dating and empowering women with their white feminist crap, when they should've just sold themselves as a dating app for anxious people.
@TheBoringAddress
@TheBoringAddress 11 күн бұрын
I have no idea why that sentence ended up with a strikethrough but it works.
@czarkusa2018
@czarkusa2018 11 күн бұрын
1:06 "Why pressure women into doing something they don't want to do?" That was the whole point of Bumble, to force them to write anything at all, usually "Hey", at an introduction. They always could and never wanted to.
@yoyochan6668
@yoyochan6668 11 күн бұрын
I love how she takes a simple topic like bumble then uses it as a base and goes deep in on the theory,
@peznino1
@peznino1 11 күн бұрын
But can you follow her arguments. I feel like one would need a degree in sociology and or feminist studies or other to follow this video. It's way over my head as a pleb.
@nuklearboysymbiote
@nuklearboysymbiote 11 күн бұрын
​@@peznino1 there's some level of assumed background knowledge to be sure, but I believe in you! It's ok if you don't get it the first time around
@ChasmChaos
@ChasmChaos 11 күн бұрын
@@peznino1 I'm glad I wasn't the only one 😅. TBH, she provided a lot of resources. Of course I don't have the time or brains to read all that and of course I can't judge 1 way or another if she was reaching or was legit based on my current knowledge. It's still a start having gone from knowing nothing to knowing something (which may or may not be legit). I think this is how it is in every field of study. A layman has no way of knowing whether vaccines are totally safe or whether government surveillance is completely thwarted if you take some precautions. You have to trust some specialists at some level in order to actually be able to function.
@honeybun3492
@honeybun3492 10 күн бұрын
@@peznino1I disagree 😅 but I also spent a lot of my formative years on tumblr in the radical feminist area…
@chrystals.4376
@chrystals.4376 8 күн бұрын
The problem though it's just not that deep. It was a terrible & cringe ad campaign that insulted its target audience, and got the backlash it deserved. Cappelle decided to blame people who are anti sex instead of reading the room.
@AODProds
@AODProds 11 күн бұрын
As a man I have always noticed this trend of women not really wanting to instigate relationships, yet older/conservative generations have always just advocated for the status quo of "Ohh just go talk to her" without much more thought to it. I have always wondered, in the absence of men instigating relationships, how demisexual and even ace most women lean towards. I think it's more than most men want to realize. I recognize I'm just a man so perhaps my opinion/perspective is not exactly warranted here, but I have definitely observed this, especially in stem fields. Theoretically, if the internalized gender norms of our societal consciousness were wiped overnight, how likely would women want to pursue men in an environment where the negative and internalized social stigmas of women pursuing men are absent? The thought that most women may very well just want to live their lives independently pursuing their own interests and getting what little kicks they want off of a magic wand is terrifying to men. I think a lot of women have come to the conclusion that men at large are very immobile in their thinking about these topics and it is an inevitability in their experience that men will subconsciously put gendered expectations on them in a relationship no matter how feminist-leaning men claim to be. For this reason, women seem to be much more comfortable with a life of celibacy and view it as a relief from all the unhealthy men/relationships holding them back, whereas men are terrified of the idea of it and have been socially conditioned to think that it is the ultimate sign of true failure in life as a man. For this reason, I've seen most men approach this topic with an alarmist fillintheblank-pill attitude taking it personally and interweaving the age-old shaming notions of "you're going to be a crazy old cat lady" and "eventually you'll need a man" when in reality these spiteful jabs come from a place of absolute terror and wanting to re-establish control over women finding their independence/power. As a man, you have two options. You can either fight it, continue to try to instigate relationships, and cling to traditional/conservative notions of gendered expectations rooted in sexual conquest equaling success in life. Or you can surrender to the void and become at peace with the single life, disassociate sexual conquest from your meaning in life, and let women choose how they want to live and be undisturbed in the pursuit of their own goals in life. No pills, no shaming, no underlying nefarious dogmatic prescriptions of ideology, just simply letting them choose how they want to live their lives.
@advsreeharivs
@advsreeharivs 10 күн бұрын
The same counter culture of celibacy exists for men also.
@brianmeen2158
@brianmeen2158 10 күн бұрын
It would be equally as interesting to go Ask 1,000 men if they would still pursue women for dating and relationships if they had no sex drive .. I bet many of the guys(if they truly gave it some thought) would admit that they most likely would not still pursue women(for serious relationships) if the sex was not in the equation.
@nunyabaznus7851
@nunyabaznus7851 10 күн бұрын
@@brianmeen2158 not really true. for one thing, reproduction. We do not have artificial womb technology at the moment, so yes a relationship is required for any man that wants a family and children at some point. It goes deeper though. companionship and intimacy, the need for human touch which releases cortisol which releaves stress and anxiety in men, and just feeling wanted and needed by another person, these essential needs are not going away
@tricatame7427
@tricatame7427 10 күн бұрын
Best comment here barely getting noticed. Exactly sir, everyone underestimates how uninterested women actually are. There is a like a small window of interest for women typically in their twenties when their biology may fool them into making a baby and thus needing male input and becayse they are more gullible inexperienced and do want progeny and family and to be loved and supported while childbirth absolutely makes tgem more vulnerable and needy. But soon as that phase is over, women do realize that was just a phase. We emotionally discard the men tge way they physically discard after the deed. Sadly, as men get older they need women more while women need them less. Thats what all the panic induced insult hurlings from men are. The panic over tge absence of much needed nursing and other misc social services they cant get from otger men.
@rozap_8356
@rozap_8356 10 күн бұрын
Isn't this why there is pressure on men to provide? I think you make a lot of good points, but omit the part about attraction to provisions. If (as a man or a woman or neither) you possess some skill, resource, or interest that someone wants from you, they pursue it. I think that's why a lot of women go after men initially. And I don't think it's necessarily a shallow thing, everybody seeks security to a certain extent. It's a little unfortunate that the way out of the problem you describe is so traditionally gendered (man as a provider) but historically it has worked. Obviously it can create a problem long term as you're tied to your partner and less independent but that's the reality of living with other humans. I definitely wouldn't have the great life I have without my wife, and she wouldn't have it without me, so dependency is not necessarily a dirty word if it's consenting and non abusive. I think the answer here is that there is no answer for everyone. I think the "woman hating gamer" men and the "men are obsolete" radfems drive a lot of discourse but they are not actually serious people.
@AlexanderSkinnerVids
@AlexanderSkinnerVids 12 күн бұрын
Congrats to the Bumble marketing team, they managed to be creepier than they guys on the app. (Bad joke, but still)
@Bishop3k
@Bishop3k 12 күн бұрын
Creepy guys? Ohhh, you mean the majority, who is invisible. Gotcha.
@AlexanderSkinnerVids
@AlexanderSkinnerVids 12 күн бұрын
@@Bishop3kshh, I’m just weaponizing their language against them. The women who started bumble would totally overuse the word “creep” to the point where it means absolutely nothing.
@Pratt11
@Pratt11 12 күн бұрын
Bumble creepier than my uncles and ex-home boys 🗣️🔥
@GenericUrbanism
@GenericUrbanism 12 күн бұрын
What an accomplishment. /s
@anniee5487
@anniee5487 12 күн бұрын
real
@jibarabicha4853
@jibarabicha4853 12 күн бұрын
Back to the drawing board. Humans are still human and need face to face interactions. We are not robots, so an app really takes all of those elements needed for attraction and reduces people to a pixel.
@damianalejandro6959
@damianalejandro6959 11 күн бұрын
Sure then explain to me how I met people in dating apps
@JimJamTheAdmin
@JimJamTheAdmin 11 күн бұрын
​@@damianalejandro6959what part of this comment said that you never met anyone through dating apps?
@ChasmChaos
@ChasmChaos 11 күн бұрын
@@damianalejandro6959 🤦
@lonestarr1490
@lonestarr1490 10 күн бұрын
We shouldn't stop at dating apps. Tear down social media with it, for it's the same thing.
@GilboPaints
@GilboPaints 11 күн бұрын
I genuinely appreciate how you’ve framed this as individualistic vs systemic. It really helps frame a lot of what I try to say but haven’t been able to do so correctly.
@My_defeat_is_assured
@My_defeat_is_assured 12 күн бұрын
The dating app fatigue/failure is a referendum on the fatal flaw of the techoptimism so characteristic of the aughts more broadly. That is, that through apps things like social isolation could be fixed or that apps should be incorporated into all social relationships. Since no one likes dating apps, the question becomes do we even need this thing.
@damianalejandro6959
@damianalejandro6959 11 күн бұрын
Yes. Except winners like you Casanova
@AndyAlegria
@AndyAlegria 5 күн бұрын
I think dating apps have a market, even if they are not used for dating at all, as entertainment.
@Isinlor
@Isinlor 2 күн бұрын
I loved OkCupid back in 2015. I could look for nerdy women that are pretty much impossible to find in real life. That's how I found my girlfriend and we are 9 years together.
@michaelsmith953
@michaelsmith953 12 күн бұрын
Lmao so glad ive never seen those bumble ads...whoever made them must be a boomer
@Praisethesunson
@Praisethesunson 12 күн бұрын
Saw one of the billboards off the I-95 in Philadelphia
@rhobot75
@rhobot75 12 күн бұрын
Especially the nun one given the average age of nuns in the US is pushing 50.
@ville__
@ville__ 11 күн бұрын
‬‭‮SLAMINA‎‎ GNISUBA‎ DNA GNIPAR‎ EVOL‎ I ‬‭‮RETTEB‎ YAW‎ SI‎ TNETNOC‎ YM‎ ESUACEB _
@zarathustra4649
@zarathustra4649 5 күн бұрын
The whole team is a bunch of millennials and gen zs lol and add to that most of them are women.
@danielsykes7558
@danielsykes7558 10 күн бұрын
1:50 as a gay man brought up in an insular sect, I can see that bumble was trying to do something important having women be the first to reach out, But this correction barely skims the surface of the social conditioning women have been trained into. They still expect a man who takes the lead, plans and pays for dates, & who "chases". But while any partner who makes more money than the other should take up the paying role when necessary, it's important that men not take up this "chaser" role, and women need to understand how awkward (& consequently creepy) the early stages of asking people out goes. Some men never learn. I've been stalked by women and assaulted by men, but even I think that women and men need to meet each other in the middle, walk in each other's shoes, and switch roles often enough to get an understanding of what are healthy expectations and non-toxic behaviors.
@felipealegriagaete4111
@felipealegriagaete4111 8 күн бұрын
I agree with yout
@aussiecomrade8163
@aussiecomrade8163 11 күн бұрын
"Moralising tendencies in social movements. Is it productive?" I'm taking this as another reminder to touch grass, stop fixating on gate-keepy leftist in-fighting on socials, and do productive organising instead. Thanks comrade. Another dope video, as always.
@MrKoalaburger
@MrKoalaburger 11 күн бұрын
The only place I see so much leftist infighting is online. Never seen it irl.
@Paolo_Naour
@Paolo_Naour 12 күн бұрын
My english teacher recommened you to my class, and I really find myself enjoying your videos, you are a very well spoken person
@antraks794
@antraks794 12 күн бұрын
That is a hell of a good teacher! As one myself, it is encouraging to see students actually listening to some of the things we say. Thank you for this :)
@rararazzamatazz
@rararazzamatazz 6 күн бұрын
While her content is good and I am not commenting on that, it is a sad state of affairs that the linguistic studies have been completely co-opted by feminist theory and marxism... What use does an English language teacher have talking about feminist theory or any social or economic theory for that matter??? It is simply them taking themselves far far too seriously. Teach writing narrative, syntax and grammar and leave the rest.
@Megaghost_
@Megaghost_ 11 күн бұрын
The reaction towards relationships lacks an anticapitalist perspective. You don't achieve anything if you just refuse hetero relationships but reproduce the same cultural norms with people of the same gender as yours. If heterocapitalism is understood as a political regime, you can be as "gay" as you want, and for the system you are the same as any hetero couple: consume, marry, procreate (by acquiring a womb or sperm) and produce the Family, the same thing that along with Private Property and the State, Engels criticized 150 years ago. BTW, for those who speak spanish I recommend Leonor Silvestri's work. You can find her classes recorded here.
@BrazilianThinker
@BrazilianThinker 11 күн бұрын
Alice, I'm a male from Brasil and I'd like to praise you and your work. Not only you bring a lot of essential reflexions to the table of political and socioeconomic discussion, you do it in a very didactical way. I love your content and I learn so much from it! Thank you for existing and doing what you do! Hugs from South America!!!
@Vladd7
@Vladd7 4 күн бұрын
“I go on the apps to get a self esteem boost” said no man ever. This privilege is exclusive to women.
@seabreeze4559
@seabreeze4559 4 күн бұрын
ah yes the privilege of being potentially stalked weirdly, a lot of women complain men never actually wanna meet up, sometimes they are actually married secretly so yes esteem boosts are a big reason
@TheHanyuuuuu
@TheHanyuuuuu 4 күн бұрын
It's so great on dating apps for women, so many privileges that there 3-4 times less women on dating apps then men. They just don't want too much of a good thing! 🤣
@LeadHerring
@LeadHerring 2 күн бұрын
There are pros and cons to how girls use dating apps but having watched a lot of my female friends use them I'd say the cons far outweigh the pros. I do agree though for most guys that there aren't even those positives when it comes to apps though
@Shwanson4
@Shwanson4 Күн бұрын
Eh, it can be a self esteem boost… I’ve met some scary women online too.
@PutkisenSetä
@PutkisenSetä Күн бұрын
@@seabreeze4559 The men don't wanna meet up because you're being catfished, doofus.
@bogdanbuduroiu5889
@bogdanbuduroiu5889 11 күн бұрын
A point on the roots of feminism and actually dismantling partiarchy. This comment might sound misogynistic but I assure you it’s not: how can we build a truly equal society, tear down patriarchy, when cases like South Korea where emotional political movements and figures can appeal and radicalise a mass of men against feminism. I don’t see how our current political systems can become resilient to this, and it feels like women have a modicum of liberation nowadays because men allow it (by not violently opposing it). Happy to chat on this
@daaara
@daaara 11 күн бұрын
very informative video. Maybe part of sexual empowerment is liberation from feeling less than because you have too much sex or not enough sex. In that lens, incels/femcels and promiscuous people are being crushed by the same boot of societal expectation.
@KasunGamage
@KasunGamage 11 күн бұрын
Can you explain what's the point of the video..?(With respect, I don't get it)
@lexp6099
@lexp6099 8 күн бұрын
@@KasunGamage Their last sentence is the point: the system is terrible, but choosing political celibacy doesn't change it, and only provides the individual with a sense of moral superiority because they think they've beat the system, when they're not actually doing anything to change it. A lot of people seem to be missing the point that if you're not interested in sex, hookup culture or anything else like them, this video is not talking about you. If you're interested in sex but choose celibacy solely because of society''s views on it, you're still upholding purity culture. And traditional views on gender roles and sex hurt all sexes and genders.
@seabreeze4559
@seabreeze4559 4 күн бұрын
@@lexp6099 a choice for self care isn't anything about purity
@andyjblosser
@andyjblosser 10 күн бұрын
I think the backlash also reveals the hubristic bossiness of advertisers. The goal of advertisers is to become master of our souls, and they reveal this cocky mentality when they go beyond telling us what shoes to wear to commanding our dating lives.
@kkorova
@kkorova 11 күн бұрын
I absolutely love that women are taking over the power over apps which essentially commodify sexual relations. I will say though, just as a demisexual (a different point of view), why is being celibate so ground breaking? Are allosexuals really THAT horny? How is not having sex so powerful? Seriously? Do people really have a need/crave for sex? Fascinating.
@czarkusa2018
@czarkusa2018 11 күн бұрын
The people that get to have a lot of it get used to it, it's like cigarettes. They freak out when they can't get any.
@IronJhon788
@IronJhon788 11 күн бұрын
@@czarkusa2018 I agree. As all dopaminergic activities, the more you engage in them, the less pleasureable they become.
@IronJhon788
@IronJhon788 11 күн бұрын
Also, it is kind of funny that we are resorting back to becoming a little bit more puritanical and conservative on the sexual sense. Humans cant understand what middle ground means. It is all about extremes.
@honeybun3492
@honeybun3492 11 күн бұрын
Sex is so central to majority of the population (allosexuals) that it’s as important as food. I think everyone’s poly and trying to even just be with one person is so difficult for allos and why cheating and divorce (bc of cheating/boredom) is so prevalent. -another Demisexual who notices the strangeness of sexuality ALSO “everything is about sex. Except sex, sex is about power.” And what do people want more than anything? Power 😮 it’s a false sense of security in an ever-changing world and allos hold onto that with a death grip
@damianalejandro6959
@damianalejandro6959 11 күн бұрын
I sense a sentiment of moral superiority in your comment. It is ok and normal for people to be horny and want to get laid. And I say this basically being demisexual/low libido. But I don't think I am special or better
@jayzee4097
@jayzee4097 10 күн бұрын
Alice, I think hetero men are sitting there asking, "What about me", "Why can't I succeed in this world", and those frustrations are legitimate things that need to be addressed without an accusatory tone, judgement, or telling them to suck it up. Also, Korea has a huge sexual violence problem that is rarely talked about, so it's awesome to see feminism make it into pop culture there.
@seabreeze4559
@seabreeze4559 4 күн бұрын
no that's narcissism, they're adults they can figure it out without a woman, fish bicycle
@wexpmedia5889
@wexpmedia5889 Күн бұрын
@@seabreeze4559Keep that same energy for the hundreds of issues women are constantly complaining about.
@NelsonGuedes
@NelsonGuedes 12 күн бұрын
Bumble had to change their women-message-first policy because women found it too stressful and often didn't know how to initiate. Like, yeah. Men have known that for quite some time. Women are still the ones who are making the choices, men just get what we can. That's why, for example, the nightclubs want to be attractive to women so men follow. That's because everyone is still following patriarchal gender roles. Bumble tried to challenge one aspect of those gender roles - that men must initiate - and women didn't like it.
@awsambdaman
@awsambdaman 12 күн бұрын
That was my favorite thing about bumble too. I didn’t like always having to message first on Hinge and Tinder and stuff. But yeah a lot of women were really dry texters
@czarkusa2018
@czarkusa2018 11 күн бұрын
1:06 "Why pressure women into doing something they don't want to do?" That was the whole point of Bumble, to force them to write anything at all, usually "Hey", at an introduction. They always could and never wanted to. On nightclubs and bars, "ladies' night" the night when drinks are cheaper for women offers up drunken women as advertising. I've always wondered if women knew they were being presented by the bar.
@lazysnorlax3015
@lazysnorlax3015 11 күн бұрын
I rlly dislike how lazy the women were on that app. I could tell imediately which girl I'm going to have a connection just by how the responded. Guys usually had to develop game or a sense of humor but many women at least that I matched with had zero game whatsoever and I ended up losing interest.
@baklazha
@baklazha 11 күн бұрын
@@czarkusa2018of course we know, nowadays I see that most women finally understand that bars clubs etc see them solely as product that is sold to men so these places are extremely dangerous and thank god are becoming less popular among young women
@czarkusa2018
@czarkusa2018 11 күн бұрын
@@baklazha I'm relieved!
@crashb800
@crashb800 12 күн бұрын
I think we need to do more work in investigation the idea of men being sexual actors seeking out women and women being passive objects of desire and particularly how our understanding of heterosexuality and our cultural institutions seemingly refuse to interrogate this. I find, for myself as a guy, that it feels like I have to be the one initiating everything whether I want to or not because I'll never be with anyone unless I don't. I imagine there are plenty of reasons why women don't approach that aren't based in sexual attraction, but I don't really know the reasons all that well. My ideal, for now, is that anyone should be able to approach anyone, and that the person being approached should be able to say no. What I mean by this is that women could approach men or men could approach men or anything else and it's fine. I guess my biggest annoyance with guy-girl dating is the fact that guys are placed into the leader role and girls are placed into the follower role pretty much regardless of whether is suits them or not. I obviously placed this discussion within a giant binary, and I think there's something to be said about how the erotic standard is one person leads and the other follows. I'm sure there are other ways of doing relationships. Point and case, sexual liberation is not really about having more sex, but finding the ways in which sex and courting are intertwined with patriarchy and exploring other options.
@fairywingsonroses
@fairywingsonroses 11 күн бұрын
As a woman, the reason I don't approach men (even when I'm in a committed realationship with them) is because men will almost always take or expect more than is offered, and many get upset when women set boundaries on what is being offered. If you offer to hold hands, they want to put their whole arm around you. If you offer to make out, they want the full hands-on experience as well. If a woman says yes to sex once, they're expected to say yes every time. Even a casual conversation often turns into a request for more. As a woman, I feel like it's never enough. Even in committed relationships, I'm often faced with this dynamic of the man expecting more when more is not being offered, and a lot of men take the rejection personally, even when the reasons for the rejection have nothing to do with them (i.e. I had a long day, and now I just want space). While many men do respect the word, no; it doesn't change the fact that the expectation is still there; the feelings of rejection are still there, and quite frankly, it's exhausting to try to navigate. It's just easier to not approach men in the first place knowing ahead of time that you will either have to put firm boundaries in place and hold them against a constant barrage of begging, manipulating, coercion, etc, OR be prepared to give more than you want to offer. Both take an immense amount of mental and emotional energy and take away from the more permenant and nuanced parts of establishing/keeping relationships. As a woman, I feel like there is never a balance between what is expected (especially in terms of sex and intimacy) and the actual resources and experiences that each partner has to offer. I often find myself wishing that men would tone down their expectations for sex and intimacy and just appreicate the moment for what it is, even if it's just a casual conversation. It doesn't always need to be more in order to be fulfilling.
@clementwee4460
@clementwee4460 11 күн бұрын
@@fairywingsonroses Then tell women not to judge men for "prowess" then, and all these sources of stress will be gone. Men are stressed too, because women judge them on "prowess". But when women judge on "prowess", it is euphemized as "satisfaction" and "fulfillment" instead. Men just can't win ... You can't even accept people accepting no. They have to "not feel rejection" in order for you to feel "safe". But hey, you ARE rejecting them, aren't you?
@Pete_xp
@Pete_xp 11 күн бұрын
The whole thing's f*cked, unfortunately.
@agapitoliria
@agapitoliria 11 күн бұрын
Your comment is right, the first answer is right... They are kind of a cycle. If I'm expected to "lead" because the other person will take a passive, distanced role, any kind of step the woman takes will feel like a "oh so I should lead this way" which is f up for everyone involved. This is what patriarchy means really.
@lonestarr1490
@lonestarr1490 10 күн бұрын
​@@fairywingsonroses Thank you for comment. Reading it was an enlightening experience for me. For once, it points out possible roots for the conflicts I faced in my previous relationships. But I also noticed a swelling rage in my stomach reading it, fueled by a terror of rejection that, I reckon, is always there under the surface. When my mind wanders I sometimes have mixtures of daydreams and intrusive thoughts, that women just don't want anything of me and that there's nothing I can do about it; that there's nothing I can do to earn the intimacy I crave. And it must come from a place that is tremendously old and deeply ingrained in my brain, for it resembles the experience of being treated unfairly as a very small child. Like the world is going to end because you won't get what you want. I know that, on a rational level all the points you're making are valid and fair. I know that I have no right of feeling crushed by it. But I can't help it and I really have to reflect on why all of this is that way.
@s.e.studios1386
@s.e.studios1386 12 күн бұрын
I think Alice is right on point. My problem with the anti sexual revolution crowd is not that they dislike hook-up culture but they see chastity and 'saving' yourself for marriage as the opposite of hook up culture when often it has the same motivations. They hold on to their virginity to sell it (covered by a spiritual cope) and then criticise Only Fans. They say people are obsessed by the status of notch count but they are equally obsessed by notch count just in the opposite direction and still a life choice driven by status concerns.
@pouchika5672
@pouchika5672 12 күн бұрын
Or maybe some of us don't wanna have sex with random men and wish for a more intimate sex life that hook-up culture doesn't provide. Believe it or not, some people actually want to have only one partner.
@MegaRBN14
@MegaRBN14 12 күн бұрын
Some of us see sex as an intimate act that should only happen within the context of a relationship with a special person, not necessarily one partner for life or nothing until marriage (I don't consider myself conservative in any way, btw). If you fuck any random person you barely know you're devaluating your intimacy. Also, it's quite irresponsible. I am concerned by the massive amount of people who would have sex without talking about politics, abortion, religion or economics. Accidental pregnancy with an anti-abortion religious nutjob would ruin any man's life.
@inbb510
@inbb510 12 күн бұрын
I am "obsessed" by the notch count because a high number is essentially a proxy for promiscuity. And I don't want to date a promiscuous woman that has slept around with 10+ men and who has probably picked up STIs on the way. As many replies to your comment have said, it turns out people actually want a more fulfilling and deeper connection than just a one night stand.
@myca9322
@myca9322 12 күн бұрын
not all the responses to your comment proving it correct! unfortunately the kind of person who makes a preemptive decision about the 'type' of relationship they want to engage with, is unlikely to understand what it takes to deeply bond with another. pure, genuine love can come from surprising places. and its cultivation needs intentional care. by closing oneself off to possibilities, one only limits their own ability to see things as they are and develop their own capacities to care.
@CosmicErrata
@CosmicErrata 12 күн бұрын
​@@pouchika5672This.
@Alias_Anybody
@Alias_Anybody 12 күн бұрын
Political lesbianism doesn't work, because you can't manifest your sexuality. Celibacy however is a different topic.
@pollysshore2539
@pollysshore2539 11 күн бұрын
They came out of the gate demanding that hetero women leave their husbands, get rid of their sons, stop dating and sleeping with men, shaving, wearing makeup, doing their hair, wearing flattering clothes, saying this, doing that, thinking this.. and become lesbians for the feminist cause. That? Or at the very least call yourself a political lesbian and remain celibate in solidarity. No, it did not go over well at all. The fact that they had joined in a legislative alliance with Christian Nationalist politicians, and reduced the large amount of work done during the sexual revolution to a joke also did not go over well. Removing Christian Nationalists legislation, that is… removing several harsh social and legal punishments for having consensual sex outside wedlock, for being attracted to someone that was the same sex as you, for being attracted to someone of a different race … on and on … was reduced to “teaching girls to have sex like men and do XXX”. Unfortunately the same thing is happening in this video. The backlash to this spawned the sex positive feminists movement, which was also primarily focused on combating the legislative alliance between separatists and Christian Nationalists and the terrible rights eroding legislation it spawned.
@pollysshore2539
@pollysshore2539 11 күн бұрын
Separatism is also not feminism. They might have some shared goals but it’s a different movement all together. One that also sought legislative power over women bodies and decisions. A look at how separatists have treated adult sex workers gives a glimpse into how they would treat women at large. Separatists have no problem defining their own sexuality - and they shouldn’t - but they have a problem with allowing others to do the same. They want to define it for them and control every aspect of it. They are notoriously authoritarian and socially conservative (believing in harsh social and legal punishments as a way to gain and maintain control over others). It was a rather terrible thing to do to feminists that were fighting for their right to be with who they wanted on their own terms. Reducing largely successful - therefore largely supported - feminist movements to a stereotypical joke was r a great thing either. *Historically you will find the majority of feminists attempting to remove Christian Nationalist/white supremacist legislation that controlled others bodies and attempted to control what happens in their bedrooms, and separatists working with nationalists to create legislation that controls peoples bodies and what happens in their bedrooms. We are not talking about obvious crimes, here. Everyone sought various restrictions for crimes.
@KD-_-
@KD-_- 10 күн бұрын
It's interesting the degree to which we're expected to put on soft gloves for such a crazy ideology because they're on the same ish side. There's an implication there for conversion therapy with the idea that you can convert sexuality, and I'd expect it to be less acceptable.
@amaurylannes
@amaurylannes 9 күн бұрын
Celibacy is still just a form of separatism
@pollysshore2539
@pollysshore2539 9 күн бұрын
@@amaurylannes It is, and it won’t take off. It never has. Some people might be claiming celibacy during a dry spell but unless they join a convent it will go out the window quickly. Human nature ensures it.
@Pratt11
@Pratt11 12 күн бұрын
I once tried dating on bumble, as a guy, this was the most...average app ever? Like I really got it for the “Women initiate convo since women empowerment” stuff because I'm mostly awkward and was tired of tinder, but like...people ghost a lot on this app, LIKE A LOT!!! (Maybe its just my place but yeah)
@cheaxel
@cheaxel 12 күн бұрын
"Hi"
@Pratt11
@Pratt11 12 күн бұрын
​@@cheaxelHi indeed, Chea
@vic44rd
@vic44rd 12 күн бұрын
@@cheaxel I never used it myself but a woman sent a friend of mine "." as the first message lmao. Just a period. A lot of the women using the app really did not get the memo.
@ryerye9019
@ryerye9019 12 күн бұрын
80/20 Rule. 20% of users engage in 80% of the conversations. I've had the longest conversations on Bumble, but neither of us bothered to ask each other out. Something about Bumble is a total buzz kill, pun intended.
@notnullnotvoid
@notnullnotvoid 12 күн бұрын
Same, 100% of women's first messages were some variant of "Hey" and then you're expected to start the conversation from there just like on every other app. "Women message first" makes literally no difference to anyone's experience lmao
@andiralosh2173
@andiralosh2173 12 күн бұрын
Separatism always devolves into culty purity politics. It's a space where the leaders define the righteous path, alienating followers from the broader society and it also sheilds the broader culture from the those most critical who are happy to leave, black hats for all involved
@phoenixfritzinger9185
@phoenixfritzinger9185 12 күн бұрын
I kinda feel like it’s the coward’s way out too. Like just going and retreating into your turtle shell instead of like fighting for any sort of change.
@f1mbultyr
@f1mbultyr 12 күн бұрын
@@phoenixfritzinger9185 And? People are fucking tired. Let them check out!
@andiralosh2173
@andiralosh2173 10 күн бұрын
@@f1mbultyr fair enough. I think there's a middle path for affinity work. Moral judgement for ineffectual praxis certainly doesn't't change anyone's mind. We can only really lead by example, and there are a plurality of paths to needed work
@nunyabaznus7851
@nunyabaznus7851 10 күн бұрын
@@f1mbultyr except we live in a society. your actions have a profound effect on everybody else, like the butterfly effect, causing typhoons halfway across the world. And now we have a weird system where vvomen are complaining that they are thoroughly ignored in public, and less attractive men are raging out because they are invisible and can't find love.
@KD-_-
@KD-_- 10 күн бұрын
Women's separatism gives me almost as many 🚩 as the MGTOW guys do. Interacting with the proponents of either is generally unpleasant at best and I try to avoid it. Though I think political lesbianism is actually more crazy than most men's incel ideologies. You don't see them actively trying to present as gay to uphold their "solidarity." It is funny though when one with a large social media following gets a girlfriend and everyone melts down about the "betrayal."
@ANTREU96
@ANTREU96 11 күн бұрын
I love how you describe that if activism turns to a morality choice that movement has already lost. I see this behaviour in many segments of more left leaning topics not only feminism. There is alot of "morality bashing" on the left and it only serves to the benefit of the right
@catvalentine4317
@catvalentine4317 11 күн бұрын
For me, the current trend of right men has just led to me being repulsive to them so that they leave me alone irl. "Drop her immediately if she has hairy legs"? Fine, I'll drop the rasor. Less profit to men too. But I am aware that when I'll start working again (I'm a grad student), I will probably have to shave in order to keep my job. I wouldn't get fired for that explicitly, but there are ways. Patriarchy.
@KateeAngel
@KateeAngel 10 күн бұрын
Wear pants
@teaja211
@teaja211 12 күн бұрын
I mean not surprised they struggle. app is worse than tinder and tinder is baaad like really bad.
@AndyAlegria
@AndyAlegria 5 күн бұрын
How is Bumble worse?
@ggfgfj
@ggfgfj 3 күн бұрын
I think Samantha Jones from Sex and the City is a good example of a genuinely sexual liberated individual. Yes, she probably did get an ego boost from the men she managed to seduce but I don't think it's why she pursued sex. Nor was she out for social status points (she was already pretty high up on the ladder regardless). She merely enjoyed sex, was open to experimentation and with the consent of equally willing partners - was participating in a lifestyle that very much rejected the entire structure of purity culture. She never perceived herself as doing anything morally reprehensible. In fact when she caught her friends like Carrie silently judging her for her decisions, she called them out on their purity bs.
@michaelmcguire7526
@michaelmcguire7526 3 күн бұрын
A better slogan for Bumble would’ve been “women come first”
@lament22
@lament22 12 күн бұрын
why are you french
@redgentleman2412
@redgentleman2412 12 күн бұрын
Gave me a good laugh 😂
@Lily-ni5po
@Lily-ni5po 12 күн бұрын
Better question, why aren't you?
@Derpja
@Derpja 12 күн бұрын
@@Lily-ni5po I’m at least 1/16th French do I count
@lif6737
@lif6737 11 күн бұрын
Why is anyone French in this day and age?
@saumitra6711
@saumitra6711 11 күн бұрын
hakim use your real account!
@jirnena_
@jirnena_ 11 күн бұрын
as former user of bumble, I always ended up deleting the app within few days because in spite of the many likes or matches i received, the texts had no answer and until this point I think that people (mostly men) are there for validation on there looks or how desirable they want to feel. on the other side, for me feels humillating being ´hanged on' on waiting the answer on the next 24hrs or the conversations are the most mundane (since you cannot create intimacy through text in few days) and people just don't show interest to give follow app. The experience as a whole feels deshumanizing, of course, myself have become a commodity; picture like this: you are walking in a see of people, bumping into them, staring, but no one stops to make a conversation with you. Maybe people nowadays are just looking for a rush of emotions, to feed their ego and expectations, but in reality will be different.
@IronJhon788
@IronJhon788 11 күн бұрын
Welcome to how men feel when rejected or used for validation. The real human experience.
@notnullnotvoid
@notnullnotvoid 11 күн бұрын
Oh believe me, if men want to feel desirable, the absolute last thing they will do is go on a dating app.
@dickiewongtk
@dickiewongtk 10 күн бұрын
You know most men experience this on dating app right?
@Berutoron
@Berutoron 10 күн бұрын
I obviously can't speak for every heterosexual man on Bumble (though I am one of them), but I wonder if the lack of response isn't due to how many of us heterosexual men use dating apps, including Bumble. While I don't do it myself, I often hear that many men tend to swipe right on every profile, and only once they get a match do they decide whether the profile is attractive to them or not. So you end up with situations where people match together... and then nothing happens. Or, in more... pathetic (?) cases (and I'm gonna out myself here), the guy (e.g. me) will try and pay more attention to who they swipe right on, but get so few likes that sometimes they'll just match out of desperation anyway. In other words, I don't seek validation, but I want mutual attraction and a relationship but can't get one, so I go "whatever, I'll like them back, we'll see what happens". If the woman sends me a message, I then (and only then) decide if I'm really interested in them or not. I know, it's stupid, but that's been my experience at times. To be clear though, in most cases my experience is more like this: I get a like from a woman once in a blue moon (almost never someone I liked first), I (possibly) like them back, and then I never hear from them. And if I do get a message, either I message them back only to be met with extremely boring replies (i.e. I'm the one having to ask her things about her even when her profile is barebones, and she doesn't ask me anything even though I completed mine). Recently I've also been dealing with a couple of fake profiles that just tried selling me on some cryptoscam once we started messaging outside of the app, so that's fun. But before some people get ideas: I don't mean this as a criticism of women on dating apps. Dating apps are just shitty and make us all behave poorly. The details vary depending on gender and sexuality, but the big picture is still that these products make us all miserable towards ourselves and selfish with others. In a "post"-covid world and for homebodies like myself especially, this can be very depressing.
@pendragon2012
@pendragon2012 13 күн бұрын
That's what makes capitalism so insidious. No sooner do you think you're making progress on one issue or another then a company takes over and finds a way to make riches off it for the white men who run the company. I know that's been an issue for Juneteenth things here in the States. Great video as always, Alice! 🙂
@Pratt11
@Pratt11 12 күн бұрын
How the f@ck is this comment 1 day old when the video is 10 seconds only? ☠️😭
@pendragon2012
@pendragon2012 12 күн бұрын
@@Pratt11 Patreon, dude.
@Pratt11
@Pratt11 12 күн бұрын
​@@pendragon2012Nvm bud, I didn't realise that 😓
@comradetrashpanda8777
@comradetrashpanda8777 12 күн бұрын
I don't think capitalism cares if the company is run by white men
@BigV24
@BigV24 12 күн бұрын
It happens all the time and destabilises movements that start off with noble causes. It's inevitable and leads to cynicism which is sad.
@LiquidDemocracyNH
@LiquidDemocracyNH 8 күн бұрын
First of all: I strongly agree with the anti-celibacy ads message. I think it's ridiculous to pretend that sex and dating isn't an innate part of our nature. People choose Celibacy for bad reasons. I think the best way to get across what I'm getting at here is making a comparison between celibacy and introversion. Introversion is maybe an actual personality trait, or a result of a neuro-atypicality like autism, but in a society that makes it hard to have community and easy to isolate alone in your bedroom on your phone, introversion becomes a way of internalizing your own alienation. A way of saying "I'm actually alone because I want to be alone. I don't want community. I don't want friends. I just really value my alone time...24/7, on the internet." Similarly, to me, celibacy has become a logic of acceptance for our terrible dating status quo. We say stupid shit like "I just need some time to find myself" either as a way of keeping people we're not attracted to away from us, or as a cope for why we're not trying harder not to be alone. The truth is that dating is hard, and some people just give up. But this is just as pathetic as giving up on anything else in life you care about. You shouldn't give up on being happy and convince yourself you never wanted a partner in the first place
@brentblackburn976
@brentblackburn976 11 күн бұрын
This channel is so good at sounding so biased until the last 5 minutes where everything comes back super balanced.
@danimariafe
@danimariafe 12 күн бұрын
Honestly, I am exhausted. personally, I just do whatever makes me happy, I think I am ace, at least somewhere in the spectrum, but I do not shame women who participate in hook up culture. However, I do enjoy having these conversations with other women in my life, because not everyone understands how wanting to be 'free' can be actually worse for us. I often think that, thanks to the misogynist culture, we have more to lose if we engage in heterosexual relationships. I know it is impossible to escape gender norms 100%, I try my best, but I also do not think the responsibility should be placed on women only, we need to held men (and society in general) accountable. In that way, we can have healthy and meaningful relationships, separatism cannot be the only solution. Amazing video as always, greetings from Peru:)
@Megaghost_
@Megaghost_ 11 күн бұрын
Absolutamente de acuerdo. And even in homosexual relationships there is the possibility of enforcing traditional gender roles that make them not much different from any heterosexual relationship. Some gay couples reproduce the same habits hetero couples have. They see the traditional family as the way to go, not as a social construct from the last centuries of western culture. Te recomiendo leer a Leonor Silvestri, sus clases se pueden encontrar acá, es muy lúcida para tratar estos temas. Saludos desde Argentina.
@brianmeen2158
@brianmeen2158 10 күн бұрын
Gender norms are interesting because the few women I’ve dated that claimed to want gender roles to be eliminated also tended to want me(as the man) to be traditional in many ways . When I brought this up they’d give it some thought and realized that they truly don’t want to get rid of all gender norms lol.
@charlieducey8880
@charlieducey8880 Күн бұрын
Now, the issue with Wittig's novel is, perhaps unintentionally, the exact same issue with classical Marxism: it's utopian. It is not possible for women to live without men for any longer than one generation (for obvious biological reasons) and it is not possible to have a classless _modern_ society with communal ownership of all necessities because of human psychology, a topic which Marx tries his best to denegrade or outright avoid. Maybe it could work in a group of 10 people, but even then it seems utopian. What is needed is a _realistic_ response to realm problems and not impractical ideological impositions.
@rafeverao4105
@rafeverao4105 11 күн бұрын
I know this is a regular part of your research and video production, but thank you for always showing and citing the texts you refer to -- as someone relatively new to feminist theory, it's good to have a contemporary reading list for these things. Plus my university has some of Firestone's work, so yay free access
@annarboriter
@annarboriter 8 күн бұрын
"with the advent of birth control" hormonal contraception is merely one form of birth control
@GRBtutorials
@GRBtutorials 3 күн бұрын
It’s not just hormonal contraception, other forms of contraception (such as condoms) weren’t widely accessible either until relatively recently.
@annarboriter
@annarboriter 3 күн бұрын
@@GRBtutorials You get a lot of mileage with "relatively recently". It can mean whatever you want it to mean and you needn't even provide any dates. Coitus interruptus is also a form of birth control. Women have always known how to have sex without getting pregnant. It's only been in the later half of the 20th century that women have seen clear advantages to not getting pregnant: opportunities for education, lower infant mortality rates, expanded labor markets in office work etc.
@jamesgrow2463
@jamesgrow2463 12 күн бұрын
I’m always impressed by your content. You decompose topics so well, you articulate your analysis and ideas brilliantly. Viewing your content is always such a delight.
@paxwallace8324
@paxwallace8324 12 күн бұрын
I was so lucky because those 60s hippie girls were just hitting their 30s when I was in my 20s they were all feminist all sain people were they were Yoga teachers, Modern Dancers, Co-op mangers, artists, musicians, Earthmother Gardeners/massage therapists on their book shelves were The Whole Earth Catalogue the Tao Te Ching, the i-Ching, Diet for a Small Planet, Tom Robbins, Mary Daly, Our Bodies our Selves, the Joy of Sex, Shar Hite's The Hite Report on female orgasm. These women weren't part of that materialistic Disco scene. They were what was most fascinating about the late 70s and 80s. I'm 65 now and can't imagine what the equivalent of that counter culture would be today.
@fleurosea
@fleurosea 12 күн бұрын
I’m studying creative art therapy, that culture is still out there, building on the shoulders of those who have come before. These people identify with the “post-post modern”(I hate that name 🙄) or “new materialism”
@TheAmericanAmerican
@TheAmericanAmerican 11 күн бұрын
I'm just a boringly straight man in his 30s but I like to think that the progressive left is carrying the feminist torch? I mean I'm a Marxist Socialist and most of my like-minded peers 100% agree with the video here so I truly have hope for the feminist movement. We just gotta get rid of the TERFs and TradWifes first lol ;)
@shizz3907
@shizz3907 12 күн бұрын
I’m genuinely curious. As a guy who went through a glow-up in college and became one of those guys that makes women hate dating apps (endless situationships, ghosting, etc.) and I will say I’m not proud of my contribution to the current state of dating, I still find it really strange how it seems that many people don’t realize the issue here. I want anyone to tell me why this is wrong but what I see is that few men with very little self-control or maturity that women find very physically attractive end up having so many options, to the point where it was super common for me to literally have 5-6 female partners at a time that I would sort of cycle between. And my friends were doing the same thing to different extents. Some of our less genetically fortunate friends were not getting that same kind of attention at all, like lucky to get a match every few weeks. It feels like women honestly are all dating or sleeping with the same men and some don’t know about it. Like I’ve met guys I didn’t know before and we talk about dating and find out we slept with the same like two girls Edit 1: Im adding in numbers to my edits because these thoughts are continuously developing and I may have more later. I think that a lot of people currently caught-up in hookup culture are there unwillingly, and I think that this is the fundamental problem. There is too much pressure on people who really want a relationship and not just a hook-up to hook-up, even without input from their partner. Why? Because casual sex is perceived to be so easy to get nowadays, especially as we think about the people we find hot like "dang she, he, or they must be able to hook-up with anyone they're so hot" that there's this pressure that if you don't hook-up, someone else will, and then they will lose interest in you. Okay I don't know how any of these things tie together I am just sort of listing different issues I see in modern dating. That being said here goes the next issue. The lack of community reallllllyyyyy enables the bad actors in modern dating. The reason why I and my friends were able to have so many girls we were sleeping with at a time who were not aware of each other is because we met them off of dating apps or instagram. These girls had no way of knowing each other because dating apps and social media gave us the ability to connect with people we never would have naturally connected with. The atomization of society makes it really really easy to take advantage of, use, and discard people with almost zero social cost to pay. If one of the girls I was talking to started asking me for more commitment, I simply just ghosted, she probably lived 5 miles away from campus anyway and I wasnt going to see her, nor was anyone that I knew going to see her. So basically I was only an asshole in her head but that was okay because she was getting ghosted anyways. Again, not proud of any of this, but I think that ghosting is a large part of dating fatigue and a huge part of the function of community is that it regulates and enforces the rules of intimate partnerships or connections. For example: It's way easier to cheat if you and your partner have no mutual friends that would recognize you chatting up that one hot person at the bar. Okay I might think of some more stuff later
@kissless_518
@kissless_518 12 күн бұрын
There probably is something to that 80/20 rule after all...
@f1mbultyr
@f1mbultyr 12 күн бұрын
Nice victim blaming, my guy
@shizz3907
@shizz3907 12 күн бұрын
@@f1mbultyr Nah dude not victim blaming. Just telling my very anecdotal experience. If anything what I am saying and what I explicitly did say actually is that men with a lot of options and very little self-control or desire to commit are who are driving a lot of our dating woes, just speaking from experience.
@awsambdaman
@awsambdaman 12 күн бұрын
shizz3907 I respect your honesty! I’m a dude and I had a lot of hookups in college too. I don’t really feel as bad cause a lot of the women were down to have sex. Idk if I have sex with a woman do I owe her a relationship? Like I don’t agree with leading women on but if they want to sleep with me that’s them making that choice
@MrKoalaburger
@MrKoalaburger 11 күн бұрын
​@@awsambdaman Young women seem to innately assume sex = relationship. If I could give one piece of advice to every young woman out there it'd be "Just cuz he thinks you're hot doesn't mean he wants to be with you". But embodying that idea would require 1. Young women be more assertive in their dating life, or 2. They become celibate. Neither will happen in large numbers.
@ryankelly2835
@ryankelly2835 12 күн бұрын
i got a bumble ad before this video played
@quantenmoi
@quantenmoi 12 күн бұрын
Love your content. However, I reject the dichotomy you present between hookup culture and purity culture. While purity culture certainly exists, I think the predominant paradigm is monogamy culture. I personally feel like there’s a strong connection between my D and my heart. And I think many other men feel this way too. Certainly, a lot of women do. So, rejecting promiscuity (for lack of a better word) isn’t necessarily buying into some normative patriarchal structure. I think it is primarily people recognizing their natural inclination to connect sex and love. Of course, there’s a spectrum, and not everyone feels this way. But I think most people do.
@Staenhus
@Staenhus 11 күн бұрын
Isn't monogamy just another aspect of purity culture though? I mean, there is a pretty strong link between sexual purity and saving yourself for "the one", or at least someone you might think is them. There is an aspect of ownership to that which feels kind of patriarchal and capitalistic to me ("You're mine and I'm yours", "I will never love anyone but you", "You are the only one for me", etc), especially since female virginity and male ownership have a historical context. Think about it like this: What is your no-no when it comes to romantic/sexual relationships? Can your SO be naked in front of people they are attracted to or who are attracted to them? What about looking? What about kissing them? Whisper in their ear? Kiss them on the cheek? Masturbate to pictures/videos of others? None of that is intercourse, and yet the taboo around those actions is part of monogamy culture. Isn't that about purity, and doesn't it affect women more than men? That's not saying that everyone should be promiscuous or polygamist, or that sexuality and romantic connection is not linked for many, or for you specifically. Hell, polygamy can be very patriarchal as well, as we all know. However, I think that "natural inclination" is a bit of a dangerous term to use for these things. You can have sex for many different reasons and not being connected to one partner might be very freeing because of that. Additionally, loving more than one person romantically is something that is extremely discouraged in our society, even though it clearly happens to people a lot (referring to divorce/cheating numbers). Is there then really a "natural inclination" to connect sex and love, or put another way, to only have sex with and love one person at a time? I don't think there is a dichotomy between hookup culture and purity culture theoretically (again, there are other ways to have sex and/or have relationships that are conceptually possible), but I think there is one practically, which the video refers to. The way our society is formed around sex and love forces us into one or the other; either look for love through sex, or sex through love. Either you date a lot, or you date only based on opportunities presented. Either you have sexual mobility, or romantic stability. Embrace capitalism or embrace ownership... and isn't that just the same thing with a different name? I'm mainly spitballing here, so take my points with a grain of salt. Monogamy is fine and for many (even most) might be the ideal way for them to live their life. I'm sure both hooking up with different people and saving yourself for that special someone are viable strategies for many. The question is about the social rules within those norms and the inflexible nature of them, and whether that's healthy for people or not. I personally don't think they are and I think that discussing love, sex and relationships from a non-normative perspective is preferable to understand ourselves better, find alternative strategies and form less fragile relationships with others. That's my take anyway. Sorry about the length.
@quantenmoi
@quantenmoi 11 күн бұрын
​@@Staenhus I do think there's a natural inclination to connect sex and love. It's my own experience. And I think there is some science to back up that it's a general human trait - granting that the relevant scientific fields have replication issues. And I don’t want to get too hung up on monogamy. Maybe I should have avoided that term. My main point is the connection between sex and love/deep emotional connection. This connection might happen in other types of close group relationships as well - polyamory, polygamy polyandry. I just think most humans are not well suited to what we might call "acquaintance sex."
@sunglassesemojis
@sunglassesemojis 6 күн бұрын
It’s impossible to have large scale change without also having individual change. People who are able are absolutely responsible for making poor moral choices. You can’t recycle your way out of climate change, but you also can’t legislate your way out of it if individual behaviors & attitudes don’t change.
@chronometa
@chronometa 10 күн бұрын
I wonder if we are just exchanging one thing or another? Why not just have a place where we can choose what works best for us? If someone believes in soul ties and wants a low body count then that should be okay without that person being criticized. There's pros and cons to both imo. I'm not religious at all but I definitely don't like feeling like a number on a roster. Before BC I also believed there was a non political,biological incentive for not having sex with someone as well.
@dismiggo
@dismiggo 12 күн бұрын
What exactly do you mean at 12:58 with the statement "[...] giving up heterosexuality."? Even after rewatching that segment several times, I still don't understand the point you (or the author you were citing) were trying to make, as you obviously can't "give up" your sexuality, because sexuality is not anyone's choice.
@burpeesquad
@burpeesquad 12 күн бұрын
Maybe you should rewatch the whole video. She makes it clear in the first part.
@TheCommunistColin
@TheCommunistColin 12 күн бұрын
I think the implication is just that the people being discussed become celibate and stop looking for a partner and choose to enjoy other things instead. Like of course they can't just press a button and become gay, they are still attracted to the opposite sex, but they consciously choose to forego any engagement with their sexuality and stop finding partners.
@vaska00762
@vaska00762 12 күн бұрын
It's definitely something I find myself being conflicted on. I'm a "straight" trans woman - but basically almost no (straight) men want to really commit to being with someone who can't bear their children, not forgetting fragile heterosexuality. This, plus fetishism of trans people from pornography makes it incredibly tiresome. But I have 0 attraction to women - I can appreciate aesthetics and platonic connections certainly appeal to me, but as much as I'm deeply tired of the men that just don't respect who I am as a person, I can no more change my sexuality as I can change my gender identity.
@odrez
@odrez 12 күн бұрын
I had a look at the article and my interpretation is that "Giving up heterosexuality" refers to "the act of not participating in heterosexuality to cause change" framed as a personal responsibility that would somehow then fix heterosexuality as in "heterosexual relationships in their current state". She acknowledges that it doesn't work like that and the expectation is put unfairly on women having to make radical choices and not men. It also doesn't protect from reproducing the same dynamics in other relationships or communities posed as the alternative.
@televisionblitz
@televisionblitz 12 күн бұрын
Giving up heterosexuality as a practice, a non-man having sex with men in this case, rather than the Identity, of being a non-men who's wants to have sex with men.
@LeandroD1
@LeandroD1 12 күн бұрын
I loved this video, and I found it quite interesting to delve deeper into the feminist perspective on these kinds of issues since the sexual revolution of the '70s. As a man, I can clearly see the commodification of women on these types of apps, and how, if a man can't stand out, it will lead him into a cycle of self-loathing and depression as time passes and he doesn't get any likes.
@camiliabastos9816
@camiliabastos9816 12 күн бұрын
Love the " the same way you should boycott Isr..oops" 😂
@sivanmisgav9468
@sivanmisgav9468 11 күн бұрын
Anything commodified.. well... becomes commodified... No app is "feminist" no such thing as "green capitalism" no product is "consumer friendly". There are degrees of course. But the incentive of revenue is the goal, even if there are real good intentions in the begining.
@anguskane6359
@anguskane6359 12 күн бұрын
07:15 One might argue that we're not focusing enough on poverty, but suggesting that the right criticizes feminism merely to divert attention is misleading. Instead of tackling conservative arguments head-on, there's a tendency to label figures like Peterson and Shapiro as part of a vast conspiracy, which seems far-fetched. I say this because I miss seeing nuanced perspectives from the left on KZfaq that genuinely engage with the right's complaints, and vice versa. Additionally, the right's viewpoints currently resonate with a significant number of people, particularly men. This is concerning if the right is indeed wrong, and it's up to the left to persuade people otherwise.
@m0en
@m0en 12 күн бұрын
Have you considered making your own KZfaq channel? Nothing should be stopping you from entering the conversation. I for one like content with a nuanced perspectives.
@anguskane6359
@anguskane6359 12 күн бұрын
I doubt that having a channel where I simply ramble and question everything would attract an audience or contribute meaningfully to the conversation. We need people who are smarter and more eloquent than I am to discuss these complex issues. I just hope for more nuanced discussions. It's concerning that men are turning to the right while the left seems unsure how to reach them.@@m0en
@m0en
@m0en 12 күн бұрын
I get what you Are saying. I subscribe to both right leaning and left leaning content. If you want nuace you could check out contrapoints. I have recently conumed alot hoemath content and wish someone would critique his perspective. All though he may have some points regarding dating that seem valid, his explanations for why we are where we are has conservative undertones and has for the most part been unchallanged.
@cdw2468
@cdw2468 12 күн бұрын
this is an interesting perspective, but i have to ask for clarity: what exactly do you think are the arguments that the right presents that the left should be responding to that don’t simply legitimize falsehoods?
@fiveleavesleft6521
@fiveleavesleft6521 11 күн бұрын
​@@cdw2468That male and female psychology has evolved to be innately different (on average) and many of the things branded "unequal" are actually the outcomes of those differences playing out in the world.
@Michael-eq8th
@Michael-eq8th 11 күн бұрын
Im a man who’s been celebate for 8 years. Ive been anti capitalist for longer that that. I feel pretty free from patriarchy. Ive recently started dating again, and I tried bumble first. It feels pretty rooted in patriarchal norms. I feel a little cursed that the women who are most enlightened, are the hardest to find. It’s a bit of a trap that Ive fallen into. Celebacy was a really positive life decidion for me that changed my perspective and I admire that freedom of thought in others. However, that quality also makes me unlikely to meet them socially.
@DrAnarchy69
@DrAnarchy69 2 күн бұрын
It amazes me that dating apps don’t realize that a large part of the reason why people leave is because you need to pay monthly subscriptions to actually have a functional app
@mrjoda1118
@mrjoda1118 12 күн бұрын
Citing yourself like a true thinker. I would like to do the same
@MCSorry
@MCSorry 11 күн бұрын
The epitome of badass.
@uschurch
@uschurch 11 күн бұрын
@@MCSorry * delusion
@oj3730
@oj3730 11 күн бұрын
I mean, enunciating your argument and then providing the support for it is standard procedure in science lol
@MCSorry
@MCSorry 11 күн бұрын
@@uschurch You're acting like Alice wasn't an expert with written work. And, unfortunately for you, she is.
@TheRealSykx
@TheRealSykx 11 күн бұрын
@@uschurch lol cringe
@karlaschauer5409
@karlaschauer5409 11 күн бұрын
I personally like dating and dating apps, it get’s exhausting after a while so I take a break on it regularly, but I also come back to it, because it’s fun. I should mention that I am polyamorous, so I am not searching for “the one” and there is not really a reason for me to quit dating apps altogether, even when I am already in a loving and committed relationship. But from my experience it is possible to find meaningful connection and have valuable experiences through dating via dating apps.
@raresmocanu1743
@raresmocanu1743 10 күн бұрын
In eastern Europe, moving west was seen as a ticket to paradise in the early 2000s. By the time I finished high-school, the economy shifted and I missed that train - now it's average both here and there. Feels the same with this. I'm a socially inept dude who got to 23 without any experience in dating or hookups. I finally got my shit together mentally, only to see that everyone has had their fill and their fun and their suffering and they're now over that stage. And so I missed another train. I'm probably not looking in the right places, but life just feels like a bunch of missed trains and a lot of preparation for something that always has a deadline shorter than the time it takes me to prepare for it.
@johannageisel5390
@johannageisel5390 8 күн бұрын
I think you're probably better off searching for a good partner than a hookup. There are lots of women without much experience too, who are looking for somebody they have a deep connection to.
@scottgreen132
@scottgreen132 10 күн бұрын
6:26 wait I thought women used beauty products for themselves and not for men? So what are they "not putting in effort" for?
@delly2088
@delly2088 2 күн бұрын
[LONG] I feel like there's a class aspect to this that I haven't seen being sufficiently touched upon. I was inspired by "Right Wing Women" by Andrea Dworkin and "Why Women Have Better Sex Under Socialism" by Kristen Ghodsee. I think the sexual revolution was a bourgeois revolution, historically progressive against sexual feudalism so to speak, but nevertheless the origin of our social problems, alongside the economics causes of course. The sexual revolution was a bourgeois revolution in the sense that it freed women's bodies from the constraints of wife and mother for life, but also opened them to the "sexual marketplace", no longer were they seen as docile meek servants (children, essentially) but rather as a walking pair of buttcheeks, to be exchanged among less socially high ranking men rather than couryed and locked, which is far more dehumanizing in my opinion. Now, we need a sexual socialist revolution (accompanied by a regular socialist revolution of course), one that overcomes woman as commodity, hell, sex itself as commodity, as conquest, as status symbol and simply as just an intimate act people do that ends then and there. Sex personally is something i enjoy but like i dont HAVE to have sex. My body count is 2 and should the chance show itself, fine, should it not, fine too. I understand not everyone shares my... not even libido cuz that's kinda high, its more what i do about it, which is not let it inform my entire personality and politics. Aside from the abvious (patriarchy is the opioid of the masses) i think the main reason young cis men are shifting further and further right is cuz they're just not taught to stop thinking with their dicks and start with their brains. Like sex is cool and all but it's not that big a deal! Stop letting it define you!! Overcome bourgeois sexualisation!!!
@BengalaFraca
@BengalaFraca 11 күн бұрын
The good thing about depression is that my sex drive is practically inexistent
@KateeAngel
@KateeAngel 10 күн бұрын
Take antideptessants. They dump libido too, but also stop depression
@TheLyricalCleric
@TheLyricalCleric 11 күн бұрын
Lysistrata’s revolution continues!
@kevindenelsbeck7444
@kevindenelsbeck7444 5 күн бұрын
Is the reduction to the opposite poles of free-sex and purity culture maybe a bit *too* reductive, especially towards such extremes? I'm seeing growing reactions to hookup culture that recommend reserving sex for those you have a genuine emotional connection to. Not necessarily implying commitment to marriage with (now or in the near-future), but making intimate physical acts a consequence only of intimate emotional concordance.
@davedsilva
@davedsilva 6 күн бұрын
Bumble used to laugh at how women getting a turn with the same guys was empowering
@humanbeans7952
@humanbeans7952 12 күн бұрын
my goodness your channel is a breathe of fresh air in the youtube cesspool
@humanoid4338
@humanoid4338 11 күн бұрын
Everithing + capitalism does not equal what you where hoping for 😂
@Jeffur2
@Jeffur2 11 күн бұрын
Social norms can't guide one's actions if one chooses to reject them and supplant them with one's own guiding philosophy of how a respectable person navigates society. We all know these expectations are unjust, arbitrary, and archaic, so there's no reason to respect them by letting them guide our behavior.
@Staenhus
@Staenhus 11 күн бұрын
That's not really true, imo. Firstly, there is the active vs passive aspect. You need to be very active in order to reject social norms, because what norms do is form our behaviour when we're passive, i.e. tired or relaxed or similar. It's harder going against norms when you don't have the energy to do so, for the same reason you're more likely to buy fast food. It's easier, you don't have to think actively to do it. Secondly, norms are formative even in the rejection of them. They present a binary choice to be made when there might not be one in reality. A good example is race, where everything that isn't white is "racialised" even though reality is a spectrum of colours and experiences. Biracial people feel this a lot, because they're stuck in between; considered racialised and othered by white people, rejected as too normative by whatever minority group they're ascribed. See the discussion within the black community about "true blackness", especially after the Kendrick/Drake blowup, e.g.. Thirdly, even if you somehow find an individual behaviour that is truly independent of norms, a large part of the human experience is interaction with others. Meaning that normative culture still has an impact on you, if only in the way that people behave towards you and the way you're forced to act in order to do basal things. Believe me, I'm neurodivergent so I feel that aspect strongly in my life. This is why structural change/norm dismantling is so important. Individual change is great and a part of that, but an assertion that breaking normative culture is just a matter of personal rejection belies the complexity of sociological functions. You are being guided even when you don't think you are; choosing an alleyway instead of the main street doesn't mean you're not affected by the structure of the city.
@Vent69420
@Vent69420 10 күн бұрын
As someone who meets and has fun with people in person, it baffled me how these apps just sideline and ignore normal people while promoting the attractive ones who get swiped. When real life is easier to meet people than online dating apps, you know their business and purpose is flawed. They promote one night stands despite acting like they want to make an app you “delete” after finding a partner
@fennavanbreda2420
@fennavanbreda2420 12 күн бұрын
wowww Alice, this was an especially good one. When you started explaining the concept of transgression, many of my own misplaced feelings of shame fell into place. Thankyou for your well informed and always nuanced video's!!
@gwyn2151
@gwyn2151 12 күн бұрын
I think it's interesting that celibacy has been part of feminist and women's liberation movements since the dawn of time. I think it can be a very useful tool to achieve change in society as long as it doesn't start to involve morality. Sex should not be a moral issue, but it is, and that's the problem.
@mayam9575
@mayam9575 12 күн бұрын
Even in 411 BCE! Lysistrata an ancient Greek play about a group of women starting a sex strike to try to force their husbands into peace talks during the Peloponnesian War. In more recent history it was a big part of peace movements in Liberia during the second civil war there too.
@DemosthenesKar
@DemosthenesKar 12 күн бұрын
Well, if it lasts a generation, the only members of the new generation would be the children of the conservative women that didn't care. Thus you achieve a much more conservative society which is what will probably happen in korea.
@subcitizen2012
@subcitizen2012 12 күн бұрын
Not sure about since the dawn of time. Christian patriarchy was a significant portion of western history and all but required celibacy as a form of enforcement for patriarchy. Those were the norms that were shed, at least in protest, in the 60-70s feminist movement. It's pretty incredible how much and how quickly circumstances and contexts shift. I'm all for women and feminists protesting with celibacy, but don't forget the roots and history of sex itself as protest either. Sometimes I wonder what the role of feminist men is supposed to be in all of this. We're just here, also being jostled around by patriarchal and capitalist society.
@semantick
@semantick 12 күн бұрын
​@@DemosthenesKarChildren do not inherit their parent's values as if it's a genotype. This "outbreed the left" narrative is one of total nearsightedness. Large families, especially those born out of solipsistic and totalitarian ideologies like conservatism that promote the idea of children as the sole property of their parents, often produce maladjusted children that grow into maladjusted adults. This cultivated unease and fear is insanely useful for rightoids insofar as directing the sufferers into their fascistic ideologies, but in instances where anyone left of them manages to finally cobble together community care and action, there's usually a fair split in the divergence of lifestyle. Sometimes it even springs up out of the oppressive ideology itself, such as ex-Mormons and the safety nets they attempt to provide for others attempting to leave LDS.
@JohnSmith-tl8pq
@JohnSmith-tl8pq 12 күн бұрын
@@DemosthenesKar Precisely. Liberal women don't breed, so in just another generation, they will go extinct and be replaced by a new generation of conservatives.
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. 12 күн бұрын
(Cue that Bumble India ad where two cute guys meet) I see that ad and feel like throwing chocolates at the screen and yell “LIAR!”
@Pratt11
@Pratt11 12 күн бұрын
Bumble India is the WORST!!, Like I genuinely can't tell if here they are even women or just guys trolling me or the “Casual only” shit
@RyuKyu.77
@RyuKyu.77 10 күн бұрын
As a bisexual indian guy, I WISH! WHERE ARE THE CUTE INDIAN GUYS?! WHERE'S SHAHRUKH KHAN? ALL I SEE IS UNCLES
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. 10 күн бұрын
@@RyuKyu.77 Nothing wrong with older guys but what are the priorities? That is the question
@RyuKyu.77
@RyuKyu.77 10 күн бұрын
@@PokhrajRoy. Indian men focus waay too much on s@# which has led me to limit my exploration, maybe I must wait till college where maybe good guys are available
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. 10 күн бұрын
@@RyuKyu.77 I wish you good luck
@JohnDeBrazen
@JohnDeBrazen 12 күн бұрын
I have to wonder if Bumble is just normalising the worst aspect of dating sites that creates incels where you have a large number of men who don’t have any way of standing out apart from their looks and a short bio.
@czarkusa2018
@czarkusa2018 11 күн бұрын
1:06 "Why pressure women into doing something they don't want to do?" That was the whole point of Bumble, to force them to write anything at all, usually "Hey", at an introduction. They always could and never wanted to.
@jirimakovsky6619
@jirimakovsky6619 6 күн бұрын
Bumble app story is so funny because girls don't use them because of ghosting, time consumptipon and its lowering their self-esteem (men have this all the time btw.). For a feminist app it gives a lot of power to men, I love it. :D
@cvlturecast
@cvlturecast 11 күн бұрын
11:48 this is gaslighting as its finest
@siduozhang8624
@siduozhang8624 6 күн бұрын
I recommend every man and woman to read Bell Hooks' book The Will to Change: Men Masculinity, and Love. It profoundly moved me, as a man. Because among all these, in my view, anti-men voices in the name of feminism, there are still intelligent feminist thinkers that believe the solution to the damaging nature of patriarchy, is to be found by women and men together. Ane men are also the victims of patriarchy. Unfortunately, most movements in human history, tend to morph into entirely something else and are hijacked by the human ego.
@lovelover4408
@lovelover4408 4 күн бұрын
bell hooks is one of the best modern feminist authors. I recommend her book “feminism is for everybody” for the same philosophical perspective.
@VARMOT123
@VARMOT123 5 күн бұрын
French pronunciation of indian names is so cute and funny at the same time
@Sara-ci9bl
@Sara-ci9bl 12 күн бұрын
The video is so good I have to pause it every few seconds to think 💙
@subcitizen2012
@subcitizen2012 12 күн бұрын
God I wish I could sit with Alice and pick her brain about all this. We need to protect her!
@Bojoschannel
@Bojoschannel 12 күн бұрын
She's so good you forget she's french
@cdw2468
@cdw2468 12 күн бұрын
@@Bojoschannelshe single-handedly makes me think “maybe french people aren’t so bad after all”
@x6da9crain
@x6da9crain 5 күн бұрын
19:06 female rappers are also needing women to fail to have success. They say certain thinga in interviews but lyrics in thier songs always go against what they said...
@Benfry57
@Benfry57 Күн бұрын
On a more trite note, the “apps” are such a waste of time. Every conversation becomes the same, dry blather. This video is far more interesting than that observation, but it’s worth mentioning.
@wannabeSam96
@wannabeSam96 12 күн бұрын
I cheer on those women who participate in hook up culture because it serves THEIR desires, but I also want to say that I think it can be hard as a leftist to personally be more on the side of celibacy or low body count, whatever, and not be viewed conservative because of that. So I definitely support women who decide to not partake in hook up culture even though they seem "less cool" because of that.
@sulimanthemagnificent4893
@sulimanthemagnificent4893 10 күн бұрын
Abstinence is power.
@ShadowBlitz776
@ShadowBlitz776 10 күн бұрын
Holo doesn't agree with you
@Wofie96
@Wofie96 11 күн бұрын
I go on the apps here and there, then I delete them. I mostly find now people aren't actually looking for partners, they're looking for company, a distraction. Tell me why a guy was talking to me consistently for 2 months knowing he could be moving across the country for a promotion at any time.
@neutral.chaotic
@neutral.chaotic 11 күн бұрын
I've never felt more fortunate to be asexual and, consequently, happily celibate. ❤
@lucasdahlgren4920
@lucasdahlgren4920 11 күн бұрын
Great video, and a special thanks for addressing the individualistic moralization of activism. The idea that there is one right morality and all others are wrong, that this then takes away the blame from those who caused the problem ( the societal structures) and puts it to the individual, alianating them in the process
how liberal feminism turns into fasc*sm
21:58
Alice Cappelle
Рет қаралды 501 М.
In Praise of Great Exposition
19:03
Thomas Flight
Рет қаралды 925 М.
孩子多的烦恼?#火影忍者 #家庭 #佐助
00:31
火影忍者一家
Рет қаралды 23 МЛН
MEU IRMÃO FICOU FAMOSO
00:52
Matheus Kriwat
Рет қаралды 38 МЛН
Please be kind🙏
00:34
ISSEI / いっせい
Рет қаралды 186 МЛН
small vs big hoop #tiktok
00:12
Анастасия Тарасова
Рет қаралды 25 МЛН
the attention economy is killing us.
21:58
Alice Cappelle
Рет қаралды 168 М.
Trump’s Second Term: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)
29:15
LastWeekTonight
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН
Male Weepies: A Misunderstood Genre
43:26
Broey Deschanel
Рет қаралды 161 М.
the downfall of traditional relationships.
18:26
Alice Cappelle
Рет қаралды 324 М.
Why are Gen-Z Women so Much More Liberal than Men?
8:58
TLDR News Global
Рет қаралды 504 М.
the toxic hedonism of male travel vloggers
16:27
Alice Cappelle
Рет қаралды 112 М.
Birth control and the anti-feminist backlash
28:50
Alice Cappelle
Рет қаралды 116 М.
孩子多的烦恼?#火影忍者 #家庭 #佐助
00:31
火影忍者一家
Рет қаралды 23 МЛН