That's the first time I've seen someone rank Linda Ballantyne above Keith Wickham. But you're right, this is a great example of how casting a woman as a boy can actually work. And nice job using Colleen O'Shaughnessey as Tails for reference, too!

michael angelis' percy was great especially when he said the line 'DON'T CALL ME DIRTY PERCY!!!'

I love how both Thomas and Percy have a perfect voice actor.

Nigel Pilkington is definitely my favourite voice actor for Percy, and I truthfully agree that he's the best voice for him. Like John Hasler's Thomas, he captured lots of energy, emotion and youth.

I never thought about it before, but Christopher Ragland's Percy voice actually complements Joseph May's Thomas voice really well! Great video! (minus Robin Smith not making the top 5 😪)

Didn't expect Nigel Pilkington to make the list, and while he does a good job as Percy, for me, my all-time favorite Percy VA is none other than Linda Ballantyne herself!🙂 She really not only captured what Percy's true character is, but also made him sound like an actual British schoolboy (and I love how she isn't trying to put on a voice to make it sound interesting, but this is one of the few times where the VA is the character). Plus, in some scenes, she really has a lot of fantastic line deliveries, one of them being when Percy spies on Splatter & Dodge at the Magic Buffers along with the quote "I am brave" really shines through. While Susan Roman doesn't work for James in MRR, Linda Ballantyne actually works for a young character like Percy perfectly! Seriously we NEED more interviews with her and the other MRR voiceover artists regarding their work on the movie! As for my least favorite Percy VA, I know this is gonna question most ppl, but I really didn't like Michael Angelis' performance as him, especially in later seasons he made him sound too much like a younger James, but high-pitched. Also, I never really go near the online videos from 2020, so I really don't have that much to say about Rob but I can agree that he never amped up his game with other characters previously voiced by a few others like Keith Wickham and others (also funnily enough, it's surprising to see you use the footage from Rainbow Sun Productions' MRR presentation).

I agree on all of these Side note, when rob voices any character the only thing that pops into my head is james

I might be in the minority here, but I think my favourite Percy voice was the lispy voice Angelis gave him in the HiT era. I'm just weird that way 😃 If I can remember back to the last time I marathoned the show, I think his American voice (I think Martin Sherman) was better than his British voice. Probably my second favourite Percy.

Ok thoughts on all of these voices: Rob Rackstraw - 100% agree with you Robin Smith - he's not that bad imo Martin Sherman - *i think his voice in Season 15 singlehandedly made me think Percy was a girl when I was like 3* but in literally any other season I think he sounds kinda fitting for Percy. Stephen Donald - agree with you again Keith Wickham - again, agreed Linda Ballantyne - three agrees in a row, the voices in TATMR are really underrated Christopher Ragland - really adorable and wholesome, i like this one Michael Angelis - perfect for the model series where there's only one narrator doing everything Nigel Piklington - pretty great voice, though i think it's a three-way tie between him, Christopher and Linda for the best Percy voice imo

"I'm Percy the special!" ☠️☠️

My favorite voice of the 6 main characters Thomas jhon hasler Edward kieth Wickham Henry Kevin frank Gordon niel crone James Michael Angeles Percy kieth wickham

Nigel Pilkington does the perfect Percy voice. Maybe it’s a little too high pitched but he is pretty much spot on voicing the character.

4:13 - 5:36, 7:19 - 9:00 THANK YOU!!! This is nice. I mostly agree of what you say on the voices. Nice job bro!!

Oh my God, in the last voice actor video, In season 19 - 24, you think Joesph is a decent voice, but now, you think that Christopher has a better voice? That's great. I think Gordon will be next

🥇 Nigel Pilkington (UK) 🥈 Linda Ballantyne 🥉 Christopher Ragland (US: S19-21 > BWBA) Keith Wickham (UK) • S13-15 👎🏻 • S16-18 👍🏻

Linda Ballantyne is pog. Your referral to Cars peaked my interest in your explanation of how annoying Mater and Martin Sherman both got overtime, I'd love to hear more Cars stuff from you in the future.

This is my ranking: 1) Nigel Pilkington 2) Keith Wickham 3) Lynda Ballentyne 4) Christopher Ragland 5) Martin Sherman 6) Michael Angelis 7) Steven Donald 8) Robin Smith 9) Rob Rackstraw

Pretty good choices of your favorite Percy voices my favorite will clearly will have to be Christopher ragland.

I have to admit, another fantastic video! I enjoy Michael Angelis, Keith Wickham, and Nigel Pilkington as a whole, especially with that English vibe, but the others are definitely interesting to compare to. In general, if you ever needed me for a project of any sort, I’d be happy to help you. I may create more videos in the future, but we’ll have to see. For your latest video, an outstanding 10/10!

Linda has to be my favourite Percy voice. I feel like Percy is better off being played by a woman, as in character, he is a really young engine, younger than Thomas.

I love these hundreds of sonic references in the video

Awesome. Voices of Henry next or soon in the near future

I love Michael Angelis' Percy voice. He sounds very funny, same thing with James. R.I.P 1944 - 2020 I will you never forget you. 💖💖💖💖💖💖

7:19 do you know that Percy US voice actor was born on the same day I was born and also the same year as the TV series of Thomas the Tank Engine and friends AKA season one

3:25 Nostalg isnt Always God

And also Percy kind of sounds like Dobby from Harry Potter

I was just watching the Thomas voices ranked video then found out you just uploaded this

I would love to see a video on the rest of the steam team this is such a good video I'm subbing

YES GEORGE CARLIN

Yeah, I don’t really know why they had Percy sound more like James in the new learning segments either. And how did Keith Wickham have a big booming voice for Gordon but also make a little kiddie voice for Percy? Also, 1 more thing: 13:44 *wide Percy.*

My favorite: Thomas voice: Ben Small Edward voice: Keith Wickham Henry voice: Keith Wickham Gordon voice: Tie between Kerry Shale/Neil Crone James voice: Rob Rackstraw (UK) Percy voice: Nigel Pilkington Toby voice: Colm Feore

Honestly, I wasn’t a fan of Linda voicing Percy in TATMR, but at least she gave it everything she had. Other than that, great video and hope the next character voice ranking video will be James.

i kinda like james and percy's tatmr voice.. and i agree colline is THE best voice for tails

ooo i love ranking videos!

Haulliah! Haulliah! Haulliah!Haulliah!Haulliah! WHOOOOOOOOO! 🥳🥳

awesome video, maybe we can see one on Gordon or toby

I’m so happy that you like Nigel Pilkington’s Percy too!

A yo I lowkey like Thomas s voice in the workprint of magic railroad

Percy's voice sound like James's voice in learn with tommas

I’m imagining Sailor Percy rn.

I would've loved to voice Percy as he is my favourite engine. If anyone ever wanted someone to play Percy in a project. I'm available. 😁

Nigel Pilkington is definitely the best Percy voice and it sounds Awesome

5:45 tbh I really like her voice for Percy. Personally I think it’s the best voice for him. Followed by Christopher

James: Then, Billy had an idea.......... As Soon As Merlin Says The Magic Wish Word............

James sounds like Nz Stick S4 Percy sounds like Frank/Archie and Stick's Brother

It's interesting to find out that Tatmr was originally gonna have all the engine characters voiced by the narrator.

I wonder how many times he said percy in this video

Linda Ballantyne and the voice actor for James in TATMR both did the US D.i.C dub for Sailor Moon

Can't wait for James or Edward!

If I had to choose a fav Percy va it's Martin Sherman, which is the same way I feel about Thomas, who also voiced Percy from 2009 to 2014 in T&F.

The UK dub just always sounds the most natural, no matter what.

The ending is perfect.

I agree with you on Micheal Angeles' voice for Percy because sure John Bell's and Michael Angeles may balance off of each other's perfectly but it makes Percy sound too old as it's one of the reasons why I think the model series should have had more than one person to voice all the characters.

Sailor Moon as Percy and Sailor Jupiter as James are, IMO, the most interesting casting choices they made for TATMRR.

Then Thomas, now Percy, who's going to be next? Maybe Toby? I still love the Farquaar trio.

Now I have that feeling James VAs is next

Can we please see you dvd collection of fireman Sam and bob the builder pls

S4 Percy sounds like Frank/Archie from The Koala Brothers

My favourite Percy voice was Michael angelis’ take on him during series 5-7 he sounds perfect but his best voice is James I love his take on him.

Aus Percy/The Mini Controller sounds like Bob and Roley

My favorite is Linda Ballyantine.

Nigel Pilkington and Christopher Ragland are the best voice actors while voicing Percy because the Percy is similar to the voice of Trevor but Keith Wickham voicing only Edward Henry Gordon James and Percy and allowing Ben Small to voice Thomas and Toby until Thomas and Toby ended up getting voiced by John Hasler and Rob Rackstraw

You should do James next

We just need James now to complete the trilogy

im scared i just got a ertl percy 2 hours before this was released

0:35 I respect your opinion, Rob sounds better when he's James in UK/US and the Great Railway Show announcer Speaking of Rob Rabstraw I love to see James' voices next

Percy the Small Engine (Voiced by George Carlin (S1-4), Alec Baldwin (S5-6), Linda Ballantyne (2000) and Michael Brandon (S7))

Can you do James now? Thanks!

I have a few things to say about this. First off, I actually thought Martin Sherman was going to be dead last, because you had someone screaming when you said he also voices Percy in the Thomas Voice actors video. (Question: Which would you rather listen too: Squidward playing his clarinet are Martin Sherman voicing Percy?). Second, I am sad that my favorite voice of James was horrible with Percy. And finally, how would you rate Christopher Rageland's villain Percy voice from the episode Free The Roads?

Do either Edward or Gordon next.

For me I like all the US voices because I grew up with them, so I find them good

can you do all the voices of diesel

Please do Best James Voices!! I can tell Rob would be Number One! Or even Angelis .

What epsiode is the cgi percy and Harold footage from

In my opinion all the CGI Percy voices are horrible. I never liked the thought of Percy being a young character after Season 3 as it really ruins the development and growth in the Classic Series and after 2002 no narrator or voice actor could really get that perfect Percy voice in my opinion

If Percy (whether as a male or female) were to be done by a voice actress in English, I'd go with Tiffany Grant who was the original English dub voice for Asuka Langley Soryu on _Neon Genesis Evangelion._

Yeah Keith Wickham's voice for Percy is really good I like it

Voice percy from learning with Thomas sounds Loke Private from penguins of Madagascar

I agree with all of these! I think James is next on the list, don't you think?

"Hey this wall taste like shut"

Do edward

Do james next

When's your next video it's been 2 months

I swear sometimes the US dub is just a punching bag for the Brit’s.

Can you please do diesel next

The first one is just james

have you realize that your channel Icon Of Thomas has a missing wheel

Nigel owns Percy voice And Trevor also

My favourite Percy voices is Michael angelis

Where you been for 1 month

Christopher Ragland was amazing as Percy until big world big adventures.

My list for Percy’s voices 1. Nigel Piklington 2. Christopher Ragland 3. Keith Wickham 4. Stephen Donald 5. Linda Ballantine 6. Robin Smith 7. Rob Rackstraw 8. Martin T. Sherman

11:34 Delayyyed!! I thought there was a chance he could be kidnapped or killed!

0:00 0:28 0:44 1:11 1:17 1:25 1:47 2:01 2:54 3:08 3:31 3:35 3:42 4:05 4:40 5:40 5:44 6:07 6:20 6:51 7:19 8:06 9:02 9:25 9:53 11:11 11:39 12:09 12:30

LINDA BALLANTYNE is the voice of Percy

So which one is your favorite percy voice just replied please

number 9 percy sounds like james LOL XD

The UK Percy Version along with US Is okay for me. but I think The UK Version is sweet in my opinion

Do diesel next

I hope James is next