So the two new" ministers " are against growth and wealth but take a £30K a year increase in salary 🤔🤔🤔🤔

Spectator TV is always top class when Andrew is on. I could listen to him pontificate on anything

Mr Neil is still the master of political journalism. No one of his stature, anywhere on the horizon.

If this alliance ends the political careers of Sturgeon and Harvie, it will have served a useful purpose.

“Some grit in the Oyster“. Forget what a good speaker Neil is due to his unbiased well researched interviewing. Should be knighted’

Sturgeon should drop the much used line - it’s the will of the Scottish people - it isn’t. Its a small percentage, and reducing number of Scots.

The problem I have with sturgeon's claims to green credentials is that she's against the Union having any benefit from oil and gas industry, yet bases all her hopes and claims for an independent Scotland on oil and gas production.

I sincerely hope that Andrew Neil returns to GB News. His is an incredibly important voice in the culture wars.

Great to listen to Andrew

How about getting back on GBNEWS ?

Andrew Neil is the best journalist in recent times. It is a genuine shame to see him without a solid platform to stand on.

I would like to see more of you Andrew. Glad you are back.

Still no currency solution. The number 1 problem. Not even bothering to hide it and absolutely no solution proposed whatsoever. Laughable.

“A ploy for independence”? 🤣😞🤣 So let me get this right, the French, Americans, Irish, Indians and Russians all made ‘a ploy’ for independence. 😳😆

Did the Scottish Green cadres train under Pol Pot in Cambodia? There are striking similarities. But they are probably too young to remember just how badly things went in Cambodia. Or in Mao's murderous Cultural Revolution. And too ignorant to see where their own policies would lead

It's only the establishment that wants to preserve the Union. If the English people were given a vote on a Scottish referendum, a large majority, being utterly fed up with Scottish whinging and incessant demands for more funding, would vote to give them independence. A massive two fingers! Imagine a Westminster parliament without any annoying Scots Nats in it, especially the insufferable Ian Blackford. I'd vote for that in a heartbeat! Bring it on!

Andrew Neil is, as always, the act to follow and there are few who can do so. Clear concise, informative and sensible comments .

thank goodness someone still uses the word "no". so underused these days

Very simple scottish people she's become a pain in the ass .vote her out of office ? And remain whithin uk union ? and prosper , what's the problem ? just stay as you are?as part of the U.K?

Many of us unfortunately live in Scotland and we are totally sick and fed up with the SNP's neverendum strategy. My wife and I are a couple of pensioners, although, not that old yet. What we want is a quiet life, which is not a lot to ask for, however, we cannot face having Sturgeon going on and on about Indyref 2, then it would be Indyref 3, ad nauseum. We all need a rest from all of her nonsense!

How come Andrew Neil isn't on GB News any more. After all he is chairman of both? I've been surprised how balanced GB News is... slant is centre right but they certainly let both sides speak and often have guests that are from the other side of the political spectrum.

Great shame that GB News seems to have lost your services Mr Neil. Where else do we find a political journalist, commentator and interviewer of your calibre?

And nice to see you back sir x

Glad to hear you lavish such praise on Alex Salmond Andrew , you didn’t speak in such glowing terms in the past. We all know you are vehemently opposed to Scottish independence.

The A9 goes from Perth to Thurso and is horrific! It's not just a bad road that goes from single track to duel back to single along it's entire length but it also has 'average speed cameras' dotted all along it that makes travelling on it incredibly frustrating as people panic and then go down to 40mph which along a busy single lane makes overtaking impossible.

Hmmm... I don't think alot of people in Scotland watch Spectator TV.

For grown up objective political analysis who other than Andrew Neil and Nigel Farage is it worth listening to?

I hope she try’s to hold an illegal referendum and is jailed.

So am I to take it Andrew Neil has left GB News alltogether now. I can't find anything on the internet about whether he's coming back or not.

Plz don't praise the new bridge over the Forth. Road networks on either side of the bridge are a disaster. Long traffic delays everyday. Travelling North over bridge 5 lanes of traffic trying to merge into 2.

When is Andrew Neil coming back to GB News?

U Always Get The Truth From Spector And GB, News,

Johnson should simply close her chamber down and arrest the ringleaders. Like Spain did.

So the people of Scotland vote for parties who want a second referendum and suddenly there's no mandate. This is the English definition of democracy which Neil buys into in a big way.

Tell me how renewable energy in Scotland is going to work in one of the poorest countries in Europe. How do we store the power generated during the day to service the the evening demand. What people forget or don’t know cold water takes an enormous amount of energy to heat up and an enormous amount of space to store, not forgetting the maintenance of these systems Then the fights begin to see who gets the first shower. There’s great example of this in the people’s palace room kitchen with steel tub in front of the coal fire, how very private in this society who can’t make its mind up what it is. Only now it’ll be in front of the wood burner, with the cry you better have sanitised it when you’ve finished with it. It’s like a Billy Connolly sketch from the 60’s How very sustainable.

All these comments on Scottish resources. But the elephant in the room is the Scottish Isles who hold 80% of Scottish oil want nothing to do with an independent scotland and will apply to leave the union with Scotland.

The greens and SNP are the best comedy double act since Morecambe and Wise🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧😂

When I was a kid, a "greenie" meant something else.

I’m all for an independence for both Scotland and Northern Ireland but not under that type of malarkey.

She is doing somthing very radical and she is thinking outside the norm of the political box that we scots suffer year In year out from Westminster so whats wrong with that deal that has been done

Didn't the Tories manifesto promise no more referendums? I know Boris's promises are not worth a lot but I can't see him breaking this one for the SNP.

I think Andrew is right on Afghanistan, but I'd go much further. More like "Suez Crisis", China now has a dominant position in the world economy, and United States cannot afford to play superpower games. If she is lucky, she can play second fiddle as a great power throughout the 21st century, like Britain did in the 20th century. On a lighter note, the living standards of the majority of the populus improve exponentially without tax being funnelled for the military industrial complex.

Andrew sounds like a plastic Scot because he has mostly lived and worked in London ;-) I have lived and worked in London most of my life too. However if one of your parents live in Scotland, like myself, do you have to go through immigration, what currency will you use? Can't anyone see the total hypocrisy of voting to stay in the European pseudo union, but leaving a tried and trusted union you've benefitted from for literally hundreds of years?

How much did you get Neil to comply to tyranny ???

Regardles of whether Boris says yes or no, it will be Carrie and not him who decides whether to agree to Sturgeon's demands or not.

I would love to come on the show and pick holes in Brexit. Obviously very worried about Scotland leaving the uneven union.

I'm a Communist. I'm only here for Cindy.. ! 🥰

I see the Spectator still can't mention Brexit

Andrew get back to GB News soon

Can’t bear the woman, she’s only signed up Mr Harvie to make up numbers, but still will lose the 2nd try. Come on Scotland see this woman for what she is.

Let them leave then we can use English money to help our elderly and poor.

Well said Andrew.

No sane person could pretend that Britain runs a 'capitalist' economy; it is full of special interest restrictions that would be utterly intolerable in the country that actually does run a capitalist economy. Corruptions there are really ultra-sophisticated, deeply embedded, and so long-standing as to be largely invisible. It is as corrupted as could be; how the benighted largely abused and often impoverished population labours under all these difficulties one really does wonder - but of course ordinary English people have always been kicked, ever so cleverly, in the gonads, by whichever ruling group that happens to find itself in a position to abuse and oppress. Compared with the dreadful and ever-worse reality in brexit England, places running more socially integrated societies such as France, Sweden, Holland, Norway, Finland are vastly nicer places to live for the overwhelming majority of the citizenry. Sturgeon is a reaction generated by a Scotland which has a living standard not much higher than 60% that of small, resource-starved Denmark. What does Neil want??? He seems a strange man now. Has he not seen the grim reality of his country of accent???

She knows that she doesn't have the votes so she will not call one. Her nationalist party campaigned on 'another indy ref' so she will need to keep making "just around the corner" noises.......but she knows the votes aren't there. The party knows the votes aren't there. The snp and green parties are now hoping their supporters will not notice when they don't get what they were promised. 😂

Two clowns have joined the circus and the taxpayers will pay for it.

What has the Royal Family got to do with Scot Greens? What is their policy on defence, immigration, Russia, China ..... Hong Kong ??

Glad to see Andrew is well and back at work he has been missed.

Och Neil....ye ken ....you know your havering mannie... The simple answer is Scotland must create its own Central Bank, thus creating its own currency, which it can set its own interest rates and it will be agreed by the BIS , IMF etc Its simple, there is no other way. Regarding the confirmation that all pensions will be honoured, under EU rules funds must be set aside for the existing pensions, obviously from the day of Independence then its a new system. Before the referendum a Scots Constitution must be created submitted to the UN, EU and all countries around the world, after independence ratified in the new Scottish Parliament.

The Scottish Conservatives are big fans of the Circular Economy and say they will introduce a back benchers bill.

Please come back to GB News Andrew - we miss you.

Andrew Neil saving journalism. Anyone know how Murdoch (Rupert, the Son(s) who run Fox/WSJ and/or the family at large)?

Andrew Neil another Hypocrite.

Boris Johnson show? 🤣🤣 we’ll see about that

as long as they go 100% and there’s a proper border everyone i know is all for them going, in fact give the English a vote and scotland would be gone in a heartbeat.

Nice one andrew.

Andrew Neil. Big let down. Bottled it on QT. Got a roasting form that pathetic writer. Part of the establishment.

He's a french jock for god's sake ?

At COP 26 you will see the Scottish government, big energy and academia.

Brexit totally changed things for Scotland, so on that basis I think they have a right to another referendum, and a chance to rejoin the EU. In Nicola Sturgeon's position I would just organise another referendum, regardless of what Boris wants. Short of sending in the army, there's nothing he can do to stop it, and if the majority vote for an independent Scotland standing in the way of this would probably be politically untenable.

Is that Andrew Neil the left wing Journalist.

"Och! Squeak squeak! I goh a lood of childish lunatics orn ma sade!!!!"

Aaah Andrew Neil- what a fine piece of gammon.

There would be no shortage of rental property if all property belonged to the public.

Andrew N ... Class operator

Parliament can pass a bill for Scottish Independence, and it will all fall flat if the monarch will not sign it!

Any respect I have for Neil , and there was plenty , has all but gone with his utterances on Question Time .

Why is the interviewer not even acknowledged in the video information?

Please come back to GB News

David Cameron & Alex Salmond 2014 - Referendum 7 years - 2021 May vote - SNP (59%) & Greens (7%) - YES!!! 62% EU Scotland YES!!! Boris Johnson & court lol :) Goodbye England - 317 years forever

He wouldn't be stupid enough to try and stop it.

Thank God he left GB news, its a baseless channel that is not 'news' but gossip instead. vile station.

I had respect for Andrew Neil for setting up a new unbiased news channel. However I have now lost that respect due him bailing on the fledgling company. Taking his ball home after such a short time is unforgivable.

As you say there was a referendum in 2014 so it's done. Johnson gets a lot of stick but he's canny and a Unionist. It is in his reasonable gift to just say no to a second ref given the 60% pronouncement. Even with the latest tax rise manifesto revisions he is very cleverly and consistently pulling the rug from under Labour who in my view will not get into government again for a generation.

Boris is hardly any better

I've watched Andrew Neil on GB News for the past few weeks so I don't know who this imposter is.

Is Andrew Neil still presenting at GB news?

I learnt a lot from that exchange. Really interesting discussion from the much missed Andrew Neil.

Let them leave the union think of the money we would save The English support them in reality with extra money per person we will save money if they leave

"rent control is bad" say again when me and my partner I pay £1000 a month for rent.

Shes fit

He's still worth a listen but his miscalculation over GB News raises questions about his judgment.

Someone needs to invest in better wifi

I'm torn between wanting to keep the union together and the prospect of watching The People's Republic of Scotland slowly disintegrate for a few years before begging to rejoin.

Not very democratic of you Brillo

When O when is A. Neil going to buy a proper camera and microphone for goodness sake. It's pathetic - a valued broadcaster and commentator doing it all on a cheap laptop. Compare the two pictures in this broadcast, both the quality of the pictures and the difference in sound. Look at her position and lighting and compare to him; and who's doing the talking? That bloke on the cheap laptop, because it'll do.....For less than £150 it's possible to buy some first rate kit and do a broadcast that is on par with the quality of his content.

The independence vote was a once in a generation thing so she wan't get one.

Active travel is walking and cycling

Tempting to welcome Scottish Independence just to see how green they are.

Wishful thinking Andrew

Sarcasm becmes you Andrew!