I believe that she has in fact PTSD. Because I have it and I know the thought processes, the patterns, and her testimony was consistent with it. Either AH is a perfect actor, which I doubt due to her performance in her movies, or some of the allegations are true, even if exaggerated due to her presumed histrionic disorder. I believe that Depp is in fact how he is depicted by Heard, but Depp is also a good actor, so what do you expect to see in court? If Amber's whole thing was just an act, why couldn't she make a good impression outside of the stand? Because no one in her team warned her about the obvious signs of her alleged disorders and how to avoid them?

Every single time there is someone saying this, no one is saying you are like amber heard she is just an example of a very bad case of bpd that is completely unregulated. Jesus. I dont feel the need to remind everyone that not everyone with my condition is exactly the same I give people a little credit. Also that was drew experience in treating border lines he said clearly 'just in my experience' you dont get to tell a doctor their clinical experiences arent true. Sorry it's not really how things work and what makes you think you know how other bpd people act with their doctors in private?

@@ryanwalker8843 I am not speaking up for each person with BPD dg. But most people I know are violent towards themselves, not other people. I wouldn’t care but this is really a high-profile case. I know my own BPD and that I am not like her. But I know so many people who are afraid to see therapist/psychiatrist… they don’t even need to have BPD. I am just tired of stereotypes. Idk, maybe I am too much like my dad who was a lawyer, since I was not even 10, I stood up for other people. People around me know what’s going on with me and no one ever compared me to Amber(or Jodi Arias…and other infamous women who were diagnosed with BPD). But I was super lucky to have supporting family(or my mum at least..), so I had many chances to understand what’s actually going on with me. Many people never felt even like 10% of the support I got in my life. I just feel so sorry for people(not just with BPD but I don’t have OCD or some other mental illness that is really misunderstood). Honestly, I’ve been pretty lucky in my life. But I’ve met so many people who weren’t and they didn’t even have psych.dgs. that have so much stigma around that dg. I am not commenting just because I personally don’t think that I am like Amber. I just know so many people who don’t try to seek help because they don’t have any support system around and are worried that people would judge them. Trust me, it’s not my hobby to write that”: I AM NOT LIKE AMBER” … But so many people are afraid to speak up, find help and it often ends up very tragically. I know that I am not a famous person and my comment probably won’t make a difference even for a 1 person who needs help. But I don’t care… there are people who need to know that they are not alone. And just say something like: “ I have BPD, I am not like Amber..bye” isn’t enough for me. I probably won’t help anyone but if there is even a small chance that someone will read my comment(or from someone else who has similar problems) … and maybe realize that they are not bad.. idk. I want to become a peer in a future. I have zero confidence … but I am not going to delete my comments. I am not defending just myself… but everyone with BPD(well not just that, many people who have mental issues are afraid to speak up deserve a chance in their life). My comments aren’t just about me… well I am writing what’s my life been like… but I am not doing it because I am bored and I want people to feel sorry for me. You know, I am glad that you’re ok with your dg. and that you don’t feel like you have to defend yourself. Honestly, I am not being cynical…good for you. But I’ve been in hospital and met people during CBT … my life was really super easy compared to many others. My mum loves me and supports me…Not everyone is that lucky. I know I probably won’t make a difference… but it was my choice to speak up. Thank you for your comment, I am glad that you feel this way. But sadly I’ve met many people who had no one in their life… many relatives&friends don’t even believe in mental health problems. I wish you the best, I am happy that you don’t feel like you have to say that you’re not like Amber. * I am not that much delusional - I don’t think that my comment is going to save the world😂🤦🏻‍♀️

@@MSeliskaZ You read like you're an Amber Heard, but an online version. You jump from one point to another, avoiding the simple crit that Ryan Walker brought up. This video is not about YOU. It's about Amber Heard and her traits that are common with BPD cases. Work on yourself first before "I am not defending just myself… but everyone with BPD," because your BPD is legible in your comments. BPD is partly getting too emotional about things. Work on yourself first. You matter! #strongmind

@@MSeliskaZ I hear you, & as someone who also suffers from BPD, I appreciate the points your trying to make. I recently read somewhere that there are 256 possible combinations of BPD symptoms, & that doesn't even factor in the severity of each symptom in individual sufferers. The result is that any two individuals with BPD can present quite differently, to the extent that they don't even appear to be suffering from the same disorder! Then you have a case as high profile as this, & well-known experts like Dr Drew providing commentary, & it has a substantial effect on the public perception of the disorder. I wish that those providing commentary would be more mindful about making general characterizations about the behavior of those with the disorder & either stress a little more the diversity of presentations, or refrain from expressing general characterizations.

@@BrodyBaddis I am not saying that I am not emotional😂 I am extremely emotional. “Thanks” for calling me online AH… I respect your opinion. You read my two comments and if that’s enough for you to call me that… ok. And I’ve started seeing psychiatrist when I was 13(I had anorexia&was super anxious). It’s been around 15 years… people see some kind of progress but I know that I am still not ok and I still need therapy. And I jump from one thing to another a lot… my doctor explained to me that it’s probably my anxiety and that my head would love to just say everything … for a while they thought I might have ADHD but no. If you talked to me about something complefely different- I’d be the same. Trust me or not(you are probably not gonna) but I usually delete lot of things that I do. Things that aren’t even related to mental health. But even some music that I listen to… couple hours later I have some of my another extreme mood swing and I am able to get mad at myself for posting it&delete it asap. I just commented what I like&don’t like about this video… I know many people who had partners with BPD and see us all as the most evil people on Earth😂 I am trying to be respectful…But to survive and get better.. I am need to get rid that part of me that is constantly sorry. If I have problem with someone’s opinion… then it’s only my problem. People don’t have to agree with everyone - each one of us is allowed to have his/her own opinion. Other people might be right&I might be wrong. You matter as well and I hope you’re doing ok.

Me too! x

Really even when she would cry with no tears and suddenly give stone faced the second a lawyer spoke and the go back to pretending to cry? No in this occasion she was clearly acting and it was the poor quality of the acting that tipped us off. So if she has to act then she dosent really believe. I agree that she probably distorts alot of stuff like johnny leaving as abusive. But if you have to pretend to cry and then forget to keep the performance up the second a lawyer or judge spoke. No she knows the violence stories are made up. It's not debatable if you believe it you dont need to fake it. She would even do acting tricks like looking down and getting into character forgetting that part normally gets cut out by the editors in movies so the Audience dosent see it. Her she would literally look down 'okay find my motivation get into character and start' then look up and start talking. Bad acting that's what sank her she cant act and we all saw that.

@@ryanwalker8843 hey don't be me wrong. She's crazy. And JD was definitely innocent. But just as this video is suggesting, yes she did ACT that's the illness. Is it real? Of course not. She did OVER PLAY AND I'VE EXAGGERATE the situations. Did she do it well?? Heck no. She's terrible actress. Idk how she's got the roles she has. Did you listen to this video? This is exactly what these experts were saying. Histrionic Personally Disorder will cause the person to imagine stuff happened when they didn't. These Drs have to take another person into the exam room for proof that the things the patients will come out and say are false. They believe things happened that didn't.

@@scrantonstrangler8301 I think it would be helpful in the context of AH personality disorder diagnoses to talk about secondary gain and the motivations for same. Obviously for AH, money and fame appear to be primary motivators. But, what about sympathy, adoration, martyrdom, and attention? This woman stole someone's rape story and recounted it as her own, long before she posed as a DV victim. Then, her manipulation if the media has been a case study in itself. Manipulation if the insurance companies. Manipulation of her peer group enablers and useful idiots. My gawd, the list goes on and on.

I’ll give you some perspective of how Histrionic people are since I’ve met at least one in high school who fit the profile: • They act very similar to Narcissist’s in terms of grandiosity, attention seeking and a lack of empathy. The key difference though is that Narcissists like to be the ones in charge and Histrionics would rather have someone else lead them. • Histrionic tend to not have a single original thought in their skulls. They will often change opinions based on who they are with and when it’s convenient for them. (Ex: My former friend with HPD unfortunately had the habit of being influenced by her bullies to turn on me and other people. She was easily manipulated) • Also Histrionic people have the habit of dissing friendships to fit with other people but when their tribe doesn’t work out or are rejected, they’ll eventually come crawling back to former friends (or at-least try to). The reason why is because their self image is entirely dependent on fitting in with the popular crowed and they’re willing to risk disregarding good relationships to do it regardless if the people they’re trying to appease are not looking out for their best interest. (Ex: I know my former friend told me to “get lost” because I was apparently ruining her chances to be initiated with a another group that was bullying her). • They can also be very sleazy. (Ex: The person I knew in high school who had this problem, was often jumping from one unstable relationship to another before the previous had even concluded). • Another trait from them is that they can believe that relationships are much closure then what they really are. (Ex: When I first met this Histrionic person in high school, I defended her because she was getting bullied. Afterwards we started talking as friends through zoom and she was quick to call me her “brother” even though we had just met. She did the same with other strangers she met). • They can also be moody and emotionally manipulative. (Ex: I know my former friend would often cry when I’d call her out on her disloyalty and say “Stop your scaring me”). • Lastly, they can engage in reckless sensation seeking behaviors. (Ex: My aforementioned former friend would do this all the time. From licking a dirty stall to get initiated into group, to choking a girl due to jealousy over a guy who liked her, to slitting her own wrists to relieve stress (had to call the school staff to talk to her on that one), and finally to doing drugs with random people). That should give you an idea how histrionic people are like.

@@scrantonstrangler8301 did you not listen to what they are saying. They are saying she belives it. You dont need to act if you believe it you just say what you felt happend. How did you miss that. If she is ACTING the she knows damn well it's not true. What Drew was saying is no they dont know that it's a lie because that's how they experienced it. If it's a delusion you dont need to perform you belive it. Listen when people are talking you might understand more. Hes saying its NOT acting its distortion and she actually believes that's what happend. Before you say did you listen to what they said... why dont you try listening to what's actually being said. Acting is not required if you belive. LISTEN when people talk.

It’s disgusting how people victim shame male survivors

Agree. There was no credible evidence that JH was abusive at all.

I don't think he believes JD was an abuser...but that AH was believing what she was saying even if it never happened...because of her desorder... Well maybe the desorder can explain some of the actions...but there were many premeditated lies, a hoax so...

Oh shucks. Thank you so much x

That's such a beautiful comment....at least he's helping someone..😂😂😂🇦🇺

I have no sumpathy gor Amber. Yes, she had plenty of drug and alcohol issues but she is a horrible person.

Maybe Johnny's simply a better actor?...

And the trial/recordings also showed JD did a lot to help her and make things work...So yes he ended by also using offensive words... by reacting .Who wouldn't have reacted ? It would have been worrying if he took it again and again without reacting.. At least he didn't hit her....

@@betina6885 exactly !

Could you elaborate how the trial showed this? As far as I'm concerned, the trial was about your right to speak about the abuse you've endured even if you don't have convincing evidence. The trial didn't really convincingly support either sides' story from an objective standpoint. I personally also believe that both abused each other. But this implies that Heard was abused. So if you're an abuser, do you lose your right to free speech about the abuse you've endured yourself? I think this ruling is a black milestone for free speech. Depp couldn't prove beyond any reasonable doubt that Heard hasn't been abused. Just because Heard is histrionic, you can't assume that everything she said must have been a lie without any ground truth to it. They would have to prove this as well, in addition to the disorder. They failed to do so. Sure, Heard also failed to show that Depp was like this with anyone else. But she didn't need to prove this. The burden of proof was on Johnny's shoulders.

Being married to Johnny gave her a lot more 'authority' to publish her lies. And a lot more attention since they were openly together for several years. She wasn't with the other two long enough for anyone to really buy into what she says.

Hi Dr. Das. You & Dr. Drew have good content about JD & AH on this video. I didn't follow their trial because it didn't really make my favorites list. Still I always enjoy your videos from your channel. Peace & spectacular times to you, love, Janine Smiley🙂😀🤩🤗😎☕🍪☕🎂🍩☕🍰🍫🍨🍧❣🖤

What I mean at the end is that they lack actual empathy but feel empathetic from others perspective and to themselves because A) others will be idolized be people with bpd and will believe their (often) self reporting abuse towards them, and they'll feel empathy due to the idiolization they get B) people with bpd will project and idolize others and themselves first and feel like they're empathetic but if they split and demonize they don't mind seeking revenge which isn't true empathy, or they might feel guilty but it's not guilty for their actions that caused separation, but the fact that it's caused them to be abandoned and demonize themselves at that moment.

I have struggled with BPD all my life, & I think there is some confusion between the term "guilt" & the term "shame." And I also think that our hypersensitivity to the opinion of others causes us to try to minimize our onus in the situation rather than own up to what we've done & express real remorse.

@@nannettefreeman7331 which is again about the view of self and others that's splitting. Each cluster b trait has difficulty showing remorse because of a false separation of self and others that happens in early stages of life normally. We should talk about it without demonizing it but without pretending it doesn't happen to those with bpd. This is actual awareness, not misinformation. It also helps a lot with misdiagnosis, like "quiet bpd" which was never a thing, it was 18-24 year old girls with adhd or depression being misdiagnosed with "quiet" bpd until later on when they matured as human beings they were diagnosed correctly with adhd/depression or sometimes even nothing because it was circumstantial to young adult life and instability. If we didn't try to stretch so much the label of the diagnosis and stuck to how the personality is formed, why and what to do to help create healthy coping mechanisms instead of splitting and projections and form a stable sense of self, we would actually help those with bpd, not start a war with the bpd community about the "good" quiet ones (which was mostly misdiagnosis) and the "bad" "narc bpd" ones. Because people with bpd felt like comparing themselves to people who didn't even have actually the same diagnosis. Which made them feel shame. Not guilt, but shame, which never helps, feeling shame doesn't help anyone, feeling guilt when being guilty does. But also end the war between bpd and other cluster b pds because it's not mental health awareness and acceptance, it's mental health discrimination and splitting on mental health disorders

Wow you are delusional. He was a mess after what happened to his friend River!! How dare you?! And Anthony Foxes own wife found him he ran off look it up. Don’t come in here with crazy ass conspiracies you know nothing about. She had the power she was young, feisty, beautiful and SUPER manipulative. He gave her whatever she wanted! Do some more research and stop following lies from the MSM.

Christi Mack who is an actual survivor or SA and DV had NO problem testifying on tv to what happened to her! However she had proof and truth on her side. Not lies.

Objection, speculation on the above.

JD has his issues. Bashing Amber? Excuse me, Amber bashed Johnny in so many ways it’s a miracle he appears to be on his way to recovery. Yes, recovery, hopefully for his drug and alcohol abuse, but MAINLY for his recovery for what she put him through for years. I am a survivor of DV and SV and I saw and a lot of what I went through in Johnny’s mannerisms. In NO WAY did I see any of that in Amber. Those of ‘like’ stick together. I as a survivor I can smell the stench of an abuser! It took 2 very long years to stop blaming myself for my abuser’s actions and to stop thinking about the abuse every single day. Thank goodness I have a wonderful family that helped me work through all that my abuser put me through. That was 10 years ago. Actually, somewhere in that time frame that abuse popped into my head and for some thankful reason I could not even remember my abuser’s name. So I pray that Johnny can heal quickly from what Amber did to him. So take your “bashing Amber” comment and really think about all she did and accused him of and ask yourself, TRULY, ask yourself where’s the proof. She had no proof of any of it. I can’t believe someone who loves another taking pictures of their loved one, passed out or nodding off, then sharing them with others. That’s cruel, and the things she did regarding TMZ. Sorry I don’t think bashing Amber passes in my playbook and the many thousands+ survivors who disagree with all of her BS.