this might seem a little random to my channel, but one thing i love is music production (i did it at uni) so whilst i was sat messing around today for my own enjoyment, i decided i wanted to share, because that intro sounds SO pretty. also helps when ariana has actual angel vocals. enjoy x

Usually songs backwards sound like shit or are creepy but that sounded great

This is not ghostin *this is hauntin*

0:30 it sounds like she’s saying i love you 🥺

At the beginning of sounds like she’s saying “I love you” 🥺

The beginning sounds like flashbacks, many moments, many pics, many people passed in my mind during this and now I'm crying listening to the rest of the song

the intro made me cry tf

Play this at my funeral bye

never delete this.

When u said "u need to hear this!" I felt like there's somebody there who actually cares :)

I break down every time I hear Mac's voice. listen closely towards the end of the song. you can hear Mac say " I Love You Ariana" ❤️

Play this at my wedding. But play the original ghostin' at my funeral.

That intro tho 😍

that intro sounds very cinematic. i could imagine someone (maybe ariana) in a pretty dress running through a dark forest and finally reaching the end where she escapes the darkness, revealing a meadow full of flowers and she finally smiles, eyes kind of teary idk

gurl. i'm haunted by this song in a new way now.

I found many "sad versions", "reloaded" versions, acoustic ones and always thought, sorry but it can't get sadder than the original, and can't get more beautiful or more haunting, yet angelic... But, boy, you managed it! I can't stop hearing it and wishing this was the official song! Kudos to you for what you did! This is amazing!

when mac says at the end of the song “i love you ariana” gave me chills and it makes me cry

This n headphones sound so beautiful

This is haunting, Rest In Peace Mac

I GOT LITERAL CHILLS FROM THE INTRO

Try this 1. Open another youtube tab 2. Type Rainy mood 3. play both at the same time 4. Enjoy the magic

This is a song you will hear in heavens waiting room

If this is not played at my wedding, I’m not going. 5:03 It sounds like Mac Miller is saying “I love you Ari Grande”

wow I'm crying it's so beautiful.. Imagine an 8d version of this

Okay- *Wow*

My eyes instantly tear bc i can feel all of Ariana's pain in these wales. She didnt deserve this pain. Any of it. @arianagrande

That intro😭😭😭I just listened to the rest and I definitely prefer this to the original❤️

im cryin always when i hear it. 🖤

the beginning sounds like an angel crying

crying forever bye

i'm not a fan of ariana but this song is something special. i really wish she would make music more like this, but she's more into her pop-happy songs. all the luck to her

Oh bish this is beautiful

The intro sounds like, the moment u died and every memory u have is replaying on your mind.

This is almost better than the original i -

i need this intro as my ringtone!!!!

I want to someone to play this at my funeral and when I go to Heaven 🥺❤️

5:02 “i love you ariana” ? :[

The heavenly/ethereal vibes of this song have me on the brink of tears 💗

Can you make a version of the intro but like a one hour loop or soemthing? It sounds so beautiful 😍

this is absolutely amazing. i listen to this every night so i can sleep. wow mac is watching from above, he’s proud. ariana is so strong. thank u for this. i love this

She literally sounds perfect even in reverse girl BYE-

I could not ever imagine the album cover being that way

ghostin is such a beautiful song

In the intro it feels like she's sobbing I CAN'T 😭😭😭😭

"ghostin" I know you hear me when I cry I try to hold it in at night While you're sleepin' next to me But it's your arms that I need this time (This time) Look at the cards that we've been dealt If you were anybody else Probably wouldn't last a day Every tear's a rain parade from hell (From hell) Baby, you do it so well You been so understanding, you been so good And I'm puttin' you through more than one ever should And I'm hating myself, 'cause you don't want to Admit that it hurts you I know that it breaks your heart when I cry again Over him, mm I know that it breaks your heart when I cry again 'Stead of ghostin' him We'll get through this We'll get past this I'm a girl with A whole lot of baggage But I love you We'll get past this I'm a girl with A whole lot of baggage, oh, yeah Though I wish he were here instead Don't want that living in your head He just comes to visit me When I'm dreaming every now and then (And then) And after all that we been through (And after all that we been through) There's so much to look forward to What was done and what was said Leave it all here in this bed with you (With you) Baby, you do it so well You been so understanding, you been so good And I'm puttin' you through more than one ever should And I'm hating myself, 'cause you don't want to Admit that it hurts you, baby I know that it breaks your heart when I cry again Over him, mm I know that it breaks your heart when I cry again 'Stead of ghostin' him We'll get through this We'll get past this I'm a girl with A whole lot of baggage But I love you (But I love you) We'll get past this (Past this) I'm a girl with A whole lot of baggage, oh, yeah

This is a beautiful song 👋👋🌟🌟

I've never heard something so beautiful in reverse Also I wish I heard this before because I used to be obsessed with Ariana Grande but now I grew out of that phase sadly and this is beautiful

this is heaven.

I haven't cried this much over a song since the sad version of In My Head. This is so anguishedly beautiful 💌 idk how they managed to create a song that mimics an emotion so accurately !

I would do anything to listen to this song for the first time again

❤️❤️❤️fav song off the album

So... when i arrive in the heaven i hear this? 🥺🥺

i think its a secret messages behind this hidden vocals🥺🥺💘

I still believe that Ariana is an angel sent by heaven .❤️

Sounds like heaven omg so good thank you for this

Wow this masterpiece needs to reach everyone 😔👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

I'm crying right now because I have depression and anxiety and this year has been so hard on my relationship. And when I here this song the ''him" in the song is my depression 😔

That's incredible! Amazing work!!

this is amazing

Omg this is so beautiful 😭

A litte different, but still very nice.

OMG how am I only finding out about this!! This is so beautiful 😍

im crying 😭THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL!😩

I actually love this

this is just oh my god...im speechless

This literally gives me chills🥺

the intro 🥺💗

this sounds like heaven

This made me wanna cry, it was so beautiful

Gives me chills how beautifuly it was composed

wow.

The instrumental in beginning reminds me of something from Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and i cant handle it

I’ve watched videos of ari and mac for 2 hours and now this,, yo i’m in full on tears

omg i never noticed it said i love you that is so beautiful

This is so beautiful I'm crying😭😭😭😭❤❤❤

I'm crying

every time I lose myself, I come back to this song and everything’s ok for just a few minutes.

I NEED this in my spotify playlists! 😫

omg, playing the speed limit or slowing down limit on 0.75 is honestly.....it honestly sounds like magic!!!!!!!

bish u did that

i’m...... i’m crying.. i can’t say something. just thank you. 🥺

I got chills in the beginning part

this is lit heaven

Wow I fell like I’m in haven I’m living for it

I got goosebumps geez

Crying throwing up rn 😩😩😩😩

I recorded ghostin cover and I did it with the harmonies too, and fits so good for me, thank u so much for this idea!!❤

The intro makes me feel mac is standing behind me and starring at me 😭🙏🏻

the intro is heavenly omg

I am getting goosebumps 😱😱

This jus woke up my soul

wow crying 💔

3:40 the way she says baby

Wow!!! It's like you woke up from a dream 0:57

Sounds like cry omg it’s amazing

bro this song.. makes me sob.

woah

3 years now. hurts sm

oh no... here i go again... I'M CRAYING

omg the intro