Arthur survived the whole Blackwater shit but this definitely surpassed him.

“This place used to be a pig farm” 2 pigs remain however

The facial animation work on RDR2 more than paved off to make this scene comedy gold imo.

I wish I could’ve seen the Mocap of roger Clark making that face lol

Remember I was like: Wait… WWHHHHAAAT? WTF is going on here?

“Say Micah I got a place with a lot of money”

Arthur : Oh shit... why am I here again ? I think I must have been drunk for too long...

Arthur's face is like whaaat the fuu

At that moment he realised there was way more fcked up shit than blackwater

I love Arthur’s face when he’s confused

I can’t believe the differences in this scene between John and Arthur. Arthur’s facial expressions seem more comical and improve this cutscene so much lol

“Ayo what the fuck….”

Arthur just like: “get me tf out of here….”

"before we lost our ma and pa" Wait a second... *_OUR?_*

Rdr2 encounters are more fucked up than GTA 5 encounters

"That meat is so tender" made me lose it 💀

"Ima head out" "No you're not"

Arthur has been through so much. He haas seen so much violance, so many corpses.... yet that has to be his most traumatic experience

I remember that as soon as I realized what that meant I was like “WHAT THE HOLY SHIT IF WRONG WITH THESE PPL*

*Arthurs like:* "Somethin' ain't right..."

I've never seen a more "WTF" face ever 🤣

I haven’t played any red dead redemption From the beginning of the short I was like “oh they’re cannibals and are serving him human.” Turns out they just from Alabama. And this felt grosser

“Meat is soo tender..” 👀 that zoom in had me dead asf

The face Arthur makes when he's processing the fact that those two are brother and sister just sends me 🤣🤣

Arthur's face when he figures out what's going on is the best 😂😂😂

This just has Arthur so concerned that I felt his soul try to leave

Arthur’s dumbfounded expression never failed to make me chuckle. 😂

I literally had to pause the game and say “I beg your pardon?”

I mean if they weren't siblings it seems like a nice relationship

The dial up tone killed me plus Arthur’s face of course!! 😂

The way his eyes move trying to evaluate the situation is priceless.

Imagine Trevor in this situation and nonchalantly telling that it's a human and needs some more spice to lessen the slight sweetness of it. Then when he hears that they're siblings and all that. He probably would have a similar look like how he looked at the guy who let him do it with his wife and didn't tell Trevor that it was his wife.

"Dutch I thought you said we was going to tahiti?" "Arthur it's even better than tahiti, it's virginia"

The moment where it clicks for Arthur never ceases to crack me up

Lul. Rockstar and their shiny sense of humor.

His eyes glancing back and fourth killed me😂

I did this as John and I gotta stay it still holds up 😂

His reaction is priceless 😂

I was so shocked too but I laughed so hard seeing Arthur's reaction

" *our* ma and pa-" "Oooooook time to turn myself in with milton"

Reacting to this for the first time made me howl 😭😭

I love the sound effects on this video, fits perfectly 😂😂😂

His face still kills me😭😭

Hol up Wait What's going on here Ok I'ma head out

He's all like: "So... Ooh, no, no, no... Can't be what I'm thinking."

I wish I could back in time and play this game again to be shocked by this two! Nowadays I just go in and blast them right away hahaha

“It's a short life but it's a merry one.” Yeah it's gonna be short if you live like Nikocado Avocado.

The face Arthur made absolutely killed me

The sound effects make this so much better

His face got me 🤣

he was looking back and forth like.”What the hell did i get myself into?”

John:you eat babies

If you know that they are siblings and killed there parents when they was little

I remember I was like: What the fuuuuck?

When I was here doing the eating part and they offer u up a drink I was hesitant to not drink it cause something was definetly wierd but I drank it then passed out then went back and showed them no mercy

Run Arthur! Run!

His face says "whatever is going on here i want no part of it and I should've left an hour ago"

I remember this cutscene I was like "ayooooo"

Arthur is like”oh shit”

"now hold on a damn minute, what in tarnation?"

Arthur was like: "The hell is going on here"

That’s the moment where everything clicked for Arthur

When I seen that my brain bought a plane ticket and left the country

"Ahahaha, uhhhh I'm full thanks I'll be goING RIGHT FUCKING NOW OH GOD"

He had a genuine smile like a friend being invited for dinner, so grateful. And then it got way beyond the border of wrong.

He be like, Hold up, wait a minute, somin ain’t right

Lmaooo yo bro this was wayyy funnier then it should have 😂😂😂

I've seen lots of clips of this, but this ones a winner!

It took me a little while to realize that they both shared the same parents I was like “Oh no both of their parents died at the same time” then I saw Arthur’s face and I was like “Oh shit”

I'm getting cannibal hillbilly vibes from this interaction they seem to be brother and sister and they say it used to be a pig farm so what are they eating that's so nice and tender

His face is perfect it’s just a confused face, but the dialogue and the facial movements are foreshadowing sum

The meet is so tender

"our" 💀💀💀

The way Arthur’s eyes are moving is hilarious 🤣💀

1899 biological shenanigans

The way arthur darts his eyes left and right was like "the fuck is got myself into"

This is the first time I actually laughed hard as hell at a video like this

The editing in this clip is absolutely hilarious🤣🤣🤣

When I seen Arther stare. I swore I heard Banjos string softly in the background..

"I GOTTA GET OUTTA HERE" was my immediate thought when seeing this scene

I wasn’t to surprised when I played this but his face made me burst out laughing

Author's face bro gets me every time 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Dial-up sounds were great.

After all of the shooting and gunfights, this is what surprises and shocks Arthur.😂

When I first saw this I instantly knew what really happened and I found human skulls and bones in a cabinet so I was like "what the fu..."

Mom:go hang out with the neighbors kids The kids:

"MMM... That smells delicious!!" My brother when he smells the toilet after he uses it:

Arthur say taste diffrent is because Arthur just eat a goddamn human body💀

Arthur had a loss of words

Arthur was like"this is beyond me"

Arthur”what ??” 😅 get out there while you can!!!

When I did this, Arthur already had tuberculosis and he looked sickly so he looked even more disgusted with them

Bro the dishes clanking is so fucking realistic

Arthur’s literally seen the worst of the worst but this is the only time I see him face like this

Bruh the radio business sound got me

He’s genuinely seen it all

Arthur is a very VERY battle hardened man, but this would shock every person if delivered like that 🤣🤣

WE CANT WE R IN TEXAS!!!!

Anyone else screech like an amused child when the vine boom happened?

Hhhhh. Wait a second.. Who are you??