A customer came in with one of those F-Types last week.. my god it sounded incredible!

As a former F-Type R owner I would take that over the R8. Had zero issues with mine over the years and I think it has alot more character than the R8. It is also a much better daily driver but if its going to be your weekend car the R8 is definetley not a bad option.

I would say keep the F-type but that's just because I just bought one yesterday and I know how awesome it is😊

I’d keep the manual R8 all the way. Both cars are great but the look of the R8 is just on another level.

I’d keep the Jaaaaaag

I would keep the jag everyday. Jaguar today are not old man’s cars… looks a lot better than the R8…

Keep the f type and tune it 🔥

If it was an F type coupe R (with the full 550bhp) I’d definitely be keeping that as the coupe is so sexy. However I don’t like the look of the convertible so I would keep the R8.

Not even close for me. R8.....the Jag is a nice car but no where near as special as the Audi...Im sure you knows this in your heart TBH. plus you're not 60 !

I think it has to come down to how much you use them. If you need a daily or long range cruiser, has to be the Jag. If you use it as a weekend toy, and just use it for a blast, the R8. I couldn't choose without lots of internal debate, but I'd have to go with the one that best suits how I use a car. Good luck 👍

Surprised to see so much love for the Jag, which is agree with…. I think

To me the R8 is just so much more special. If you can afford to keep it running well it seems like the obvious choice. It's a supercar, the gated manual with the mid mounted V8 that you can see in your rear view mirror is amazing and you'd have to spend double the money to get that experience anywhere else. The jag makes more sense if you're doing tons of mileage, but it's just so much less interesting. If it were me I'd keep the R8 and pick up a convertible again when I had the money. There are a lot of front engine/RWD roadsters out there, I bet you could get a similar experience for less money. EDIT: Oh and congrats on the house!

Really I think the only reason to keep the R8 is if you really are sure you want a manual. I don’t think it has anything else on the f type. Sounds and looks can be argued either way but it’s slower, less reliable, has worse tech and I’d guess less comfortable. So brain says F type but follow your heart. Keep which you want most. Which you’re most happy with and look back at when you get out etc. i would sell the R8 but like you mention it’s not my or anyone else’s car so yeah pick whichever you love most

I never considered a 2 seater until I saw the FType. The FType takes on different personalities depending on how you configure it. This blue one is unique and is a keeper. My British Racing Green is arriving 10/18

Hi Ben I saw you at Collecting Cars today at Bicester Heritage .I wanted to come over and say hi but you were surrounded by people . My name is Trevor and I’ve been a Sub for a few years and loved the Boxster and now R8 series. Anyway maybe next time I will make more effort to say hi . Keep up the good work on the channel mate 👍

I am keeping my r8 because it’s easier to fine another f type than a gated r8 soon you won’t fine them and it will go up in price because they don’t make them with manual anymore 😢

Sell both and get a combination of the two which is a Firesand Orange AWD Jaguar F-Type SVR Coupe! 😁👍 575hp, much sharper handling, mega V8 noise and also a great GT car!

audi superrr❤❤❤❤

What a wonderful problem to have -- like choosing between two supermodels. Either choice is a winner, even though I own the Jaaaaaag and love it.

I think AUDI R8 is way way better...it's sound ...it's power...it's manual Gearbox and it's looks and being able to see that stunning engine is incredible 😍

7:44 - The attention is because the R8 is so Lamborghini-ish. It's definitely in the supercar category. You know it's an Audi when you spot the emblem, but you quickly realize it's a special Audi. I've known about the Audi R8 before I actually saw one on the road. When I finally saw one, I did a double-take because I thought for a moment it was a Lamborghini, not a Ferrari, a Lamborghini.

Both are fantastic. Keep the Audi…..looks that bit more special. I also think jags are for older people, bit like mercs! May be a bit controversial….but I am a bit older😂

Such a tough choice ! I had the make the same and with the car being my daily…. I think you know which one I went with . The R8 is nice but the interior is definitely dated and quite frankly, the R8 would need some work due to its age

Easy choice, the jag! That model will never look outdated whereas that Audi…

Very difficult decision. If it was v10....I would definitely recommend the r8....im not a convertible person and the gated Transmission made me lean to the r8. That is a serious dilemma lol... which sold 1st? Betting r8

sell the R8 because the other option is a Jaaaaaaaaaaaag!

Keep the R8! Its a much more special car and will only continue to go up in value since its a gated manual!

Hi Ben, great video. I'm in a similar predicament, I've got a 60's mustang and a 80's 911. one needs to go as i want to go for a V8 R8 also, its hard to make a decision!

The r is awesome but I have r8 and an xkr.

R8

keep jaguar ftype of course

Sell jag as r8 super car and to dream of

8:30 - I think he means that particular car, because the Audi R8 comes with AC like all other modern day cars.

Very hard choice.. both could easily be toured cross country not mention with ac lol. Very tough

Lovely cars 🚗🚙🚘👍👍👍👍👍⭐️⭐️⭐️

Keep the one you like more as long as you don't need luggage space...then neither. I have the F coupe...the coupe has space enough for one plus luggage....otherwise.....but the Jag is much better looking and sounding.

Keep the F-type...100%

As someone who hopes to own multiple cars in the future, can I ask how you do your insurance? Do you have policies for each car or a broker who covers all your cars under one policy or anything?

At your younger age I would say keep the Audi and enjoy it. You can always buy an F type in a few years time. That way you get to have both cars in time and in the right order😎

Keep the r8

Have you decided?

Keep the audii have a tt but would love a r8 one day in black stunning car

Ben can you give me a recommendation for the best car detailer

Hmmm, not sure have an f type r, very reliable rocket 670 bhp ... sush dont tell anyone, R8 nice but would have to be a V10 anyway, my jag is quicker.

Keep the R8 :)

Personally I prefer the facelifted F-Type compared to the original, so with that in mind in this instance I would pick the R8

The Jag for me also does'nt look good in a Cab.......same as the 911...the coupes are far nicer and look finished

That’s the v8 dinosaur r8, it’s rubbish.

It's nice to have a convertible but stick with the R8 because I believe the F-Type will be nothing but problems like its predecessors.

/…..sell jag

That orange is disgusting and looks horrible. The decision is easy.