I just noticed the tents - Wonderful! Really takes me back, camping down by the tracks...

The Hornby Jinty was my first ever Loco. Over 50 years ago.

I have four of the Bachmann Jinty and I've been perfectly happy with them.

Glad to see you got off easy this time! I really love the running sessions and your layout. Cheers! 😊👍

I'm kinda new to model railways, maintenance of my locomotive is an area I'm not 100% on yet learning loads from your videos. Thank you for doing these videos Bill

hi Bill, great video..i ave 2 Triang jinties made in 1967.good solid and reliable and easy to maintain,nowadays Bachmann is leading the way with jinties

It amazing what a service can do to a loco Keep safe ARP

Bachmann every time, they are brilliant.

I have the Bachmann Jinty in early British Railways livery. Sam's Trains did a review a while back listing its many shortcomings. However mine has been super reliable for the past 5 years and I love it to bits.

Hi bill brilliant video again love your layout I have 2 hornby jinty I do like them very much keep up your brilliant videos and good work Bernard

Bill, the Hornby Jinty is a Railroad model. It is simpler mechanically and less detailed than the Bachmann. Its also not DCC ready though your layout is DC and so its less of an issue. The Hornby model will be a lot cheaper as well.

Hi Bill good interesting video as usual, my favourite jinty is the Hornby SDJR version for the best all rounder, ie looks and good running capability. Cheers Tim Knight NZ

I have a Hornby one in Maroon with the XO4 motor runs really well if a little noisy.

I have an early Hornby one with a X04 motor, runs like a dream, and a heck of a lot easier to open up for maintenance, only one screw, straight down the chimney.

Ahh glad you fixed the Hornby jinty video, bit strange lol

I'm a big fan of Bachmann's 0-6-0 Chassis that they use for the Jinty and Pannier tanks. I'd go with the Bachmann Jinty personally. Not sure if you'll do DCC at all but the older models without DCC readiness are usually available for good prices.

Gotta get a Jinty 👍 I bought three off Ebay cheap and requiring repairs

I actually have that Hornby Railroad LMS Maroon Jinty in the cabinet! Very good runner, looks the part at any distance, although I do believe they are falsely advertised as being DDC ready. They're not, the only DCC Fitted Hornby Type M 0-6-0s come with the train sets I reckon. Highly recommend it if you want it.

Hi Bill..another great video 👍🏻..I’ve a few Bachmann Jintys and having had a hornby example to I’ve found Bachmann to be a better quality build..although I suppose it’s personal preference really

I don't about best but I've got the Hornby S&DJR Jinty which IMHO is the best liveried Jinty. I got mine very cheaply as a non-runner. It turned out that the connecting rods had been put on wrong and stopped the wheels turning. It may have been a factory error as there was no sign of usage on the wheels.

I still have an old triang jinty running well

As an LMS man, I have a bunch of Jinties, as they were one of the most commonly used locos on the LMS, both for freight and passenger duties. The Bachmann model that you serviced there would be the most detailed and accurate. On the downside, they can be a little temperamental, I find... but then, you're good at servicing things. The Hornby Jinties are fine also, and I wouldn't be without mine. They're not quite so accurate, but they're good, solid, dependable locos. The Hornby model hasn't evolved much, other than updated motors, and both older and newer motors have worked ok for me.

I've got a handful of Hornby Jintys. They aren't the most detailed but the newer ones with the type 7? (i think) motor in run very well :)

Great video Bill, I would recommend getting the Bachmann version. How about the LMS Maroon Jinty No.16440? There are two left in stock at Olivia's Trains. I have one too.

I have models of both the Hornby and Bachmann locos, and feel that the Bachmann is the better from a detail point of view, as the Hornby one is a much "older" design, but it is a good runner!

That one certainly came out of the “shed” a lot quieter

I would say the Bachman Jinty is the better lco but as always its up to the buyer to decide

Sorry I can't help the the best Class 3 Jinty loco. I have been giving some of emlocos a run round my layout. Sadly I seem to have accidently cause one of the two motors in my Heljan LMS Beyer Garratt loco to burn out! Not sure what to do with it at this stage! I'll try and check out replacement motors for the things. But I would just add that the Bachmann Jinty is the newer and perhaps better detailed model, wether it is better in the long run then the Hornby model I could not say.

I have the J13 jinty in the GNR livery

With the grinding noise it was making at the start I was mentally shouting at the screen “turn it off you’re hurting it”! It was like fingernails on a blackboard to my ears. Love these videos. Your layout is looking smashing too.

Quite a difference between Bachmann and Hornby on jinties . The Hornby one dates from 1978 . It’s ok but is definitely a Railroad model now . The Bachmann one is more detailed and runs better . Red ones aren’t authentic . There is a Hornby one with 16xxx number based on a preserved red one , but it’s not a colour they wore in LMS days . I think Bachmann released a Collectors Club special of this same loco , but very scarce and probably expensive. Before then there are the Tri-ang Hornby but these are really past it now .

As others have said, the Bachmann version is the more detailed but, I wouldn't mind betting that the Hornby one will run for many years longer with fewer problems.

Bachmann one hands down! Better mechanism and more prototypical.

What's the handy looking electric tool that you used to move the wheels ( when testing the pickups)? Nice work

I have one and it makes a clicking noise when running in reverse only, running forward its OK. Any ideas TIA

I've bought several railroad jinties recently for conversion to other classes. The running of these varies from silky smooth to absolutely terrible and with so many variations in chassis design it is really luck of the draw. I did get a nice running J83 (68472 in BR apple green) which is the same chassis as the jinty but might be a better fit with your other Scottish locos

Ware do you get your oil and grease from plus the Re-magnetisation unit

Is there any space for some locomotives service and repair as I got three that need your excellent service and repair skills

Hi Bill do you know where I can buy a magnetiser Regards Dave

Sorry to say this bill but your curtains need ironing