Y’know, I never thought I would go this deep down the rabbit hole. But just when you think you’ve settled you stumble even farther down..XD Happy tho, cause so many others are along for the ride. plus I’d say the fan base is pretty cool dontcha think? :)

Damn ,The time goes so fast

You got me sucked into this. I applaud your influence, lord.

What a great comment. You gained a new subscriber sir.

I miss my old time when I remember all maplestory quests and detail from old one, every pokemon gen1-4, every touhou charecters and now hololive

If there is a screen, there will be bad apple for it

I would class those under variations of 34 really

Please tell me those rules have been made canon. Because they should.

So you're telling me there's 270 rules between these two

@@tristen9736 Bad Apple is old, Hololive is new, whether those rules are real it would make sense for there to be so many rules between them.

Yeah lmao, it’s pretty wild.

A Same desu Gawr Gura desu!

Same I get somewhat nostalgic thinking about on how I came across every member like an anime that just got its 5th season and I’m watching the hell out of it

Yeah... I watched both the original bad apple and this one month ago and now I know all of their name... I'm falling really deep in touhou rabbit hole hole and hololive rabbit hole... Help!!!

We are deep insode the hole..

わかりみしか無い。作者様有難う

そして最後も船長で終わらせるのもエモい

最初｢霊夢は巫女だからみこちと交代じゃないのか｣って思ってたけどホロイズムで船長と霊夢が入れ替わったの思い出して天才だと思った

トワ様かと思ってた

@@YZKR107 一回本家のやつ見てきた方がいいんじゃない？エモいとか以前に最初に林檎を持ってた人に最終的に戻るんだよ？それでキャラが変わってたらおかしいだろww

Absolute mad lad

Sora also plays piano irl so it's fitting that she plays the keyboard

Who's fubuki facing to in 2:33 ?

@@yukio2380 mio

Holy shit madlad

@FBK町民 修正しました、助かる！

2:11 獅白ぼたん

@@NasuWatamate 1:59 貓又>白上>黑上>兔田

1:28 polka

@@leodd9385 nonono she kiara KFP CHEF RIGHT CHEF HAT AND CHICKEN

それな！

Ptsd

0:52 ここで半分に分かれた演出からそれなってるって思うとすこ

🤩

このコメ欄見て鳥肌がすごい

Thank You For The Timestamp Of Almost Every Hololive Member In The Bad Apple Hololive Version

(About My Top and First Comment It's A Thankful Comment Because It's The First Comment In This Comment Section and I Want it To Be Special If You Don't Mind)

2:05 yes it's Korone.

2:11 Shishiro Botan i think is mio u see her left foot

Nice

yep

🤣👍 that sums it up!

Yes.

Throw in the mashup of bad apple with apple bottom jeans by pluffaduff with this and it be perfect

Finally huh

Not have amelia watson

Thanks a lot

No Azki 😥

Where is the duck?

nice

まつりの亀頭が火を吹くぜ！

True

May i ask who?

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/lbJkgcliz9LXZo0.html

True

FFS. I didn't think from that point od view but it makes sense now.

"If you can recognize them just from their silhouette then you know the character design is good"

well i thought like 2 people were haato and marine and aqua have a surprisingly similar outline

I also think that Calli is just at the right place

Months ago, my husband and I were talking about how if this were ever done, who would be placed where and almost everyone is exactly where they should be in my mind. I legit teared up at how perfect it was

Even Ayame too

Gura: *puts a presenting gesture* "a"

mood

A

Also the Coco last stream just ended

The almighty "A"

Yeah, it would be hard to include everyone ya know.

@@truedryad There were a few repeats that could've been utilized. Like maybe put Coco with Kanata and Suisei instead of Sora.

@@1mikeap4 Ohh yeah it is!

see, even in this cmt they forgot '' AZKi ''

There is no hololive id too

マジそれな、多分ニコ厨の正義

KZfaqいつかニコニコに支配されんじゃねの？

自分的にはニコ動の時代また帰ってくるから得しかないが

ま、MADじゃなくてMMDなんだがな

@@user-ex9kk7fb3f 違和感無さ過ぎて自分気がつかなかったw

これもいいんだけど、やっぱ本家のすごさを再確認できるね。

きれいな影絵（？）だろ。ウソみたいだろ。11年前なんだぜ。あれで。

@@Riozissou_bot マジやべぇよな

@@Riozissou_bot うp主が今の時代に作ってたらどんな神曲になってたんだろ…気になる

綺麗な影絵してるだろ？あれ、11年前なんだぜ...

they credit the model sources, they didn't make them

Why does nene dont have 3d yet? I think i missed something

@@milkitalix2419 Nene's 3d model is gonna be based on her new outfit not her original outfit, so it's going to take a bit more time.

@@milkitalix2419 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/f5-ge6aqqpO6cXU.html

@@milkitalix2419 Basically, her redesign messed up the timetables for her being able to join the Gen 5 3D Debut. Her design got changed because it was Chinese inspired right when Hololive was pulling out of China over the whole Taiwan thing.

同じ飲みべえ笑

The 酒豪

しかし影絵でパッと見別の東方キャラが浮かぶ

流石です　肝臓

魔理沙の部分もシオンさんだと分かりやすいと思いました。

Lmao ikr

Yes

Yup

me neither

I was wondering about the choice, but of course, why didn't I remember that! Thanks for the explanation! I was here just wondering why not Sora, since she's the "main character". xD

that's right! good

I mean that's how I felt about the original but not nearly as many comments about that there as there are here. Guess that means I'm old.

and im dissapointed of myself by not recognizing all of their silhouette

it's intentional. the silloutes of the models are designed specifically so you can tell them apart, because it is a major feature of character design. TF2 has a similar design strat with their characters.

You should be

That power is so powerful that u are scared.

0,0

0:00 Staato

Makasih bang

末期とは失礼な！もう止まらねえだろ！

止まるんじゃねえぞ…

止まるんじゃねぇぞ…ホロライブ……

俺はとっくに末期だったな

そ、そんな、普通だと思ってたのに………

hololive  Solo Debutants Also known as hololive 0th gen.[30] Tokino SoraRobocoSakura MikoHoshimachi SuiseiAZKi hololive 1st Generation Yozora MelShirakami FubukiNatsuiro MatsuriAki RosenthalAkai HaatoHitomi Chris hololive 2nd Generation Minato AquaMurasaki ShionNakiri AyameYuzuki ChocoOozora Subaru hololive GAMERS Shirakami FubukiOokami MioNekomata OkayuInugami Korone hololive 3rd Generation Also known as hololive Fantasy (ホロライブファンタジー). Usada PekoraUruha RushiaShiranui FlareShirogane NoelHoushou Marine hololive 4th Generation Also known as holoForce (ホロふぉーす).[31] Amane KanataKiryu CocoTsunomaki WatameTokoyami TowaHimemori Luna hololive 5th Generation Formerly known as holoFive (ほろふぁいぶ) before Mano Aloe's retirement, now known as NePoLaBo (ねぽらぼ). Yukihana LamyMomosuzu NeneShishiro BotanOmaru PolkaMano Aloe VIRTUAL KZfaqR WIKI We have rolled out a new mobile experience to you. For more information, click here. VIRTUAL KZfaqR WIKI Hololive  Hololive Production (ホロライブプロダクション Hororaibu Purodakushon), or simply known as hololive (ホロライブ), is a Virtual Idol agency consisting of Virtual KZfaqrs supported and created by Cover Corp. As of November 2019, the total number of subscribers for the VTubers on KZfaq and bilibili are 2.6 million and 3.5 million, respectively, with four of the VTubers getting into the top 10 spots for VTubers on bilibili: Shirakami Fubuki (2nd), Minato Aqua (5th), Natsuiro Matsuri (7th), and Akai Haato (9th).[1](Last updated in April 2019 for bilibili top 10 spots) History On 13 June 2019, they announced the start of the audition for the third generation of hololive VTubers, called hololive Fantasy (ホロライブファンタジー). Auditions started from 13 June until 23 June with the screening starting and ending a day later and the interviews from 14 June until 28 June.[2]During hololive karaoke party on 7 July, two of the members, Usada Pekora and Uruha Rushia, were announced.[3] On 25 December, the fourth generation was announced.[4] 2020 On 20 March, hololive's Twitter account announced auditions, which were held from 20 to 30 March, for two new members.[5] On 23 April, hololive's English Twitter account announced the beginning of auditions for English speaking VTubers and that their official site would support said language.[6] On 3 July, hololive Indonesia Twitter account announced auditions for its second generation, from 3 July to 19 July.[7][8] On 6 August, hololive's Twitter account announced the introduction of its fifth generation, none of whom were members open for audition during March.[9][10] On 8 September, hololive's English Twitter account introduced the first members of "hololive English" and a new hololive English channel created to promote their content, with a creation date of September 7th.[11][12][13] On 30 November, hololive's official Twitter account announced the start of auditions for VSingers for hololive English; auditions were open until 29 January JST.[14] On 1 December, hololive's Indonesia Twitter account announced the debut dates of its second generation members.[15] With the retirement of Rosalyn on 27 December, hololive China officially ended its activities. 2021 On 12 February, hololive English Twitter account announced the audition for its second generation, with the audition going from 12 February to 26 March.[16] Inonaka Music Inonaka Music (イノナカミュージック; also shortened as INNK MUSIC) is a music label under hololive that launched on 19 May 2019.[17] Currently, AZKi is the only VTuber affiliated with the label, as Hoshimachi Suisei, who started activities under Inonaka, was transferred to the main hololive group on 1 December 2019.[18][19] Holostars Holostars (ホロスターズ) is the male Vtuber group of Hololive Production, initially operating under a separate agency. Auditions for the group began on 27 May 2019[20], and they began their activities in June as three members made their debut in advance. 2019 On 2 September, the agency added three more members to the roster, formally establishing Holostar's 1st Gen.[21] One of the new members' identity was kept secret until 17 October, who was revealed to be Rikka.[22] The Holostars KZfaq channel also posted a PV of the 1st Gen members, confirming Rikka's addition to the group.[23] On November, they announced their second generation featuring 3 new members, which started their debut on 7 December. On 2 December, Cover announced that it would be merging all of its VTuber agencies and music label to form "Hololive Production." However, the male Vtuber group continues to operate under the name "Holostars".[24] 2020 On 3 May, they released a trailer announcing their third generation[25] and a preview presentation of their 3 new members, naming them "TriNero".[26] However, TriNero started debuting on 29 April. On 29 June, it was announced Holostars second generation of VTubers would be named "Sun Tempo".[27] 2021 On 1 March, they announced Holostars first program on KZfaq[28], which was transmitted on 4 March.[29] Members hololive Virtual KZfaqrs (From Left to Right, Upper Row: Coco, Luna, Watame, Okayu, Korone, Mio, Fubuki, Noel, Miko, Flare, Pekora, Marine and Rushia; Middle Row: Kanata, Suisei, Towa, Ayame, Shion, Roboco, Sora, Haato, Mel and Aki; Bottom Row: AZKi, Choco, Subaru, Matsuri and Aqua.) The actual roster of VTubers endorsed by hololive are the following: hololive  Solo Debutants Also known as hololive 0th gen.[30] Tokino SoraRobocoSakura MikoHoshimachi SuiseiAZKi hololive 1st Generation Yozora MelShirakami FubukiNatsuiro MatsuriAki RosenthalAkai HaatoHitomi Chris (suspended) hololive 2nd Generation Minato AquaMurasaki ShionNakiri AyameYuzuki ChocoOozora Subaru hololive GAMERS Shirakami FubukiOokami MioNekomata OkayuInugami Korone hololive 3rd Generation Also known as hololive Fantasy (ホロライブファンタジー). Usada PekoraUruha RushiaShiranui FlareShirogane NoelHoushou Marine hololive 4th Generation Also known as holoForce (ホロふぉーす).[31] Amane KanataKiryu CocoTsunomaki WatameTokoyami TowaHimemori Luna hololive 5th Generation Formerly known as holoFive (ほろふぁいぶ) before Mano Aloe's retirement, now known as NePoLaBo (ねぽらぼ). Yukihana LamyMomosuzu NeneShishiro BotanOmaru PolkaMano Aloe (retired) INoNaKa MUSIC  AZKi hololive Indonesia (ID) hololive ID 1st Generation Ayunda RisuMoona HoshinovaAirani Iofifteen hololive ID 2nd Generation Kureiji OllieAnya MelfissaPavolia Reine hololive English (EN) hololive EN 1st Generation Also known as -Myth- or holoMyth. Mori CalliopeTakanashi KiaraNinomae Ina'nisGawr GuraWatson Amelia Holostars  Holostars 1st Generation Hanasaki MiyabiKanade IzuruArurandeisuRikkaKagami Kira Holostars 2nd Generation Also known as SunTempo as of 28 Jun, 2020.[32] Astel LedaKishido TemmaYukoku Roberu Holostars 3rd Generation Formerly known as TriNero (トライネロ) before Tsukishita Kaoru's retirement, now known as MaFia (魔フィア). Kageyama ShienAragami OgaTsukishita Kaoru Staff Motoaki Tanigo (YAGOO) (Cover/Parent company CEO)A-chan (Editor)Daidou Shinove (Holostars' manager)EnMa (Ina, Amelia, and Gura's manager)JenMa (Kiara's manager)

@@sutrisni9162 you must be fun hanging around with in a party no?

@@sutrisni9162 mmmm salut

I can name every touhou character from the original Bad Apple, but I'm still not at the point yet where I can recognize every idol here.

@@sutrisni9162 sees the first half ok good you fell in the right hole sees the word wiki okay now that's just cheating

Surprise Seeing you Here (Again) Tyler lol ,Yeah Very Amazing

Will You Make Another Mashup Of Hololive Members Singing Bad Apple? LoL Looking Forward to Your New Mashup

After fallen in the hole for more than 365 days, I still cannot recognize all their silhouette(mostly En)... I am disappointed in myself

I've Only Fallen In This Rabbit (Hololive) Hole For Exactly 3 Month's It's April 1 Now and I've Started Fallen Through This Hololive Hole Since Jan 1 2021 and I've Identified All Of Them So Yeah Love Hololive

F i recognize more than 80% from that. So i was too deep now

Ah yes, I love the fact that That happened to me twice (with the original (touhou) and with this (Hololive))

Being here since the Age of Monarchs, A.K.A. the Kizuna Era, this was a fun game for me.

if only you knew how bad things are

@@cornedbeef46 lunatic yeah

But there's only one VTuber that actually looked like a Touhou character

@@MaminakaMrpaperbag i need the name of that vtuber

It's Ayame

Gura and her almighty "A"

We can't. We'd be missing one.

@@joshuagabrielcatindig7607 a bit more than one

@@anonymouslyforgotten5592 ...are there more here?

@@joshuagabrielcatindig7607 Just noticed that not all the holo members are here. If they were all here, yes, but in this case, no nevermind.

@@anonymouslyforgotten5592 I did mean of all who were featured.

ジル説ない？

ぽよ余？

I thought it was Mio

@@asnad59 I was wondering that too, but it looked like both had the exact same shape. I took a look at the comments and realized that it is indeed Shirakami and Kurokami.

I know I'm 2 months late, but I went looking for this comment when I noticed it. Thought it was Mio as well, but I realized when I looked closer. Awesome detail that I imagine not too many people noticed.

Wait, marine is touhou fans, well that's new for me

@@idhanhaffani7494 Her actual touhou content aside, "AHOY!" (if not more Marine's songs, didn't look into it) was made with IOSYS of the "Cirno's Perfect Math Class" and "Marisa Stole the Precious Thing" fame. Also it took her the least tries of all Hololive girls to defeat Sans, IIRC.

Touhou fan here... XD

@@idhanhaffani7494 You should see her fangasming when Zun appeared on her radio show she does with Fubuki.

Also I don't know why Touhou X Hololive fans always forgot to mention this. Marine and a lot of HoloJP members collaborated with COOL&CREATE to make a Touhou Doujin album called "Gensokyo Holoism". It has 3 original Touhou songs and 3 Touhou cover songs, with 6 story chapters involving the Holo members voice acting. It's available on DLSite

Hmmm, are there any pirate in Gensokyo right now?

だって東方だもん

後、こっちはメンバーの繋がりが曖昧な配置も多いのが気になるね

初手2枚ムズ過ぎた

まだまだだなぁ！

初期衣装じゃないからか？

​@@user-fz6sn7zy7c 初手2枚は大分優しいくないか？

@@user-fz6sn7zy7c 東方好きと魔女 そんなにむずいか？

I forgot one more, Amane Kanata/Tokoyami Towa to replace Fubuki in the place of Tenshi Hinanawi (because TENSHI 😄)

Also during Eirin and Kaguya part, I want Moona to replace Eirin (y’know, moon goddess and everything) and Pekora replace Kaguya reaching for the Moon since she did “reach out” to Moona for a collab

@@misstrashtaker6787 oh yeah that could work also. Good point. Too bad there is no MMD model yet for Moona

Well, Flandre and Haachama don't really share personality, but I guess Haachama was added due to the "creepy smile". The image of Flandre was highly altered by the fandom, while she was originally a little (495 y/o) girl, that was not allowed to leave outside the mansion unless her sister allowed it, and that spent most of her time in the basement (and also her room), with destructive powers, emotional instability due to not knowing most stuff and staying home all day (cough cough most people in quarantine) and actually mainly being pretty chill........... To a psycho that destroys everything while acting as a kid, and a cold blood murderer that is trapped inside the basement by her own sister during 495 years. Yeah, that's a BIG difference-

@@arcanedarkling nice to know that, thanks for sharing 👍