That's a legit rub comparison,I was looking for someone to compare that weber rub up against other big brands,well done!

I think this would have been a more valid evaluation if you had skipped the sauce just had them taste them dry so the flavors of the rubs would really stand out.

Appreciate you taking the time to review all of the rubs you do awesome work look forward to more videos

I personally love the Weber and so does everyone else I cook for. I will be using it for upcoming comps this year

Appreciate this shootout. I always scoffed when I saw the weber stuff at the grocery store. I've got a rack on right now with Weber rub.

Just found your channel and dig it ! I had used the Weber rub last weekend for the first time, same ribs as yours, (Smithfield)used olive oil for a base and to say the least they was ok...to me and a couple others found it to be salty as hell. So I believe I'm gonna pass that up next time. I usually use Mccormicks apple wood rub, and no complaints from that. I'm gonna have to look into that THE BBQ RUB I hear alot about it on videos. Anyhow keep up the good work !!!!👍

great video thanks, I have been using the jack daniels for years ,it is kick ass rub ,I have tried many ,I will order some of the bbq rub from Malcom ,his vids are great also.thanks

Love what you have done here and look forward to more comparison videos big SUB from

Hard to beat Killer Hogs for pork. That Butt Rub is great for pulled pork. Even used it for drumsticks.

I use the Weber with extra paprika. Comes out great!

Great video, straight and too the point

Great episode, I would like to see what you think about grilled non-coated chicken wings and coated buffalo chicken wings. A chicken rubs/spices comparison.

Awesome review, man! Keep the videos coming!

Can any of these rubs work in a kitchen oven? I do not own a smoker *YET*

Try McCormick Memphis pit bbq rub , it's really good . Comes in pouches at Wal-Mart etc

I'm new to testing rubs but I used jack Daniels BEEF rubs on some ribs last night, and they were AWESOME! Idk the difference between the pork and beef ingredients or taste but I'll be testing that myself soon. Nice video, would like to see u do the testings w out the sauce tho.

Great video....and if you or any commentators could help me out id apreciate it...im looking for agreat rub with very little salt. A non salty bbq rub for beef. I make burgers and season the meat before forming the patties. Im looking for a rub that had almost no salt

Great video! thanks bro!

Ive used the weber before and its very good just cant find it anymore

👍good job , i enjoyed this video!

Thanks for the review

As soon as I saw the Weber rub in the competition I was well if this guy knows a good rub then it will win lol Hands down my favorite rub also! Perfect texture and blend of sweet and salty. I will have to try the killer hogs though. Thanks for sharing

Great video man, and WOW not one thumbs down vs almost 500 thumbs ups.

I can't wait for that brisket episode... you know it's coming

I find it hard t beat killer hog rub. with that being said my back up rub is the weber

Nice review!

I know this would be hard but different wood flavor taste comparison would be great

How long does bad byrons stay good?

What no Everglades?

Cool vid. Cheers

I have been using Worchestershire sauce as a binder on everything, it adds a bit of umami to the meat.

i like bad byron's its pretty universal

I'm have to agree with you brother that Weber Smoking Rub is a good rub especially for the price I usually use it with another good rub color up with Malcolm Killer hog rub

Yeah you have to do a blind test, the name brand recognition ie Jack Daniels and Weber people know, something that has the word Shit and Butt in thier name I think turns most people off. But a great I would love to see more just with different rubs. Keep them coming Now let me go and hit the button.

My family and I love the Weber rub only one I use

Next time would you add some Lambert's Sweet Rub O' Mine and would you try it without the barbecue sauce

I bought the Webber Smoking Rub for my first ever brisket.....I only used Webber rub on it and I felt the same on the clumping of the rub on the meat and I didnt at all care for the flavor it gave the meat....Maybe if I used it with a combination of another rub it might of been ok, but it just seemed to suck up any moister in the meat

I was curious how "special shit" would do, the color was not there, but I love large flakes of pepper. Amazing it was the most expensive, yet it was dead last. I just bought a char griller akorn kamado so im soaking up the info! Thx again.

Good job squaring up them ribs

I think the better test would be to add nothing extra, wrap only...

people that don't eat alot of bbq always like the rubs with sugar , I don't like any rub with sugar in it .

Awesome ribs but it should have been without the barbecue sauce so you can get the full flavor of the rub to heck with barbecue sauce yeah there's some they're good but everybody should like it just with the rub on it and paste the rub and the rib meat thank

I did not see Weber winning that. Wow.

BOYLOOKAHERE. I LOVED THAT VIDEO. VERY WELL DONE. I JUST SUBBED TO YOUR CHANNEL

Id bet the rankings have to do with that the top two had sugar in them, sweet and salty is too good on the taste buds

Extra tender means they have been injected with a salt brine solution before packaging. You should look at the sodium content when you buy. I stay away from those types of ribs.

Ya know Malcom atKiller Hogs sells his rubs in 5lb bags. Way cheaper & you can use the shit out of it!

Damn Karim, you look hammered as fuck lol

I tried butt rub didn't like it. Didn't really have much flavor I thought.

Why would you put sauce on them if your reviewing rubs? Click.

Hands down killer hogs

Butt rub ribs had NO fat -

Need more videos, you did weekly videos but your struggling with monthly..... So many views and subs for a young channel could be huge if you put it regular content....c'mon man. Only thing I didn't like was comparing rubs why dilute with bbq sauce honey and brown sugar making it harder to get true taste

Butt Rub is way to HOT. Jack Daniels is good tho

but rub was the worst i ever had ..nasty shit ...my fav is the Weber ..i have never tried special shit but the others i have..Weber is on top for me